Department Store Debit Cards Pros & Cons

June 5, 2013 | Posted By: Christine Luken | Categorized in: Finance, Shopping

As a financial coach, Iím well-prepared for the onslaught of high-pressure credit card sales pitches that seem to come EVERY time I get in the checkout lane when shopping. No, no, NO credit cards for me! I havenít had a personal credit card in close to ten years. Iíd gotten myself into plenty of trouble with credit cards in the past and itís just better that I donít have one. I have debit cards for two personal checking accounts and my business account, and havenít missed having a credit card at all.

As a coupon queen, there are times when I envy the discounts and extra coupons that store credit card holders enjoy. Then I remind myself that numerous studies have shown that people spend 12 Ė 18% more when shopping with a credit card versus cash or a debit card.

So I was totally caught off guard at the Target checkout a month ago when the cashier said, ďWould you like to apply for a Target credit or debit card?Ē ďOh, no thank you,Ē I said. ďWaitÖ What? Did you say Ďdebit cardí?Ē Yes, thatís right! You can get the SAME benefits of having a Target credit card without going into debt and paying 22.9%. The same goes for Nordstrom. The Target and Nordstrom debit cards link to your existing checking account and have all the same discounts and rewards as the store credit card. (These cards do not replace your bank debit card, as they can only be used in that particular store.)

There are several other major retailers that have pre-paid debit cards, which are NOT linked to your personal checking account. The Kroger grocery chain has pre-paid debit cards which can be loaded at the register with cash or via direct deposit from your bank. This enrolls shoppers into their 1-2-3 Rewards Program to earn free groceries and other perks. Even Wal-Mart has a pre-paid debit card program in partnership with American Express, called Bluebird.

Is there any downside to having a store debit card? There are some possible risks to consider, but I think they can be overcome. One downside to store debit cards is that they may not have the same fraud protection as credit cards or a bank debit card with a Visa or MasterCard logo on it. You might want to open a checking account just for the purpose of having that store debit card attached to it, rather than linking it to your regular checking account. This way you can limit the amount of money that is exposed to possible fraud. However, in order for someone to use your debit card, it can ONLY be used at that store or website and the person must also have your PIN. The other downside is that it can take a few days for the debit transactions to clear, and if you donít have enough money in your checking account when it does, youíll be charged an insufficient funds fee. Hereís your easy solution: Keep enough money in the account to cover your purchases! The nice thing about the pre-paid cards is that you canít over draw them.

So, will store debit cards now be the wave of the future? Thereís a growing movement in personal finance to shun credit cards and be more responsible when it comes to spending, due to the teachings of people like Dave Ramsey and the state of the national economy. Only time will tell if the store debit card trend will catch on. Itís not just a benefit to the consumer. Stores benefit by paying fewer bank processing fees when the customers purchase with a store debit or credit card. Sounds like a win-win to me!

Cash Back Resources

Additional Money Resources

  • Nordstrom Coupons
  • Walmart Coupons
  • CVS Coupons
  • American Express Coupons
  • Credit Cards Aren't Evil: You are!
  • 5 Top Financial Apps of 2013
  • Getting More From Store Saver Cards
  • Reducing Credit Card Interest Rates

  • Share this:
    June 5, 2013 | Posted By: boards5503
    The author's failure in choosing debit cards over credit cards demonstrates how she must be an awful financial coach. There are many reasons that credit cards are superior to debit cards and any good "financial coach" should have the discipline to be able to take advantage of the CC benefits while avoiding the pitfalls.

    I guess a second grader can truly teach a first grader everything they need to know.
    June 5, 2013 | Posted By: MarsdenFubar
    Thanks for the reply boards5503! I agree and disagree at the same time. I am all about responsible credit card use, and using the advantages to the max. On the flip side, some people really shouldn't have a credit card. They can't control the spending, and that can lead to high interest payments on a big debt. Debit cards allow people the convenience of a credit card, but restrict how much they can spend with some perks thrown in as a bonus.
    June 5, 2013 | Posted By: MissCrabette
    I think boards5503's point is that it's kind of sad when a so-called "financial coach" does not have the self-discipline to utilize credit cards to her advantage.

    I guess there's always someone in worse financial shape than you who will see you as the pinnacle of financial know-how and will eat up whatever financial advice you have to dish out.

    But back on the topic of store debit cards, I don't see the difference between charging too much on a credit card (and failing to pay the balance in full) and overdrawing your checking account via one of these store debit cards. What's that? Overdraft protection, you say? What good will that do you when you have no more cash in your account to buy food and other necessities?
    Post A Comment
    Log in using Facebook

    TRUSTe online privacy certification

    While FatWallet makes every effort to post correct information, offers are subject to change without notice.
    Some exclusions may apply based upon merchant policies.
    © 1999-2014