Weber Performer Charcoal Grill Review

June 2, 2010 | Posted By: Troy Redington
Excuse the long sappy introduction - BBQ is a sensitive subject.
In a past life, I was apparently a BBQ Guru. By past life I mean '3 or 4 years ago.' By BBQ Guru - I mean 'really enjoyed it immensely and excelled at it more than the average backyard griller.' I was no where near the level of Steven Raichlen, but that didn't prevent me from trying. Unfortunately, a fail of epic proportions took away my BBQ mojo and sadly, I lost all interest in backyard cooking.

Late last summer, about one year after throwing away my Char Griller Super Pro - which I LOVED btw, I started feeling the urge to grill again. Nothing extreme, just steaks or meat on a stick type things.

After thinking about it all winter, this Spring I decided (begged my wife) to buy another grill. As much as I loved my Char Griller, I couldn't buy another one. The combination of buying something that I already threw away once and the fact that it took me 3 hours to put that heifer together convinced me to buy something different.

I've heard over and over again on Weber forums that Weber grills last forever, so I went for it. I went with the Performer for its easy lid opening system, the touch'n'go ignition, and the giant work surface.



Purchasing
I quickly learned that there were no bargains for this grill. Which sucks, because I'm a cheap ass kinda frugal. It was $329 everywhere online and local. I asked several local places if they ever go on sale and was informed of Weber enforces a MAP Pricing policy - which means there is a minimum advertised price. I could have saved on sales tax by buying online, but it was nice out and I wanted to do some grilling ASAP, so I bought it locally at the Village Green. I had to run to Walgreens to pick up a little can of propane and some crappy Kingsford charcoal.

Assembly
I'm unhandy. I'm known for over-tightening screws and bolts to the point of them breaking or stripping. I tend to rush things, lose parts, or put parts on backwards due to unclear instructions, etc. Needless to say, I was a little bit hesitant about putting this beast together. I was pleasantly surprised how easy the assembly was though! The instructions were clear enough to prevent any accidental part swapping. I was able to do everything by myself. I was missing ONE single screw though, the one that held the two pieces of plastic together on the lid's handle. I called Weber, and they sent a whole new handle assembly FedEx Next Day Air. Way to go Weber!

One Touch Ignition
I was amazed at how easy it was to light the charcoal with this feature. You can pile your charcoal right on the middle of the charcoal grate or use the included charcoal baskets. Turn on the gas, push the red button, wait 5-minutes, turn off the gas, wait another 5 or 10 minutes and your coals are ready to cook. No stinky lighter fluids, no hot chimneys or flying embers of newspaper, no singed eyebrows.

Hinged Cooking Grate
The cooking grate has hinged flaps on both sides. This makes it super easy to add fresh charcoal to the already burning charcoal when you're doing longer, indirect cooking or smoking. They come in VERY handy - as you can add charcoal without having to move your meat. Initially I had concerns of the 22.5 inch surface being too small for big cookouts, but I think it will be fine for MOST grilling.

Giant Work Surface
I'm not one of those TV griller chefs who does all the prep work right there by the grill. (I also pronounce 'Cilantro' the normal way) That just seems more difficult than it is worth. However, the attached work table is GREAT for setting down plates of raw or cooked food, glazes, seasonings, wood chips, beers, fire extinguisher, etc. It is huge and relatively scratch and heat resistant. On its front edge there are 3 hooks for hanging your tools.

Contained Ash Pan
I remember as a kid, the ash pan of my Dad's Weber grill would often fall off and go blowing around the neighborhood. It was basically a thin piece of aluminum shaped like a hubcap that clamped into the undercarriage of the kettle to catch ash and glowing charcoal embers that fall through the vents. Not much has changed with the flimsy little hubcap ash pan of the lower end Webers, but the Performer and a few others have a sweet ash pan that is completely enclosed. When it is full, just lift the pan's handle and turn to release it. If you find yourself having to empty the ash pan too often, try switching from Kingsford to a lump charcoal. better flavor, longer burning, less ash.

Tuck-Away Lid Holder
I'm glad I wasn't the one who had to name this feature. This thing is the weird looking hoop on the left side of the kettle. It is also my favorite feature. No more trying to hang the kettle lid by its little hooky thingie. No more setting it down on the ground and hoping your kids or dog don't lick the hot enamel. No more holding it in one hand while you try to balance a plate on your arm and pull steaks from grates with your other hand. No no, with the Tuck-Away Lid Holder, just gently lift the lid and shove it to the left a bit. It slides right into this sleevy thingie and out of the way. It's like a hinge, but it's not.

Charcoal Bin
Honestly, I had very little hope for this feature. A plastic trashcan looking thing that clips to the cart and has a wire preventing it from opening too far? It looks and feels flimsy. However...it works. I keep a couple 5 pound bags of lump charcoal in there at all times. It opens with ease and stays shut on its own. The charcoal stays dry too.

Thermometer
The Performer model comes with a thermometer built in to the lid. This is GREAT for monitoring temperature without opening the lid and feeling with your hand. Every time you open the lid, you add 15 minutes of cooking time (so I've heard.) The temperature gauge might not be too useful when you're cooking burgers, brats, or steaks, but with longer cooks it is very handy.

Overall I'm VERY happy with this grill. It is solid, not shaky at all. The wheels seem durable. The steel grate is easy to clean, but harder to get awesome grill marks than the cast iron grates of my old Char Griller. I have been thinking about replacing them with these cast iron grates
Share this:
Comments
June 2, 2010 | Posted By: stelfson
Great blog! Too many lines to quote. Love the review! Nice job!
June 2, 2010 | Posted By: Venreth
My dad had one of the first generation of the Performers, he actually won it in a drink recipe contest! He LOVED it! The gas start charcoal was so cool. Yeah..that loopy-thingy that holds the lid...awesome! The charcoal bin...nice.
Granted, his eventually did die a horrible, sad, long awaited death. (I think he had his for nearly 15-20yrs) He has since moved up to the Char Griller...of all things! LOL Oh, how life throws you twists!
June 2, 2010 | Posted By: lpickles
My old fashioned Weber is starting to look pathetic..with its exposed hub cap of an ash pan and sidekick chimney starter.
June 2, 2010 | Posted By: mudley
I read somewhere that the early versions had a stainless steal table top. That would be SWEET!
July 7, 2010 | Posted By: tgpumpkin
I just wanted to say thanks for writing this blog. This was the most helpful resource in making my decision. I too had a hard time finding a cheaper Performer grill. Sears appeared to be the lowest at $240, but charged a 90 delivery charge that negated the savings. Only perk I could find was free shipping through Amazon.

Though I wasn't too thrilled to spend this much on a grill, your blog and the other reviews convince me it is worth it. I want something that will last and will have a workable surface for food.
July 12, 2010 | Posted By: mudley
Thanks for your comment tgpumpkin! Let us know what you think of your grill!
Post A Comment
Log in using Facebook


TRUSTe online privacy certification

While FatWallet makes every effort to post correct information, offers are subject to change without notice.
Some exclusions may apply based upon merchant policies.
© 1999-2014