Edit

Forums
Deal Discussion

Saab 92x $6,000 Rebate maybe $7,000 Archived From: Deal Discussion

  • tweet this
  • Post to Facebook
  • Text Only
  • Search this Topic »
  • Classic
alert mods    

marayatano said:I am pretty sure VW does NOT own Porsche.

I believe that a Porsche engineer went to VW and desiged the VW bettle engine back in the 60's 70's, cant remember.


Well sort of. The Porsche engineer was called Ferdinand Porsche, and he designed the KDF-wagen in the late 30's in response to Hitler's desire for a "people's car". This car eventually became the Beetle, and company became Volkswagen.

Volkswagen and Porsche have always been closely connected, both family and business-wise but neither has ever owned the other. Projects such as the 914, 924, Cayenne/Touareg all are the result of VW/Porsche collaboration.


alert mods    

VW does not own Porsche. From VW website "The Group’s passenger car business is divided into two brand groups. Under the leadership of the Group, the Audi and Volkswagen brands are responsible for the performance of their respective brand group worldwide. The Audi brand group comprises the Audi, SEAT and Lamborghini brands. The Volkswagen brand group is made up of the Volkswagen Passenger Cars, Škoda, Bentley and Bugatti brands."

The Porsche and Piëch families (Dr. Ferdinand K. Piëch is the Chairman of the Supervisory Board of Volkswagen AG and has worked for Porsche) are major stockholders in Porsche. Dr Piëch's father was Ferdinand Porche's son-in-law. As others have mentioned, due to this familial connection both companies have worked jointly together for many years sharing platforms and technology. I hope that clears it up.


alert mods    

I definitely don't think German quality is what it used to be. Almost all north american VW's are made in Mexico and it shows. We had 2 VW's that never spent more than 5 months out of the shop at a time. BMW, MB, and Audi are pretty much in the same boat from my experience. Great design and interiors, great handling, but they need to do something about that darn check engine light. Not to mention the rest of the electrical systems. A recent European quality survey ranked Japanese brands top 5.


alert mods    

marayatano said:Guess again. Porsche+Audi+VW=Family. Cayenne=Toureg.

I believe it was a joint developement. I read that in some magazine.

Porsche spun off on its own, but the Porsche and Piech families are still on each others boards of directors. The Piech family being the majority shareholders in the VW/Audi empire.

Do you know what "interlocking directorate" means in the real world?


alert mods    

marayatano said:The only other thing I know is that some BMWs are made (maybe only assembled?)in the US.

And VW owns Bosch, but does not put Bosch spark plugs in their engins but buys Japanese NGKs. Funny, you would think that VW would suppport their own companys.


I would love to see some documentation that VW owns Robert Bosch GmbH.


alert mods    

danl said:I would be all over this deal a few months back, but at the moment I'm not in too much need of a new car. In any case, I know the wrx is a good car and all, fun to drive etc. But can anyone comment on how reliable subarus are? Just that I dont know too many ppl who owns subarus, but I do know alot of honda owners and a few regretful saab owners.


CR rated Subaru the #1 car maker in 2004 for reliablity.


alert mods    

SonOfZeus said:marayatano said:Guess again. Porsche+Audi+VW=Family. Cayenne=Toureg.

I believe it was a joint developement. I read that in some magazine.


Porsche spun off on its own, but the Porsche and Piech families are still on each others boards of directors. The Piech family being the majority shareholders in the VW/Audi empire.

Do you know what "interlocking directorate" means in the real world?that means nothing -- half the fortune 500 companies are on each other boards but that doesnt mean they all own each other

for all intents and purposes, vw and porsche are very close and basically family. however neither owns the other and are both independent. gm and holden (australia) have a similar relationship which brought us the pontiac gto -- only that was bascially a rebagde. supposedly the next gto will be more of a joint development like the cayenne/toureg/q7

bet you didnt konw, but another example would be gm and daimlerchrysler cooperation -- right now w/ hybrid engines. they share the same technology and engines and spread it across all lines. how about the lotus elise using a toyota celica engine? does toyota now own lotus? of course not. there are hundreds of such examples and cooperations

EDIT: i stand corrected regarding holden and gm -- basically like the opel of australia


alert mods    

wuhoo said:gm and holden (australia) have a similar relationship

Wrong, grasshopper. LINK>>


alert mods    

[that means nothing -- half the fortune 500 companies are on each other boards but that doesnt mean they all own each other
for all intents and purposes, vw and porsche are very close and basically family.]

True but I believe the same families are majority stockholders in both companies.

[gm and holden (australia) have a similar relationship which brought us the pontiac gto -- only that was bascially a rebagde. supposedly the next gto will be more of a joint development like the cayenne/toureg/q7]

Not true Holden is a wholly owned subsidiary of GM. It is a GM foreign based brand just like Saab, Opel, and Vauxhall.


alert mods    

I thought about this vehicle, but overall the looks of the vehicle started to turn me off. From the front it can look mean (Only the AERO) package, but the rear starts to lookugly, it really turns too much into a wagon. And If i'm spending 20k, I better like what the vehicle looks like.


alert mods    

stonepran said:I thought about this vehicle, but overall the looks of the vehicle started to turn me off. From the front it can look mean (Only the AERO) package, but the rear starts to lookugly, it really turns too much into a wagon. And If i'm spending 20k, I better like what the vehicle looks like.

Furthermore, why would anyone knowingly want their new Suburu (Saab) serviced under warranty by an indifferent GM mechanic?


alert mods    

SonOfZeus said:stonepran said:I thought about this vehicle, but overall the looks of the vehicle started to turn me off. From the front it can look mean (Only the AERO) package, but the rear starts to lookugly, it really turns too much into a wagon. And If i'm spending 20k, I better like what the vehicle looks like.

Furthermore, why would anyone knowingly want their new Suburu (Saab) serviced under warranty by an indifferent GM mechanic?


Most Subaru dealerships and GM dealerships are the same one and they probably share the same mechanics.


alert mods    

Foxbat121 said:
Most Subaru dealerships and GM dealerships are the same one and they probably share the same mechanics.


Not HERE>> let me know if you need more.


alert mods    

Subaru all the way.
Awsome performance and safety + great in rallies.
Sorry, I don't like the looks of the wagons/hatchbacks.


alert mods    

xtrabad said:Caution: I heard the $5500 rebate goes to the New Rochelle rebate center,
and requires ORIGINAL receipt, UPC, and title of vehicle to be submitted. No copies!

Note: The UPC can be easily found by removing steering column and front dash. Careful not to cut any wires. Use blow dryer as to remove UPC completely intact.

If it was an EasyRebate, I'd be all over this!



This is funny, keep up the good work

There is only one question that I have: does it work with my 400sc?


alert mods    

To the poster asking about Subaru's reliability, they were ranked the most reliable manufacturer this year.
http://www.autobytel.com/content/shared/articles/templates/index.cfm/article_id_int/409/startrow/21/year/2005/articletype/1

I have a 2004 Outback Sport (very close to the 9-2X Linear) and I absolutely LOVE it. Mine is a manual and even though there's no turbo, with 2.5 liters to work with there's alot of torque off the line. The WRX and 9-2X Aero have the smaller 2.0 engine with a turbo which, while having more HP, has pretty bad turbo lag and not as much initial torque.

Anyhow, no problems at all with my car, though I will say that the transmission is not the most forgiving so take that into consideration if you're not used to driving a manual tranny.

Oh, and it's completely awesome in the snow even with the crappy stock Bridgestone RE92 tires.
Personally, though I prefer the look of the Impreza (looks less wagon like and more like some odd hatchback) but the 9-2X isn't a bad looking car especially if you can get it for less than it's Subaru cousin.
Oh one other thing, I've heard reports of the Saab mechanics not knowing how to fix problems that have arisen with 9-2X's due to a lack of training. One guy got so tired of waiting he supposedely took his to a Subaru dealership (even though he'd have to pay out of pocket) and they fixed the problem right away.

One last thing, I'm about 5'11 and I think there's plenty of room in the front seats (tons of headroom especially), the back however is a bit tight so I wouldn't reccomend cramming tall folks in there for long trips.


alert mods    

for those of you thinking this "Subaru" may be too small for you, I strongly suggest you test drive a Subaru Outback XT (Limited if you want leather/sunroof). This puppy will make you grin from ear to ear. Keep in mind the price difference, an XT runs about $26.5K (limited $28.5K) invoice. A lot of car for the money.


alert mods    

"Sorry, your rebate claim has been denied. Reason: incorrect or missing UPC barcode."


alert mods    

I would love to see some documentation that VW owns Robert Bosch GmbH

Bosch is not owned by VW. In fact, Bosch is a privately held corporation.


alert mods    

1954oval said:Well sort of. The Porsche engineer was called Ferdinand Porsche, and he designed the KDF-wagen in the late 30's in response to Hitler's desire for a "people's car". This car eventually became the Beetle, and company became Volkswagen.

Volkswagen and Porsche have always been closely connected, both family and business-wise but neither has ever owned the other. Projects such as the 914, 924, Cayenne/Touareg all are the result of VW/Porsche collaboration.


And to expand on that, Porsche (the Dr. Ferdinand Porsche) had a desire to build his own sports car, thats why he started Porsche.


 Close

Sign Me In
Nickname: 
Password: 
Remember My Login Information:

Forget your login information?

Not Already A Member?
Sign Up Now!



Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.


While FatWallet makes every effort to post correct information, offers are subject to change without notice.
Some exclusions may apply based upon merchant policies.
© 1999-2009