When moving out of our rental today, we found mold in a closet behind a picture that was in storage. I believe the mold came from the sprinklers being on too much. The owner takes care of the sprinklers and yard, so we do not regulate the flow and it opereats during the night so we do not know how much it waters. My question is what recourse do we have if he tries to charge us for it? We are moving out of state.
Edit Directly below the faucet is the sprinkler the shoots in a 90 degree fashion.The wall with mold is on the wall that is perpendicular to the wall.
PS we have had a great relationship tenant/landlord relationship up to this point. IE always paid rent early, very little maint. needs, improved property, will be returned in very clean condition, and he gave us a glowing recommendation to our new landlord.
Thanks for visiting FatWallet.com. Join for free to remove this ad.
alamo11
Senior Member - 1K
posted: Jun. 25, 2012 @ 1:29p
Paint. Paint it and call it a day
AbbaZabba
Addicted Member
posted: Jun. 25, 2012 @ 1:35p
bleach
elektronic
Senior Member - 1K
posted: Jun. 25, 2012 @ 1:37p
alamo11 said: Paint. Paint it and call it a day
It's different with mold. OP - tell the landlord since they will want to mitigate the problem before it gets worse and they have a big liability on the property.
cheezedawg
Senior Member - 3K
posted: Jun. 25, 2012 @ 1:40p
My personal opinion as a landlord is that this is not something you could be held responsible for. On the contrary, the landlord is opened up to liability for providing unsafe living conditions.
I would tell him that you found a problem that he needs to fix.
qcumber98
Pickled
posted: Jun. 25, 2012 @ 1:59p
If the landlord is such a great guy, then why are you hesitant to contact him about this?
ryryfree
Handsome Member
posted: Jun. 25, 2012 @ 2:15p
He is aware. That is why I posted. He was suggesting the faucet was left on. That makes me think he my try to pass it on to us. We do not use the faucet.
qcumber98
Pickled
posted: Jun. 25, 2012 @ 2:27p
I used to live in a slum that had mold and termites. My lease included a statement about mold and that I was responsible for it. Landlord said to keep the bathroom window open when I took a shower but it didn't make any difference. After two years, they changed owners and the landlord. When I moved out after five years, I got my full security deposit back. Then they renovated all of the buildings.
LordKronos
Senior Member - 1K
posted: Jun. 25, 2012 @ 2:43p
ryryfree said: When moving out of our rental today, we found mold in a closet behind a picture that was in storage. I believe the mold came from the sprinklers being on too much. The owner takes care of the sprinklers and yard, so we do not regulate the flow and it opereats during the night so we do not know how much it waters. My question is what recourse do we have if he tries to charge us for it? We are moving out of state.
Edit Directly below the faucet is the sprinkler the shoots in a 90 degree fashion.The wall with mold is on the wall that is perpendicular to the wall.
PS we have had a great relationship tenant/landlord relationship up to this point. IE always paid rent early, very little maint. needs, improved property, will be returned in very clean condition, and he gave us a glowing recommendation to our new landlord.
I can't even begin to imagine how an outside sprinkler could penetrate the brick and get into the walls in sufficient quantity to cause mold. Possibly if the brick and/or mortar were deteriorated, but in the photos you post they both look superb (by the way, terrible bricking...raked joints are the worst way to do exterior bricking). I'd guess the problem was a combination of high humidity, poor insulation, and no airflow.
ryryfree
Handsome Member
posted: Jun. 25, 2012 @ 2:52p
It is in Utah, not very humid. If you look at the picture of the outside up close it is covered with snails from all of the water. I do not know why just one area would get moldy if it was just poor air flow. It is in a basement, I forgot to mention that.
alamo11
Senior Member - 1K
posted: Jun. 25, 2012 @ 3:47p
alamo11 said: Paint. Paint it and call it a day
It saves the OP the headache.
Revike
Senior Member
posted: Jun. 25, 2012 @ 4:25p
alamo11 said: alamo11 said: Paint. Paint it and call it a day It saves the OP the headache. I don't think the OP should paint it. He said the landlord already knew about it, so painting it would make it look like the OP is accepting responsibility for it.
OP should strongly reaffirm that he never used that faucet and leave it to the landlord to investigate and decide what action to take before re-renting it. It's not certain what caused the mold - it could have been from the faucet running, or from the sprinkler system, or a leak in the roof that directed water down the wall during rain, or underground drainage that directed water to that area - so the landlord cannot conclusively blame OP. Basements are problematic by nature ...
MrGlobe
Member
posted: Jun. 25, 2012 @ 4:30p
I also think it would be pretty odd to have a sprinkler spray enough water through a brick wall the cause mold. Aren't the sprinklers only on for a set amount of time each day? It also seems weird that the sprinkler would only cause mold in that 1 spot.
To me, it looks like the picture was leaning up against the wall, and since it was in a basement closet, moisture built up and sat for quite some time. Additionally, it looks like the mold is ONLY where the picture was.
king0fSpades
Senior Member - 3K
posted: Jun. 25, 2012 @ 4:32p
What is inside the wall. I strongly suspect a leak there. It is not from outside.
SUCKISSTAPLES
FW Historian
posted: Jun. 25, 2012 @ 4:34p
MrGlobe said: I also think it would be pretty odd to have a sprinkler spray enough water through a brick wall the cause mold. Aren't the sprinklers only on for a set amount of time each day? It also seems weird that the sprinkler would only cause mold in that 1 spot.
To me, it looks like the picture was leaning up against the wall, and since it was in a basement closet, moisture built up and sat for quite some time. Additionally, it looks like the mold is ONLY where the picture was. Bingo The pictures sitting there meant there was no airflow to keep the area dry. If the picture wasn't there , no mold would be there
Clean with bleach and call it a day
jerosen
Geeky member
posted: Jun. 25, 2012 @ 6:33p
Your question was what to do if he tries to charge you.
As far as I know the only real option to try and recover security deposit is to sue the landlord in small claims.
kmsandrbs
Senior Member
posted: Jun. 25, 2012 @ 7:39p
SUCKISSTAPLES said: The pictures sitting there meant there was no airflow to keep the area dry. If the picture wasn't there , no mold would be there
Clean with bleach and call it a day
While this is true, it hardly makes it the tenant's fault (unless the landlord specifically said something about not putting things against the wall in the basement). Generally, as a tenant, I expect I can put things up against the wall. That's pretty typical in most houses and does not cause mold.
I agree that you have let the landlord know there is a problem that needs to be fixed, that's it.
And the mold can definitely be caused by exterior issues, at least according to these sites:
All of which specifically talk about exterior sprinklers spraying against the house.
cheezedawg
Senior Member - 3K
posted: Jun. 25, 2012 @ 7:43p
Squirting bleach down there could cause more problems (like ruining the carpet).
christoj879
Senior Member - 1K
posted: Jun. 25, 2012 @ 8:09p
In a basement = damp and something flat against the surface = no airflow. Looks like it was just by the picture. Why not just clean it with some bleach from a spray bottle, and if the wall starts to cave when you touch it tell the LL they've got some sheetrock to replace and a leak to fix?
It doesn't look that bad. I just renovated my office and had to replace entire walls because the studs rotted away from the floor
As a landlord, I would like to learn that problem from my tenant and have it fix properly. Between you moving out and the new tenants moving in would be best time to fix the problem. I don't want to have the hidden mold, it might cause bad health issue for my tenants.
LorenPechtel
Senior Member
posted: Jun. 25, 2012 @ 8:28p
LordKronos said: I can't even begin to imagine how an outside sprinkler could penetrate the brick and get into the walls in sufficient quantity to cause mold. Possibly if the brick and/or mortar were deteriorated, but in the photos you post they both look superb (by the way, terrible bricking...raked joints are the worst way to do exterior bricking). I'd guess the problem was a combination of high humidity, poor insulation, and no airflow.
I don't know how much water it represents going through but our back yard fence is hollow concrete block and yet there are fairly extensive mineral deposits on our side of the fence from where their sprinklers hit their side of the fence.
BingBlangBlaow
Senior Member - 1K
posted: Jun. 25, 2012 @ 9:14p
I do think it could be partly caused by the sprinkler/outside (edit: these materials are porous). OP, where the mold is, is the back of that wall underground (not completely sure from the pictures)? If so, is it not brick, but concrete behind the wall?
Regardless, you've already told him of the problem. Now ask him for your deposit and a new picture frame.
cheapdad00
Senior Member
posted: Jun. 25, 2012 @ 9:27p
Is the area right below that window the level of the soil? If so, it looks like the mold is occuring below grade. You could expect water infiltration if the area has poor drainage (can't tell from the vegetation if the ground slopes away from the house there). The only thing is if there was sufficient water infiltration to cause the mold, then you would expect to see water intrusion into the basement. Is there some sort of interior french drain system in the basement? So the water infiltrates through the foundation below the brick line, stays in the wall enough to cause the mold to form, but any excess water is drained away by an interior french drain? [A bit far fetched and one would think that if there was a way for the water to drain, then it wouldn't be present in high enough concentration to allow the mold to grow].
alamo11
Senior Member - 1K
posted: Jun. 25, 2012 @ 10:25p
Now look whos right? I told you! Paint it.
sherap2
Addicted Member
posted: Jun. 26, 2012 @ 12:19a
the place where i currently live is a total mess with countless tiny mice and black mold growing every where under the walls and even in bathroom.
we caught/killed as many as 4 tiny mouse within 24 hrs and find 1 glued to death almost every 2-3 days. we don't drop or put opened foods on or near the floor and we keep our room clean always. I felt so bad for those tiny mouse crying in pain when stuck to the glue board. The landlord acts nice , talks as if he cares but he is still condescending and does nothing when there is any maintainence problem except only for emergency problems. moving out of this place within few days anyway. Despite his carelessness and condescending attitude, I never acted smart or argued with him.Maybe he thinks we are easy target becos we are asians? I really don't know! Our lease ends in june 30th and he knows we chose not to renew the lease, so the other day, he asks me when we are moving out, i said June 30th, he says you have to be moved out before noon on the 30th or there is a HOLD OVER, asked what that is and replies, one month's lease. he means he will charge us july's rent if we dont move out by 30th. June 30th is the lease expiration date. Don't we have until June 30th 12 am actually?
Pardon my English!
LordB
Senior Member - 2K
posted: Jun. 26, 2012 @ 6:58a
sherap2 said: the place where i currently live is a total mess with countless tiny mice and black mold growing every where under the walls and even in bathroom.
we caught/killed as many as 4 tiny mouse within 24 hrs and find 1 glued to death almost every 2-3 days. we don't drop or put opened foods on or near the floor and we keep our room clean always. I felt so bad for those tiny mouse crying in pain when stuck to the glue board. The landlord acts nice , talks as if he cares but he is still condescending and does nothing when there is any maintainence problem except only for emergency problems. moving out of this place within few days anyway. Despite his carelessness and condescending attitude, I never acted smart or argued with him.Maybe he thinks we are easy target becos we are asians? I really don't know! Our lease ends in june 30th and he knows we chose not to renew the lease, so the other day, he asks me when we are moving out, i said June 30th, he says you have to be moved out before noon on the 30th or there is a HOLD OVER, asked what that is and replies, one month's lease. he means he will charge us july's rent if we dont move out by 30th. June 30th is the lease expiration date. Don't we have until June 30th 12 am actually?
Pardon my English!
The date/time the lease ends depends on the lease, local, state, and even federal laws and regulations. If you want to know read up on the laws in your state as well as your lease. In general the lease will say what the rules are, but those rules can be overridden if there is a law or regulation that trumps the lease which there often are.
Also it likely is illegal for him not to have taken actions against the rodent problem. Again this depends on the laws particular to your area. You really should have been logging this issue with certified letters.
Overall it sounds like the landlord is taking advantage of you. I would bet the landlord tries to keep your security deposit and charge you an extra month rent no matter what you do... Given the language barrier and your apparent timidness it might be hard for you to take a stand.... That said if you go to court I'm betting you have a ton of stories including the mice issue where he is doing illegal things... but if you don't document them then you could be in trouble.
I would take a ton of pictures of the place and it's condition before you move out.
saladdin
Senior Member
posted: Jun. 26, 2012 @ 8:56a
Tell the landlord to pound sand.
apnagirish
Senior Member
posted: Jun. 26, 2012 @ 9:36a
Being a landlord myself, first thing I recommend is to tell your landlord. Don't be defensive as its not your fault - at least yet. try dusting it off and put some bleach. If it is caused by a leak or the sprinkler system, the owner is clearly responsible. Fixing dry wall shouldn't be that big a thing but the root cause has to be eliminated. again that fix is not your problem but make sure you have a dialog with your owner.
In order for mold to grow, it needs water, a food source, the right temperature range, and mold spores. Three of the things you cannot really control; you cannot control where the spores are (they are everywhere), you cannot control the temperature (mold even grows in cold refrigerators but grows best when it's warm), and you cannot control the food source (sheetrock paper). So three of the criteria are met automatically in your case.
The mold is there because water is there.
The black surface mold is more evident because the picture helped to retain the moisture that was seeping in through the drywall. But if you look at your pictures, there is evidence of water infiltration / damage to the left and right of where the picture was resting. (see image) (Edit: It's a bit easier to see the pinkish/yellowish "bloom" on the original, unresized images)
Behind that drywall is most likely a huge black mess of mold; on the back of the drywall and on the wood studs. You didn't cause the damage, so you shouldn't be concerned about paying for the damage. That's the landlords responsibility. Hopefully the landlord will actually seek out the source of the water infiltration (improper grade, dense vegetation too near the house, improper gutters, etc) and fix the source of the problem and not just "paint it".
The landlord should actually be appreciative that the issue was discovered during a move out; now he has time to fix the issue without affecting the tenants.
NotSoHard
Senior Member
posted: Jun. 26, 2012 @ 4:09p
SUCKISSTAPLES said: MrGlobe said: I also think it would be pretty odd to have a sprinkler spray enough water through a brick wall the cause mold. Aren't the sprinklers only on for a set amount of time each day? It also seems weird that the sprinkler would only cause mold in that 1 spot.
To me, it looks like the picture was leaning up against the wall, and since it was in a basement closet, moisture built up and sat for quite some time. Additionally, it looks like the mold is ONLY where the picture was. Bingo The pictures sitting there meant there was no airflow to keep the area dry. If the picture wasn't there , no mold would be there
Clean with bleach and call it a day
Should I expect to find mold behind any pictures I have hanging on the wall in my lower level of which half is below grade?
The picture helped keep the area moist due to lack of airflow, but the moisture didn't build up from the inside of the home. There is evidence of moisture inside the wall. Just look at the wall to the left of where the picture was sitting; there is staining from water infiltration inside the wall. Since it is below grade, the moisture is most likely coming in from the outside. Water doesn't typically get in through bricks, but it does get in through the mortar joints and it surely gets in through unsealed cinderblock below grade. Even if it's poured cement, if it isn't sealed, it will leak.
With all that vegetation (the two trees growin there need to be removed), it's no wonder that the ground is holding a lot of water. The vegetation helps prevent evaporation. If the sprinkler is wetting the brick, the water is running down the wall and soaking the ground. That kind of defeats the purpose of the gutters.
jnheinz
Senior Member - 1K
posted: Jun. 27, 2012 @ 8:17a
king0fSpades said: What is inside the wall. I strongly suspect a leak there. It is not from outside.
I was waiting for someone to say this.. It's probably a leak behind the brick near the water spigot. Some idiot probably jerked the hell out of it a few years ago trying to get their hose 6 extra inches and busted the soldered joints.
Tell him to rip up that wall and find the source.. Stop blaming you for leaving it on.
And yes, the first thing I noticed was those snails.. Obviously it is VERY damp down there. There are probably slugs too. It may be a crack in the foundation as well.
jnheinz
Senior Member - 1K
posted: Jun. 27, 2012 @ 8:19a
Oh.. how'd it go? I missed the walk-through last night post.
Bagofchips
Senior Member - 2K
posted: Jun. 27, 2012 @ 4:51p
I could interpret some of the pictures suggesting prior painting / repair attempts w/ a different color white. Some of the mold looks below topcoats of more-recent painting.
ryryfree
Handsome Member
posted: Jun. 28, 2012 @ 12:32a
Well, he again tried to suggest it was due to a faucet being left on, but his property manager suggested the sprinkled theory was much more accurate. He said the wall needs torn out. They did suggest some of the deposit will be kept, but did not specify what it was for. I asked for an itemized document with the refund check. So the story continues.
LordB
Senior Member - 2K
posted: Jun. 28, 2012 @ 2:03p
ryryfree said: Well, he again tried to suggest it was due to a faucet being left on, but his property manager suggested the sprinkled theory was much more accurate. He said the wall needs torn out. They did suggest some of the deposit will be kept, but did not specify what it was for. I asked for an itemized document with the refund check. So the story continues.
I would start dropping hints about a mold allergy and needing to go see the doctor about it and about landlord negligence on preventing mold.
I bet that would end any talk of not getting the full deposit back.
solarUS
Senior Member - 1K
posted: Jun. 28, 2012 @ 2:10p
sometimes it's nice to be a renter.
these "paint it" posts are idiotic. moving the picture will do nothing for the [probably sizable amount of] mold growth behind the wall. you have to eliminate the water source and remove all moldy materials. i think cause is either:
> an overactive sprinkler pounding the brick wall and either a) wicking through the mortar, or b) entering the wall thru an unsealed faucet hole > the (unbroken) faucet itself spraying or even leaking water behind the wall via an unsealed hole > a busted faucet pipe in the wall between bricks and drywall
honestly, with a little investigation this should be easy for landlord to assess and rectify, and that drywall HAS to be removed anyway. just turn everything on as it normally is and observe from the inside (once insulation removed). if nothing is seen dripping after a few minutes of faucet-on, sprinkler-on, then the "wicking" scenario is likely....which is easily solved by moving the sprinkler. spray bleach on studs a few times, replace insulation, replace ALL drywall in vicinity, then float mud, paint, replace trim.
Skipping 2 Messages...
ryryfree
Handsome Member
posted: Jul. 28, 2012 @ 12:40p
Well I did not get dinged for the mold, but he did stiff me around $150 for other stuff. I am glad he did not try to pawn the mold on us though.
Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.
Members of our community may attach files to a post in accordance with the User Agreement. FatWallet is not responsible for the content, accuracy, completeness or validity of any information contained in any attached file. Files have *not* been scanned for viruses. Be especially wary of Excel files which may contain malicious content.
One-time set up
Avoid the hassle of entering your information every time you buy.
•
Instant Cash Back tracking
Since we complete the purchase, we can credit your Cash Back immediately.
•
Buy with just two clicks
One click begins checkout and another confirms your purchase.
Once set up, making a purchase with FW checkout is a breeze. FatWallet Checkout confirms the after-tax
price plus shipping and, after you confirm, completes your purchase for you.
Shopping
Earn Cash Back while you shop - just 3 simple steps.
1. Sign Up so we know who to pay! (It's FREE.)
2. Shop through FatWallet for deals from your favorite stores. Your online purchases earn Cash Back that builds in your FatWallet account.
3. Get Paid by requesting a payment via check or PayPal.
FatWallet coupons help you save more when shopping online. Use our Coupons Search to browse coupons and offers from thousands of stores, gathered into one convenient location.
Forums
As part of our FatWallet Community, you can share deals with almost a million shoppers in our forums. Forum content is generated by consumers for consumers. Share deals, money-saving tips, and more. It's FREE, fun, and addicting.
Support
Our customer experience team is here around the clock - real people ready to assist.