Edit

Forums
Finance

Financial Myths and Urban Legends Thread - Post Yours Here! Archived From: Finance

  • tweet this
  • Post to Facebook
  • Text Only
  • Search this Topic »
  • Classic
alert mods    

LostInRebates said:

<< SIS
Your MYTH#1 is included as one of the things to do by an article on the MSN website.
6 steps to building great credit by Liz Pulliam Weston
http://moneycentral.msn.com/content/Banking/Yourcreditrating/P38048.asp
I wanted to mention it in this thread and see what you and others think about it.
>>

Taking out a loan IS a way to build credit, but its the most foolish way, and should only be attempted if no other way works for you.

Why pay interest on money you dont need (and may be tempted to spend) when you can just as easily get gas/retail credit cards which dont cost a thing?

I wouldnt recomend a secured credit card, but even those would likely cost less than the cost of taking out a high interest rate personal loan!

Please note the MSN article made that suggestion only as a way to "start" having credit if you have none. If you can get gas/store /credit cards, on time payment of those accounts will accomplish the same goal at less/no cost.


alert mods    

MYTH: A multi-level marketing scheme can be a legitimate business.

FACT: Legitimate businesses don't recruit distributors with the prospect of selling to other distributors. Instead, they talk about the prospect of selling to retail customers.


alert mods    

SUCKISSTAPLES said:

<< Taking out a loan IS a way to build credit, but its the most foolish way, and should only be attempted if no other way works for you. >>

I understand your point SIS, but there is an exception to your rule. My very first credit was in the form of a '90 days same as cash' for area rugs to furnish my very first apartment with. It was through a carpet chain store and they had a special financing deal going on at the time. I bought about $350 worth of merchandise on credit. They financed me through Beneficial at the time. I paid it off in the 90 days and had all the finance charges refunded to me. It was a pretty painless way to get started with a credit rating and it's been pretty easy ever since as a result.


alert mods    

I agree with Zender. Our first loan back in the early years was a $500 bank loan on our savings. Sure we paid the extra 2% interest but since then we've never been denied credit. Prior, we were turned down for a $75 sofa from JCPenneys (dang! you never forget these rejections)


alert mods    

MYTH: We're from the government and we're here to help.
FACT: RUUUUUUUUUUUN!!!!!!


alert mods    

tooshy said:

<< Prior, we were turned down for a $75 sofa from JCPenneys (dang! you never forget these rejections) >>


Rejections could sometimes be due to some wrong info store people enter in.My wife few years back ,was denied Old Navy credit card and we went and tried on the following day and she was accepted.We think person at counter the day before, might have entered some wrong info.

Of all,best way to build credit is to get store cards.If you patiently use and pay for six months, you will start getting offers for regular credit cards.


alert mods    

could you please share with us that id-locator service please


alert mods    

MyTwoSense said:

<< Myth
Quality and Price are explicitly related.

It never ceases to amaze me how many people will pay more for something because they believe that this one factor means they're getting a better product.
>>


On the other hand, an unusually accurate truism:

Good.
Fast.
Cheap.

Pick any two.


alert mods    

Very good thread!

Myth -
FW can save you ton of money!
Due to FW you end up spending more money!

Truth -
FW helps you to find the best value for your money. It's you who have to decide whether to spend more money or not.


alert mods    

MYTH: "I met with an "AMEX FINANCIAL ADVISOR" who recommended I invest into several AMEX products such as insurance, annuities, etc, and it seems like a good deal".

FACT: While AMEX generally offers many excellent products, DO NOT, I repeat DO NOT, use their FInancial Advisors.

First of all, these people are merely insurance salespeople, and most do NOT have any financial background (they will hire anyone). They are forced to recommend inappropriate products to earn their living, the products are NOT competitive, and you usually need to pay several hundred dollars for a "financial plan". There are several threads on the AMEX Financial Advisor scam here:

http://www.fatwallet.com/forums/messageview.cfm?catid=52&threadid=186605&highlight_key=y&keyword1=advisor

http://www.fatwallet.com/forums/messageview.cfm?catid=52&threadid=210159&highlight_key=y&keyword2=AMEX


alert mods    

How about... 'paying extra on your mortgage is the best investment.'

Considering current interest rates, you may well be better off putting that extra money into an index fund in the long run. (And I suppose the mortgage interest being tax deductible is a nice touch, too!)

And while not a myth, the one thing that kills me is how people just look at the payment when it comes to a car or house loan... especially on mortgages, where I've seen absolutely ungodly closing costs rolled into the principal, only to have people re-fi because of the 'lower payment'...


alert mods    

Sis said
<< MYTH: "I met with an "AMEX FINANCIAL ADVISOR" who recommended I invest into several AMEX products such as insurance, annuities, etc, and it seems like a good deal".

FACT: While AMEX generally offers many excellent products, DO NOT, I repeat DO NOT, use their FInancial Advisors.

First of all, these people are merely insurance salespeople, and most do NOT have any financial background (they will hire anyone). They are forced to recommend inappropriate products to earn their living, the products are NOT competitive, and you usually need to pay several hundred dollars for a "financial plan". There are several threads on the AMEX Financial Advisor scam here:

http://www.fatwallet.com/forums/messageview.cfm?catid=52&threadid=186605&highlight_key=y&keyword1=advisor

http://www.fatwallet.com/forums/messageview.cfm?catid=52&threadid=210159&highlight_key=y&keyword2=AMEX
>>

You are 110% correct Sis. I know a finance professor, who also coaches CFA's and grades certified financia advisors tests, who says that AMEX advisors are the worst in the field. I met one through Costco and found out how bad they are. Stay away from them


alert mods    

I especially agree with #27


alert mods    

The reply on geeting credit prompted me to remeber another experience, that I and others have found for $300 + purchases.

Myth 90 days same as cash is the best deal

Fact I have often gotten a better price by using cash upfront, anywhere from 10 - 25%. When you pull out the cash and put it on the counter and say this is all I am willing to pay, you will likely get the price at better than the 90 days no financing


alert mods    

dsmking said:

<< Sis said
<< MYTH: "I met with an "AMEX FINANCIAL ADVISOR" who recommended I invest into several AMEX products such as insurance, annuities, etc, and it seems like a good deal".

FACT: While AMEX generally offers many excellent products, DO NOT, I repeat DO NOT, use their FInancial Advisors.

First of all, these people are merely insurance salespeople, and most do NOT have any financial background (they will hire anyone). They are forced to recommend inappropriate products to earn their living, the products are NOT competitive, and you usually need to pay several hundred dollars for a "financial plan". There are several threads on the AMEX Financial Advisor scam here:

http://www.fatwallet.com/forums/messageview.cfm?catid=52&threadid=186605&highlight_key=y&keyword1=advisor

http://www.fatwallet.com/forums/messageview.cfm?catid=52&threadid=210159&highlight_key=y&keyword2=AMEX
>>

You are 110% correct Sis. I know a finance professor, who also coaches CFA's and grades certified financia advisors tests, who says that AMEX advisors are the worst in the field. I met one through Costco and found out how bad they are. Stay away from them
>>


I'll back that up 120%. I was recruited by CitiGroup to be an "Financial Advisor". I went to their interview and talked with them...it's basically telemarketing. You met with people to discuss their finances and try to get them to come in and buy some services or crap they don't need. I turned down the job ASAP, even though they pay decent (all commission BTW).


alert mods    

AWESOME THREAD!

A few suggested additions, from my own pet peeves (and sad personal experience):

MYTH: "Credit insurance" and "credit protector" programs are a good deal.
FACT: I've never seen one of these policies that's worth the cost. They often promise to pay off your debts if you die, get sick, lose your job or suffer other misfortune - but they're usually riddled with exclusions and very hard to collect on. Even when they work, you have to realize that you're actually paying to protect your creditor - not yourself. (Even worse, you often end up paying finance charges on them, which means you're paying your creditor for the privilege of paying your creditor to protect ... your creditor.) These policies are often hidden in loans and credit-card agreements, but the Federal Trade Commission says it's illegal to deny you credit based on your unwillingness to buy an optional credit-insurance policy.

MYTH: I can save money by paying to join a discount club.
FACT: The benefits of these clubs range from questionable (Sams, Costco, BJs, etc.) to imaginary (numerous scam outfits) - For the "real" clubs, the bottom line is that you have to know how much you plan to buy and in what quantities, and how much those items generally cost. Warehouse clubs are usually only a good deal if you plan to buy in large quantities and have comparison-shopped the items you're likely to buy. Ask for a free membership to look around and take notes. (I found many items selling in multi-packs at Sam's - that were cheaper in singles at the Wal-Mart next door.) For any other clubs, be very careful and Google them before you join or give them any info. Almost all of them are scams.


alert mods    

Wonderful thread.
Thanks, SIS!!


alert mods    

randomizzer said:

<< The reply on geeting credit prompted me to remeber another experience, that I and others have found for $300 + purchases.

Myth 90 days same as cash is the best deal

Fact I have often gotten a better price by using cash upfront, anywhere from 10 - 25%. When you pull out the cash and put it on the counter and say this is all I am willing to pay, you will likely get the price at better than the 90 days no financing
>>

NOT ALWAYS FACT... Many retailers get a "commission" for every credit card application they accept. And that commission at times could be more than any discount they could give you for paying cash. A retailer will almost ALWAYS give you a better deal if you pay cash over using a standard credit card (because of their CC fees). But opening new accounts is pure profit for retailers.


alert mods    

Myth: Purchasing Title Insurance on my home will protect me from any future disputes over my property/land (such as easement problems, not knowing about buried pipelines, etc.)

Fact: Most title insurance policies are written to protect the bank not the homeowner. If you purchase standard title insurance and later find out you have a problem with your property, the title insurance company will do nothing for you. Most title insurance is a scam and unless you get your own policy, in your name, not the bank's, they will tell you "tough luck" when you need to make a claim. They will also have specific requests in order to be able to file claims (such as needing a full legal survey (which is not required in many states) before insurance is purchased, etc.) so you need to check this out as well and read all the fine print. They will do almost everything to keep from paying a claim if there is a problem. No wonder title insurance was rated as one of the most profitable businesses in the US. They pay almost no claims because there are so many exclusions, etc.


alert mods    

hotandhumid noted:

<< Fact: Most title insurance policies are written to protect the bank not the homeowner. If you purchase standard title insurance and later find out you have a problem with your property, the title insurance company will do nothing for you. >>

Excellent point. Is anyone here particularly knowledgeable about how to intelligently shop for title insurance, particularly the "Extended" policies which (in theory) provide somewhat more protection for the buyer?


 Close

Sign Me In
Nickname: 
Password: 
Remember My Login Information:

Forget your login information?

Not Already A Member?
Sign Up Now!



Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.


While FatWallet makes every effort to post correct information, offers are subject to change without notice.
Some exclusions may apply based upon merchant policies.
© 1999-2009