|
-
-
GreedyBumps
- Ancient Member
rated:
posted: Jul. 12, 2004 @ 9:35a
MBNA. I had a 19,000 MasterCard with them. They closed it without notice when I applied for Merrill Lynch (got a $20,000 CL). When I called them to inquire as to why they have closed the account without at least talking to me (maybe I wanted to split the CL between the two - while I as actually hoping to combine the CLs) they did not have a good answer - "do you want the card or not?". |
-
-
EugeneV
- Ancient Member
rated:
posted: Jul. 12, 2004 @ 4:43p
Penguinator said:Bank One closed my $15K VISA charge card after I suddenly paid it down to 0 when my 0% balance transfer expired. They said "too much credit elsewhere, balances too high, etc." All it was is lots of 0% interest balances of about $80K total.
Is having "too much credit elsewhere" a legitimate reason to lower your CL??
Perhaps it may be worth it to lower your CL on unused cards (that were used once for 0% BT and have been useless since)? |
-
-
citifan
- Senior Member
rated:
posted: Jul. 13, 2004 @ 9:13a
Citibank bumped my due date to 4 days earlier and according to the CSR, shortened my billing cycle. I only noticed when my due date changed from the 17th to the 13th. When I asked why, he told me it was because I "pay my balance in full every month, and they want to shorten the time I can borrow money, interest free."
He changed it back and said it wouldn't change again. |
-
-
genenpet
- Frivolous Member
rated:
posted: Aug. 2, 2004 @ 5:02p
Fusa/BankOne , Rate from 10.99 -> 23.99 for outstanding balances on other cards. They hit the report on a day in which a bal transfer was shown on one card and not yet credited to the other, so it was a really strong debt spike... |
-
-
SUCKISSTAPLES
- Charter Member
rated:
posted: Aug. 2, 2004 @ 11:48p
GreedyBumps said:MBNA. I had a 19,000 MasterCard with them. They closed it without notice when I applied for Merrill Lynch (got a $20,000 CL). When I called them to inquire as to why they have closed the account without at least talking to me (maybe I wanted to split the CL between the two - while I as actually hoping to combine the CLs) they did not have a good answer - "do you want the card or not?".
Wow, closing the line w/o notice is harsh. When I applied for the Barnes and Noble MBNA card (my 3rd MBNA card) they gave me a $5k limit and reduced the credit line of one of the other cards by $5k. Then, 6 months later, they bumped that reduced credit line by 9k! And there was NO USAGE of the card! |
-
-
bryanboy
- Member
rated:
posted: Aug. 10, 2004 @ 9:46a
I have this thing about balance shuffling -- you know... shuffling around your balances each and every month to different creditors depending on the statement closing date so your credit reports reflect a <10% utilization.
National City closed my $15K Visa yesterday because of a balance transfer mishap with USAA.
I requested USAA about 2 weeks ago to transfer my $4K national city balance. The next day, I left my card at a gas station and reported it as lost. I specifically asked USAA about this and they said "the balance transfer will be cancelled due to the fact that it hasn't been processed yet and once the system asks for authorization on the old card, it will be declined." I even asked whether they can put it on the new card and they said I can only do it ONCE I RECEIVED THE REPLACEMENT CARD.
Fine, I thought.
So I paid $4K to National City out of my checking account.
Over the weekend/Saturday when checking my balances with National City, low and behold I have a -$4K credit balance.
The USAA balance transfer got processed -- so what I did was immediately transferred the $4K back from National City to USAA online.
Then yesterday when I called National City customer service to verify whether it went thru, they transferred me to their security department who told me my account has been permanently closed to due suspicious and high-risk activity.
I explained the balance transfer mishap and the lady said the BT back to USAA won't get processed and the funds will be on hold until they finish their investigation.
I literally choked over the phone -- I asked what was I supposed to do when I now owe it to USAA? The rude rep said I'm pretty much on my own.
I called National City Executive Resolutions Center/higher-ups/ivory tower yesterday and am dealing with a representative there. She will get back to me in the next few days. I also wrote a letter to USAA complaining the misleading information the rep told me.
National City is my FIRST credit card/tradeline. I got this almost 2 and a half years ago.
I started from a $500 unsecured card, then to $1K, $1.5K, $3K, $5K, $8K and just 2 months ago, $15K.
I have an impeccable history with them -- no lates, always made LARGE payments. There's also nothing derogatory on my credit. I noticed they pulled a copy of my transunion credit report yesterday as well.
At this point I'm still terribly shocked and frustrated. |
Message edited by: bryanboy on 2004-08-10 09:47:06
-
-
SoBeyondTheNorm
- Greedy Member
rated:
posted: Aug. 21, 2004 @ 2:06p
MarkM said:I've had MANY accounts close after being dormant a long time. I don't think it's even worth bothering to list those.
Anyone else who's had this happen? I have some cards I haven't used in a while and I don't want to lose history due to account closed. I'm just wondering what the least time I can get by without use. |
-
-
civad
- Broke Member
rated:
posted: Aug. 21, 2004 @ 2:57p
MBNA- reduced Credit limit from $ 6500 to $ 5000 due to "non-use"
Discover Card - Reduced limit from $ 3500 to $ 2000 due to my BT's to other CC's.
I cancelled the Discover card, only to have them calling me every now and then asking me to renew. |
-
-
kaiotes
- Shopaholic Member
rated:
posted: Aug. 21, 2004 @ 9:32p
just make a charge of like a dollar at your fav gas station every say 4 months and imo you should be OK.
SoBeyondTheNorm said:MarkM said:I've had MANY accounts close after being dormant a long time. I don't think it's even worth bothering to list those.
Anyone else who's had this happen? I have some cards I haven't used in a while and I don't want to lose history due to account closed. I'm just wondering what the least time I can get by without use. |
-
-
EugeneV
- Ancient Member
rated:
posted: Aug. 23, 2004 @ 12:17p
civad said:Discover Card - Reduced limit from $ 3500 to $ 2000 due to my BT's to other CC's.
How would they know about your BTs? To them it appears as payment... |
-
-
bibbub
- Member
rated:
posted: Sep. 7, 2004 @ 11:16p
co-ask.
EugeneV said:civad said:Discover Card - Reduced limit from $ 3500 to $ 2000 due to my BT's to other CC's. How would they know about your BTs? To them it appears as payment... |
-
-
bibbub
- Member
rated:
posted: Sep. 7, 2004 @ 11:20p
I used to have a target store card. The card was closed by the issuer because of no activity. I later called. They said they will close it if there is no activity in three years. Does it negatively affect my credit score?
Chase card increase my APR 10.99% to 23.24% before the end of the 0% APR. And, that's the only card I carry a balance. Gee.... I am not terribly concerned because it doesn't really affect my credit score, though sort of insulting to me. |
-
-
xoneinax
- Senior Member - 5K
rated:
posted: Sep. 7, 2004 @ 11:52p
bibbub said:Chase card increase my APR 10.99% to 23.24% before the end of the 0% APRDid you ask why ? |
-
-
bibbub
- Member
rated:
posted: Sep. 7, 2004 @ 11:57p
xoneinax said:bibbub said:Chase card increase my APR 10.99% to 23.24% before the end of the 0% APRDid you ask why ?
Yes I asked. They said they pull out my credit report saw that my balance is high. But that's the only card I carry balance, and I have another card having a couple of thousands but I always paid in full. |
-
-
alwaysTempted
- Senior Member
rated:
posted: Nov. 12, 2004 @ 11:59a
Bank One.
I noticed a hard inquiry on my account. I called to ask why. They said my account had come up for review, and during that review, decided to close it based on because I had "$230k credit available elsewhere" and "too many inquiries" (6 on EXP in the last 2 months, 10 in the last year....19 overall on EXP in the last 2 years).
Credit analyst kept asking over & over why I needed so many cards. I explained that each issuer had different promotions, different reasons, yada yada. She said that only way they'd re-open my account is if I closed some of my cards.
Interestingly, I do have approx $30k in 0% balances (all < 50%) ... when I pointed out that all my balances were < 50%, she specifically said "no, your balances are fine, we dont care about that."
other background: never late on anything, credit scores all in the 700s |
-
-
mbaker4096
- Senior Member - 1K
rated:
posted: Nov. 12, 2004 @ 3:44p
That's too bad. Sounds like Bank One's cleaning house as part of the merger process.
We'll see if my number comes up. Currently I'm down to $104-106K reporting as current balances on my CCs. $260K in available credit, or more if they decide to include my $145K HELOC.
Been lucky and dodged the bullets so far. Hoping my luck continues.
BTW - Did you have an outstanding balance, 0% or otherwise, on the card they reviewed and closed? |
Message edited by: mbaker4096 on 2004-11-12 15:44:39
-
-
hdpr14
- Member
rated:
posted: Nov. 15, 2004 @ 2:12p
Back in June, Citi lowered my limits on my two cards from $19,500 and $4,500 to $1000 each, I learned this the hard way when I was declined a charge. I had just paid both of these lines to 0. My usage was to use them and pay them off monthly, however I carried a balance waiting for a customer to pay me. The balance followed by the payment was the red flag. They then felt I was a risk. I did have them restored, but it took a call to the Presidents office and a copy of my current report showing that the rest of my cards were not maxxed out. I faxed a current report, of my choosing, instead of them pulling a hard. HTH HD |
-
-
alwaysTempted
- Senior Member
rated:
posted: Nov. 15, 2004 @ 2:32p
mbaker4096 said: BTW - Did you have an outstanding balance, 0% or otherwise, on the card they reviewed and closed?
Nope, the card was only open for like 4 months and I had never even used it. It was actually on my list of cards that I had recently opened, never used, and was going to use in case they were wondering why there was no activity after opening it.
The frustrating part about this situation is that their #1 concern seemed to be the inquiries, but of the 6 inquiries I have on EXP in the last 6 months, they are responsible for THREE of them! One when I initially applied for the account, another for address verification (had to send in utility bill showing my address) as part of application process, and then the third one which flagged my account for review + closure. Seems a bit hypocritical to complain when they are the #1 offender. |
Close
|
|
 |
 |
Not Already A Member?
Sign Up Now!
|
|
Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.
|
|