Edit

Forums
Finance

I'm going to startup a Roth IRA - which company to go with? Schwab? Vanguard? Archived From: Finance

  • tweet this
  • Post to Facebook
  • Text Only
  • Search this Topic »
  • Classic
  • Go to Page :
  • 12 3 4
alert mods    

Bedrocked:

Funds have minimums, even if they are from the same family. So, for every Fidelity fund u buy, u have to shell out $2500 as the minimum. However, you can add the 500 u have to the fund that u bought recently, since most of them require a minimum additional investment of $100 or $200 only


alert mods    

chewychevy said:Vanguard charges 10 dollar fee a year if you keep less than 5g's in your retirement account. So all you have to do is max out your Roth Ira this year at 3gs (not today the 31st as they may charge you 10 dollars). Then anytime after April 15th add in the additional 2gs before the end of the year. You skip out on the 10 dollar fee a year (which I assume they charge at the end of the year).

A


You assume wrong, they will assess it in June.


alert mods    

chewychevy said:Any combination of money before the April 15th and afterwards but before December 31st totalling 5gs should allow you to avoid the fee.
You can invest 2005 Roth IRA contributions before April 15.


alert mods    

taylor said:chewychevy said:Any combination of money before the April 15th and afterwards but before December 31st totalling 5gs should allow you to avoid the fee.
You can invest 2005 Roth IRA contributions before April 15.


Isn't April 15 deadline for 2004 and not 2005?


alert mods    

April 15th(2005) is the latest date you can add to your 2004 contributions of your IRA.

Jan 1st(2005), is the first day ou can add to your 2005 contributions.


alert mods    

How about ameritrade? There's no fee to open a roth IRA account or to maintain it. However, if you want to buy stocks, then there's a transaction fee.


alert mods    

I have 3000 in hand to try to figure out where to invest. After doing research on FW, I know a couple of companies.Please rank these bank to open Roth IRA: Schwab, Vanguard, Fidelity, Scottrade, Ameritrade. I like Scottrade and Fidelity because they have branches near my home. I can ask them if I have a question, I'm not good for investmeant(not my mojor). Also, I can max out by cash because I dont want to pay wire transfer of my CU, $25 per transaction. Any comments and advises are greatly appreciated. It's time to rush now, I just figure out this website and feel interest to start keeping Roth IRA. Again, thank you for your help.


alert mods    

I'm a Scottrade owner about to jump ship to Brownco. Better fees for mutual funds along with a longstanding brokerage that hasn't messed with anything since I've first started to take notice of them (2001 or so). Also great margin rates, and Scottrade is still assessing fees on Oakmark and Matthews Asian funds even though I'm like 99% sure they're supposed to be NTF.

BROWNCO!


alert mods    

thanks boden11...
I dont want to pay wire transfer, Brownco doesnt have any local office. How come I can open an account. They charge me $25 per transaction.


alert mods    

anyone considered firstrade? They seem to have very little fees with mutual funds investing compared to other brokers.

Any comments?

Need to roll mine over and start one for the wife before 4/15.


alert mods    

Hi there, I need a comment from you before I call the broker.
Okie, I want to open Roth IRA in Scottrade with $1000. I'm a fulltime student last year(until December2004) and get all Financial Aids, graduated after that. I have no job now, unemployment. So, what's distribution year is best for me 2004 or 2005. I'm afraid I got a trouble for 2004 and I already filled out Tax form.
thank you for your help.


alert mods    

I need help on this too...
Vanguard charges $10.00 fee on each fund unless if your fund is below 5K or if your combined funds are under 50K. Anybody knows how much Fidelity charge for maintaining several funds ? I called Fidelity and asked a representative, he didn't answer me exactly. I am not sure about Schwab either. Any info will be greatly appreciated.


alert mods    

If you have no idea what you are doing - go talk to a broker. As an financial consultant with a major brokerage firm I can say that the costs associated with dealing with a pro on this stuff really can be worth it for a lot of people.

Just take a look at what they recommend and do it yourself if you want to screw them...but seriously I think if you have no investment experience have someone else that you feel you can trust working with you on it.

Good luck to you - and dont bother with index funds...a good mutual fund manager really shines in down / sideways markets - which I think we're heading into.

Enjoy


alert mods    

SeriusBlack said:If your goal is to buy into a good (individual) stock, or roll your IRA/401(k) into a good investment stock, try Bank of New York's low, low fee on General Electric stock. When I direct rollover my 401(k), it's all going into GE Stock. This is one of the last companies you could expect to earn less than 8-10% return each year.


Its advice like this that really makes me glad that I am able to help people in what I do for a living. geeze /slap


alert mods    

fishzebby said:I need help on this too...
Vanguard charges $10.00 fee on each fund unless if your fund is below 5K or if your combined funds are under 50K. Anybody knows how much Fidelity charge for maintaining several funds ? I called Fidelity and asked a representative, he didn't answer me exactly. I am not sure about Schwab either. Any info will be greatly appreciated.
Here's a direct quote from a Fidelity chat session:

"Our IRA accounts have no annual maintenance fee. Fidelity mutual funds with a balance below $2,000 on the valuation date (typically second Friday in November) are charged a $12 low balance fee."

But a no-fee IRA from some companies can cost more than an IRA with a $10-20 annual fee from a low-cost company like Vanguard.


alert mods    

If your goal is to buy into a good (individual) stock, or roll your IRA/401(k) into a good investment stock, try Bank of New York's low, low fee on General Electric stock. When I direct rollover my 401(k), it's all going into GE Stock. This is one of the last companies you could expect to earn less than 8-10% return each year.

Maybe with play money on the side, but your retirement account???? You gotta be kidding me!


alert mods    

bNeta86 said:If you have no idea what you are doing - go talk to a broker. As an financial consultant with a major brokerage firm I can say that the costs associated with dealing with a pro on this stuff really can be worth it for a lot of people.But what if the person chooses the wrong broker, such as the one in my city who once went bankrupt and who likes to sell variable annuities inside IRAs? Both the good and bad ones often sound the same to us laymen.

With only a couple of weeks left to make 2004 contributions to an IRA, I think that any undecided person shouldn't rush into anything that could turn out to be a mistake but just put the contribution into a money market fund IRA at a fund company that charges almost nothing in account maintenance or termination fees.


alert mods    

But what if the person chooses the wrong broker

Which is very easy to do.


alert mods    

i found this out the hard way. something to consider is that vanguard seems to have lower initial buy-ins for funds, even with some non vanguard funds. i believe fidelity is $2500 minimum for any fund. so if you're just starting out vanguard allows you the ability to buy more funds with your max 2004/2005 contributions. theoretically if you just started in 2004 and you max last year and this year you could buy a max of 7 funds with vanguard and only 2 with fidelity.


alert mods    

Is there really an advantage of going with the bigger brokers when you can go w/ a smaller one with less fees? They're both SIPC protected. Assuming you're making the investment decisions yourself.


 Close

Sign Me In
Nickname: 
Password: 
Remember My Login Information:

Forget your login information?

Not Already A Member?
Sign Up Now!



Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.


While FatWallet makes every effort to post correct information, offers are subject to change without notice.
Some exclusions may apply based upon merchant policies.
© 1999-2009