• Go to page :
  • 1 234
  • Text Only

Does anyone have experience with Western Financial bank before, they seems to have pretty good rate at 3% (at least until 6/1/2005). Any opinion?

3/2/05 update: They change their rate couple days ago from 3.00% to 3.25% now, and the rate guarentee to end of 2005.



From what I've been reading - you are better off with www.emigrant-direct.com - no minimums, and the same 3%

~Bill


I had WFB about 2 yrs back and they were good in all aspects.


Be forewarned about ED... the online portion of this bank went live in Dec 2004 (or roughly that time), and at times, they seem very unprofessional. Their pages look hokey and many features do not work.

I have been waiting since Friday morning for a password reset. The online password form did not work, so I called the CSR and was told to sent an email to emigrant@emigrantdirect.com. No reply since. Very hokey!


OP, please change your title to reflect that this thread is about Western Financial bank's 3.00% Online Money Market account as there are plenty of Money Market accounts out there that are not as interesting as this one!

edit: I added this thread to the rate thread.


Western Financial Bank is at 3.25!? I'm hesitant to move my ING account over to Emigrant because I didn't like their website / service. But 3.25 might be too good to pass up, the 5k min is not too bad!

http://www.wfb.com/Personal_Banking/Checking_and_Savings/savings_rates.htm

Anyone have any experience with them?


These are the terms for the account now paying 3.25% - 'guaranteed' til end of 2005

Online Money Market Account &
Online Money Market Plus Account

Rate information - Your interest rate and annual percentage yield may
change. At our discretion, we may change the interest rate on your
account daily.
Interest rate tiers -
$0 - $4,999.99
$5,000 - $9,999.99
$10,000 - $24,999.99
$25,000 - $49,999.99
$50,000 - $74,999.99
$75,000 +
We reserve the right to change both the number of tiers and the dollar
amount of each threshold. The interest rate may be the same in all tiers.
Compounding and crediting frequency - Interest is compounded
daily and credited to your account every month at month-end.
Interest computation method - We use the daily balance method
to calculate the interest on your account. This method applies a daily
periodic rate to principal and earned interest in the account each day.
******Effect of closing an account - If you close your account before
interest is credited, you will not receive the accrued interest since the
previous month-end.*******
Minimum balance to open the account - $5,000.00.
Statement frequency - Statements are issued at quarter-end. If you
have electronic funds transfer activity, statements are issued at month-end.
Accrual of interest on non-cash deposits - Interest begins to
accrue no later than the business day we receive credit for the deposit
of non-cash items (for example, checks). Internet initiated ACH deposits
begin earning interest on the day the deposit is credited to the account.
Transaction limitations - You may make six transfers from your
account per monthly statement cycle, but only three may be payments
by check, draft, point of sale, or similar order to third parties. There is
no limit to the number of withdrawals in person, by mail, or at a
Western Financial Bank ATM.
Fees - An excess withdrawal fee will be charged for each transaction in
excess of the stated transaction limitations. Account may be subject to
closure. Refer to the Personal Banking Fee Schedule for fees associated
with excess withdrawals.
Non-proprietary ATM transactions - Non-proprietary ATM
transaction fees will not be assessed on this account by Western
Financial Bank.This does not include surcharges that may be assessed
by the company or institution owning the ATM/terminals.
Other restrictions - This account is only available online through
www.wfb.com. A fee will be charged for in-branch transactions.
Refer to the Personal Banking Fee Schedule for fees associated with
in-branch transactions.
Closing an account - Written authorization bearing an original
signature from a signer(s) on the account must be received by us in
order to close your account. Upon receipt of such authorization, we
will close your account, issue a check payable to the named owner(s)
of the account, and mail the check to the address of record.


My experience: good bank, good cust service, be careful when you close account as highlighted above: they will not pay interest for the month in which you close account.


They also charge $10 if account closed in 90 days.

Anyone know if they offer check writing with this account?


Wow 3.25% until Dec 25 instead of 3.0 until mid year. MM account allow you to write up to 6 transactions per month, and 3 checks per month. That's what I rather take this MM instead of emigrant-direct, I need to write 1-2 checks per month.They have several branches in LA but nothing close to my home so I think I will use either electronic transfer or mail in for deposit.


all168 said: Wow 3.25% until Dec 25 instead of 3.0 until mid year. MM account allow you to write up to 6 transactions per month, and 3 checks per month. That's what I rather take this MM instead of emigrant-direct, I need to write 1-2 checks per month.They have several branches in LA but nothing close to my home so I think I will use either electronic transfer or mail in for deposit.

They say you have to open by internet (not at a branch) and there are extra fees if you ever deal with their branches.


OP: can you update your title to reflect the exciting 3.25%, good until the end of the year? I think that rate should get some attention!


Thanks, OP. Planning to move ING fund over. Applied on-line without any problem. Good find!
Edit to update status: You have to call to activate the account. CSR did a credit 'soft inquiry' to verify identity. Fund(s) is set up to ACH from bank account(s). Take about 3 business days. An email will be sent with account information and then you can access it on-line. Welcome package will be sent via US mail to receive in the standard 7-10 business days. Only thing is that if you want checks- 30 checks will cost 7.50. Online bill payment is 4.95/month. Since I don't plan to do anything with this account, this is not a problem but something to consider for those who do. Took about 15 minutes on the phone fairly painless, will see how the email and online access turn out.


tylr said: Thanks, OP. Planning to move ING fund over. Applied on-line without any problem. Good find!
Edit to update status: You have to call to activate the account. CSR did a credit 'soft inquiry' to verify identity. Fund(s) is set up to ACH from bank account(s). Take about 3 business days. An email will be sent with account information and then you can access it on-line. Welcome package will be sent via US mail to receive in the standard 7-10 business days. Only thing is that if you want checks- 30 checks will cost 7.50. Online bill payment is 4.95/month. Since I don't plan to do anything with this account, this is not a problem but something to consider for those who do. Took about 15 minutes on the phone fairly painless, will see how the email and online access turn out.


tylr, since you already opened an account, do you know what happens if the balance falls below $5000? Do they charge any low balance fee? Do they close an account? Also , how do you move money back and forward? Is it like ING, where you link it with your checking account? If it is how many checking accounts can you link it with?


chrnkm said:
tylr, since you already opened an account, do you know what happens if the balance falls below $5000? Do they charge any low balance fee? Do they close an account? Also , how do you move money back and forward? Is it like ING, where you link it with your checking account? If it is how many checking accounts can you link it with?


According to the CSR, if balance falls below 5K, you don't earn any interest, no fee. Did not ask whether they would close the account or not. There is no option to link to external accounts from WFB but that's why I ordered checks so that I can either link the WFB account from ING/VB or just deposit the check to my day-to-day bank account.
By the way, there is a comment from a poster in Cheap's HY Banks thread about this being a 'promotional' rate; JMO but most of top HY banks (Superiors, ED etc.) have similar or less timeframes for guaranteed rates. I'll take the end of '05 anyday with only 90 days early closure limit vs. 6 months for some banks. Will see in 3 days how seamless or not this process and online access are.


Thanks OP. I just submitted my account information online and called them and verified the account information.


If you don't want to spend the 7.50 for checks, and there are no externally linked accounts, how do you withdraw your money? (you'll get hit with a fee if you go into a branch)


Excellent question. Supposedly you can use their ATMs at no charge, but if you're not near a branch you're likely not near one of their ATMs so you'd be hit with a surcharge (only one though since they say they don't charge). Also it's $1.50 to do an in-branch transaction with this account. Doesn't sound so great.

Edit for clarity.


This is the email I got a while ago:
Dear Cheap,

Thank you for opening an account with Western Financial Bank. This is a confirmation that your Online Money Market Plus account has been opened and that the electronic funds transfer you authorized on 2/1x/2005 from your account number ending with xxxx was processed on your behalf on 2/1x/2005.

You will be receiving a welcome package in the mail with account information and a signature card. Please remember to complete the signature card and return it as soon as possible. Once we receive the completed signature card, access will be provided to your account.

Please take the time to let us know how you rate our service by clicking the following link:

http://www.elisten.com/web30/surveys/xxxxx

If you have any additional questions, please don't hestitate to call us at 1-877-WFB-1234.

Thank you.


I did mine in mid-Feb and still haven't recieved my packet. I didn't get any account info, I think we have to wait on the packet and from my experience it will be at least 2 weeks.

And tylr, I agree about the whole teaser vs promo vs guarantee rates. I posted a response in my thread but if there is need for more discussion we can do it in this thread since it is in regard to this deal.


ucsdgaspasser said: If you don't want to spend the 7.50 for checks, and there are no externally linked accounts, how do you withdraw your money? (you'll get hit with a fee if you go into a branch)

When I was talking to the CSR I was told that I could transfer money online so I thought there would be linked accounts. But I don't have proof yet.


Re transfer money online, I also asked and verified with CSR that this was for internal accounts only (ie. WFB to WFB) but I have no proof at this time either so we'll wait and see.


Their csr gave me an entirely differnet answer than the previous 2 posters.
She said that you could do external ach transfers 'anywhere without prior links' simply by entering your external account info each time you want to transfer.

Too bizarre! Sounds like they don't have a clue there.


sloppy1 said: Their csr gave me an entirely differnet answer than the previous 2 posters.
She said that you could do external ach transfers 'anywhere without prior links' simply by entering your external account info each time you want to transfer.

Too bizarre! Sounds like they don't have a clue there.


Well, that would be consistant with my answer, I was just assuming linked accounts, but as long as I can do transfers online I am happy. I guess this is turning into a YMMV. I should be getting the info packet in the mail soon and will report my experiences.


Good find! Thanks OP.

The gentleman I spoke with indicated that ACH transactions could be done in and out (6 times, per Reg. D), but that the external bank would have to initiate them.

So I applied and will link up my CapOne account as soon as I've sent in my signature card.

Woohoo!


These guys are slick, they'll pay you a whopping 3% apy for a 5 year cd. Must have hired Scrooge in the long term dept.


Ouch. I asked them to transfer just $5 for the initial funding of the account. How much do they take? $5,000. Ugh.


So how do we make the future deposit? Does WFB provide(Can we) ACH?
Thanks.


mbaker4096 said: Ouch. I asked them to transfer just $5 for the initial funding of the account. How much do they take? $5,000. Ugh.

Comeon, with high $$$ balances, 5 is understood to be $5000.

LOL, reminds me of that movie where the guy goes and orders ribs. The owner yells back to the kitchen, "One order of ribs!" and the guy says, "No, one rib." Owners says "Wha'cha mean one rib?".

... guy (Chris Rock) asks the owner, "So you got change for the $100?"



It also says in fineprint

link for 3.25 promo

APY is accurate as of 3/1/05 and assumes principal and interest remain in the account for one year.


what does this mean? Is it like a CD where we cannot withdraw anything, or they reduce the ineterest rate if we withdraw anything??


NoDiscount said: Comeon, with high $$$ balances, 5 is understood to be $5000.I think I made it pretty clear.

I was asking about calculation of interest if my balance were under $5K and then said I wanted to start out with $5 and would ACH in additional funds to bring it up to $5K at a later date.

No worries. Just found my bank balance at -$3476 this morning and quickly transferred in funds from my HELOC to cover it. Don't think I was charged anything for the temporary overdraft.


ramkyk said: assumes principal and interest remain in the account for one year.They're just emphasizing the difference between APR and APY, and that the quoted APY of 3.25% is due to daily compounding interest, not a simple interest calculation.


I had an account with WFB a few years ago. No complaints about them. If you need assistance, just give them a call or you can get help online, too. Just make sure to keep a minimum balance of $5000 in the account or you don't get any interest, which I had the misfortune of experiencing.


Cheap said: sloppy1 said: Their csr gave me an entirely differnet answer than the previous 2 posters.
She said that you could do external ach transfers 'anywhere without prior links' simply by entering your external account info each time you want to transfer.

Too bizarre! Sounds like they don't have a clue there.


Well, that would be consistant with my answer, I was just assuming linked accounts, but as long as I can do transfers online I am happy. I guess this is turning into a YMMV. I should be getting the info packet in the mail soon and will report my experiences.


I got my account info today! Metered on the 24th and got here today.

Looks like linked accounts. There is space for 2 account #/routing numbers on the signature card (only one line is filled out with the info from my initial deposit) followed by this text:
"Voided" check(s) on the above account(s) is required documentation and must be included with the signature card for the deposited items to be released. I understand that I may initiate electorinic deposits via the Internet to only those account(s) indicated above upon WFB's receipt and approval of the completed signature card with the attached "voided" checks from me. I hereby authorize WFB, to process electronic deposits initiated via the Internet to only those account(s) indicated above.

Transfers to WFB will be deposited on the 3rd business day from the date of the ACH request.


Thanks for the info, Cheap!

So there *is* some sort of online interface for initiating ACH transfers between WFB and the rest of the world...very cool. A little weird that inbound transfers are simply ignored for 2 days (guessing that means no interest during that period?) but assuming you don't have to move funds regularly, ít's still a pretty good deal.

I'm in the process of moving over money from Superior Savings (3.04% APY, $10K minimum, no online interface) and looking forward to getting my documentation. Noted that Western Financial can be linked into my CompassWeb (Yodlee) aggregation service so I'm doubly pleased -- Superior's lack of internet banking kinda precluded them from any sort of aggregated reporting/review.


mbaker4096 said: Superior's lack of internet banking kinda precluded them from any sort of aggregated reporting/review.

Great to know about the linked account info. I got the welcome letter last night, one day after application and I'm looking forward to getting my package. OT: Superiors does have an online interface not very robust but they do have it.
https://www.bankonsuperiorsavings.com/cashman/eCashmanSignon.Asp


Cheap said: Cheap said: sloppy1 said: Their csr gave me an entirely differnet answer than the previous 2 posters.
She said that you could do external ach transfers 'anywhere without prior links' simply by entering your external account info each time you want to transfer.

Too bizarre! Sounds like they don't have a clue there.


Well, that would be consistant with my answer, I was just assuming linked accounts, but as long as I can do transfers online I am happy. I guess this is turning into a YMMV. I should be getting the info packet in the mail soon and will report my experiences.


I got my account info today! Metered on the 24th and got here today.

Looks like linked accounts. There is space for 2 account #/routing numbers on the signature card (only one line is filled out with the info from my initial deposit) followed by this text:
"Voided" check(s) on the above account(s) is required documentation and must be included with the signature card for the deposited items to be released. I understand that I may initiate electorinic deposits via the Internet to only those account(s) indicated above upon WFB's receipt and approval of the completed signature card with the attached "voided" checks from me. I hereby authorize WFB, to process electronic deposits initiated via the Internet to only those account(s) indicated above.

Transfers to WFB will be deposited on the 3rd business day from the date of the ACH request.


Did you try to ACH transfer using their interface?


chrnkm said: Did you try to ACH transfer using their interface?

Yes, I did. But I can't because I didn't have any confirmed accounts yet as I had just sent back my voided check. I will try this weekend and report back.


Hope this info helps. I have setup an account at WFB and everything has run very smoothly so far. I transferred my inital 5k deposit last week and have deposited even more 2 days ago.

I received my signature card which I have already sent back.
My external checking account has been setup. This is for deposits only. You cannot withdraw electronically.
My biggest gripe with this interface is that you have to keep inputting the external checking account number/routing number/name/email address for every deposit you make.
The only methods of withdrawal are by check, ATM, or branch visit.
There is a 90 day account closing fee.
If you fall below the 5k minimum balance, you wont earn any interest. There are no other penalties for falling below 5k other than not earning interest. This wont be a problem since I dont plan making frequent withdrawals.
Withdrawal limitations are 6 per month.


gigabyte said:
My external checking account has been setup. This is for deposits only. You cannot withdraw electronically.
My biggest gripe with this interface is that you have to keep inputting the external checking account number/routing number/name/email address for every deposit you make.
The only methods of withdrawal are by check, ATM, or branch visit.
There is a 90 day account closing fee.


So you can use the ACH to deposit into the WFB account but you cannot use the ACH to withdraw from the WFB account and deposit the proceeds into an external account? do I understand your message correctly?


response to tylr:

yes that is correct


Skipping 82 Messages...

Rate hike to 4.5% from 4.25% today. Still $1.00 minimum to open.




Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.


While FatWallet makes every effort to post correct information, offers are subject to change without notice.
Some exclusions may apply based upon merchant policies.
© 1999-2012