help
edit

Forums
Finance

Best DAY to transfer into HSBC savings acct... Archived From: Finance

  • Text Only
  • Search this Topic »
  • Classic
  • Go to Page :
  • 1 2
alert mods    

I found the following on HSBC site while i was trying to transfer $ out of ED.

The transfer date for Standard and next Day external transfers must be set to the current date.

Standard Delivery (3 Business Days)*

Requested by 8:00 p.m. Eastern Time on:
Source Account Debited before Start-of-Business on:
Destination account credited before Start-of-Business on:

Monday
Tuesday
Thursday

Tuesday
Wednesday
Friday

Wednesday
Thursday
Monday

Thursday
Friday
Tuesday

Friday
Monday
Wednesday

Saturday
Monday
Wednesday

Sunday
Monday
Wednesday
---------------------------
So Wednesday and Thursday are the WORST days to make the transfers.. since you lose 1 or 2 days EXTRA on top of their normal 2 days...

(this is probably in some thread somewhere, but just in case it isn't)

Slowest money transfer days to open an HSBC and transfer money into that account are Wednesday and Thursday if the transfer is made before 8PM EST.

alert mods    

I just scheduled a transfer today into HSBC from ED for Friday, that would debit on Monday and Credit on Wednesday. Saved couple of days of interest loss by being a little diligent.

alert mods    

xvmehta said:I just scheduled a transfer today into HSBC from ED for Friday, that would debit on Monday and Credit on Tuesday. Saved couple of days of interest loss by being a little deligent.

no, you would get credited on Wednesday.. look at the list..

alert mods    

xvmehta said:I just scheduled a transfer today into HSBC from ED for Friday, that would debit on Monday and Credit on Tuesday. Saved couple of days of interest loss by being a little deligent.

where do u see credit on tuesday ? Its credit on wed if you xfer on fri.

alert mods    

thx

alert mods    

xvmehta said:I just scheduled a transfer today into HSBC from ED for Friday, that would debit on Monday and Credit on Tuesday. Saved couple of days of interest loss by being a little deligent.

i guess by being a little deligent you lost two more days

alert mods    

nope
he didn't lose any "extra" days, transfer will occur on Friday but his account won't be debted until next Monday and his (another) account won't be credit until Wed
in a word, in the HSBC system (same with CITIBANK), losing 2 days interest is the BEST scenario, the WORST is losing 4 days (2 extra day for the weekend)
well, let's be "a little diligent": how much is the "interest" anyway? for $1000, 4% APR, interest per day is 10 cents, so it's not a big deal UNLESS you are tring to "save" more by transfer from a 4% APR account (like ED) to a 4.25% APR account (like HSBC), you will be surprised you end up losing much more ( only gain .25% more for a day but lose two days of 4% already, that's 4*2/0.25=32 days!)

btw, Etrade system is much better, you can get fund credited right away (the same business day) and the other account won't be debted until the next business day, so you may "earn" interest by doing transfer, however, Etrade account itself only provides a mearly .30% APR <$5000 or 2.6% APR <$50000, may not worth it at all.

sbhsr said:xvmehta said:I just scheduled a transfer today into HSBC from ED for Friday, that would debit on Monday and Credit on Tuesday. Saved couple of days of interest loss by being a little deligent.

i guess by being a little deligent you lost two more days

alert mods    

particular said:nope
he didn't lose any "extra" days, transfer will occur on Friday but his account won't be debted until next Monday and his (another) account won't be credit until Wed
in a word, in the HSBC system (same with CITIBANK), losing 2 days interest is the BEST scenario, the WORST is losing 4 days (2 extra day for the weekend)
well, let's be "a little diligent": how much is the "interest" anyway? for $1000, 4% APR, interest per day is 10 cents, so it's not a big deal UNLESS you are tring to "save" more by transfer from a 4% APR account (like ED) to a 4.25% APR account (like HSBC), you will be surprised you end up losing much more ( only gain .25% more for a day but lose two days of 4% already, that's 4*2/0.25=32 days!)

btw, Etrade system is much better, you can get fund credited right away (the same business day) and the other account won't be debted until the next business day, so you may "earn" interest by doing transfer, however, Etrade account itself only provides a mearly .30% APR <$5000 or 2.6% APR <$50000, may not worth it at all.

sbhsr said:xvmehta said:I just scheduled a transfer today into HSBC from ED for Friday, that would debit on Monday and Credit on Tuesday. Saved couple of days of interest loss by being a little deligent.

i guess by being a little deligent you lost two more days



there's plenty of us with over $50k in accounts, so even 1 day of lost interest is "notable"

alert mods    

Personally, I won't put over $20K in an account with <4.5%APR nowdays
why not put some money into CD/Bonds or even do some investment?
I guess everyone has one's own strategy, if you want to be on the safe side, banking is still (and always) the best choice.

alert mods    

It was a typo. You are right, my account will be credited on Wednesday.

-------------------------------
xvmehta said:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I just scheduled a transfer today into HSBC from ED for Friday, that would debit on Monday and Credit on Tuesday. Saved couple of days of interest loss by being a little deligent.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

no, you would get credited on Wednesday.. look at the list..

alert mods    

I will loose interest for only 2 days. As pointed out by particular 0.25% more with HSBC should let me breakeven for switch in 32 days. I think it is feasible to switch especially with higher deposit. With $80,000 deposit you can have $200 a year more in your wallet.

Besides liquidity with ATM and Bill Pay facilities (on top of higher interest rate) far outweighs loss of couple of days of interest due to switch.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
i guess by being a little deligent you lost two more days
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

alert mods    

particular said:btw, Etrade system is much better, you can get fund credited right away (the same business day)

AFAIK Etrade would not allow AcH to an account other than from which is came in the first place.
IOW they don't allow to transfer funds from one bank to other using Etade as bridge.

alert mods    

Huh? which etrade account are you talking about?
I signed up an Etrade MM account for the 3 month promo. Besides earning the moderate 3.75% APR, I was doing ACH transfers from/to various bank accounts all the time, no problem at all. Should this promo continue, I'd have decided to keep the account, their so-called "quick transfer" is really convenient and with the advantage of earning extra interests as I pointed out above.

adityanm said:particular said:btw, Etrade system is much better, you can get fund credited right away (the same business day)

AFAIK Etrade would not allow AcH to an account other than from which is came in the first place.
IOW they don't allow to transfer funds from one bank to other using Etade as bridge.

alert mods    

I was planning to move 80K...from Emmigrant, but losing 2 days of 4% interest comes to $18...
is there a cheaper way?

How long is the hold if I mail them a check?

alert mods    

You mail the check and you have to put the money in non- or low-interest checking account. So I think losing the 2 days ($18) seems to be the cheapest way. If not, it is still the most convenient one.

ramganesh said:I was planning to move 80K...from Emmigrant, but losing 2 days of 4% interest comes to $18...
is there a cheaper way?

How long is the hold if I mail them a check?

alert mods    

ramganesh said:I was planning to move 80K...from Emmigrant, but losing 2 days of 4% interest comes to $18...
is there a cheaper way?

How long is the hold if I mail them a check?

Have you considered a GMAC account 4.30% and faster(I believe) transfers
I am not sure if you will lose the 2 days interest with gmac

alert mods    

Better yet - transfer $$ to ING Direct NOW - and get 4.75%...

alert mods    

GeorgeCostanza said:Better yet - transfer $$ to ING Direct NOW - and get 4.75%...

True, but to take advantange of that, HSBC customers will have to transfer out of HSBC... & the promotional rate is only good until April 15th. After that everyone will probably want to transfer their money back to HSBC, so lets try to keep this on topic.

alert mods    

It really depends on how much you're transferring to INGDirect and what is the gain in doing so.

 Close

Sign Me In
Nickname: 
Password: 
Remember My Login Information:

Forget your login information?

Not Already A Member?
Sign Up Now!



Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.


  • © 1999-2009
  • Message Board Statistics RSS Feed Information
Sign up for free today, because you don't want to miss out on any more cash back than you already have! There are currently 1,091,828 people just like you registered to earn Cash Back From FatWallet. Be the next! Sign up to join the discussion & earn Cash Back from FatWallet:
close