• Go to page :
  • 1 2
  • Text Only

I am calling all FWFers who have already done the AOR, already done the 0% balance transfers and have money to move, and already have done (or are doing) the HSBC 4.8% online savings, WHAT NOW? I have some ideas (trading stock options), yet I am looking for less riskier ones.

BACKGROUND ON AOR
First – Thanks FWF for all the help assistance and information. Especially all the AOR RAMA veterans –
xerty (http://www.fatwallet.com/t/52/425743);
Bksavings (http://www.fatwallet.com/t/52/592813);
eugenev (http://www.fatwallet.com/t/52/541760)

Also, I am a huge lurker of FWF veterans - Clearanceman, Davehanson, mbaker4096, SIS, and Didyousearch. While I became addicted FW via the investment/rental property thread (I read the whole thing one weekend as I have rentals in TX) via FW I learned that my very good – not great - credit score of 780 – could be used for something more than a good mortgage rate. Pursuant to lessons learned at FW, I did the AOR thing, I now monitor my FICO at privacyguard (2 month trial period) and myfico.com (( 20% off membership) with codes found both here and at www.creditboard.com))

After my recent AOR I have the following CC:

Cards received where I will (or already have done) a 0% BT
Chase Cash Plus Rewards 5% Cash Back, $100 GC and 0% 12 months - $48,000 CL (combined old lines to new cards)
Citibank Platinum Select 0% 12 months - $32,000 CL (combined old lines to new cards)
Citibank Professional $100 GC and 0% 12 months - $25,000 CL
Schwab $100 GC, 1.9% 12 months - $28,500 CL
RBS 0% 12 months - $15,000 CL
HSBC 0% 12 months - $12,000 CL
Advanta Business Platinum 0% 15 months - $16,000 CL
Schwab $100 GC, 1.9% 12 months - $28,500 CL
HSBC 0% 12 months - $12,000 CL
Discover 0% LIFE - $15,000 CL (Begged for more CL – they would not give me a higher CL and told me I did not have enough DEBT to necessitate – Are they getting keen to 0% people)
BOA 0% 12 months - $7,200 CL
Att Universal 0% 12 months - $5,000 CL

Cards received where I will not do a BT:
American Express BLUE $5,000 CL
American Express Platinum Business $25,000 credit limit, $250 statement credit
American Express Gold Business $250 statement credit (already had one, cancelled it and got new one for 1 year and $250 statement credit)
(http://www.fatwallet.com/t/52/595755 - thanks GTFAN)

I also opened up a Citibank banking inet acct and will link a credit card for the $200 – need to keep $1,500 or 2 bill pays per month or there will be a maintenance fee

What I have learned so far.

#1 I did do the AOR thing all over 2 days over 5 weeks ago. My fico score has not dropped that much due to inquiries. It really was a non-issue. So far – knock on wood.

#2 Certain CCs really liked that I had large no-debt credit lines. – Citibank, Advanta, Schwab. Other CC- namely, Discover CC – did not at all and would not grant me a higher CL on its 0% for life. I begged for more – threatened and asked for retention, yet they would not give me a higher CL and told me I did not have enough DEBT to necessitate it ??? (WTF?!)– I wonder if they are getting keen to 0% people)

#3 I initially desired to keep each CC utilization under 50% for fico protection, yet as inquires and new credit lines appeared on my report and my fico did not drop, I could not leave money on the table ( a la mbaker4096) and am 85-90% utilization on each 0% card.

#4 I opened an HSBC online savings 4.8% and free checking accounts to pull money from my credit unions. The online savings was simple. I talked to someone on the telephone to open up the checking and it is still FUBAR – very frustrating.

#5 I called each card and asked for the % minimum payment, total the estimated payment and will put 2X that amount in HSBC checking for money to be pulled via each CC auto pay. At this juncture, I am not worried about paying over the minimum (this issue raised in another thread)

#6 I make sure to make a small purchase and pay it off every 6 months on all my non 0% BT CC so that none are cancelled and are available for other 0% offers – especially very old lines that help fico.

#7 I am on google-mail (gmail). And, I have folders (labels) to keep copies of all scanned promos (chase GC offer); confirmations of 0% transfers as they are made; and payments (folders per CC and each month) so as to never miss a payment. Gmail is terrific.

#8 CC associates get BIG gift cards/reward points when they do the 0% BT for you. I only do BT via telephone (DYD, davehanson) and I get everything I need from the associate first. If they have any a-hole charateristics – dial tone and recall for more helpful associate.

# 9 I transfer all the BT offers into my checking either directly or through my debit card (yes, I am one of those people who carry a debit card) except CITI who made me take a check?

Problems:

#1, 2,3,4, and 5 – Me, me, me, me, and me – I have an addictive personality.
I was deep in the inet – tech – nazdaq trading in 1993-2001. Made great money. I have been buying gold maple leafs for the last 3 years and have been tempted start selling a few via eBay given recent gold spot ($600/oz yea!). It is very hard to now JUST STOP and only get 4.8% on my money. This ain’t fittin in with my personality. I have been seriously thinking of doing more with the money for a greater ROI. But I do not want to be too risky after all – this is not my money.

So calling all FWFers who have already done the AOR, already done (or doing) the HSBC 4.8% online savings, WHAT NOW? I have some ideas (trading stock options), yet I am looking for less riskier ones.

Thanks in advance

 

Edit by Moderator: Thank you for participating in the forums. However, this topic has been covered in a recent post Here.



There are plenty of 5%+ short term cds out there. You can even do better with some credit union cd deals and short term bank promos. Set enough money aside in a high yield savings or money market account to cover your minimum payments and stash the rest in cds and/or promo accounts. The strategy is here - CC BT investment thread. The rates are here and here.


The way I see it, your investment options are limited to the very short term. If you lock up this money in an investment that cannot be liquidated (at least favorably) it could be disastrous. I don't need to remind you that this is not your money. You can leverage yourself into some speculative positions, but be sure you can cover yourself with excessively conservative stops and be able to cover your position if you get called. Good luck and don't let your gambling instinct take over this amount of money, or your App-O-Rama to make a few extra K per year could end up costing you big.


I am thinking about either foreclosures when the bubble bursts, stock options on stocks poised to move - i bought RMBS, yet i could have retired with the same $$ in options. Hell,i was thinking about buying maple leafs in bulk and selling on eBay. The mark-up on that site is insane for a single leaf/krugerrand. Yet i have done the eBay thing before and the listing, selling, and paypal fees make you sick (even though i usually overcharged for shipping). But i am so far beyond eBay mentally (kid's play), i would hate to go back.


Just checked eBay for Gold Maple leafs, doesn't seem to be too much profit there, but of course that depends no how much you buy it for yourself


Not completely risk free - but you could consider an options strategy with say a 5% downside protection?
Look at ADR's/GDR's and the pricing of the underlying securities. In several cases I've seen arbitrage opportunities exist; I haven't looked into the transaction costs but it might be viable.
Emerging market debt perhaps - several countries pay a fair bit above US rates and carry little risk of defult in the short run.


I have not run the number, but buy $5,000 - $7,500 worth of leafs/krugs online (no shipping fee for these amounts) and then split the coins up and compare to what each one is gettin online - i was sure i saw a 8-10% premium paid on eBay for single 1 oz. coins. I will get more exact numbers and get back with you.
Remeber also many eBay sellers are making profit on s/h


oddball1 said: Not completely risk free - but you could consider an options strategy with say a 5% downside protection?
Look at ADR's/GDR's and the pricing of the underlying securities. In several cases I've seen arbitrage opportunities exist; I haven't looked into the transaction costs but it might be viable.
Emerging market debt perhaps - several countries pay a fair bit above US rates and carry little risk of defult in the short run.

Can you please explain the arbitrage opportunity? How do you sell the underlying shares to take advantage of the arbitrage?


5% downside sounds good risk/reward. Yet what type of upside are you talking here. I too would appreciate greater explanation

Thanks in advance


I trade stock options multiple times a week. I cannot believe anyone would consider putting money from a BT into stock options. That's crazy.


danimal67 said: I trade stock options multiple times a week. I cannot believe anyone would consider putting money from a BT into stock options. That's crazy.yes


quit while you're ahead

How much more are you going to get? 5% more, 7%? It's not like you'll win the lottery . 4.8% is more than enough considering no risk at all. If your tax rate is high enough, I'd consider tbills.

IMO, the risk does not justify the reward.

If you have to gamble, gamble with your own money


Excellent job documenting your progress so far. Although I tire of new "me too" AOR threads that crop up every couple weeks on FW, yours provides a lot more useful information than other recent ones and mentions a couple cards I'd missed!

As for where to put your money. This is basically the "how should I invest $XX" question with the added twist of risk management being more necessary (since it's not your money). I'd be willing to bet you already have some great ideas on where to invest $150,000 in general (you've certainly proven yourself willing to put in the legwork required to research money making opportunities), but you're hesitant to put BT into those same ventures. I'd stick with the investment ideaes you're already considering, applying risk management considerations. In a nutshell this involves estimating your maximum potential loss over the BT period (considering investment of your $$s AND the BT $$s) and making sure such a loss wouldn't cripple you financially. If it would then only move as much BT money out of savings as is appropriate to meet this criteria.
For example let's say you're looking at a mutual fund that based on a statistical analysis you're 95% confident will lose no more than 30% in the next year. If you have $150k of your own money + $150k of BT money such a loss would cost you $100k, leaving you with $50k after paying off the CCs. If you could afford such a loss then you might consider the mutual fund opportunity.
Could go into more detail, but my next client is here...Again, I think you need to focus on the risk management angle in formulating your plan.


andrey0 said: quit while you're ahead

How much more are you going to get? 5% more, 7%? It's not like you'll win the lottery . 4.8% is more than enough considering no risk at all. If your tax rate is high enough, I'd consider tbills.

IMO, the risk does not justify the reward.

If you have to gamble, gamble with your own money


Gambling big with other people's money is the best way to do it. (eg real estate speculation)


andrey0 said: quit while you're ahead

How much more are you going to get? 5% more, 7%? It's not like you'll win the lottery . 4.8% is more than enough considering no risk at all. If your tax rate is high enough, I'd consider tbills.

IMO, the risk does not justify the reward.

If you have to gamble, gamble with your own money
seriously...if you can get 5%+ with ZERO risk, dont take 100% risk just to earn maybe 10%. Sell stuff on eBay, 20% discount giftcards, or other things with low riks of los and greater returns.
Otherwise you might as well put it half of the BT money on black, and in 30 seconds youll either be 50% up or 50% down, and be done with it.

While your thread was well researched and composed, I negged it for the following reasons: it IS just asking what do i do with $xxx, and worse, its just an example of GREED getting the best of you. AOR/BT strategies do not work out once GREED takes over. There are a lot of impressionabe and naive copycats here trying to play the BT game with smaller #s, and may be more likely to try riskier strategies to earn more when they see threads like this/ Call me paternalistic.


I agree with all the low riskers. I am on your team. If i was a riverboat gambler, i would not have asked the conservative and wise that comprise FWF for advice.

I am not looking for stock tips (i can find those myself),and I am not looking for the next 12dailypro.

i know the pit of your stomach feeling of holding options as expiration looms. i was glued to a computer for YEARS. (BUT i loved it!) I am just coming to the FWF trough one more time and, i know many here, are at the same juncture.

I have received many great ideas here. I do not want to lose my credit, investments, family life to make 2 more points. However, in my world, some investments which are deemed riskier to some are simply not to others.


dys

I revere you! And you negged me. OUCH! That hurts. But,, I am a big boy and can take a punch. I understand. But I had not intention to turn this into a high risk tread. I was just looking for ideas in the FWF domain. I thought this was timely as others are here. As for greed, I take care of a lot of people - they love my advice, but they need my $$. I am just joe average trying to stay ahead of the curve.

Thanks for reading at least


No offense to you, and I tried to explain the reason for the neg.

If you want to make more $$, look here sometimes having some seed money can allow you to make even more in these ventures, with low risk.

for example, I could take 145k and buy 30-60 cheap used cars. I typically make at LEAST $2k on each, so thats 60-120k profit. And even if I cant, Im not gong to lose money...i might just sell for what I paid. so theres a potential 100% return with nearly 0 risk of loss. And its all short term investments that will be done befoe Bt promo ends. Same with buying /reselling stuff in hotdeals on eBay. Huge profit potential, almost 0 risk of loss thanks to store return policies. But it takes more legwork.



I guess I just see big downsides to using high risk funds (BT funds from CC) for more speculative type investments. So I guess call me risk averse. Also with the generally short term nature of BT funds RE foreclosures seem poorly suited due to the fact that you absolutely would have to flip the property quickly to cash out your funds when the money goes back to the CC companies.


swraith said: I guess I just see big downsides to using high risk funds (BT funds from CC) for more speculative type investments. So I guess call me risk averse. Also with the generally short term nature of BT funds RE foreclosures seem poorly suited due to the fact that you absolutely would have to flip the property quickly to cash out your funds when the money goes back to the CC companies.

Not to mention he still has to have cash on hand to pay the minimum payments. That alone is a couple thou a month.


didYOUsearch said: for example, I could take 145k and buy 30-60 cheap used cars.

They would fit nicely in my 60-car garage.


obviously you dont do it all at once. I usually have 6-8 here at this location at any one time.


OP needs to chill out and lay off the greed or else he's going to end up like Long Term Capital Management.


Sorry guys, I am bit confuse on this App-o-Rama process. Even if you guys increase the credit limit and gets the 0% BT, don't they charge fee for doing Balance Transfer(3%? or $75 dollars). Is it worth it? Also, How're you planning to get the money out and deposit to the bank in order to get the 4.8% saving.

Thanks


I'm with DYS on this one: zero risk should be the watchword on BT investing. While all the more true for many of the less seasoned readers of this thread, that doesn't make it less wise for you...

You have plenty of other cash to put in riskier stuff. Why not consider this the conservative portion of a balanced portfolio? Indeed, when you consider that BT money is really being short bonds (which happen to carry little-to-no interest), having short-term riskless instruments to offset the BTs is really only bringing the cash/low risk portion of your portfolio to net-0%.

Moreover, as explained more completely on my CC/BT thread, depending on your profile I think you're courting trouble as it is going for 85/90% on most of these lines. Just because your fico hasn't dropped hard yet doesn't mean you won't soon experience adverse action. If you like this game, you want to be in it for the long haul, no?

(typo edit only)


$150,000 x 5% = $7,500 Before taxes

assuming 3 0% BT with fees that MAX at $75 and 3 BT with no fees = $225 cost

$7,500 - $225 = $7,275 for sticking money into an online account and setting up autopay on 6 credit cards. $7,275 for 5 hours of work - applying for credit cards, getting CL increases, applying for bank account and setting up transfers, making BT transfers, getting (and saving) emails confirming transfers and payments.

and that's passive. I love to work and I am trying to increase rewards without substantially increasing risk and while also not being flamed here onf FWF as the GREEDY newbie member.

DYS - great idea regarding hotdeals. That is somewhat what I am looking for. I do not want to hand money to someone else and cheerlead. I want participation - and with the cars - expense writeoffs.


DaveHanson

You obviously are deeper in this than I. But DUDE seriously I cannot make all the mechanations you do in and out on a monthly basis. You need a good FICO as you continuosly buy/sell RE and mortgages - correct. I spent the better part of an hour trying to figure out "how" you were doing all that you do. FOR ME What if my fico drops 100 points for % utilization per CC (remember i will have a number of high CL cards with NO utilization whatsoever. I am not buying a house. I do not need a car loan. It will not affect me in my profession. I do not even need car insurance other than liability. How will 650 (or 620) vs. 780 change my life? Let me know if I am missing something


The current FICO has to be reduced with all these new cards. Probably for a few monts.


Regarding FICO damage from inquiries

See in OP where i clearly stated
__________________________________
#1 I did do the AOR thing all over 2 days over 5 weeks ago. My fico score has not dropped that much due to inquiries. It really was a non-issue.
_____________________________

Specifically, 5 points total on all the inquiries - 8
and 5 points on 5 new accounts so far. Myfico.com send alerts to my cell phone so i will honestly list here what happens when all new accounts and % utilization hits.

But i will inform

[


patch96 said: How will 650 (or 620) vs. 780 change my life? Let me know if I am missing something

http://www.fatwallet.com/forums/messageview.php?catid=52&threadid=322874&highlight_key=y&keyword1=adverse

AOR credit trashing can lead to mass credit implosion.

Dave takes this to higher level than many of us - he's turned the art into science. You will not go wrong listening to him.


i read that thread very very closely and saw more adverse consequences from patterns such as taking out huge amounts and paying back immediately, overpaying to get a check back, etc. I also did pm mbaker4096 multiple weeks ago to get his response.

I guess time will tell, but I know many many people WAY overextended at very high rates and the CC applications are stuffing their mailboxes daily.

remember i do not need credit cards. I have been living on a credit union debit card for 9 years. I rarely carry cash.

But thanks for the forewarning. I will keep you posted b/c i am there.

also FYI i have an income that does not make $145,000 in debt a high debt to income ratio.

 


care to share that lucrative occupation/income source?


Back to the Original Question of OP - higher return.
Since you've done trading before, you must be familiar with Interactive Brokers.
However, one can invest with them with no trading.

They do offer 8% commercial notes to investors who qualify.

[Edited - had to withdraw verbatim language due to notice below.]

These are not insured, so you risk the principal if IB goes under.


patch96 said: I spent the better part of an hour trying to figure out "how" you were doing all that you do.While it's still fresh, please let me know if there's any portion of that OP or followups that could be made clearer or more accessible. I get MANY pm's about that thread--since interest appears to be great, I'd rather make it clearer up front to cut down on confusion later...FOR ME What if my fico drops 100 points for % utilization per CC ...How will 650 (or 620) vs. 780 change my life?As that thread indicates, it WILL cut down on the opportunities you have going forward to boost the size of your lines, and land tasty new deals tied to your score (which include a great many, in fact).

It also WILL dramatically increase the likelihood of "adverse action" going forward, as I, DYS, and others have detailed.

Finally, you will simply never know what other opportunity costs you incur with a significantly lower credit score. Higher insurance rates and fewer job offers are just the documented effects that folks who do this currently experience...and most are never even aware that their credit is what ended up costing them.


Do you have a Patelco Credit Union nearby? I think their treasury income account is up to 5.2% right now. Not FDIC insured, but it has private insurance and I view it as pretty much a guaranteed rate. Patelco has been around a long time.

The account has withdrawl restrictions, I think it's a month notice in advance to withdraw funds, but you can reinsert money into the account at anytime. Do a search for Patelco and you can read up about it yourself.


How do you qualify as an accredited investor? (have had an account with IB for many years)


If you haven't opened one yet, open an everbank checking account, you'll get 5.51% for 3 months.

I did something similar 10 months ago and my 0%'s are coming do soon.
Have $65,000 with MBNA. applied for 2 cards the same day, combined the card talking to a rep and they sent me a check with only 1 $75 fee

did dimilar with chase to get a 50,000 cl but got bt no fee, though they dont credit chking account so i had to shift money around and use the free cash advance feature of my capital one card.

Also got 14000 from citi, already had a 25,000 2.99 for life card with them. citi sent me a check no bt fee


patch96 said: Regarding FICO damage from inquiries

See in OP where i clearly stated
__________________________________
#1 I did do the AOR thing all over 2 days over 5 weeks ago. My fico score has not dropped that much due to inquiries. It really was a non-issue.
_____________________________

Specifically, 5 points total on all the inquiries - 8
and 5 points on 5 new accounts so far. Myfico.com send alerts to my cell phone so i will honestly list here what happens when all new accounts and % utilization hits.

But i will inform

[


when I did mine the fico didn't take more than 10 point hit, until the cards showed on the report and I brought the utilization on those cards over 90%. FICO took a 100 point drop. If i need something like a mortgage where i need good credit that moment i'll need to bring my utilization below 50%. the new credit also takes a chunk off your score, but not nearly as much as utilization


IB requests that details of the offering not be publically disseminated. The poster is in violation of that agreement.


Skipping 19 Messages...

Nice job, put it in the bank and call it a day.




Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.


While FatWallet makes every effort to post correct information, offers are subject to change without notice.
Some exclusions may apply based upon merchant policies.
© 1999-2012