Edit

Forums
Finance

HSBC vs. Citibank vs. ING vs. MBNA Archived From: Finance

  • tweet this
  • Post to Facebook
  • Text Only
  • Search this Topic »
  • Classic
  • Go to Page :
  • 1234 5 6
alert mods    

winter said: .(1) Citibank's CSR's suck hard

This is not true. They are not well coordinate and do not know what they are doing. One said "you will not qulify" that other sayed "you are". I thing much training requird(my sugestion)

(2) If you want people to read your messages, you need to take the time to make them readible rather than just tossing something out with as you say "never corrected single line".
Paragraph breaks would be a big start.

Thanks for the comment. However it is not hard to understand the message I wrote.


alert mods    

Sorry to disturb and get back on topic...
I got a letter today saying that Emigrant Direct is updating their web site "in June".
Hopefully this will make it more user friendly, and more professional looking.


alert mods    

demis001 said:winter said:(1) Citibank's CSR's suck hardThis is not true. They are not well coordinate and do not know what they are doing. One said "you will not qulify" that other sayed "you are". I thing much training requird(my sugestion) I guess you are not understanding my use of the term "suck hard".

Let me try again: I agree with you, Citibanks phone CSR's are poorly trained and mostly incompetent. Every time I have dealt with them I have not been satisfied.

I mostly try to communicate via email (msgs on the Citibank web site) these days so inevitably when the second or third CSR tells me something that contradicts the first CSR, I can quote the misinformation I was given verbatim (like the time they told me I had to open a new eSavings account to get the new interest rate). Of course even that does little other than give me personal satisfaction. (2) If you want people to read your messages, you need to take the time to make them readable rather than just tossing something out with as you say "never corrected single line".
Paragraph breaks would be a big start.
Thanks for the comment. However it is not hard to understand the message I wrote.
Speaking for myself, it is hard; I'm sure you have no trouble reading and understanding what you wrote.


alert mods    

LAXFW - your question about foreign atm withdrawals - yes, I just did it from China last week and no fees - just withdraw from the checking account which is how the MMA is classified.


alert mods    

winter said:demis001 said:winter said:(1) Citibank's CSR's suck hardThis is not true. They are not well coordinate and do not know what they are doing. One said "you will not qulify" that other sayed "you are". I thing much training requird(my sugestion) I guess you are not understanding my use of the term "suck hard".

Let me try again: I agree with you, Citibanks phone CSR's are poorly trained and mostly incompetent. Every time I have dealt with them I have not been satisfied.

I mostly try to communicate via email (msgs on the Citibank web site) these days so inevitably when the second or third CSR tells me something that contradicts the first CSR, I can quote the misinformation I was given verbatim (like the time they told me I had to open a new eSavings account to get the new interest rate). Of course even that does little other than give me personal satisfaction.

Thank you a lot. That is what really happen with citibank CSR. I hope they might be benefited from our comment!!


alert mods    

I use ING and Emigrant and like both but I don't like ING's lower interest rates. Anyway, Emigrant is completely redoing their website and will put the new site online this month. Hopefully it is easier to use than their current site.


alert mods    

What I'd like to know is what do you do with all your dormant accounts? Close them? Keep them open with minimum balances? After awhile, you start to build quite a collection of dormant or low use accounts. I don't mind rate chasing but it seems every day there is another bank or offer that is better than the last and the temptation is to move over to greener pastures. As much as I'd like to keep opening new accounts, I wonder if there should be a limit to what is prudent or does that not matter to you as long as you can keep track of your accounts. What is your upper limit?


alert mods    

tooshy said:What I'd like to know is what do you do with all your dormant accounts? Close them? No, I leave them open. You never know when they are going to have a promo or suddenly decide that they want to be the top of the heap again. Costs nothing to leave them sitting open with a minimal balance.
As much as I'd like to keep opening new accounts, I wonder if there should be a limit to what is prudent or does that not matter to you as long as you can keep track of your accounts. What is your upper limit?I haven't found that limit yet.


alert mods    

Customer service can be just as important as the rate. How do each of the companies compare?


alert mods    

A question to all experts: Which online banks discussed here have online CD management facility like ING? ING allows you to give online instructions to transfer money to savings or checking account upon CD maturity without calling or writing to them. I checked with GMAC, they don't have this facility.


alert mods    

I've had (or still have) accounts at all banks mentioned by OP except MBNA, and also CapOne Savings. In the end what I've used almost exclusively the last year or so is Presidential, Internet Checking + Premiere Savings. Especially attractive now that P has ditched the $5k minimum to avoid fee on savings.

Just a point of ref from someone whose been around these blocks.


alert mods    

I too have just gotten off the phone from a terrible experience with Citibank. I tried to open an checking account online and over the course of 1 month couldn't get it done. I sent over 5 different pieces of supporting documentation, but they were never satisified! I even was able to deposit money into the account from the branch though!!! Now I've given up and asked them to cancel. They are now going to be refunding my deposited money to my "unverified" address. What a load of crock... People should think twice about opening an online account. Seems from the posts that the process for opening the e-savings seems to work better if you just sign up for the checking account at the branch first. Then again you get no promotion


alert mods    

Citibank just raised to 5.0%. They are also removing the outgoing ACH fee. Their daily limits will be raised as well.


alert mods    

It is sh?ti bank... CITIBANK has worst customer reps. Here is the problem, by mistake, I withdrew money using my citi credit card instead of atm card. They charged me around $25 as finance charge. I asked them to cancel it. They kept me on switching from banking customer rep and credit card rep. None of them did own the problem. Ultimately, I had to pay finance charge. What would you do if by mistake you use credit card instead of ATM card at ATM?


alert mods    

Bohemian said: What would you do if by mistake you use credit card instead of ATM card at ATM?
I would be more careful next time and not blame the bank for my own mistake


alert mods    

I didn't blame the bank. I just requested is there a way they can make sure that they cann't allow credit cards (on request basis) to withdraw money from ATMs.


alert mods    

Bohemian said:What would you do if by mistake you use credit card instead of ATM card at ATM?Put a sticker label "ATM card" on your ATM card and put another sticker label "use will incur $25 finance charge at ATM" on your credit card. Foolproof.


alert mods    

I was kind of hoping SOLUTION for ALL customers, not on individual basis.


alert mods    

Bohemian said:I didn't blame the bank. I just requested is there a way they can make sure that they cann't allow credit cards (on request basis) to withdraw money from ATMs.
You did not say that in your post. Did not quite get what you meant with this but sounded like you wanted them to own up to the mistake

Bohemian said: None of them did own the problem.

Best to just forget about it and be more careful next time.
Reminds me of how my wife uses the wrong rewards Credit Card. Her answer is they both look the same from the back, I suggested how about looking at the front


alert mods    

I mean absolutely don't allow credit cards to withdraw money from ATM by DEFAULT. When you issue credit card to customer, set the amount to $0 for all credit cards. The bank is forcing customers allowing limited amount to withdraw money using credit card. As a customer, I see it as a trap. Most banks also don't clearly explain about finance charges, most of such information is hidden somewhere in agreement in small letters. When I put a credit card in ATM by mistake, I should at least get a message saying that you cann't withdraw money using this card. Why do I have to keep track of all that color coding/writing messages/marks on card etc.?


 Close

Sign Me In
Nickname: 
Password: 
Remember My Login Information:

Forget your login information?

Not Already A Member?
Sign Up Now!



Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.


While FatWallet makes every effort to post correct information, offers are subject to change without notice.
Some exclusions may apply based upon merchant policies.
© 1999-2009