|
-
-
markkundinger
- Senior Member - 2K
posted: Jun. 13, 2006 @ 11:21p
Guys, walk through this with me, tell me if I'm doing something wrong... Let's assume the OP has little free cash laying around, so something like "pay off half the HELOC immediately" just wouldn't work. However, we also assume OP does enough cash/income to make regular payments on the HELOC (god I hope it's not interest-only)
1) App-o-rama to get as much 0% credit as possible. Let's assume 50k for 12 months. 2) Use that to pay down the HELOC to 70k. Interest on a 70k loan would be... less. 3) Now you have to make the credit card payments. Those min payments combined are probably more than the HELOC payments used to be. So you have to use the HELOC to pay the credit card min payments each month. 4) Keep making the standard payments to the HELOC that you would have been making anyway. 5) ??? 6) Profit.
Okay, you happened to catch me while I'm bored, so I'm trying to work out the loan. I assume that your HELOC payment is amortized to pay off in 10 years from today.
120k balance * 9% annual * 12 months -> payment of 1,521 After 1 year, interest cost is 10,4087, ending balance is 112,238
70k balance * 9% annual * 12 months -> min payment of 887. Assume credit card payments start at 50k * 2% -> 1000 If you tried to keep paying 1521, then you'd effectively end up advancing $350 each month. I can't easily compute payoff rates on a HELOC with that is not having payments made to it, but I have a hunch that you'd have:
70k * 9% + 350/month * 12mo -> ~$6500 interest cost, ending balance would be ~74k, then add on 38k remaining CC debt. So your ending balance would be $112,200...
... hmm, that's about the same, so maybe I messed up something. Probably with regards to the different way payments would apply to principal on the heloc. Sorry. |
-
-
ZiGSoft
- Charter Member
posted: Jun. 14, 2006 @ 11:19a
I might be wrong, but I didn't get the impression that the OP was necessarily in financial hot water. I assumed he was looking for a way to pay less interest.
If that's the case then getting several 0% BT will reduce his interest burden. The min payments will be more than the 2nd or HELOC, however more of his payments will be applied to the "principle."
If there's deviation from that strategy other than to take a smaller BT and pay off just a portion of the 2nd, then I agree with everyone else. You are just shooting yourself in the foot.
You need to be able to afford to close out the BTs within a reasonable amount of time for this to be a prudent financial strategy to pay "less" interest. Anything else is just delaying the inevitable and maybe making it worst later with a temporary reprieve while you play the credit game. |
-
-
berlinsmommy
- Senior Member - 1K
posted: Jun. 14, 2006 @ 12:22p
OP, you don't by any chance have a car, truck, or SUV that is fairly new and has significant equity do you? If your credit is good, credit unions rates are around 6% for used, late model autos, and their fees are much less than what a BT will cost you. I would do this BEFORE you try BTs and trash your credit score. Also, usually these loans do not have any pre-payment penalty, so if you luck out and get a lot of BT money, you could pay off the auto loan.
As I read, one of the big things missing from your post is how much money you could afford to throw at this debt on a monthly basis. This would affect how you rearrange the debt. |
-
-
mhesidence
- Cranky Member
posted: Jun. 14, 2006 @ 12:51p
SoftwareDeveloper said:I was planning to improve my credit score and refinance after few months. What do you say on this? Would my credit score reduce a lot by taking mortgage and HELOC?
Mortgage no. HELOC, maybe depends upon how it is reported to Credit Bureaus. If reported as "revolving" (Same as a credit cards) and you are near 100% utilization (greater than 90% anyway) that hurts your FICO. Not only for one credit line being so high, but your overall utilzation will be high as well unless you have some really big credit card lines.
How do you plan to improve your credit score? Do you know what your score is?
FYI, if you do an app-o-rama that WILL hurt your FICO.
|
-
-
dcwilbur
- Ancient Member
posted: Jun. 14, 2006 @ 3:11p
markkundinger said:However, we also assume OP does enough cash/income to make regular payments on the HELOC (god I hope it's not interest-only)...I assume that your HELOC payment is amortized to pay off in 10 years from today.Most HELOC's ARE interest only and not set up as amortizing loans. There are usually of course no restrictions on paying off the balance and drawing it back up, which is essentially what you have laid out. |
-
-
xjhuan
- Tired Member
posted: Jun. 14, 2006 @ 3:23p
HELOC is a floating interest rate loan. People get into HELOC mainly for the following three reasons:
1) Interest rate is high and will go much lower. You don't want to lock in your interest at a high level. ==== Current situation is the opposite. Interest rate will go higher, not lower. 2) Don't really need it. Just for financial flexibility. 3) Need short term financing (need cash now!). Can pay off the principle in a few years.
I believe OP is reason 3). He CAN handle the payment. Just want to save money on interest.
I am in a similar situation with OP's but on a much smaller scale.
I have 45K first mortgage on my 17.5K house. 75K balance on my HELOC from Nexity Bank (1% for three month, then Prime - .25%). 35K in Amboy and HSBC eSavings (currently earn 4.75% interest rate).
I just applied for six new credit cards yeaterday. Will do another three today. If I can get 50K CL, plus $40K 0% BT promotion from my existing cards, I can drop my HELOC balance to zero, and put extra 50K in eSavings account.
My estimation is that the interest I earn from esavings accounts will offset the interest payment on my first mortgage.
Maybe my bonus next year will be 40K. Then I can pay off all my credit cards. To answer OP's question:" Ways to reduce interest on Home Equity LOC".
Here is my suggestion:
1) Go with "mbna - dept-free plan with 7.49% APR utpo $50000". Your first mortgage's interest payment will max out your itemized tax deductable. You will not get any tax benefit for your second mortgage interest payment. So anything lower than 9% is better. 2) Apply for 10 or more credit cards in one day for 0% BT for 12 mths. If your first mortgage is 525K, you have a good chance to get more than 50K BT at 0% for 12 mths. That's $4,500 saving. Some credit cards even off $100 signing bonus. 3) "3.9% for first 6 months upto $9500 in my existing discover card account." |
-
-
u2head8
- Senior Member - 1K
posted: Jun. 14, 2006 @ 4:09p
I just don’t see how OP is able to afford all the payments. If u move some of the line from HELOC to either cc or other loan, he will have more payment per month. If he can afford all the payment, it’s great. Also, if u put on the credit cards, u need to pay them off after 1 year, that’s a lot of $$. |
-
-
unknownshopper
- Senior Member<br>6K
posted: Jun. 14, 2006 @ 4:14p
And with Universal Default, one glitch and the cc interest goes sky high.
Very interesting situation. |
-
-
SoftwareDeveloper
- Member
posted: Jun. 14, 2006 @ 4:48p
Thanks for your suggestions. I can afford $4000 a month, that's like push every saving penny into the loan. My both loans are interest only. Currently the sum of both mortgages is $3750. Let's do the math:
1. $50000 in MBNA for 6 years (if I get this much loan) - $898 2. My first Mortgage: $2900 3. $50000 in CC 0% BT (if I get this much) - $1000 (2% I guess) 4. HELOC - $900 (currently) 5. $9000 - 3.9% BT in discover card - $180
Total monthly payment: 898+2900+1000+900+180 = $5878
I dont know if I have this option: 1. Borrow $50000 from MBNA 2. Refinance the HELOC with 8%(prime+1) interest rate for rest of the money. 3. Refinance my car and put the money as down payment.
I guess this would not hurt my FICO as much.
I have a 1 year old car purchase price- $15000.
FYI, my FICO is 715.
Did I miss anything?
|
-
-
sdeals
- Senior Member
posted: Jun. 14, 2006 @ 4:49p
Because OP will be in no better shape if the HELOC rate goes up, I think he needs BTs. Having the HELOC maxed out is not a good thing for his credit.
Use the HELOC to pay the CC. On a $50k BT @ 0% for 1 year and using the HELOC to pay the CC @ 2%/month, you will save $3,992.41 in interest payments. |
-
-
xjhuan
- Tired Member
posted: Jun. 14, 2006 @ 4:49p
u2head8 said:I just don’t see how OP is able to afford all the payments. If u move some of the line from HELOC to either cc or other loan, he will have more payment per month. If he can afford all the payment, it’s great. Also, if u put on the credit cards, u need to pay them off after 1 year, that’s a lot of $$.
He can always pay those credit cards by HELOC, even after one year. His balance on HELOC for the first year will be much lower than it would be. Therefore he will save money on interest payment.
Of course, he still needs to payoff the mortgage and HELOC. That's not our concern here in this topic.
unknownshopper said:And with Universal Default, one glitch and the cc interest goes sky high.
That's true. I would setup auto pay for those credit cards.
|
-
-
u2head8
- Senior Member - 1K
posted: Jun. 14, 2006 @ 5:13p
xjhuan said:He can always pay those credit cards by HELOC, even after one year. His balance on HELOC for the first year will be much lower than it would be. Therefore he will save money on interest payment. I see that...but I was thinking OP's looking for a permanent rate cut.
I think he should also try to get Home Equity Loan cuz the rate is fixed still pretty low ~6.5% for 10 years term. Some lenders might allow this cuz he get this loan to pay off a portion of his loan.
FICO = 715? A couple more inquiries will put it under 700 and that’s the danger zone.
|
-
-
SoftwareDeveloper
- Member
posted: Jun. 19, 2006 @ 4:29p
My Fico Score has been increased to 729 from 708 in this weekend. Do you guys suggest me something now? |
-
-
sloth911
- Cranky Member
posted: Jun. 19, 2006 @ 4:38p
Sell house, buy/rent something you can afford. |
-
-
SoftwareDeveloper
- Member
posted: Jun. 19, 2006 @ 5:08p
Thanks for suggestion. I dont want to sell the house. I want to reduce the total cost of the house. |
-
-
mgdeals
- Senior Member - 1K
posted: Jun. 19, 2006 @ 5:34p
And I don't want to pay my bills. I want them to pay me.
Is this a joke?
It sounds like you were using a HELOC to pay your mortgage that you couldn't afford in the first place?
You are trying to reduce your interest cost in a rising interest rate environment.
You likely have no equity in your home in a flat to falling or possibly bursting housing market.
You say you can afford $4k a month at most, yet your own calculations come out to needing $5878, and still don't see a problem.
Yet, you think you had no choice but to buy a $660k house in CA instead of renting?
What are you going to do if the house drops $100k in value or even stays flat, and you need to sell? You do know that you can't just pay interest-only forever, right? |
-
-
cameron2003
- Senior Member - 2K
posted: Jun. 19, 2006 @ 5:55p
Software dude-
Take a breath, dont panic, use your logic skills on this. You have lots of options really.
- You can and should find a better HELOC rate, like prime - 1. This will save you interest. - You can finance all or at least a good part of your HELOC temporarily with one year 0% Balance transfers onto credit cards. Go slowly here, there are tricks of the trade. - I didnt catch what your mortgage rate is. But perhaps you can refi that into something more affordable short-term.
It sounds like you need a short term fix, but dont forget long-term either.
You will be ok.  |
-
-
slimcustomer
- Senior Member - 1K
posted: Jun. 19, 2006 @ 6:06p
Typical Fatwallet thread. FW member SoftwareDeveloper poses a question asking for help and gets lots of criticism with little of it being constructive. People are making lots of assumptions, some of them wrong based on the info the OP has given us. For all we know, someone was holding a Chipotle Burrito to the OP's head when he agreed to buy this house, thus rendering this a perfectly reasonable transaction. |
-
-
slimcustomer
- Senior Member - 1K
posted: Jun. 19, 2006 @ 6:32p
-
-
blueiedgod
- Senior Member - 2K
posted: Jun. 20, 2006 @ 9:08a
mgdeals said: You say you can afford $4k a month at most, yet your own calculations come out to needing $5878, and still don't see a problem.
Best post. |
Close
|
|
 |
 |
Not Already A Member?
Sign Up Now!
|
|
Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.
|
|