I'm looking for strategies for maximizing my income. My paycheck is direct deposited into my local bank's checking account. Some of my bills accept check only (mortgage, water, sewer, electricity, gym, natural gas), and other bills I can pay with a credit card (telephone/internet, auto insurance). I also have a paypal debit card (1% CashBack, which I use for everything other then gas and groceries) and a Chase Mastercard Cash Plus Rewards (5% on gas and groceries).
So what I was thinking is when my paycheck is direct deposited, transfer it to my paypal account (which has the money market fund (currently 4.73%)) to it, and my local bank's checking account has no minimum amount requirements. Then as my bills that only take checks come up, transfer money back to my checking account and write the checks. Continue to use my paypal and chase cards as usual and pay the chase off in the grace period to avoid interest.
Then at the end of the month, which whatever money I have left over, transfer it back to my checking account and then into HSBC online savings (4.8%).
I know people have hesitations about putting money into paypal, but I've never had a problem with them, and I don't buy stuff on eBay.
Why not just have the money direct deposited into a money market checking account with a bank and save all the paypal hassles (and there are many).
opmnxtc
Thrifty Member
posted: Jun. 21, 2006 @ 8:53a
why don't you transfer your paycheck first to hsbc? the hsbc online savings has free ach transfers in and out, but they are slow.
does your local bank have free online billpay? otherwise, get the hsbc free checking account and pay your checks using theirs.
p.s. glad to see you're one of the few people with no paypal problems. me too, and i do a lot of stuff with them.
Zon
Senior Member
posted: Jun. 21, 2006 @ 8:54a
What you're saying makes sense and plenty of people bank that way, however I think you're going to find it a pain to be checking all the time to see if your money from your transfers cleared. You didn't say how much money you're talking about in your paycheck, but for example, lets say it is $5000. Even if that money would be in the high interest account for the whole month you're only talking $20 interest less tax. So you need to decide if that is worth it.
I don't have an HSBC checking account, but i'm assuming that transfers between that and their online savings account is fast. If that is the case then opening a checking account there would be a better option for what you want to do. You can always transfer some extra money to your local account for ATM withdrawals, etc.
markkundinger
Senior Member - 2K
posted: Jun. 21, 2006 @ 9:08a
a) Paypal is a titanic pain for transferring money back and forth. The transactions can take quite a while to clear, and the money "disappears" from both accounts during those couple of days. Not recommended for tight management. (their money market yield is nice though).
b) MBNA credit cards have a bill pay which might allow a few more of your bills to be paid with a credit card (no CashBack or points or anything).
So, if you can work out quicker transfers to/from a higher yield account (either within same institution or with other) or just find a checking account with absurdly high interest (Presidential), that would give you an incremental bonus... basically of what your usual balance is in the checking account.
opmnxtc
Thrifty Member
posted: Jun. 21, 2006 @ 9:13a
paypal bank transfers in and out take 2-3 days (make a transfer on Monday, see the money on Wednesday or Thursday).
presidential checking plus might be good for you:
4.50% APY on balances up to $25,000 minimum to open $1500, minimum balance to avoid monthly fees $1000 account requires an electronic monthly deposit of $200 or more from payroll, annuity, pension, or a business account
mhesidence
Dismembered Member
posted: Jun. 21, 2006 @ 9:13a
Simple: direct deposit straight to a Presidential savings or checking account (http://www.fatwallet.com/t/52/473281). Use presidential billpay to pay bills. Keep a free local account to deposit checks and use ACH to transfer money to Presidential.
tazzy531
Senior Member - 4K
posted: Jun. 21, 2006 @ 9:44a
The concern you should have is the tranfer time. I'm hesitant about opening an ING account for this very reason.
This is what I went with the Citibank e-Savings and Citibank checking account. The eSavings account is pretty competitive in terms of interest rate. In addition, I can transfer funds between the two accounts instantaneously.
opmnxtc said: why don't you transfer your paycheck first to hsbc? the hsbc online savings has free ach transfers in and out, but they are slow.
does your local bank have free online billpay? otherwise, get the hsbc free checking account and pay your checks using theirs.
p.s. glad to see you're one of the few people with no paypal problems. me too, and i do a lot of stuff with them.
The HSBC Online Savings is limited to 6 withdrawals a month (and I need more then that for my checks, CC payment, etc). My local bank has online billpay, but its slow (5 days before they mail out the bill payment, and money sitting in my checking account gets no interest). If I put my paycheck into the HSBC Checking account, I wouldn't get interest on it, whereas with paypal I get 4.73%.
For the person recommending the 4.5% checking account, I don't like that you have to keep a minimum balance and they have a large opening requirement.
opmnxtc
Thrifty Member
posted: Jun. 21, 2006 @ 9:54a
i see what you're saying.
so you basically want an account with a high interest rate, no opening and no minimum balance reqs, unlimited withdrawals, and fast transfers in and out to other accounts free.
Use citibank ez-checking and ez-savings account. Direct deposit to your Citi savings account and pour money as needed to your checking account. You will get .05% less interest compared to HSBC, but a lot less hassel IMO.
sensia said: Use citibank ez-checking and ez-savings account. Direct deposit to your Citi savings account and pour money as needed to your checking account. You will get .05% less interest compared to HSBC, but a lot less hassel IMO.
Citi's online savings has the same problem as HSBC...limited to 6 withdrawals a month. so putting it into the savings and transferring to checking as needed wouldn't work.
zoop76
Addicted Member
posted: Jun. 21, 2006 @ 10:07a
Squeezer99 said: sensia said: Use citibank ez-checking and ez-savings account. Direct deposit to your Citi savings account and pour money as needed to your checking account. You will get .05% less interest compared to HSBC, but a lot less hassel IMO.
Citi's online savings has the same problem as HSBC...limited to 6 withdrawals a month. so putting it into the savings and transferring to checking as needed wouldn't work. If you do your transfers from a Citibank ATM, there is no limit.
so you basically want an account with a high interest rate, no opening and no minimum balance reqs, unlimited withdrawals, and ability to transfer in and out to other accounts free.
hmmm...
i don't think this account exists yet.
and i'd also like them to have a local branch office. everybody can dream, right?
zoop76 said: Squeezer99 said: If you do your transfers from a Citibank ATM, there is no limit.
Citibank has no ATM's here. One of the problems living in Jackson, Mississippi is that there are no big banks here, only local and regional bank offices and ATMs.
opmnxtc
Thrifty Member
posted: Jun. 21, 2006 @ 10:19a
how about this:
this seems to me the easiest and quickest method that would work alongside your current setup.
get a line of credit at your local bank. ask them if they will not charge interest unless you have a balance at the end of the next statement, or charge any fees when you use it. so when you need to write checks, transfer money from that credit line to your checking account. then pay the balance by transferring money from paypal to your checking account and then to your line of credit.
otherwise, just get a normal line of credit, use it as above, and then pay the balance off as above asap to minimize the fees and interest charged daily.
mhesidence
Dismembered Member
posted: Jun. 21, 2006 @ 10:22a
Squeezer99 said: For the person recommending the 4.5% checking account, I don't like that you have to keep a minimum balance and they have a large opening requirement.
Presidential checking Plus Min. to open $1500. Min. to avoid Service charge $1000.
I'd be more worried about building up a bit of savings than $20 in interest/year.
Ok rather than negate the Citibank option right away how about doing something similar to what I do. I have multiple accounts with Citi for one, including two of the esavings which are currently at 4.75% and I pay no fees at all. (depends how much $ you have with them)
My check is deposited into my checking account. From there I transfer all of my funds around. Some of my bills are paid through cc in order to rack up bonuses. Those which are, I just tally up the amount and pay my cc from that checking account (through Citi's online payment system.) The amount which is going into savings I transfer into one of my citi 4.75% accounts. I do keep about $100 in a regular savings/mm account between paychecks, in case I need any cash. This way, all bills are paid right away, and my max amount of cash can go towards savings. Sticking with one bank has been easier for me and less loss of float time. Of course this isn't for everyone, but for me it works.
Zon
Senior Member
posted: Jun. 21, 2006 @ 10:40a
If the number of withdrawals from the account is a concern, figure out how you can combine your bills into just a few dates where you will be able to combine the transfers into one amount. Also call the companies to see if you can change your billing date.
I DD my paycheck into netbank MM and whenever I have a bill, I transfer the funds to netbank's checking and use on-line bill pay or write a check. Citibank looks like it has a higher interest rate but you need a $1500 minimum in order to avoid fees compaired to netbank's $250.
cameron2003
Senior Member - 2K
posted: Jun. 21, 2006 @ 11:16a
I am going to do it like this, which I admit isnt optimal, but I might adjust once I get the hang of it. I received an offer frim Ing to open an account with 4.25% with a $25 bonus. I dont think there are any fees or minimums to worry about. I also have MBNA billpay, as well as a checking account through my credit union.
Direct Deposit to Ing Billpay everything I can with my MBNA card Transfer money from Ing to checking for things I cant pay with MBNA Pay my MBNA Card from Ing Balance transfer (I still have 0% offers I can use) if/when I need to for parts of MBNA card. My HELOC is there (empty now) if/when I need it.
To improve this I think Presidential checking and/or a higher interest account than Ing some day.
asdf83
Senior Member
posted: Jun. 21, 2006 @ 11:45a
I second the presidential suggestion. The plan you proposed is pretty terrible. Look at all the transfers you have to do. Your time is worth more than that, plus you lose interest during the transfers, plus some day you’ll make a mistake and pay a fee.
You do have more than 1.5k in HSBC right? use it to open presidential, the difference between keeping this in pres vs HSBC at current rates is $4.50 a year.
Their bill pay is solid, and they don’t remove the funds until the check is cashed unlike many other bill pays.
At the least get rid of one of those accounts and keep a decent amount in checking and only transfer money into it once month.
My opinion anyway.
mhesidence
Dismembered Member
posted: Jun. 21, 2006 @ 11:56a
cameron2003 said:
Pay my MBNA Card from Ing
You cannot do that. ING will complain and MBNA will freeze your card until you call them. MBNA will tell you to use a checking account as the funding source.
cameron2003
Senior Member - 2K
posted: Jun. 21, 2006 @ 12:04p
mhesidence said: cameron2003 said:
Pay my MBNA Card from Ing
You cannot do that. ING will complain and MBNA will freeze your card until you call them. MBNA will tell you to use a checking account as the funding source.
Than why does it have a drop down box for money market as funding source?
You cannot do that. ING will complain and MBNA will freeze your card until you call them. MBNA will tell you to use a checking account as the funding source.
Than why does it have a drop down box for money market as funding source?
He's right. ING doesn't allow this. They ONLY allow push/pull to a checking. I belive some people have had sucess when they opened their ING with another MM/Savings but obviously you can't do that with a credit card.
ING is stricter than others, Emmigrant and Presidential have no problems.
asdf83
Senior Member
posted: Jun. 21, 2006 @ 12:20p
asdf83 said: I second the presidential suggestion. The plan you proposed is pretty terrible. Look at all the transfers you have to do. Your time is worth more than that, plus you lose interest during the transfers, plus some day you’ll make a mistake and pay a fee.
You do have more than 1.5k in HSBC right? use it to open presidential, the difference between keeping this in pres vs HSBC at current rates is $4.50 a year.
Their bill pay is solid, and they don’t remove the funds until the check is cashed unlike many other bill pays.
At the least get rid of one of those accounts and keep a decent amount in checking and only transfer money into it once month.
My opinion anyway.
Oh, I forgot about tax. $4.50 is more like $3.15. Bottom line, these accounts earn very little interest and its not worth sweating too much over the couple k you need to pay the monthly bills.
Seems like you have a little money, I hope you've maxed you're roth ira contribution this year.
AnonymousCoward
Member
posted: Jun. 21, 2006 @ 12:36p
No offense to the original post, but it seems like s/he is being penny wise, pound foolish. I mean if the differential in interest between 4.73% and 4.50% for $1,000 ($2.3/year) is a major sorce of angst for them, they are not using their time properly. I don't even think the difference is that big because of all the time they are going to spend transfering between Paypal and back with no interest. For the sake of your sanity I don't see how keeping the majority in your income at 4.80% and the amount you need for paying bills at 4.50% is going to be worse than losing 2~3 days of interest transfering between paypal and back at 0% interest.
Turn your AC to turn on at 1 degree higher Check the tire pressure on your tires Don't eat out 1 time Drop comprehensive coverage on your insurance (if it makes sense for your situation, YMMV) Put as much as possible into an IRA
Doing these things could all have a larger impact per year than elaborate transfer strategies you are proposing. My goodness if $2.73 is a huge deal for you than I would cancel the internet connection you are typing this on for a month and save 10 times that amount!!!
You cannot do that. ING will complain and MBNA will freeze your card until you call them. MBNA will tell you to use a checking account as the funding source.
Than why does it have a drop down box for money market as funding source?
He's right. ING doesn't allow this. They ONLY allow push/pull to a checking. I belive some people have had sucess when they opened their ING with another MM/Savings but obviously you can't do that with a credit card.
ING is stricter than others, Emmigrant and Presidential have no problems.
Thanks I send off an email to Ing to confirm this. I also noted this:
"...funds that have been on deposit for more than five business days may be withdrawn and additional deposits may be withdrawn after five business days."
5 days seems like a pretty long time to wait before I can get at the funds. What if I have a bill to pay (like mortgage). I am used to having immediate access or next day at least.
unknownshopper
Senior Member<br>6K
posted: Jun. 21, 2006 @ 2:24p
asdf83 said: Bottom line, these accounts earn very little interest and its not worth sweating too much over the couple k you need to pay the monthly bills.
Yep. Doesn't seem to satisfy the "Chipotle Addendum" rule, but I could be wrong.
mhesidence
Dismembered Member
posted: Jun. 21, 2006 @ 2:36p
cameron2003 said: Than why does it have a drop down box for money market as funding source?
FYI ING is a savings account not a money market.
mhesidence
Dismembered Member
posted: Jun. 21, 2006 @ 2:41p
cameron2003 said: 5 days seems like a pretty long time to wait before I can get at the funds. What if I have a bill to pay (like mortgage). I am used to having immediate access or next day at least.
Then your mortgage payment will be late and you'll pay a late fee or find some other way to pay costs money.
cameron2003
Senior Member - 2K
posted: Jun. 21, 2006 @ 2:42p
mhesidence said: cameron2003 said: Than why does it have a drop down box for money market as funding source?
FYI ING is a savings account not a money market.
thanks again, Ing confirmed what you said about paying directly to credit cards too. So I guess I can either transfer to checking, then credit; or try something other than Ing (which is what I am thinking now, either Emigrant or Presidential).
If I transferred to checking to pay I would have to wait 5 days for Ing, then a few more on top of that I suppose before I could even get to it.
asdf83
Senior Member
posted: Jun. 21, 2006 @ 2:58p
cameron2003 said: mhesidence said: cameron2003 said: Than why does it have a drop down box for money market as funding source?
FYI ING is a savings account not a money market.
thanks again, Ing confirmed what you said about paying directly to credit cards too. So I guess I can either transfer to checking, then credit; or try something other than Ing (which is what I am thinking now, either Emigrant or Presidential).
If I transferred to checking to pay I would have to wait 5 days for Ing, then a few more on top of that I suppose before I could even get to it.
Once you put in a transfer from ING (ACH push) it takes usually 2-3 days before its in your checking account. Your checking account should make it available immediatly.
ING isn't the fastest out there. Emmigrant seems to be a day quicker. All my emmigrant to presidential transfers happened overnight.
I havn't used ING in a while. Isn't the 5 day wait only the initial transfer into a new account?
cameron2003
Senior Member - 2K
posted: Jun. 21, 2006 @ 3:01p
asdf83 said: cameron2003 said: mhesidence said: cameron2003 said: Than why does it have a drop down box for money market as funding source?
FYI ING is a savings account not a money market.
thanks again, Ing confirmed what you said about paying directly to credit cards too. So I guess I can either transfer to checking, then credit; or try something other than Ing (which is what I am thinking now, either Emigrant or Presidential).
If I transferred to checking to pay I would have to wait 5 days for Ing, then a few more on top of that I suppose before I could even get to it.
Once you put in a transfer from ING (ACH push) it takes usually 2-3 days before its in your checking account. Your checking account should make it available immediatly.
ING isn't the fastest out there. Emmigrant seems to be a day quicker. All my emmigrant to presidential transfers happened overnight.
I havn't used ING in a while. Isn't the 5 day wait only the initial transfer into a new account?
Initially its 10 days. Here is exactly what they said:
"The initial deposit made into your ING DIRECT account is held for ten (10) business days. Additional deposits to your ING DIRECT Account are held for five (5) business days. This is very similar to other traditional banks.
For example if you contact us on Monday to make a deposit, we send a request to a Clearing House that will communicate with your bank no later than the next business day. Your bank then receives the request from the Clearing House and has up to five (5) business days to respond to the request. Your bank has two available responses, either the funds are available and they send the funds or the funds are not available and deny our request. Once they respond the Clearing House will then notify us of the response. In most cases this process will take up to five (5) business days. You can see the exact date the funds are available for withdrawal by looking directly under the transaction description on your account. When your deposits are on hold, the funds do begin to accrue interest two (2) business days after being processed.
When requesting a withdrawal from your ING DIRECT Account, the funds are usually deposited into your external checking account within two to three business days from your initial request date.
Keep in mind that when any referral or opening bonus is applied to an account, it is not available for withdrawal for 30 days"
1. Direct deposit to HSBC saving account 2. Use free HSBC Billpay (Transfer money between HSBC cheking & saving should be superfast) 3. Set a budget for your daily allowance, transfer your allowance from HSBC to local checking, and keep the rest in HSBC saving account 4. keep your local checking account
markkundinger
Senior Member - 2K
posted: Jun. 21, 2006 @ 9:50p
opmnxtc said: i see what you're saying.
so you basically want an account with a high interest rate, no opening and no minimum balance reqs, unlimited withdrawals, and fast transfers in and out to other accounts free.
How about a brokerage account with Fidelity? Money can sit in money markets earning 4+%, you have checkwriting (admittedly I haven't used the checks yet) and free ACH, no transaction limitations. The Bad News, the nearest physical branch is in Memphis.
You could accomplish similar with a Charles Schwab brokerage and bank account. Free billpay and they offer refunds on all ATM fees, no transaction limitations on either account. They even have an office in Jackson. However, the brokerage has a $2500 minimum balance.
Neither place would be a good place to walk in with rolls of nickels and make a deposit.
opmnxtc
Thrifty Member
posted: Jun. 21, 2006 @ 11:02p
does the fidelity account have opening or minimum balance reqs or monthly fees? or any other requirements? these questions are in regard to just opening the account normally, without any bonuses or such. i can't really tell from reading the whole thread on it so far.
Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.
Members of our community may attach files to a post in accordance with the User Agreement. FatWallet is not responsible for the content, accuracy, completeness or validity of any information contained in any attached file. Files have *not* been scanned for viruses. Be especially wary of Excel files which may contain malicious content.