fleetwoodmac said: Here are my questions about AOR
1) How many months/days should I wait after I payoff the previous BTs. Or does it hurt to aply for credit cards while carying huge debt?
2) If I am making $75K but declare $93K, how would they find out? Do they ever check or how would they check my salary anyway? Is it possible to declare say $135K, would that trigger an audit?
3) What is the ratio of how much I can borrow and CLI I can get vs my income? Is there such a ratio? In other words, is it possible to get $100K worth of BT while my HHI is $100K?
4) I have some business cards but none of them has a promotion for 0% BT offer. How can I utilize them? I do not have a business by the way.
1. Wait until the balances update on your reports. It does hurt to apply with high utilization/dti.
2. Not many issuers ask for financials/tax returns these days. This practice is not recommended because if you ever file for BK the debt may become non-dischargeable because of the fraud used to gain the credit. (not likely but thats what the moral police will tell you) For the most part there is zero risk.
3. This varies with each lender. There are people who have 500K of credit with less than 50K in HHI. This is becoming harder and harder but can still be done if you pick the right card issuers. My spouse has about 200K in credit and 0 income.
4. It depends who the biz card issuer is. Some issuers allow you to move the CL to another card that has a BT offer, biz or personal. Dont overlook using cards that have 0% APR for purchases instead of BTs and using the card to purchase dollar coins.
JAGLUR said: Would getting a car loan 1~2 month ahead of AOR hurt my chances of approvals in AOR? Or it wouldn't matter much as it's a secured loan? I don't think it would matter much unless your reports get a shotgun blast of inquiries from seeking financing at a dealer. This shouldn't happen if you have good enough credit to be considering an AOR but to make sure get financing set up prior to going to the dealer. Definitely do not wait until after an AOR to get a car loan, your scores are most likely going to take a dump once you start pulling the trigger on apps and continue to fall as your new accounts and balances are updated.
So is anyone on here doing full blown AOR's where they're getting six figures in BT money? I've been putting off doing another since the economy tanked. I figure at best my credit report will have just that much time to recover anyways. So is anyone really active on this and not doing small rolling AOR's?
retmilunless your reports get a shotgun blast of i said: nquiries from seeking financing at a dealer.
Maybe I am missing something, so if you seek financing at a dealer you get a bunch of inquiries? At this point, since i am still showing AOR balances here and there my score isn't super.
JAGLUR said: retmil unless your reports get a shotgun blast of said: inquiries from seeking financing at a dealer.
Maybe I am missing something, so if you seek financing at a dealer you get a bunch of inquiries? At this point, since i am still showing AOR balances here and there my score isn't super. It can happen if they need to shop your app around to get an approval or to get an approval for an interest rate you'll accept. I would definitely get financing arranged before you go to a dealer. The Penfed 3.9% deal is popular and it's easy enough to get an approval. You will still likely get one inquiry at the dealer to "verify your identity" which really means check for fraud.
retmil said: JAGLUR said: retmil unless your reports get a shotgun blast of said: ]inquiries from seeking financing at a dealer.
Maybe I am missing something, so if you seek financing at a dealer you get a bunch of inquiries? At this point, since i am still showing AOR balances here and there my score isn't super. It can happen if they need to shop your app around to get an approval or to get an approval for an interest rate you'll accept. I would definitely get financing arranged before you go to a dealer. The Penfed 3.9% deal is popular and it's easy enough to get an approval. You will still likely get one inquiry at the dealer to "verify your identity" which really means check for fraud. If it's truly just a query for identity verification rather than pulling a credit report, then it should be a soft inquiry, not a hard inquiry. The former won't ding your FICO score with whatever bureau they use for the identity check.
I plan to apply for a few cards while showing a 0% BT $35000 balance with B of A on personal report. Recent activity regarding the expedited CARD Act 2009 have forced my hand (excerpt: The Financial Services Committee unanimously passed H.R. 3639, the Expedited CARD Reform for Consumers Act of 2009, which would move up the effective date for credit card reforms from February 22 to December 1.)
I'll edit this post with my details as they come in. Adverse action from Citi and B of A leaves CHASE, Wells Fargo and FifthThird to draw from.
1) I opened a BankAtlantic card last year and I am paying it off early (in the next 3 days). I will close existing card and reapply for a new one. 2) 1st Southwest Bank of Alamosa CO gave MrsJ an $18000 limit and immediately closed her account AFTER her $16000 BT posted. I plan on applying with them. 3) I plan to apply for the OptionsXPress card. I have 29800 of biz credit with them and 13000 of personal credit. I'll try the "denied-request-CLI-to-loan-review" gimmick and see if I can get at least the personal lines consolidated.
0 EQ pulled. Applied and received card within 14 days. Immediately requested BT.
1 On 12/1/2009 rep advised that credit underwriting canceled the InsurBanc application due to one app already was being underwritten (1st Southwest application).
2 TU pulled. Closed an existing BankAtlantic Biz card to take advatage of a new 13 month term (I applied after the 13 month link was dead but will use pdf printouts of my DW's 13 month Sept 2009 application to hopefully argue for an added 7 months of 0%)
3 EQ pulled. After 5-6 attempts to consolidate an existing CHASE Sony line, I relented and settled for the meager $5k limit. Unfortunately, on my application I asked to BT $35,000 from another card - they processed a partial BT without my approval. At 3% aftertax earnings, I'll make roughly $46 from this card. Yuck!
4 EX pulled. Applied online for my 3rd wells fargo card. Back in 2008, I closed my 2007 card with them to get a new cycle of BT money (details here). I tried it again this year and they chopped my 2008 card line down from 24500 to just 3000 (denied my 2009 application).
5 EQ pulled. Called and they had to mail a paper consolidation form which I faxed in consolidating a 2007 card with a $15,000 line into the newly approved $5,000 LifeSpring card.
JAGLUR said: Would getting a car loan 1~2 month ahead of AOR hurt my chances of approvals in AOR? Or it wouldn't matter much as it's a secured loan?
I was approved for a car loan of up to $26,000 from Penfed about a month before I launched my AOR. My approval expires on December 8th. It should be interesting to see if the honor it after I pull six figures of balance transfer money out of my credit cards.
jameshasty said: JAGLUR said: Would getting a car loan 1~2 month ahead of AOR hurt my chances of approvals in AOR? Or it wouldn't matter much as it's a secured loan?
I was approved for a car loan of up to $26,000 from Penfed about a month before I launched my AOR. My approval expires on December 8th. It should be interesting to see if the honor it after I pull six figures of balance transfer money out of my credit cards. Interesting, I would assume that you pulled out your AOR before actually taking car loan and it wasn't showing on your cr other than just a single inquiry. =) I will do my AOR after new installment account hits as I am afraid I might miss a good deal on 09 models+financing deals.
jackcrawfish said: 2) 1st Southwest Bank of Alamosa CO gave MrsJ an $18000 limit and immediately closed her account AFTER her $16000 BT posted. I plan on applying with them.
MyDW got approved for similar CL recently and we planed to do BT sooner than later. I think they allow BT only after you activate it. How soon was it closed after BT initiation? (Do they e-transfer or send a check?) Thanks,
JAGLUR said: jackcrawfish said: 2) 1st Southwest Bank of Alamosa CO gave MrsJ an $18000 limit and immediately closed her account AFTER her $16000 BT posted. I plan on applying with them.
MyDW got approved for similar CL recently and we planed to do BT sooner than later. I think they allow BT only after you activate it. How soon was it closed after BT initiation? (Do they e-transfer or send a check?) Thanks,She initiated a BT on the day the card arrived (there was $0 debt reporting on her bureau at the time of BT request).
The account was closed very quickly. In fact, TransUnion still hasn't reported the tradeline at all. EX and EQ both show it as closed.
At this point, my DW doesn't care about reopen since she has the $16k for arbitrage....
retmil said: jackcrawfish said: 1) I opened a BankAtlantic card last year and I am paying it off early (in the next 3 days). I will close existing card and reapply for a new one. All the 13 month BA links seem to be redirected to 6 months now.I saw that post last night. Yep. Verified the link does read 6 months now.
At 3% after tax APY, I'd net almost $200 after the $99 fee gets paid....
I just finished a mini-AOR and I have mostly bad news. 1. US bank no longer does consolidations. $25K is the max line and $22,500 is the max BT 2. Citibank denied me for a professional card. Even after I had closed my $63K credit line with them 3. Chase will not do more than $30K toital in BTs or checks within 90 days (as per CSR)
I am down to $50K in BT cash (with a pending app for the coast-to-coast barclay's card) Between me and the wife (she got in before the Chase limits) we have only $170K. Just under 2 years ago we had over $1,000,000 of free money. So it goes.
cameron2003 said: Here is an AOR I started a few weeks ago. Still in progress:
APR Mo. BT Fee BT Fee Issuer Card Thread Apply Notes 0% 12 3% $50 Barclays I Fly America card APPROVED - $5,000; Consolidated to $13k 0% 12 2% $30 BofA NEA Platinum Plus APPROVED - $5,000; Consolidated to $7400 0% 12 3% $75 Chase Disney Rewards DENIED 0% 12 $0 $0 Citi Drivers Edge Optns Plat Sel APPROVED - $7,300; Consolidated to $18,100 0% 12 $0 $0 US Bank TheLinuxFund.org APPROVED - $15,000 0% 12 3% $99 Wachovia Visa Platinum DENIED 0% 12 3% $75 USAA Total Rewards World APPROVED - $25,000 (Invitation) 0% 12 3% $75 USAA American Express APPROVED - $25,000 (Invitation)
0% 15 3% $75 Barclays BankAtlantic Business Card DENIED 0% 12 $0 $0 Citi CitiBusiness Card with TYN DENIED
Both my business cards were denied.I'm curious to know whether you had any adverse action? This spree was from June this year and I'm wondering whether USBank and/or USAA chopped any lines down for you?
jackcrawfish said: cameron2003 said: Here is an AOR I started a few weeks ago. Still in progress:
APR Mo. BT Fee BT Fee Issuer Card Thread Apply Notes 0% 12 3% $50 Barclays I Fly America card APPROVED - $5,000; Consolidated to $13k 0% 12 2% $30 BofA NEA Platinum Plus APPROVED - $5,000; Consolidated to $7400 0% 12 3% $75 Chase Disney Rewards DENIED 0% 12 $0 $0 Citi Drivers Edge Optns Plat Sel APPROVED - $7,300; Consolidated to $18,100 0% 12 $0 $0 US Bank TheLinuxFund.org APPROVED - $15,000 0% 12 3% $99 Wachovia Visa Platinum DENIED 0% 12 3% $75 USAA Total Rewards World APPROVED - $25,000 (Invitation) 0% 12 3% $75 USAA American Express APPROVED - $25,000 (Invitation)
0% 15 3% $75 Barclays BankAtlantic Business Card DENIED 0% 12 $0 $0 Citi CitiBusiness Card with TYN DENIED
Both my business cards were denied.I'm curious to know whether you had any adverse action? This spree was from June this year and I'm wondering whether USBank and/or USAA chopped any lines down for you?
USAA and US Bank didn't do anything. I have adverse actions galore from BofA and Chase. Cut lines and cancelled cards. I got 8 Chase letters in one day a few weeks ago about cut lines. Oh well.
Anyone with any RECENT experience or knowledge about doing a $30K-$50K BT into an empty Chase CC account from another credit card like BankAtlantic, etc?
Would Chase freak out and initiate AA or would it be a smooth refund check mailed or direct deposit process?
Posted this in the newbie thread and nobody cared, so trying here as I'm considering an "Un-AOR/Cancel-o-Rama"...
I have over 30 CCs (mostly personal, some biz) including the wife's handful, very many obtained over a couple of AORs in the previous few years. With the chance of existing cards tossing worthwhile offers my way surely being nil, I'd just as well not have the "maintenance" of all these cards, or make my wife faint when she opens up the "master info doc" if I pass. Losing the ability to consolidate/reallocate and the general landscape makes scaling back the obvious choice for me. There's about 5 we use in the ol' optimal reward rotation, and then when I put the rest into piles I get 9 to keep with various reasoning and 11 to cancel (Discover Gas in Jan would make 12).
CreditKarma score at 751, I got a new mortgage in April and have no need for my credit score...would like to keep all the accounts I decide I want to keep is about it. Should I stagger the cancellations, request CLIs on cards I'm keeping before/after, by issuer? Or the hell with it and just do whatever? The total CL I cancel for personal may barely reach 10% of my overall looking at the stack; there's several business cards here.
If this matter is of any interest at all, I can make a new thread with more detail chronicling the process...
specmaker said: ColbyS said: MaddHatter said: If this matter is of any interest at all, I can make a new thread with more detail chronicling the process...Vote +1Vote +2Vote +3
I like the idea very much.
It will be very interesting to discuss the issuers you have currently and draw strategize with you on your "UN-AOR"
jackcrawfish said: specmaker said: ColbyS said: MaddHatter said: If this matter is of any interest at all, I can make a new thread with more detail chronicling the process...Vote +1Vote +2Vote +3
I like the idea very much.
It will be very interesting to discuss the issuers you have currently and draw strategize with you on your "UN-AOR"
Wowsers, alrighty then. I'll post a thread later tonight (and edit this post with its location) after compiling all the wonderful relevant data.
I think its a great idea also. I just finished closing a bunch of accounts (I had over 70 when you add in the wife
No retention offers at all. Only discover even asked me if I was sure I wanted to close them. Only a few even asked why. That's 40 cards among Citi, Chase, Discover, Cap One, (biz and personal for those 4) US bank, PNC, Mechanics, Commerce Bank, UMB, Bank of the West, Vectra Bank of America and AMEX were wife only, I'm keeping my $170K limit cards There are probably a couple I forgot And not a single offer. VanceWade said: Great idea. I will be very curious to see if/which rentention offers they make available to you.
devildoc said: I think its a great idea also. I just finished closing a bunch of accounts (I had over 70 when you add in the wife
No retention offers at all. Only discover even asked me if I was sure I wanted to close them. Only a few even asked why. That's 40 cards among Citi, Chase, Discover, Cap One, (biz and personal for those 4) US bank, PNC, Mechanics, Commerce Bank, UMB, Bank of the West, Vectra Bank of America and AMEX were wife only, I'm keeping my $170K limit cards There are probably a couple I forgot And not a single offer. VanceWade said: Great idea. I will be very curious to see if/which rentention offers they make available to you.
I'll presume these were so recent so as not to be able to say what AA resulted? Looks like you put a tidbit in my Un-AOR thread QS, thanks. But also please share in that thread if at any point you do experience any fallout from you cancellations (as I surely will).
I did a 20K BT from BankAtlantic to a Bank of America card with 0 balance but when I called BOA to get a refund of the negative balance I was told that they'll have to send the funds back to its origin not to me. They will not send a check to me or do a direct deposit to my checking account.
Any thoughts on this and how to overcome this obstacle?
JimboUS said: I did a 20K BT from BankAtlantic to a Bank of America card with 0 balance but when I called BOA to get a refund of the negative balance I was told that they'll have to send the funds back to its origin not to me. They will not send a check to me or do a direct deposit to my checking account.
Any thoughts on this and how to overcome this obstacle?
How many reps did you talk to? Are you sure it's not a check TO YOU instead of DD?
I spoke to one and she put me on hold to check. She came back and she said it is against BOA policy to give me the funds. I asked for a check to me and she said no, and after I asked for DD, also no.
A year ago they send me a check for overpaying but it was for around $100.
JimboUS said: I spoke to one and she put me on hold to check. She came back and she said it is against BOA policy to give me the funds. I asked for a check to me and she said no, and after I asked for DD, also no.
A year ago they send me a check for overpaying but it was for around $100.
If anyone has any ideas please post.
I had a similar experience with US bank 2 months ago.
But that was a genuie overpayment. They insisted in returning the fund to the source. No problem for me.
APR Mo. BT Fee BT Fee Issuer Card Thread Apply Notes 0% 12 $0 $0 Citi Drivers Edge Optns Plat Sel APPROVED - $7,300; Consolidated to $18,100
cameron, what was the method you or others have used to successfully consolidate a Citi credit line over to a 0% Citi card? I must have called 5 times after a recent aor and every rep I got said they couldn't do any credit line movement from one Citi card to a Citi card with a 0% offer on it.
APR Mo. BT Fee BT Fee Issuer Card Thread Apply Notes 0% 12 $0 $0 Citi Drivers Edge Optns Plat Sel APPROVED - $7,300; Consolidated to $18,100
cameron, what was the method you or others have used to successfully consolidate a Citi credit line over to a 0% Citi card? I must have called 5 times after a recent aor and every rep I got said they couldn't do any credit line movement from one Citi card to a Citi card with a 0% offer on it.
Maybe they changed, I called once and they did it, back in June.
The method that may work is to request a CLI on the 0% card, get denied, appeal to a credit analyst, then accept their suggestion to transfer credit line from another card. This costs a credit inquiry and is YMMV.
MaddHatter said: Posted this in the newbie thread and nobody cared, so trying here as I'm considering an "Un-AOR/Cancel-o-Rama"...
I have over 30 CCs (mostly personal, some biz) including the wife's handful, very many obtained over a couple of AORs in the previous few years. With the chance of existing cards tossing worthwhile offers my way surely being nil, I'd just as well not have the "maintenance" of all these cards, or make my wife faint when she opens up the "master info doc" if I pass. Losing the ability to consolidate/reallocate and the general landscape makes scaling back the obvious choice for me. There's about 5 we use in the ol' optimal reward rotation, and then when I put the rest into piles I get 9 to keep with various reasoning and 11 to cancel (Discover Gas in Jan would make 12).
CreditKarma score at 751, I got a new mortgage in April and have no need for my credit score...would like to keep all the accounts I decide I want to keep is about it. Should I stagger the cancellations, request CLIs on cards I'm keeping before/after, by issuer? Or the hell with it and just do whatever? The total CL I cancel for personal may barely reach 10% of my overall looking at the stack; there's several business cards here.
If this matter is of any interest at all, I can make a new thread with more detail chronicling the process...
I notice the CITI Identity monitor computes my average line of credit and states this is a positive (higher the better). My average is pulled down because I have a number of cards with $100 limits. These once had bigger limits but I had asked that the lines be reallocated, leaving a minimum in case there were attractive offers or for some other reason I wanted to use these cards again.
If it is true that having a high average ine is good, I (and probably many others) could raise our averages by canceling some of these cards. Would that be wise (usual caveat about not canceling cards with a long history). any advice as to whether that might be wise?
I notice the CITI Identity monitor computes my average line of credit and states this is a positive (higher the better). My average is pulled down because I have a number of cards with $100 limits. These once had bigger limits but I had asked that the lines be reallocated, leaving a minimum in case there were attractive offers or for some other reason I wanted to use these cards again.
If it is true that having a high average ine is good, I (and probably many others) could raise our averages by canceling some of these cards. Would that be wise (usual caveat about not canceling cards with a long history). any advice as to whether that might be wise? It may be good for some issuers internal scoring or be beneficial in a manual review but having high average lines is not something Fico claims is a factor for your score. I wouldn't close cards to raise my average.
Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.
Members of our community may attach files to a post in accordance with the User Agreement. FatWallet is not responsible for the content, accuracy, completeness or validity of any information contained in any attached file. Files have *not* been scanned for viruses. Be especially wary of Excel files which may contain malicious content.