I just saw this on GigaOM:Skype backer takes on ETrade with free trades
Morten Lund, the guy who was the earliest backers of Skype is at it again. He has financed Zecco, a start-up that will allow consumers to trade stocks for zero commissions, versus $10 to $20 that many online brokers charge today. Other investors in the company include former Dutch Coca Cola CEO Pier Baarsma and Soren Kenner former chairman of McCann Erickson MRM Europe
CEO Jeroen Veth, a 37 year old entrepreneur and former Merrill Lynch Vice President is heading up the company and contends that most of the old school online brokers spend too heavily on marketing and thus have to charge higher prices. Lund and crew believe that the actual trade costs about $2 and if they can lower the cost of marketing to near zero, they can offer zero commission trading. They will make money with what else - advertising.
"Our model is different. We run a lean operation, use the latest technology and rely entirely on word of mouth, guerilla marketing, viral campaigns and public relations to get the message out. As a result we can look at the $2 per trade as the cost of doing business – and still turn a tidy profit"
Zecco, in company’s own words is at “the intersection where online brokerage meets Yahoo Finance and Myspace,” and offers tools such as free blogging, forums etc. The big question is can they make it happen? My gut says that there will be some who will be attracted to this service because of its free nature.
Others will show up at the service because of the forums, and the community, and many are already looking for options to Yahoo Forums. In the long run this could cause old school companies to look at their own pricing structures hard and lower their prices. But can Zecco be the next ETrade, well not sure about that. What do you think?Seems that the service is about 18 days away from going live. Zecco
I'm waiting for the one that literally comes with a free lunch.
mikekosten
Member
posted: Sep. 21, 2006 @ 1:29p
It says you can open an account on 10/9...free is free! It would be nice if they give you some free money to invest too, no?
xerty
Senior Member - 2K
posted: Sep. 21, 2006 @ 1:30p
Sounds like they included all the right buzzwords - maybe I can buy into their IPO before anyone notices they aren't making money . FWIW, there are plenty of ways to lose money to your broker besides the $10/trade commission. You can get "bad fills" (a little worse price than the real market price), and since this difference is often a proportional cost (ie fraction of the share price), it can be more important than the fixed cost commission when trading lots of shares.
b0mbrman
Broke Member
posted: Sep. 21, 2006 @ 3:00p
Sweet, this is what I've been waiting for.
I'm gonna buy $1000 worth of the S&P 500...as each of the 500 individual stocks
LH2004
Frivolous Member
posted: Sep. 21, 2006 @ 3:12p
b0mbrman said: I'm gonna buy $1000 worth of the S&P 500...as each of the 500 individual stocks You jest, but that's what I'd love to be able to do -- and constantly sell whatever's down and hold whatever's up, to create a great big capital loss machine.
But I forsee this heading the same place as everyone who's tried it before. And remember, it's going to be some serious commissions to get rid of all those stocks with somebody else.
b0mbrman
Broke Member
posted: Sep. 21, 2006 @ 8:04p
LH2004 said: b0mbrman said: I'm gonna buy $1000 worth of the S&P 500...as each of the 500 individual stocks You jest, but that's what I'd love to be able to do -- and constantly sell whatever's down and hold whatever's up, to create a great big capital loss machine.
But I forsee this heading the same place as everyone who's tried it before. And remember, it's going to be some serious commissions to get rid of all those stocks with somebody else.
Oh, I'd love to do it in all seriousness, as well.
Or, alternatively, own different market sectors (S&P 500, small cap, developed int'l, emerging markets, etc.) in ETFs and rebalance every week.
b0mbrman said: Or, alternatively, own different market sectors (S&P 500, small cap, developed int'l, emerging markets, etc.) in ETFs and rebalance every week.If you're dealing with baskets that large and trading that infrequently, you can afford to pay some more substantial commissions. Trading, say, 10 times a week, or about 500 a year, with a portfolio of, say, $200,000, MBTrading- or sogoinvest-level commissions would be pretty tolerable as a fraction of assets. I'd love to be trading individual stocks, maximizing security-specific volatility, trading maybe 1000 times a week, just for the sake of realizing losses for tax purposes; even $1 a trade would then be pretty outrageous.
This aught to be intresting. Free trades have been tried before. I wonder what makes them think it will work or do they even care. From what I understand they already have a website and are just adding the feature that will allow trades.
Also if they are going to pay the bills with advertising then the customer has to pay by being bombarded with pop-ups and flash ads while they are trying to decide on which stock to pick. I will keep and open mind though.
russler
New Member
posted: Sep. 22, 2006 @ 2:53p
Maybe this is just designed to get a lot of us to check out their website. A short period of free trades to build the community. Then, over time the free trades go away, but still some people stick around for their forums and other services which they have found useful. Not a bad ploy if you ask me. And they still have all of your information for marketing purposes long after free trades are a vague memory.
Sweet deal!
codename47
Senior Member - 3K
posted: Sep. 22, 2006 @ 4:35p
Reminds me of freetrad.com from Ameritrade. I need to hear a more compelling reason than just free trades to get me over there. Super low margin rates, high credit interest rates, something...
TTrader
New Member
posted: Sep. 25, 2006 @ 1:59p
Sounds right on the money Russler. I think I am going to go with sogo. At least I know the CEO William Yeh knows what he is talking about. I just checked him out and he has a huge background with the market. He already has a company that handles high volume trades for huge companies called genesis securities. He created sogoinvest to offer these same discount cost per trade prices to the individual investor. Who is creating zecco? and what is their purpose? That is what i want to know.
b0mbrman
Broke Member
posted: Sep. 25, 2006 @ 2:11p
TTrader said: Sounds right on the money Russler. I think I am going to go with sogo. At least I know the CEO William Yeh knows what he is talking about. I just checked him out and he has a huge background with the market. He already has a company that handles high volume trades for huge companies called genesis securities. He created sogoinvest to offer these same discount cost per trade prices to the individual investor. Who is creating zecco? and what is their purpose? That is what i want to know.
Morten Lund, the guy who was the earliest backers of Skype is at it again. He has financed Zecco.... Other investors in the company include former Dutch Coca Cola CEO Pier Baarsma and Soren Kenner former chairman of McCann Erickson MRM Europe
CEO Jeroen Veth, a 37 year old entrepreneur and former Merrill Lynch Vice President is heading up the company....
Anybody sign up for this yet? The website seems a little slow, probably because its opening day. I am going to sign up later today and I will let you know what I think about the site.
Sam506
Thrifty Member
posted: Oct. 9, 2006 @ 9:17a
Yes, I signed up early this morning. The 2500 initial deposit is not that big a deal for the amount of trades I do per year. Still have to mail in the signed form (14 pages to read) and make the deposit. It was an easy setup though (probably 10 minutes total). I plan to try this for a while. Will have Ameritrade account and this for a while to compare. May them move everything to Izone or IB if not happy with Zecco. Love Ameritrade though (6 years in it), just too expensive with more discounts available.
Good luck to you.
honghong322
Thrifty Member
posted: Oct. 9, 2006 @ 9:23a
I just held off and I put money into the Sogo account. Since I don't trade a lot the 3 dollar trades won't kill me.
Dracolith
Senior Member
posted: Oct. 9, 2006 @ 9:42a
honghong322 said: I just held off and I put money into the Sogo account. Since I don't trade a lot the 3 dollar trades won't kill me.
I agree; i'm figuring i'll just sub to Sogo at the Gold level, and use 5 automatic trades a month.
The ability to buy small amounts of fractional shares is worth the small price, IMO. Especially to invest $200 month evenly into stocks that happen to have a high-share price.. some as high as $3,000/share; no way to do that with Zecco, afaik, yet.
scanchain
Senior Member
posted: Oct. 9, 2006 @ 12:23p
Dracolith said: Not everything free, $3.50/trade after 40 trades in a month.
High margin interest, high opening balance of $2,500.
misc fees $75 for an ACAT. Seems like they dropped the ACAT fee to $50.
kevin7776
New Member
posted: Oct. 9, 2006 @ 1:27p
they have been talking about zecco on cnbc on and off all day
There are few things that I think it is wise not to shop for based on price alone, major surgery being one example and stock brokers being the other.
Maybe they will be ok for certain folks (small trade sizes where commissions really add up) but I think in the long run most people would be better off with one of the name brand discount retail brokers (Ameritrade et al) or direct access brokers (interactive broker, MBT).
adityanm
Happy Member
posted: Oct. 9, 2006 @ 9:23p
scanchain said: Seems like they dropped the ACAT fee to $50. It still does not tell if it is for incoming or outgoing transfers or both. It also does not tell me what happens if my balance is less than $2500.
adityanm
Happy Member
posted: Oct. 9, 2006 @ 9:35p
Ivanist said: The service is not going to last long. The only they will survive is to get huge volume.
The service is already lousy and system full of bugs. I tried to open an account and it haanged up my computer while trying to save my application. I had to reboot my computer and I am afraid if it may happen again while I am trying to trade.
scanchain
Senior Member
posted: Oct. 9, 2006 @ 9:44p
adityanm said: scanchain said: Seems like they dropped the ACAT fee to $50. It still does not tell if it is for incoming or outgoing transfers or both. It also does not tell me what happens if my balance is less than $2500.You could ask them but a fee for ACAT is usually for outgoing only. I haven't heard of a brokerage that charges for an incoming ACAT.
nuid
Senior Member
posted: Oct. 10, 2006 @ 2:21p
Margin rates as well as the interest they pay on cash balances are very unfavorable.
Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.
Members of our community may attach files to a post in accordance with the User Agreement. FatWallet is not responsible for the content, accuracy, completeness or validity of any information contained in any attached file. Files have *not* been scanned for viruses. Be especially wary of Excel files which may contain malicious content.