Edit

Forums
Finance

Retail Cash Management Products FAQ Archived From: Finance

  • tweet this
  • Post to Facebook
  • Text Only
  • Search this Topic »
  • Classic
alert mods    

We will keep this thread to Retail Cash Management Products unless people want to learn about institutional ones also. Reason why I recommend sticking to retail ones for most people on this board is because they can be bought at many places with small min buy in. While institutional ones in general require either a Private Bank account or investment banking account and require much larger min buy in.

Retail Cash Management Products Defined:

An Auction Rate Security (ARS) is a debt instrument with a long-term nominal maturity for which the interest rate is reset through a dutch auction process, which resets the coupon rate (or dividend rate). Auctions are typically held every 1, 7, 28, or 35 days; interest on these securities is paid at the end of each auction period, or based on a separate schedule. In a dutch auction, a broker-dealer submits bids, on behalf of current and prospective investors, to the auction agent. Based on the submitted bids, the auction agent will set the next interest rate by determining the lowest rate to clear the total outstanding amount of ARS.
ARS holders do not have the right to put their securities back to the issuer; as a result no bank liquidity facility is required.
As bank liquidity has become more expensive, the auction market has become increasingly attractive to issuers seeking the low cost and flexibility of variable rate debt.

Pros and Cons of Auction Rate Securities

For issuers, ARS offer low financing cost, in some cases more attractive than traditional variable rate debt obligations (VDROs). No third-party bank support is required, and there are typically fewer parties to the financing process. ARS eliminates renewal risk and the risk of increased fees. There is no exposure to bank rating downgrades, and ARS offer the same flexibility found in traditional VRDOs.

For buyers, ARS provide a slightly higher after tax yield/ taxable yeild than money market instruments due to their complexity. Most securities are AAA rated as well as federal, state and local tax exempt but there are taxable version as well. They also provide an opportunity to diversify one's cash equivalent holdings. They require much lower min purchase amounts over VRDO's.

Some negative aspects of ARS include lower liquidity and potential drops in the coupon rate. Lower rate then VRDO's.

Auction Rate Securities Overview

The interest rate on ARS is determinded through a Dutch auction process. The total number of shares available to auction at any given period is determined by the number of existing bond holders who wish to sell or hold bonds only at a minimum yield. Existing holders and potential investors enter a competitive bidding process through broker/dealer(s). Buyers specify the number of shares, in denominations of $25,000, they wish to purchase with the lowest interest rate they are willing to accept.Each bid and order size is ranked from lowest to highest minimum bid rate. The lowest bid rate at which all the shares can be sold at par establishes the interest rate, otherwise known as the “clearing rate”. This rate is paid on the entire issue for the upcoming period. Investors who bid a minimum rate above the clearing rate receive no bonds, while those whose minimum bid rates were at or below the clearing rate receive the clearing rate for the next period.

Most places like Fidelity, Etrade, Scwaab, Citibank, BOA do not allow you enter a competitive bid unless your buying a large block normally over $1Million.

There are is something else called a Prefered auction rate securities theses are offered by Pimco, Nueven and Blackrock. I would stay away from these as you are buying debt from closed ended bond funds.

Just like anything else depending on where you buy your ARS from the rates will vary. I buy some from Citigroup and there rates tend to be ok. I have noticed some time Fidelity rates are better tho. And as the rate is based by demand rate leader can change from place to place. But both Citibank and Fidelity will tell you expected yeild so if you dont like what you hear you can always sell your position in 1 ARS and swap to another. I personally dont bother as I would be switching position more than likely every week.

Fidelity shows you there inventory online. You goto research then fixed income then under Muni hit resets to see current day offers. They only show you inventory tho durning market hours. Citibank requires you either call your assigned broker or an 800 number to get info on them.

Currently these instruments are yeilding taxable rates between 5.18-5.33% from Citibank. Remember bonds are quoted as a rate so you need to compound them yourself or compare them savings account APR and not APY which is compouded.

Fell free to ask any questions I will try to answer them as best I can.

BTW this are super low risk. In 20 years they have been offered there has never been 1 issue that has defaulted nor a failed auction. But I am sure either is possible.


Fidelity's Municipal Resets New Issue Offerings sorted by Next Anticipated Rate

Fidelity as Reported by Sushiosushi now allows Buy at Bid and Hold at Bid for all orders. No idea when they started to allow this as I dont buy my mine via Fidelity but when FAQ was orginally started Fidelity like Citigroup only allowed that option on large block orders.

Purchasing through Fidelity:
No fees/commissions for purchasing and selling municipal resets. You can do this through your Fidelity Account at no charge.
HUGE HUGE HUGE RISK OF FAILED AUCTIONS, THE CONSEQUENCE OF WHICH IS YOUR MONEY MAYBE LOCKED UP LONGER THAN YOU ANTICIPATED. And, possibly, actual defaults and loss of principal.

Read the entire thread before you invest. (Feb 14, 2008)

AGREED, YOU MAY LOSE ALL INTEREST AND PRINCIPAL! The ARS market appears to be melting down and THE ORIGINAL POST NO LONGER REPRESENTS THE VERY HIGH RISK! Do not purchase a "reset" without knowing everything about the underlying issuer, insurer, and underwriter! (Feb 14, 2008)

DO YOUR RESEARCH RESOURCES
RATING AGENCIES: Fitch Moodys Standard and Poors
INSURERS: ACA AGC AMBAC CIFG FGIC FSA MBIA Radian XL Capital
MARKET DATA: SIFMA ARS Indices SIFMA 7-Day ARS Index @ Bloomberg

SIFMA ARS Information

Message edited by: bejota3 on 2008-03-10 08:40:11 CDT
alert mods    

So basically if we dont have 1mil+ to play with this isnt for us?


alert mods    

davef139 said:So basically if we dont have 1mil+ to play with this isnt for us?

If by 1 million plus you mean $25,000, then yes, this isn't for you.

For that matter, if you can't tell the difference between $25,000 and $1,000,000 then this probably isn't for you anyway.


alert mods    

The OP says: "Most places like Fidelity, Etrade, Scwaab, Citibank, BOA do not allow you enter a competitive bid unless your buying a large block normally over $1 Million." So where exactly can you get say just one $25,000 share?


alert mods    

Grobe said:The OP says: "Most places like Fidelity, Etrade, Scwaab, Citibank, BOA do not allow you enter a competitive bid unless your buying a large block normally over $1 Million." So where exactly can you get say just one $25,000 share?

OP says: Buyers specify the number of shares, in denominations of $25,000, they wish to purchase with the lowest interest rate they are willing to accept.


Investors should pay close attention to the minimum required investment which is typically $25,000.


alert mods    

$1million = Submit a bid through a broker for a block of shares at an interest rate you specify.
$25,000 = Buy ARS that broker has purchased in auction

This the correct distinction?


alert mods    

Sorry if I was not clear.

You can buy ARS with as little as $25K.

If you want to submit a competitive bid tho most brokers require you to buy a min block of $1 million. Same way T-Bill works for small purchases you can not enter a competitive bid but have to accept the clearing price.

So for example when I buy them from Citigroup in small blocks I get choice to buy or sell or hold. If I was to place a buy order for a block of a $1 Million I could enter a min yield I am willing to accept and if the clearing price is below what I entered for min yeild I am willing to accept my position will be liquidated for me or not purchased. So maybe I enter 5.25% as my min bid. So my order gets filled this week as clearing price is 5.30% but next week the clearing price is 5.15% and my position gets liquidated then following week clearing price is 5.27% and my position gets filled again.


alert mods    

Smith Barney Web page explaining ARS in details

Here is a better explanation of how ARS work and how Citigroup runs them. This web page is from SB web page. Only things I can see different from CPB and SB is that SB web page does not mention you are required to buy $1 Million + blocks to be allow to place "Hold order at a rate" and "Buy at Rate" orders. So it might be very possible that SB has the same rules that CPB does. I know Fidelity web page does not let you place a competitive bid at all. You have to call over the phone and they allow large block buyers to place them.


alert mods    

What are the current going rates on this type of investment?


alert mods    

Look at the URL in ScootyPuffSr's post and click on See Current offerings. Most seem to be tax exempt and thus have the lower tax-exempt type rates.


alert mods    

superdrew said:What are the current going rates on this type of investment?

There are 3 different ARS listed on Fidelity web page and I see 7 on Citigroup page.

Highest yeild today is on Fidelity web page at 5.20% Citibank highest yeild today is listed at 5.18%. Yesterday tho both Citibank and Fidelity had issues for 5.26%

Remember ARS can yeilds can vary ever day because it is subject to dutch auction. Also I noticed rates tend to be lower on friday and higher always on monday for 1 day auctions. Also rates tend to be higher at the end of the month too and lower at the begining of the month.


alert mods    

Am I wrong to think that Fidelity will charge a minimum of $75 dollars to enter and exit one of these ARS? Their commission sheet states $1.50 per bond per transaction, which would yield $37.50 to purchase a 25K minimum block and another $37.50 to exit your position. If so, then at least through Fidelity, transaction costs can significantly cut into your earnings...


alert mods    

No one charges anything to enter or exist these instruments that I know of. I have checked with E-trade, Fidelity, Citibank and BOA in past currently I am buying them Citibank only because I keep most of my cash there.


alert mods    

Thanks for the reply, dolmar.


alert mods    

So basically, these notes are bought at par (not discount like tbills)and interest (at the rate which is set via dutch auction process on the specified auction reset date) is paid on the next reset date? i.e. intrest is deposited into your trading account after the 1/7/28 day period and then the process starts over again and you can hold/buy more/or sell. Is this right?


alert mods    

CMEtrader said:So basically, these notes are bought at par (not discount like tbills)and interest (at the rate which is set via dutch auction process on the specified auction reset date) is paid on the next reset date? i.e. intrest is deposited into your trading account after the 1/7/28 day period and then the process starts over again and you can hold/buy more/or sell. Is this right?

Yes except not all issues pay interest at each reset. Some issues pay montly but thoses seem to be daily resets for the most part but not always. I have seen some weekly ones also trade with accured interest.


alert mods    

FWIW
I have noticed on the linked Fidelity offerings that a handful of issues have a "minimum quantity" of 5 (though most are 25). This may interest those who may not want to commit as much $.

I am considering municipal resets b/c of their tax advantages (I am in a high tax bracket in IL, and many of these ARS offerings are around 3.5% which is a taxable equivalent of around 5.55% for me). Comparable tax-exempt MM funds offered by Vanguard and the others offer a rate of around 3.5% that is federal tax exempt, but is still subject to the IL 3% tax (residents of CA,NJ,NY,OH,PA can invest in MM funds that offer both federal and state tax exemption, but I don't have that option). Thus, this discussion board and Dolmar's expertise really helps me to figure out what investment choices I have.

However, another option I am looking at is opening an account with GE Interest Plus (this has been discussed briefly on FatWallet in an archived thread FW discussion).
This may be a better choice for those who are reading this thread and considering in taxable ARS. While not FDIC insured (like ARS), a GE Interest Plus account is basically a retail version of investing in AAA rated (like the ARS securities we have been discussing)GE notes with checkwriting privelages and total liquidity. The highest rate tier also looks like it is as good or better than most of the ARS rates I have been seeing.

Less than $15,000 - 4.80 Rate / 4.91% Yield (APY)
$15,000 to $49,999 - 5.05 Rate / 5.17% Yield (APY)
$50,000 and more - 5.30 Rate / 5.43% Yield (APY)

Dolmar, I would apperciate any thoughts on ARS vs GE Interest plus re taxable investments...


alert mods    

CMEtrader said: GE Interest Plus
Less than $15,000 - 4.80 Rate / 4.91% Yield (APY)
$15,000 to $49,999 - 5.05 Rate / 5.17% Yield (APY)
$50,000 and more - 5.30 Rate / 5.43% Yield (APY)


They are paying the same thing as ARS not better. I have seen ARS on Fidelity and Citibank going as high as a rate of 5.40% for 28 and 35 day issues. Also CMEtrader you keep forgeting one thing most MMF in general are quoted as APY thus they are compounding the rate. All bonds are quoted in terms of rate as you really cant compound the interest inside of the bond. But you can always deposit the interest into another account to compound. If you happen to get a weekly coupon payment on your interest payment and deposit it into higher yeilding MMF you should be able to out preform GE account just because you are copounding more often so even if you savings accounts pays a little less your APY between ARS and copounded interest in your savings account should end up being a little more than GE.

Also as far as Vangaurd tax-free MMF you also need to consider 1 more thing they all hold between 5-20% ATM bonds. If you buy AMT-exempt ARS they are paying between 3.4-3.5% which is same as Vangaurd MMF which is one of the highest yeilding one but if you are subject to ATM you going to pay taxes holding Vanguard fund on the % of AMT bonds that fund holds. For Example NY and CA are about 18% which will lower your return and if you are not subjext to AMT both Citibank and Fidelity and many other places also sell ARS that are subject to AMT and are currently paying closer to 3.7-4%.


alert mods    

Perhaps I can clear up some of your issues. Having read this thread quickly, the biggest issue is rates, and quantities.

Let's start with rates. The real deal is that the rates are not set by Citi or Fidelity, or any firm for that matter. they are set by the issuers, reset weekly, monthly, 35 days, etc depending on the issue, and they ALL are about the same. the reason that some issues appear higher today is because the reset dates might be different. If one resets on Tuesday, then on Wednesday, it might reflect higher or lower than one that resets on Thursday, for example. I see most offerings each day, and from one issuer to the next, they are all withing 5 basis points, or so. You might also notice that towards the end of each quarter, rates rise quite handsomely for both taxable and Muni ARPS (ARS). This is somewhat smoke and mirrors. Money Markets try to get their yields reflected high for print in the papers so you put money with them. Also, they re jigger their portfolios as their maturities roll over.

Most of these instruments are sold in either $25,000 or $100,000 increments. I have not seen $5000 on these yet, but it is possible Fidelity or others might internally break them up. THey are book entry anyway, so they never leave in physical form. They might also not transfer from one firm to another in odd lots. Worse, however, is that if the issue is transferred, the new firm probably won't be willing to redeem it at your request, since $5,000 is not a valid tradeable qty. remember, they trade in $25k and $100k denominations.

There should be no fee for purchase or sale of any of these either, that I know of. They are liquid, however, while you might be able to enter your redemption any day, it won't settle until the reset date at most firms. In other words, your money won't be free until each reset date, for withdrawal or reinvestment elsewhere.

So - I either added value, or confused you even more! LOL.

By the way, depending on where your accounts are held, check on their tax free money market rates compared to your bank deposits or taxables.. depending on your bracket, you might be pleasantly surprised and make a change.

Happy Investing!

edit: I noticed a warning about AMT in some Tax-Free funds. absolutely something to check if you are subject to AMT. The Municipal (tax-free) Auction Rate Preferred's may also be subject to the AMT, depending on the underlying issues. Be sure to ask your broker if the particular issue is in fact subject to the AMT. This applies only to the Muni offerings.


 Close

Sign Me In
Nickname: 
Password: 
Remember My Login Information:

Forget your login information?

Not Already A Member?
Sign Up Now!



Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.


While FatWallet makes every effort to post correct information, offers are subject to change without notice.
Some exclusions may apply based upon merchant policies.
© 1999-2009