|
-
-
WalStMonky
- Happy Member
posted: Mar. 25, 2007 @ 8:10p
it's known? Who knows it? Please source that claim of reclassification 'months after' as I doubt it highly. |
-
-
psychtobe
- Senior Member - 2K
posted: Mar. 25, 2007 @ 8:14p
it's an interesting idea, but tehre are a lot of potential catches. I have several 0% purchase cards and could put in maybe $30k without going over 90% utilization... tempted, but I don't want to be the first one! |
-
-
ls7corvete
- Member
posted: Mar. 25, 2007 @ 9:37p
it's an interesting idea, but tehre are a lot of potential catches. I have several 0% purchase cards and could put in maybe $30k without going over 90% utilization... tempted, but I don't want to be the first one!
Ditto, maybe someone with experience from forex trading or forex.com can share some opinions. Like the rest of FW I would like to know how to do this with minimal risk of loss. |
-
-
WalStMonky
- Happy Member
posted: Mar. 25, 2007 @ 9:44p
They offer a practice trading platform, which I've downloaded. Lots of pretty graphs and stuff, and a very sexy woman talks to you when you push buttons. I think I'm short the yen and long the Euro, both against the dollar. But I could have that backwards or sideways, I don't know. I am sure those are the 3 currencies involved, lol. But really it sure isn't like trading Nasdaq in 1999. A whole lotta nothing going on. |
-
-
WalStMonky
- Happy Member
posted: Mar. 25, 2007 @ 10:02p
Sheesh, talk about penny ante. |
-
-
Namshik
- Senior Member
posted: Mar. 25, 2007 @ 11:07p
ls7corvete said: it's an interesting idea, but tehre are a lot of potential catches. I have several 0% purchase cards and could put in maybe $30k without going over 90% utilization... tempted, but I don't want to be the first one!
Ditto, maybe someone with experience from forex trading or forex.com can share some opinions. Like the rest of FW I would like to know how to do this with minimal risk of loss.
try this site http://www.cmsfx.com/en/forex-center/forex-online-tutorial/ |
-
-
ls7corvete
- Member
posted: Mar. 26, 2007 @ 12:01a
Namshik said:ls7corvete said: it's an interesting idea, but tehre are a lot of potential catches. I have several 0% purchase cards and could put in maybe $30k without going over 90% utilization... tempted, but I don't want to be the first one!
Ditto, maybe someone with experience from forex trading or forex.com can share some opinions. Like the rest of FW I would like to know how to do this with minimal risk of loss.
try this site http://www.cmsfx.com/en/forex-center/forex-online-tutorial/
Good information guys but I was looking for advice on how to deposit with CC, make the minimum transactions required and withdraw via check, ACH etc, all with minimal risk.
From what I have read forex.com seems pretty shady but I have no experience here. |
-
-
Namshik
- Senior Member
posted: Mar. 26, 2007 @ 1:06a
ls7corvete said:Namshik said:ls7corvete said: it's an interesting idea, but tehre are a lot of potential catches. I have several 0% purchase cards and could put in maybe $30k without going over 90% utilization... tempted, but I don't want to be the first one!
Ditto, maybe someone with experience from forex trading or forex.com can share some opinions. Like the rest of FW I would like to know how to do this with minimal risk of loss.
try this site http://www.cmsfx.com/en/forex-center/forex-online-tutorial/
Good information guys but I was looking for advice on how to deposit with CC, make the minimum transactions required and withdraw via check, ACH etc, all with minimal risk.
From what I have read forex.com seems pretty shady but I have no experience here.
when you mean shady, if you're referring to the restrictions on the min # of trades, those are only required if you choose to add the promotional items for referrals and/or deposit bonus. |
-
-
ls7corvete
- Member
posted: Mar. 26, 2007 @ 8:21a
No, I mean poor reviews that I have read. |
-
-
linuxboy
- Happy Member
posted: Mar. 26, 2007 @ 11:06a
Having done this with multiple brokers and quit due to an unfavorable risk/reward ratio, I can say it is risky and often not worthwhile for a 1-2% churn. Here's why
1) Before every withdrawal above 2500, the accounting department does a quick check on your previous quarter/year (depends on their whim and on the broker). If you do not have a certain number of transactions (they never say how many that is, but in my experience it is around 30-45 transactions with at least 1 lot/minilot per round trip), they automatically refund the money via credit card, even if your initial deposit was by check or debit card. What they actually do is check the authorization details for your last deposit via CC and post a credit through a reverse (like a refund).
2) I have searched for a basic scalping strategy that requires no constant monitoring and would get me 30-45 transactions with breakeven results. I've read the major forums, in English and Russian, and have found nothing like that in all the strategies people have posted. It might exist, and if you've found it, kudos to you.
The combination of forex risk, the need to make many transactions to be able to get cc money out via check, and the inspection every withdrawal undergoes makes this risky and very time-consuming for such a low churn percentage.
Having said this, it should work for your first 2500-5000 in deposits if you are willing to make a few trades and keep your money with a broker for at least half a year.
This has been discussed before. I'll try to find the archives. |
-
-
MarketVViz
- Senior Member - 1K
posted: Mar. 26, 2007 @ 3:44p
Yea, if this was legit, everyone with a 1% (or better) Cash Back credit card would just be making the max deposit every month and then withdrawing the money (more than 12% annual return with no risk if you aren't trading with the deposit money). Add me to the list of skeptics, especially since so far no one has even posted that they have had success with it. Remember they have to pay substantial fees to the credit card companies, they are just going to put the money back onto the card it originally came off of. |
-
-
formerkeo
- Senior Member
posted: Mar. 26, 2007 @ 8:32p
Okay, let me tell you how they, the FW geniuses did it. First they made a......Sikes! I do think if we tell you, it will not work any longer. You guys got a big mouth. Hey guys, these newbies have a blabber mouth, becareful what you tell them or it will hurt us. |
-
-
formerkeo
- Senior Member
posted: Mar. 26, 2007 @ 8:36p
By the way what FW'er do, is legitimate business. Quit ranting off to credit card companies and make life difficult for us. Man FW got snitches, just like prison. |
-
-
markber
- Senior Member
posted: Mar. 26, 2007 @ 9:56p
If anybody is interested, I just added a list of credit cards with 0%/low APR for purchases to the thread about 0%/low APR credit cards (used to list credit cards with promo rates for BTs only). |
-
-
JohnGalt69
- Senior Member
posted: Mar. 26, 2007 @ 10:19p
linuxboy said: 1) Before every withdrawal above 2500...
I don't see a problem here. Sure there isn't more to it than that? |
-
-
carolinacasper
- New Member
posted: Mar. 27, 2007 @ 12:18a
Minimum Trade trade would be a $100,000 lot with 1 to 100 margin (futures traders think this is crazy, but trust me, it is not) So $1000 principal is used to back up the minimum trade lot.
USD/EUR cross, in my opinion is the most traded and with a 3 pip spread it is one of the cheapest. Each pip on a minimum lot trade is $10. So 3 pips x $10 is $30 cost to trade if you open and immediately close a trade at the same price.
10 trades is required to get the minimum amount of money on a $25,000 account. Therefore if you open and close a trade at the same price you are spending 10 x $30 = $300 to gain $200.
If you want to profit from this deal, you will need to learn how the forex market works so you can make profitable trades and close your account 10 trades are completed or if your risk seeking enough continue trading like myself. 
And no, I haven't taken of this advantage yet, I currently use another forex broker. |
-
-
linuxboy
- Happy Member
posted: Mar. 27, 2007 @ 10:03a
JohnGalt69 said:linuxboy said: 1) Before every withdrawal above 2500...
I don't see a problem here. Sure there isn't more to it than that?
No, I don't think they even care for small withdrawals and will just cut you a check. Unless you deposit via cc and withdraw and request a check in 2 days or have a history or depositing and withdrawing with no account activity.
Point is, if you have a lot of activity, they make money on the spread, which covers their transaction fees, so they let you get away with it. The broker is not stupid. They might even have a breakeven calculation that they apply to each withdrawal made by check when the deposit is through cc (so many round turns of such and such currency). If you make money on forex constantly, you are in the 5% of people who can. Then, sure, go ahead and make an extra 1-2% from the cc deposit. Otherwise, this is not simple and fairly risky. I have seen euro moves of hundreds of pips (hundreds of dollars when trading a minilot) in an hour. It happens. If you're on the wrong side of the trade, there goes your entire 2% of credit card rewards, and then some. It's a bit sweeter with the forex.com bonus, but still very risky. |
-
-
ls7corvete
- Member
posted: Mar. 27, 2007 @ 11:38a
Eh, I dont like the spread on forex.com.
If I can find anouther site with better spreads I would consider this. |
-
-
JohnGalt69
- Senior Member
posted: Mar. 27, 2007 @ 11:20p
linuxboy said:JohnGalt69 said:linuxboy said: 1) Before every withdrawal above 2500...
I don't see a problem here. Sure there isn't more to it than that?
No, I don't think they even care for small withdrawals and will just cut you a check. Unless you deposit via cc and withdraw and request a check in 2 days or have a history or depositing and withdrawing with no account activity.
Point is, if you have a lot of activity, they make money on the spread, which covers their transaction fees, so they let you get away with it. The broker is not stupid. They might even have a breakeven calculation that they apply to each withdrawal made by check when the deposit is through cc (so many round turns of such and such currency). If you make money on forex constantly, you are in the 5% of people who can. Then, sure, go ahead and make an extra 1-2% from the cc deposit. Otherwise, this is not simple and fairly risky. I have seen euro moves of hundreds of pips (hundreds of dollars when trading a minilot) in an hour. It happens. If you're on the wrong side of the trade, there goes your entire 2% of credit card rewards, and then some. It's a bit sweeter with the forex.com bonus, but still very risky.
Okay I see a problem there  |
-
-
jairocon
- Senior Member - 1K
posted: Mar. 31, 2007 @ 12:36p
I'm currently using fxcm as my forex broker (no initial deposit bonuses) - but I only trade for fun with my play money.
Since my trades are usually executed within a span of hours (buy/sell) I never had to deal with interest charges. Recently I shorted EUR/USD and decided to let the trade run until I hit my limit.
So I shorted 1 mini lot ($100) EUR/USD at 1.3300 on 3/16. It's gone up and down (my limit is set to 1.3200, and it's hit as high as 1.3410 but I still have enough confidence in the trade anyway).
What I didn't realize is that because of the interest differential btw EUR/USD, I'm making $0.56 in interest every single day while the trade is open. If everything was left being equal, I'd make $204.40 in interest on a $100 deposit(trade) in 1 year!!!*
*remember this is because of the fact that 1 mini-lot costing me $100 is in fact $10k being traded (100:1 margin).
Of course nothing stays the same in a forex market and the sheer unpredictability of it makes any investing pretty much a bet. Still, with dollar being at historical lows against EUR - it could make sense to short a larger amount and set your limits. You either could make profits by hitting your limit order, or if it takes longer - you'd be making money through the interest differential. (Then again you might as well lose it all)
Anyway, just a thought. |
Close
|
|
 |
 |
Not Already A Member?
Sign Up Now!
|
|
Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.
|
|