Edit

Forums
Finance

Charles Schwab 2.01% checking account in: Subjects › Deal

  • filter:
  • Tell A Friend
  • tweet this
  • Post to Facebook
  • Text Only
  • Search this Topic »
  • Classic
alert mods    
rated:

Chuu said:Very interested in this deal, and have two questions:

1. Is this deal dead? The highest rate I can find on checking is 0.75%, savings a paltry 1.05%.
2. Is it still extremely difficult to transfer money out of savings? I'm trying to find a bank where I can move money between savings and brokerage accounts instantly, and the last time I looked people told me that CS made it tricky to do so.

1. Yes, their rates are rather poor at the moment.
2. Yes, the savings account is still very poorly integrated into their system. You need to do an external transfer to move between the brokerage and savings accounts and you cannot move directly between savings and checking. They are allegedly working on this.


alert mods    
rated:

That really is too bad. Free ATM fees would have made up for the interest rate if I could do instant transfers.

Out of curiosity, is there any bank that currently meets #2? At the time I couldn't find any.


alert mods    
rated:

Chuu said:That really is too bad. Free ATM fees would have made up for the interest rate if I could do instant transfers.

Out of curiosity, is there any bank that currently meets #2? At the time I couldn't find any.

If you mean instant transfers from a bank to a brokerage...no..that does not exist.....

If you mean a bank with excellent savings rate and excellent checking rate that you can make instant transfer from savings to checking as you need money to pay bills and the like,
then you should look at Alliant Credit Union (see fw thread on it)....2.0% apy on Savings...1.75% apy on Checking, and while no surcharge rebates, instead you get 80,000 surcharge free atm coverage nationwide, through atms that have COOP/ALLPOINT/ALLIANCE ONE/CU24 networks.....plus nice online banking/bill pay and excellent customer service.....


alert mods    
rated:

Speaking of Alliant, I think it's ridiculous to charge a $10 Overdraft fee when tied to your savings...

Anyhow, do you happen to know the out of country ATM Transaction Fee Alliant charges? It's not listed in their fee schedule.

Message edited by: CurlyKicker on 2009-09-29 02:03:40 CDT
alert mods    
rated:

CurlyKicker said:Speaking of Alliant, I think it's ridiculous to charge a $10 Overdraft fee when tied to your savings...

Anyhow, do you happen to know the out of country ATM Transaction Fee Alliant charges? It's not listed in their fee schedule.
You might have better luck asking about Alliant in the Alliant thread.


alert mods    
rated:

billrubin said:Chuu said:Very interested in this deal, and have two questions:

1. Is this deal dead? The highest rate I can find on checking is 0.75%, savings a paltry 1.05%.
2. Is it still extremely difficult to transfer money out of savings? I'm trying to find a bank where I can move money between savings and brokerage accounts instantly, and the last time I looked people told me that CS made it tricky to do so.

1. Yes, their rates are rather poor at the moment.
2. Yes, the savings account is still very poorly integrated into their system. You need to do an external transfer to move between the brokerage and savings accounts and you cannot move directly between savings and checking. They are allegedly working on this.

******************************************************************************************
I am under the impression that you can transfer from savings to brokerage in 1 day. The funds are available to trading immediately but if you want withdrawals, there is an
additional 3? day hold. I've heard the 3 days at least twice; today I heard 1 day. Not sure who to believe.

I am under the impression that you can transfer from checking to brokerage in 1?day. I can't be sure but I think I heard the 1 day a few times. Today I heard instant. Not sure
who to believe.

If you have savings and want to transfer faster to brokerage, set up checking at the bank (no min, no fees), so you can transfer savings to checking (instant?), then transfer from
checking to brokerage (1 day or instant?). That I've heard at least twice.


alert mods    
rated:

Everyone who told you was correct in some way or another. Transfer settling depends on the source of the funds. Transfers between checking and brokerage can be completed same-day. Transfers between brokerage and an outside institution have a 3 (business) day hold. So it looks like the savings account is considered external for the purpose of transfers. I don't have a data point on savings to checking.


alert mods    
rated:

When you call in a transfer from savings to checking, the transfer is made immediately.


alert mods    
rated:

So there seems to be some confusion on the ATM rebate overseas. As best as I can understand, there is no foriegn exchange fee from Visa/Schwab for using the card overseas for ATM or POS. Also, just like domestically, any surcharges/fees from an ATM withdrawal are refunded. The only fees that you could get hit with is from a vendor for POS purchase.

Is that right?


alert mods    
rated:

SegaRob said:So there seems to be some confusion on the ATM rebate overseas. As best as I can understand, there is no foriegn exchange fee from Visa/Schwab for using the card overseas for ATM or POS. Also, just like domestically, any surcharges/fees from an ATM withdrawal are refunded. The only fees that you could get hit with is from a vendor for POS purchase.

Is that right?

My understanding is that fee for ATM withdrawal are refunded but that the foreign exchange fee is not covered. Not 100% sure tho.


alert mods    
rated:

that's what the brochure says that comes with the card....


alert mods    
rated:

But people have said there is no forex fee on both the Schwab checking/ATM card and credit card.


alert mods    
rated:

The documentation indicates that there is a 0.8% currency conversion charge. It is impossible to concretely confirm whether or not this is charged in practice, because the statement does not indicate the applicable exchange rate or withdrawal amount in foreign currency, just the USD value of the withdrawal. Most who have actually used the card abroad have found that the functional exchange rate is less than spot + 0.8%. Consequently, many have made the assertion that there is no forex fee on the card. Personally, I found the Schwab CC to have a better exchange rate than the debit card, so I think it's possible that some forex fee is charged, but it is less than the typical 0.8%.


alert mods    
rated:

Something else that many are not aware of is that, if you actually have any kind of assets in your Schwab brokerage account (etfs, stocks, money market funds), that after a few months of doing transfers, a new feature "kicks in" that gives you IMMEDIATE WITHDRAWAL AVAILABILITY on funds you transfer in Money Link on The Schwab One side, and can then be instantly transferred to your Checking Account on the same business day....

The amount that becomes immediately available for withdrawal or transfer to another Schwab account is equal to the total amount of assets you have in your Schwab One account...So, no 3 day wait to be able to move it to checking....

The feature isn't something you request...it activates automatically after you have done transfers into moneylink for a few months without any "transfer bounces" or whatever...in other words, you have a reliable transfer record).....

I know because i get it on mine (i have Money in a Bond Fund in my Schwab One).....

Message edited by: craig10x on 2009-10-01 13:37:23 CDT
 Close

Sign Me In
Nickname: 
Password: 
Remember My Login Information:

Forget your login information?

Not Already A Member?
Sign Up Now!

  • Quick Reply:  Have something quick to contribute? Just reply below and you're done! hide Quick Reply
     
     
    Click here for full-featured reply.


Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.


While FatWallet makes every effort to post correct information, offers are subject to change without notice.
Some exclusions may apply based upon merchant policies.
© 1999-2009