Edit

Forums
Finance

Offer to Switch Citi Dividend to World Mastercard -- a Citi Scam? Archived From: Finance

  • tweet this
  • Post to Facebook
  • Text Only
  • Search this Topic »
  • Classic
alert mods    

As a Diamond Preferred holder since 2004, I have been quite pleased (except for the 6000 pts switch needed for a $50 gift card) with it. The question I haven't seen answered about this "offer" is "Why" Citi is doing this? It certainly doesn't benefit the cardholder. Might it be cosmetic window dressing after the congressional hearings? The 75000 pts. limit is a new twist and cause for me to reject the "offer."


alert mods    

volvoswede said:The question I haven't seen answered about this "offer" is "Why" Citi is doing this?

Citi gets a higher interchange fee (the percentage fee assessed on each transaction) for World products:
pdf link

It's not a huge difference. Maybe 10-20 bps on average, but that's $1M-$2M on every $1bn in charges. Also why they've been pushing co-branded AMEX cards and business charge cards.


alert mods    

Well folks I thought I was going to keep my old card, but CSR offered me 6% on everyday spending + driver miles for the drivers edge card. I was leery of getting my CashBack in terms of auto related products, but he said I could use it as Thank you points, which works great for my student loans. So I'm doing this.


alert mods    

For Those of us that got the Chase Freedom card you can change it to the Chase Freedom World Mastercard for no fee and it has all the same benfits of the regular freedom card and a world card.


alert mods    

Not to mention, you also get a new account number which might mess up any automatic payments that are setup using your card. I also received the upgrade letter. Might decline the upgrade.

- CCG.


alert mods    

EVERYONE HERE IS CONFUSED!!! To sum up 5 pages of threads:

This not a no-limit credit card with revolving credit. There is a limit. If you go over it you will not be charged a penalty. The confusion is that there are credit cards out there with a revolving line of credit.

"Card agreement states that the customer has flexibility to make purchases in excess of his/her credit limit. Therefore, we do not report to the credit bureaus the revolving credit line amount. We do report the current balance to the credit bureaus and maintain that our credit reporting is accurate." -media relations citi card.

IF YOU DO NOT PAY IT OFF BY THE DUE DATE YOU WILL BE CHARGED THE OVER FEE.

Also I am no credit expert but for those of you worried about longevity I loose my card about once a quarter. And I have to get a new card number. I have an excellent credit score. By that logic I have never had my citi card for more than 4 months.

This card has all kinds of useful/useless benefits that can be found here:

www.mastercard.com/us/personal/en/aboutourcards/credit/world_card.html

I agree this has to be some kind of scam. all i can think of is this:

1) Merchants have to pay higher fees to accept this card like they do with a normal rewards card.
2) there is no preset spending limit this might entice a few idiots to spend too much on their card and have to pay interest. My limit is pretty low so if i take advantage of the $1,000 off a private jet rental i will owe quite a bit of interest as i pay it off over the next few years.


alert mods    

tbigone said:Also I am no credit expert but for those of you worried about longevity I loose my card about once a quarter. And I have to get a new card number. I have an excellent credit score. By that logic I have never had my citi card for more than 4 months. There's a difference between replacing a lost card and converting to a different product. All credit card companies that I'm aware of are able to replace a lost or stolen card with a new card number, but everything else on the account remains exactly the same, including longevity. I worked as a CSR (but not for Citi) and there was a specific procedure for lost or stolen cards that issued a new number but didn't open a new account or anything like that.

Whenever you start talking about converting a card from one type to another, there's a risk (but not a guarantee by any means) that they could close the original account and open a new one, or something similar. That, along with the unknown of how they'll report the credit limits, is why people are declining this offer. If the new benefits are good for you, by all means go for it, but it sounds like most people here don't have use for the new features, so why risk it?


alert mods    

tbigone said:EVERYONE HERE IS CONFUSED!!! To sum up 5 pages of threads:

This not a no-limit credit card with revolving credit. There is a limit. If you go over it you will not be charged a penalty. The confusion is that there are credit cards out there with a revolving line of credit.

"Card agreement states that the customer has flexibility to make purchases in excess of his/her credit limit. Therefore, we do not report to the credit bureaus the revolving credit line amount. We do report the current balance to the credit bureaus and maintain that our credit reporting is accurate." -media relations citi card.

IF YOU DO NOT PAY IT OFF BY THE DUE DATE YOU WILL BE CHARGED THE OVER FEE.

Also I am no credit expert but for those of you worried about longevity I loose my card about once a quarter. And I have to get a new card number. I have an excellent credit score. By that logic I have never had my citi card for more than 4 months.

This card has all kinds of useful/useless benefits that can be found here:

www.mastercard.com/us/personal/en/aboutourcards/credit/world_card.html

I agree this has to be some kind of scam. all i can think of is this:

1) Merchants have to pay higher fees to accept this card like they do with a normal rewards card.
2) there is no preset spending limit this might entice a few idiots to spend too much on their card and have to pay interest. My limit is pretty low so if i take advantage of the $1,000 off a private jet rental i will owe quite a bit of interest as i pay it off over the next few years.


No one here is concerned with going over their limit or being charged an over the limit fee. They are concerned that no credit limit will be reported to the Credit Reporting Agencies. When the CRAs don't have a credit limit they will often use the highest reported balance. If that highest balance is this month it will appear as if you are at 100% utilization even if you are below 50%. This could have catastrophic effects on your accounts.

You are the one confused.


alert mods    

Anyone knows if this new card has "Best Value Gurantee".
It states "Price Protection" as a benefit. I am not sure if that is the same.

My current dimond preferred has BVG on it and that is why I have it in the first place.

TIA


alert mods    

I see I was clear as mud. There is a credit limit on the card. So Citi Bank reports the limit.

They do have a card with revolving credit. This card they do not report the limit on.


alert mods    

I can't find the answer to my question on MasterCard or Citi's websites… but does anyone know if the Dividend World card has Extended Warranty Coverage like the Dividend Platinum does?


alert mods    

mhsu1 said:I can't find the answer to my question on MasterCard or Citi's websites… but does anyone know if the Dividend World card has Extended Warranty Coverage like the Dividend Platinum does?

Yes, the exact same coverage...


alert mods    

So after reading through this thread... there doesn't seem to be any major reason NOT to decline the card?


alert mods    

tbigone said:I see I was clear as mud. There is a credit limit on the card. So Citi Bank reports the limit.

They do have a card with revolving credit. This card they do not report the limit on.



okay, assume it does report the limit. What if you spend more than the limit in one month? That will be over 100% utilization.


alert mods    

tbigone said:I see I was clear as mud. There is a credit limit on the card. So Citi Bank reports the limit.

They do have a card with revolving credit. This card they do not report the limit on.


Considering that even the Citi CSRs acknowledged that not reporting the credit line was a legitimate concern to one of the people on this thread, I don't know how you can make comments like this unless you are the person in charge of this credit card at Citi.


alert mods    

For thoes who think will lost credit history, my expeirence is, last time when I changed my Citi MasterCard to Citi AmericanExpress, the history is showing the same account, let's say, since Aug. 1999.


alert mods    

People still think Fair, Isaac are incompetent. Sigh.


alert mods    

WalStMonky said:People still think Fair, Isaac are incompetent. Sigh.

I know you aren't a believer in the credit line limit not reporting hurting your credit theory. However, there are people who have seen their FICO score go down due to the fact that their high balance matched their current balance.

Given that FICO comes from Fair, Isaac (even has Fair Isaac in the name) I don't know how you can not "think" this.


Rather than sighing, why don't your provide contradictory evidence. Not just a premise that Fair, Isaac is smart and therefore they wouldn't do something dumb, therefore they wouldn't do this. All I've seen you do is present circular logic.


alert mods    

Just got an email with the same offer to upgrade.


alert mods    

I called yesterday to decline the offer. She made the changes in about a minute -- but not before making me a *sweet* balance transfer offer of 6.99% for 12 months. In the same breath (as if she could tell I was going to decline), she asked: "Do you have any stocks or other investments that are returning more than that rate?"

I can't believe Citi would condone trying to get people to take BT (or convenience checks) money to play in the stock market. And she didn't even mention the 3% fee (no cap) that all the checks I've been getting recently feature.

Yeah, I know a sure thing in the stock market that will return over 10% in the next 12 months & I really want to risk the 24% (or higher) rate that I'll be charged on the money after the year is up...crazy.


 Close

Sign Me In
Nickname: 
Password: 
Remember My Login Information:

Forget your login information?

Not Already A Member?
Sign Up Now!



Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.


While FatWallet makes every effort to post correct information, offers are subject to change without notice.
Some exclusions may apply based upon merchant policies.
© 1999-2009