DiabloD3 said: Updated: Eq to 697 from 713 Ex to 696 from 716 TU to 697 from 725 PFICO to 702 from 712
Recent additions: So, I decided to try for a Citi card again, a Diamond Preferred Rewards card for the 5% in TY points for groceries among other things, and not only got it but a $4k limit; shortly after, Citi calls me and offers me a Citi Professional card, which I accept the offer and not only get it, but also get a $10k limit (JACKPOT).
THEN HSBC sends me a letter offering me their new Household 2% CashBack card, which I applied for and received a $500 limit, and I've also requested that my other Household card to be merged into the new one (giving me a $1k line total, hopefully). The request is still in the queue.
I currently have 1 Eq, 4 TU, and 11 Ex hard inquiries. My average card age is 10 months, and my total history is 1 year and 9 months long.
The RevolutionCard has not appeared on my report, has anyone else seen this on their reports?And this all happened AFTER your chase balances were paid down, right? It funny what that (along with a little bit of time) will do. As you were told from the getgo, you had to get things in order first and have some patience. Glad to see it's finally working out for you.
Now, just dont get all gung-ho again - if you do much more, expect your hands to be tied for another 6-12 months. If you want to leave yourself with more options in the near future, then hit pause for a bit and let these new developments settle in before continuing.
DiabloD3
Senior Member
posted: Apr. 1, 2008 @ 8:59p
I am victorious! All three FICO scores are above 800!
...
April fools!
So yeah, scores mostly stabilized compared to last month. I currently have no Eq or TU hard inquires on my reports again (thank God for bumpage). Ex still has 11 inquiries, which 3 are up to disappear in May.
Eq: 692, down from 697 Ex: 705, up from 696 TU: 689, down from 697
Household completed my combine cards request, and my 2% CashBack card is now $1000. I'm really hoping that within the next 6 months that other banks notice my Citi Professional's $10k limit and automatically up to match.
markkundinger
Senior Member - 2K
posted: Apr. 1, 2008 @ 10:22p
You know, over the next 3-4 months, you'll have some cards age 6 months, and some age 12 months. That might help a bit. The most important thing is still to keep utilization low AND KEEP THE INQUIRIES DOWN.
I don't know what kind of household income you've been reporting on the apps. That is, unfortunately, quite a limiting factor for these things.
I would guesstimate that after a 4-6 months of keeping your nose clean, you might really be ready for a full on AOR. Scores might still not be too high (they'll probably hit a medium-term plateau), and results might not be too impressive, but at least you'll have a good chance of getting cards with most of the major and middle banks out there.
CoffeeEater
Greedy Member
posted: Apr. 1, 2008 @ 10:53p
Just jump off a bridge, Diablo. No one wants to hear about your crappy credit scores, serial CC applications, and lack of self-control. I loathe you.
Actually, diablo, had you taken advantage of the citibank CLI on crack feature? Did that make any difference?
DiabloD3
Senior Member
posted: Jul. 5, 2008 @ 3:57a
Yeah I did take advantage of it, and it changed the score decently, about +20 points average, and it turned my Citi Diamond card into a $25k card, but left my Citi Pro card at $10k (due to a 6 month no CLI rule that applies to new Pro cards but not new consumer cards, apparently).
Now, the other day Chase upped limits on both of my cards without me asking to $10k each (up from $2k and $1k). My recent score average is at an all time high.
Equifax Experian Transunion WAMU
May 687 674 686 697
June 729 710 725 716
July 723 726 715
Edit: I wish this forum had a symbol that outputs an html fixed width text tag Edit 2: I updated the first post to reflect whats happened thus far. Edit 3: Okay, Citi CLI crack changed my score more than I thought. Edit 4: C tag ftw.
markkundinger
Senior Member - 2K
posted: Jul. 5, 2008 @ 10:37a
- Could you re-re-edit the OP to show what the initial credit lines were on the cards before the CLIs?
- What's your inquiry situation like right now, how many, and what age?
- I think the "code" (C) tag can work to do fixed-length formatting.
- Tentatively, I'd still let these accounts age some more and bask in the big credit limits, hold off on more inquiries, pay down balances, and then you could probably go for a real AOR.
DiabloD3
Senior Member
posted: Jul. 5, 2008 @ 11:45a
Ahh, the C tag isn't in the symbols popup. I assume it does the code html tag.
I'm not currently looking to add any more credit yet until my youngest accounts hit 6 months and average age hits a year.
Inqs are currently screwed up because of TU's happy time super fix plus (f$%ktards).
Eq has one thats not even a week old (tried to get HSBC to CLI on my 2% card... no go), Ex has 8, newest is 4/2007, oldest is 8/2006, TU has 8, including three from Feburary that came from the Household 2% card and the two Citi cards. So yes, TU is up from 0 to 8.
I'll re-edit the op to reflect original credit limits as well in a second.
DiabloD3
Senior Member
posted: Aug. 1, 2008 @ 4:00a
For August: Eq: 704 Ex: 701 TU: 700 PFICO: 704 (As of July 1st)
Inqs: Eq: 1 Ex: 8 (1 to bump off by the end of this month) TU: 1 (BUMPAGE WORKS AGAAAAAAAAIN!)
Average age of all cards: 12 months Age of newest card: 5 months
Dear FW: When do you think the credit market will stop sucking? Tommorow? 6 months from now? 6 years from now? By the time I'm sending my grandchildren off to college?
markkundinger
Senior Member - 2K
posted: Aug. 1, 2008 @ 9:24a
Who knows? And when it stops sucking, who knows if the environment will be better or worse for AORs?
I say you set an arbitrary time for the AORs, and to hell with the credit markets. Base it on inquiries. Make it so that your NEWEST inquiry, on any bureau, is either 6 months or 12 months old, then go for it.
Because you're approaching a plateau in your credit scores and credit lines, where the only way to raise them is to get older and have grandkids, or make more money.
Also, try making more money.
DiabloD3
Senior Member
posted: Aug. 1, 2008 @ 2:23p
Making more money isn't even an issue theoretically. I can lie about my HH income (except to AMEX since they actually will call people's bluffs). NOTE: NOT THAT I AM RECOMMENDING PEOPLE DO THIS, CONSULT A LAWYER AND YOUR RELIGIOUS OFFICIAL OF CHOICE BEFORE HAND.
I may just try a forever rolling AOR. Also, it seems the number of credit lines I have that are in $0 standing are really increasing my score, and I'm not entirely sure why... my total usage is below 20% and below 90% on any single card, so that shouldn't be kicking in that hard.
markkundinger
Senior Member - 2K
posted: Aug. 2, 2008 @ 1:21p
The number of cards that have ANY sort of balance also is a minor factor in credit scoring. Lots of cards with balances, even if small ones, will lower it slightly.
DiabloD3
Senior Member
posted: Aug. 2, 2008 @ 1:41p
Hmm, interesting. Is this fixed math, or is it based on the number of lines you have?
markkundinger
Senior Member - 2K
posted: Aug. 2, 2008 @ 3:10p
Beats me, but it's been cited as a factor for adverse action. "number of cards with balance" as opposed to "balance carried on cards".
DiabloD3
Senior Member
posted: Aug. 18, 2008 @ 1:09a
Re: bumpage I'm currently using NatCity, Chase ID Protection, and CreditKarma.
On Equifax, NatCity and Chase ID Protection have a slew of inqs going back to Feb (out of 96 total), and have bumped hards off. On TU, CreditKarma and Chase ID Protection have only a few dozen inqs going back to July (out of 71 total), and I only see four from NatCity. Hards have bumped off.
I think based on this, I think NatCity is being canceled as TU is where I get the most hard inqs.
markkundinger
Senior Member - 2K
posted: Aug. 18, 2008 @ 3:01a
So, you're spending like $40 a month to bump off a single TU inquiry and a single Equifax inquiry?
DiabloD3
Senior Member
posted: Aug. 18, 2008 @ 3:08a
*cough* Actually the TU one left. Its just a lone Equifax one now.
Hell, just go for it now and get it out of your system.
DiabloD3
Senior Member
posted: Aug. 18, 2008 @ 11:16a
Maybe soon. I wanna get balances back down (had to charge $4k lately) before I go for it. I'm afraid that if I go attack AMEX, BOA, Discover, and whoever else I don't already have cards with, they may just flat out deny me for a card or (for cards this is an option with) not give me a 12 or 15 month BT but just a 6 month BT.
Alimo
Member
posted: Aug. 18, 2008 @ 3:37p
DiabloD3, I just read quite a bit of your "AOR" thread. If you're going to post on a finance forum and ask for help, LISTEN TO THE HELP. You're happy getting thousands of dollars in credit limits; some of these guys are making thousands off BT money each year and they're still figuring out ways to get more.
There's a lot of things you do that puzzle me. I'm a noob compared to pretty much everybody here so I can only imagine what the veterans are feeling when they read your thread. Patience is key to the game. Exercise some. People are giving you advice. Take it in and use it.
And for God's sake, stop getting all these hard inquiries for CLI's. There's a thread for avoiding hard inquiries for CLI's. Go read it. Might as well read the other threads on AORs while you're at it.
DiabloD3
Senior Member
posted: Aug. 18, 2008 @ 11:15p
Almo, you yourself sound like you haven't actually read this or the threads you mention. This thread is over a year old, and may be the longest AOR windup in history. Patience is something I have a lot of. The CLI thread (and dozens of others) clearly state Chase always hard inqs on CLI request, this is an unavoidable problem, however (before bumpage broke on TU products) it only took 2-3 months to bump a TU query off so it actually wasn't that big of a problem.
All my issuers except Chase, HSBC, and Citi do not allow requesting CLIs, and the majority of my hard inqs hae not been from CLI requests but from account open requests. If I didn't listen to the help as you state, I wouldn't have a $25k Citi card (thanks to whoever started the Citi CLI Is On Crack thread), which in turn caused Chase to automatically up both of my cards (without CLI request) to $10k each.
And, as per the help you state, its been proven that 2 or 3 hard inqs do not inhibit an AOR in any way, I'm just being overly cautious.
markkundinger
Senior Member - 2K
posted: Aug. 18, 2008 @ 11:34p
Diablo, for your Capone card with the chump limit, go to the creditboards forums, search for the "magic number", and see if you can call them and talk them into a bit of a bump.
DiabloD3
Senior Member
posted: Aug. 19, 2008 @ 1:40a
Oh! I almost forgot to mention, WAMU sent me a letter the other day, my WAMU Business has been upped to... $3000! How generous! No, seriously!
Alimo
Member
posted: Aug. 19, 2008 @ 5:50a
Bro, it's been over a year and you STILL HAVEN'T HAD YOUR AOR. That doesn't tell you something?
Go back and read your posts, then say what you want to say. If you want me to thread crap and bash you in your own thread, go right on ahead. If you want to save face, do it over PM.
DiabloD3
Senior Member
posted: Aug. 19, 2008 @ 10:43a
Or I can just report you to the admins for thread crapping an AOR thread. Which do you want more?
I started this thread with less than $5000 in credit and now am heading towards $70,000. I'm pretty sure FWF would agree that I'm heading in the right direction here.
DiabloD3
Senior Member
posted: Aug. 19, 2008 @ 12:25p
Okay, so, I just got off the phone with Capital One's magic number... they won't up my limit, but they were happy to lower my APR down to 14.9%! They won't up it until I heavily use the card. Blaaargh. I should wave money in front of both WAMU and CapOne until they raise my limits. Maybe then I'll be in tip top shape to do a AOR
Alimo
Member
posted: Aug. 19, 2008 @ 1:58p
I think I wrote "if you want me to thread crap..." and left you with a second option. I'm not sure what you'll be telling the Admins if you wanted me to reply in your thread.
I'm pretty sure FWF would have agreed you're heading in the right direction if you had made any money off your credit cards. You should've had a mini-AOR by now and should be planning to execute an actual AOR. BTW, people have gone from $50k -> $200k in credit limits from a single AOR.
Anyway, what was the point of you starting this thread? To list your credit history's life story or to get help? Or both?
DiabloD3
Senior Member
posted: Aug. 19, 2008 @ 3:15p
So, I'm thinking KevinKevinKevin has a new nick, AlimoAlimoAlimo.
Oh, and BTW, $5k -> $70k is a 14 fold increase, $50k to $200k is just a 4 fold increase. I'm not sure where you were going with that.
Going from no credit -> any credit is any infinite increase...way more than a 14x increase. I was talking in terms of total gain. And it's over a very short period of time whereas yours took a couple years. Because of the Mod's request, I won't post anything that'll be considered arguing.
My advice to you is to pay off your cards ASAP. Call the credit bureaus and make sure they update the reports so you have no balance reporting. Idk when you went for your soft-pull CLI requests, but if it's been a little while, give them one last go. AVOID HARD-INQUIRIES. Your 1 last inquiry is not important. 1 inquiry = ~a 2 point drop.
Get a list of cards ready NOW and get it critiqued while you pay your balances off. Who knows when the credit market will stop sucking. Can you make money now off of 0% BT offers? Yes. So why wait?
And I wasn't joking when I said you need to read (and re-read) more threads.
Nonaii
Senior Member
posted: Aug. 20, 2008 @ 7:33a
This is an interesting thread on what not to do. To be honest, I don't think Diablo is much different from the higher rollers here who apply apply apply. It's all a game, and it feels good to succeed. The higher rollers just get thousands of money in balance transfer interest out of it while they're at it, and are more tactical about their credit safari. But the hunt is the same.
Otherwise, patience is a virtue.
I also believe the following post has a lot more general wisdom in it than snark:
Alimo said: Bro, it's been over a year and you STILL HAVEN'T HAD YOUR AOR. That doesn't tell you something?
Where do you (or any of us) want to be a year from now? When we look back, do we want to be satisfied with how far we've come, or agonizing over how we could have done things differently? When we're in the same place we were a year before, that's not progress. When we're only slightly better off than we were a year before, that's better, but it isn't the best.
I think the focus on App-O-Ramas here has distorted the credit picture for many people. There are people who can afford to make a game of credit chases. I'm not one of them.
Diablo, I thank you again for making this thread and keeping up with it for a year. I wish you continued success in your small business, so that it grows into a bigger business. I also thank everyone who has entered this thread with advice, whether it was taken by Diablo or not. Someone else reading it may have.
DiabloD3
Senior Member
posted: Aug. 20, 2008 @ 1:02p
I apologize to anyone if they think I haven't taken their advice. A lot of advice given to me in this thread I have simply stored away for a later time because I haven't hit the point where I feel I can optimally use it.
A lot of people, Alimo included, have said I should simply do the AOR now: no I won't yet, for one reason: many BT offers still have fee caps and I need to make sure I can hit many of those as possible. For example, if a BT has 3% fee but a cap of $200 (highest I've seen), I need to BT at least $6666 to hit the cap, which implies a credit limit of at least $7800 (using 89% max utilization as a guide).
Now, BOA's Check For Offers form says that if they issued me a card now, it'd have a $5000 limit on any of the three offers they send me. One of them, the BOA Visa Platinum Plus, I get 12 months 0% APR on purchases and BTs both, with a $75 fee cap. The CLI they issue me would have to be at least partially accurate to the $5000 limit they offer me on the prescreen form, or over $2900.
So you can see why I'm still trying to shore up how my report looks: if BOA is only willing to give me $5k on my first line with them, whats even the point? And I still have to worry about what AMEX and Discover think: last time I fished for credit from them I was denied, although this was a year ago so things may have changed.
Alimo
Member
posted: Aug. 20, 2008 @ 2:01p
AMEX may want to see aged accounts, I don't know. For my mini-AOR, that was Discover's reason for denying me. My scores were 748/749/749 and a pretty HHI so I'm pretty sure when they told me they like to see 3 major credit cards with at least a year of history, it was correct (I only had 2 credit cards pre-AOR).
What was the point of getting your other CC's when they only give you $500 credit limits? You start somewhere with each company. If you want, apply for 2 BOA cards. IIRC, BOA is lenient when it comes to reallocating your lines. Check up on Citi and Chases's reallocation policies. You have decent lines with both. If you get a low limit, you can reallocate to them.
BTW, my recommendation was more for 1-2 months from now, but preferably sooner. Pay all your balances off ASAP and wait til the $0 balances report onto your credit reports. You can speeden the time up by contacting the bureaus. Make sure all your credit limits are reported. I think some cards report your credit limit as the highest amount you've ever put on the card.
You are looking to ABSOLUTELY MAXIMIZE your profit out of your first AOR. You'll just end up waiting and waiting. What if 6 months passes? That's 6 months of (less) profit gone to waste. Less profit > no profit. Start it sooner. Get your feet wet. Stop planning every last detail. If one minor detail doesn't go according to plan, you'll beat yourself up over it if everything doesn't go perfectly. What's the worse you can lose? You might get a couple hundred dollars less over a period of a year.
Anyway, it's your life, your credit, your money.
DiabloD3
Senior Member
posted: Aug. 24, 2008 @ 6:52a
I've updated the OP post. I'm going to merge my Sony card into my Amazon card so if Chase decides to reallocate to issue I don't have to worry about my Amazon card being hit heavily.
Is there any known problems with Cardselection? Like, do they actually pay out as promised?
Also, is there any reason why I should not lie heavily about HHI?
Alimo said: AMEX may want to see aged accounts, I don't know. For my mini-AOR, that was Discover's reason for denying me. My scores were 748/749/749 and a pretty HHI so I'm pretty sure when they told me they like to see 3 major credit cards with at least a year of history, it was correct (I only had 2 credit cards pre-AOR).
What was the point of getting your other CC's when they only give you $500 credit limits? You start somewhere with each company. If you want, apply for 2 BOA cards. IIRC, BOA is lenient when it comes to reallocating your lines. Check up on Citi and Chases's reallocation policies. You have decent lines with both. If you get a low limit, you can reallocate to them.
BTW, my recommendation was more for 1-2 months from now, but preferably sooner. Pay all your balances off ASAP and wait til the $0 balances report onto your credit reports. You can speeden the time up by contacting the bureaus. Make sure all your credit limits are reported. I think some cards report your credit limit as the highest amount you've ever put on the card.
You are looking to ABSOLUTELY MAXIMIZE your profit out of your first AOR. You'll just end up waiting and waiting. What if 6 months passes? That's 6 months of (less) profit gone to waste. Less profit > no profit. Start it sooner. Get your feet wet. Stop planning every last detail. If one minor detail doesn't go according to plan, you'll beat yourself up over it if everything doesn't go perfectly. What's the worse you can lose? You might get a couple hundred dollars less over a period of a year.
Anyway, it's your life, your credit, your money.Exactly - with a young, thin file such as yours, the profit from an A0R is in the signup bonuses, not BT money. Each day you delay taking step one is another day you have to wait to take step two (where the BT profit comes into play).
markkundinger
Senior Member - 2K
posted: Aug. 25, 2008 @ 10:03a
DiabloD3 said: Also, is there any reason why I should not lie heavily about HHI? a) It's lying. b) You will fail any financial reviews. Most notably done by AMEX.
DiabloD3
Senior Member
posted: Aug. 25, 2008 @ 10:36a
Well, I know AMEX ones can be shorted by calling up and canceling the card... shouldn't this also work with other banks? Also, I can just refuse to participate in the witchhunt, the worst they can do is just cancel the card and ask for the money back anyhow.
Alimo
Member
posted: Aug. 26, 2008 @ 1:57a
You shouldn't just assume that's all they can do. I would think if your credit card was canceled due to falsifying documents, it would show up on your credit report. Just a guess, but you should make sure nothing will happen first.
Either way, I'm with markkundinger on this.
With regards to your OP, it doesn't look like you're chasing bonuses as much as you should be. And yes, cardselection does pay. It took about a month, iirc, for me to get my check, but it came.
DiabloD3
Senior Member
posted: Aug. 26, 2008 @ 2:56a
To be honest, there really aren't that many bonuses left out there. Almost every issuer out there has retracted their tendrils a fair bit due to the credit crunch. That said, through Cardselection alone I'd be making $205, the CitiBus TY is 15k TY points, the Citi PremierPass is 10k TY points, and the Discover Bus has a $100 bonus (after spending $1000); plus there is the no fee BT cards.
So real bonuses alone I'd automatically be making about ~$550. It may not be up to what other AoRers have done, but its $550 free dollars.
I think I'm going to add the Advanta 2.99% for life of BT card, but I remember people having problems with that company but I can't find anything now that I'm actually looking for it. Does anyone remember what the problem was?
Edit: The AMEX Starwood card has 10k Starwood points... are these useful for anything? I don't fly, and tons of cards have bonuses related to flying.
Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.
Members of our community may attach files to a post in accordance with the User Agreement. FatWallet is not responsible for the content, accuracy, completeness or validity of any information contained in any attached file. Files have *not* been scanned for viruses. Be especially wary of Excel files which may contain malicious content.