Edit

Forums
Finance

My Second App-O-Rama (06/19/07) - jairocon - In Progress Archived From: Finance

  • tweet this
  • Post to Facebook
  • Text Only
  • Search this Topic »
  • Classic
alert mods    

Google is your friend
Elan is the company servicing a lot of the cards not issued by the biggest banks. Similar to the FIA division of Bank of America, former MBNA cobranded credit cards.


alert mods    

Very nice detailed post on your second AoR. Since I am still on the fence about doing a second I am interested in following the results, especially on all those deferred. My worry about a second AoR is the majors like CITI, Chase and BoA either reducing my CL's or giving me crappy lines on new cards, And rejection would kill me. I think the only way I could do a successful AoR would be to include business cards. My company has a 40 year history of excellent credit, So I know I could get some nice lines. Just not sure if I should drag it into the AoR game. I always remember some business advice from my Father, One was "Don't crap where you eat" and "Don't stick your d!ck in the paycheck" I already screwed up on the second and don't want to go 2 for 2.


alert mods    

scott1961 said:Very nice detailed post on your second AoR. Since I am still on the fence about doing a second I am interested in following the results, especially on all those deferred. My worry about a second AoR is the majors like CITI, Chase and BoA either reducing my CL's or giving me crappy lines on new cards, And rejection would kill me. I think the only way I could do a successful AoR would be to include business cards. My company has a 40 year history of excellent credit, So I know I could get some nice lines. Just not sure if I should drag it into the AoR game. I always remember some business advice from my Father, One was "Don't crap where you eat" and "Don't stick your d!ck in the paycheck" I already screwed up on the second and don't want to go 2 for 2.

scott, you sure are a scared puppy. i know you have a lot to lose, but the odds of you losing any of it are very, very small. you know this game is not rocket science, and you are obviously quite adept at managing your finances. take advantage of your business credit, and continue to keep your personal credit relatively spotless. AOR earnings are super small potatoes for someone with your wealth, so the only reason to do another would be for fun. if you don't think it would be fun, skip it.

and rejection, who cares about rejection? you're not asking anybody to the prom!


alert mods    

lhendricks92 said:

scott, you sure are a scared puppy. i know you have a lot to lose, but the odds of you losing any of it are very, very small. you know this game is not rocket science, and you are obviously quite adept at managing your finances. take advantage of your business credit, and continue to keep your personal credit relatively spotless.

Not worried about losing anything I just don't get how it would work. Wouldn't the money have to go into our corporate bank account? Who makes the minimum payments? Then how do I get it out without being taxed? I would have to explain what I am doing to my controller and our accounting firm and not sure I want to do that. I guess I should go read up on some business AoR threads


alert mods    

scott1961 said:
Not worried about losing anything I just don't get how it would work. Wouldn't the money have to go into our corporate bank account? Who makes the minimum payments? Then how do I get it out without being taxed? I would have to explain what I am doing to my controller and our accounting firm and not sure I want to do that. I guess I should go read up on some business AoR threads

ok, got ya. i haven't involved my company in my business credit card games. i BT to personal cards and personal savings accounts. no money actually goes through my company. i just look at these cards the same as my personal accounts. in many ways, the issuers do the same thing. that's why they ask for your SSN and hit you with hard pulls on your personal report. the beauty is that they DO seem to treat these accounts differently when it comes to utilization, and of course the accounts are hidden from the personal CRAs. no one has in the forum reported any adverse action from high business utilization.

and, if you're worried about your business credit rating, it appears that payment timeliness is what matters, not utilization.


alert mods    

scott1961 said:lhendricks92 said:

scott, you sure are a scared puppy. i know you have a lot to lose, but the odds of you losing any of it are very, very small. you know this game is not rocket science, and you are obviously quite adept at managing your finances. take advantage of your business credit, and continue to keep your personal credit relatively spotless.

Not worried about losing anything I just don't get how it would work. Wouldn't the money have to go into our corporate bank account? Who makes the minimum payments? Then how do I get it out without being taxed? I would have to explain what I am doing to my controller and our accounting firm and not sure I want to do that. I guess I should go read up on some business AoR threads

Scott1961: Why not just apply for some Business Cards using "Scott Consulting, Inc.", leaving your 40-year old business out of the picture? Bus cards are your friend IMO.


alert mods    

Saturday's mail:

- Chase biz came with only $10k CL! That's how much they took from my personal line! They were supposed to add $5k CL on top of it. I'll have to complain about it when I call to activate. Still waiting to see if the United cards were approved or not.

- BofA biz card showed up w/ $25k line as expected, terms included w/ card specify BT fee $10 min, uncapped. I'll still take the BT and then complain about the fee.

- Citi Biz denied (don't know which one) - says too many inquiries. Although I also got an email that Citi Biz was approved. So most likely one denial and one approval - will see which one.

- Fidelity card came with $8k CL.

- National City (personal) came with $10k CL.

- Wells Fargo denied the personal card, stating that I have short history as a Wells Fargo customer!!! What the heck are they smoking? I've had their checking account since 1996! I don't use it much, nor keep much money in it, but it still is active. I'll call them and complain.

- RBS Kroger denied stating too many inquiries. Will call for reconsideration.

I have yet to call the issuers - I gave my home number on the apps, not my cell number - and I'm home mostly at nights, when the credit decisions departments are closed... I don't want to call from my cell, since it's unlisted and last year during AOR I called to activate my cards from a different phone number and number of banks got spooked and it took a while to "de-fraud" the cards.

So for Saturday mail - we added $18k to personal, but we're subtracting $5k from biz lines.

Total new CLs approved (so far):
Personal: $132,000
Business: $32,000


alert mods    

I'll be updating the thread in a few minutes - I'm in the process of calling about the rejections - it is pretty tough to argue when they come and say something along the lines: "Sir, you have 10+ new account inquiries on 6/19 - I really can't approve you for an account - I don't understand why would you need so many new accounts..."

Anyway - the good news:

#18 - National City Business - $10k approved! I called in about the rejection and the lady on the phone overturned it. I asked for 15-20k, she said she can't go higher than 10k since I already got 10k on personal.

#12 - Wells Fargo - called in about the ridiculous rejection (insufficient duration/relationship w/ Wells Fargo) - they reversed the denial but it will still take 1-2 business days for a new decision.

#08 - Kroger - that was a pretty strong NO when I called in about the denial letter. No wonder - they pulled on 6/22 - 4 days after the AOR - and they pulled Equifax where most of the damage happened!

I have 3 more denials to call about: #27 principal bank (Equifax), #28 first bankcard (probably Equifax - ICS), #29 citi business (Equifax) -- I don't really feel like calling - since these were late applications and all were Equifax pullers - so I'm not surprised these were denials.


alert mods    

By the way:

More Cards Received:

#08 - Capital One Biz $7k CL
#10 - Citi Biz $12k
#17 - BofA NFL $2k CL
#21 - Chase United Biz $15k CL
#30 - Am.Ex Starwood Biz $24k CL

Cards Approved
#20 - Chase United $10k (they just moved $10k from my older Chase card)


Cards Denied
#29 - Citi Biz Premier Pass - too many inquiries (Equifax) 6/20

Extra CL received:
#15 - Fidelity, which was approved for $8k - got a bump upon activation to $10k

Will update totals and OP in a few minutes.


alert mods    

Holy Smokes - just got a call back from National City Business - and they increased the CL to $20k!!!. I spoke to the Credit Underwiter lady and when I asked for 15-20k, she hesitated and said that the most she can approve for is 10k, then I mentioned that I'd like to take advantage of the BT offer, but she wouldn't budge. And 15 minutes later I get a call that she spoke to a supervisor and because of my great credit history they agreed to approve me for $20k! Awesome!

I just got done talking to M&T Business (it's the application I submitted earlier this week. I verified all my info and they were really keen on putting "doing business as" on the application - so now it will be My name DBA Company name - even though I am a sole prop and the Company name is not registered anywhere. Oh well, we'll see how that turns out. She said it will be another 3-5 business days for decision.


alert mods    

Total new CLs approved (so far):
Personal: $134,000
Business: $82,000

I am still waiting to see/hear anything from:
#04 - Juniper Biz (this should have been approved I got an email that it was, but nothing in regular mail)
#05 - Citi Driver's Edge
#23 - Wachovia (I have a feeling I didn't apply for it)
#32 - Citi AA personal (It's most likely going to be a denial)
#33 - FIA Schwab (I'm starting to get a feeling that I didn't apply for it)

Reconsiderations in the air:
#12 - Wells Fargo (personal)
#19 - M&T (business) - this one should be actually numbered #35

Interestingly, I have a $100 payment on my MBNA card, which I put as a BT target on the Juniper applications, but I asked for $20k BTs on those... so that's very weird, as I didn't pay $100 towards that card.

The only BT so far that was processed was Integra $4.9k (out of $5k line) going into my MBNA card. Besides the BTs that I asked for on the applications I have yet to do any other BTs, as I'm trying to organize this whole circus.

All of a sudden I have 37 active credit cards in my credit card folder and I'm running out of room


alert mods    

jairocon said:it is pretty tough to argue when they come and say something along the lines: "Sir, you have 10+ new account inquiries on 6/19
The line I'm tempted to use is "Sorry, I was making my annual review of my credit cards, and I asked I inquired for increases from many of them before applying for yours. It got kind of out of hand."


alert mods    

very, very nice results. congrats!

As far as CapOne, you said "request a high BT (mostly treated as purchases)"

I can't figure out CapOne and the whole purchase=BT thing. Can you break it down for me...and slow?


alert mods    

markkundinger said:jairocon said:it is pretty tough to argue when they come and say something along the lines: "Sir, you have 10+ new account inquiries on 6/19
The line I'm tempted to use is "Sorry, I was making my annual review of my credit cards, and I asked I inquired for increases from many of them before applying for yours. It got kind of out of hand."
Mark - that's precisely what I said that I was just asking for CLIs, the Kroger woman said in a very stern voice - these inquiries are not from CLIs, these are new account applications! I guess the inquiries are also tagged with whatever reasons they were pulled for (CLI, new account, ...). And while I pointed out my great record, no negatives, fairly long history, fairly high lines, high balances reported and then paid - she wouldn't get pass the inquiries and then also pointed out that I have a large number of accounts that are only around 1 year old. So I gave up.


alert mods    

lhendricks92 said:very, very nice results. congrats!

As far as CapOne, you said "request a high BT (mostly treated as purchases)"

I can't figure out CapOne and the whole purchase=BT thing. Can you break it down for me...and slow?
For the Biz application there was no place to request a BT on the application. Otherwise I would have asked for at least $20k. It's been reported that asking for high BT w/ Cap1 results in high lines. What it comes down to is this:

#1. BT fees = none
#2. BTs are treated as purchases - so there is actually a grace period and if you pay them off before the statement cuts then no interest is charged (or so I read on other threads).

Take it with a grain of salt as I have no experience with it yet.


alert mods    

jairocon said:#2. BTs are treated as purchases - so there is actually a grace period and if you pay them off before the statement cuts then no interest is charged (or so I read on other threads).

I see, so they're high maintenance BTs, in that you have to request and pay them off every month (and the purchase promo rate doesn't apply). Thanks for the explanation.


alert mods    

lhendricks92 said:jairocon said:#2. BTs are treated as purchases - so there is actually a grace period and if you pay them off before the statement cuts then no interest is charged (or so I read on other threads).I see, so they're high maintenance BTs, in that you have to request and pay them off every month (and the purchase promo rate doesn't apply). Thanks for the explanation.I think I read somewhere that Cap1 is very eager in sending BT checks out. So people use that.

Bad news - M&T seems to have pulled Equifax (I was hoping for Transunion pull)
ELANFINSVC 07/05/2007 Equifax

Since that's inquiry #18 within last 6 months, I can safely predict that it will get denied. Oh well.


alert mods    

jairocon said:Instant Results: deferred
Deferred Results: Approved for $8k CL! Asked for CLI upon activation - approved - new line: $10k!
Note: it is a Visa Signature card - doesn't report CL - will need to see what can be done

Do you mean Fidelity 1.5% Cash Back is not reported in your credit report at all like a business card? or that it reports credit balances instead of CL??


alert mods    

pyro123 said:jairocon said:Instant Results: deferred
Deferred Results: Approved for $8k CL! Asked for CLI upon activation - approved - new line: $10k!
Note: it is a Visa Signature card - doesn't report CL - will need to see what can be done
Do you mean Fidelity 1.5% Cash Back is not reported in your credit report at all like a business card? or that it reports credit balances instead of CL??
It is not a business card, so it is reported on my credit report. Secondly it only reports high balances, not the whole CL. Does anyone know if I can "downgrade it" to a regular platinum card?


alert mods    

I've been able to get FIA to report my true CL on the Fidelity card, although it does seem to be YMMV.


 Close

Sign Me In
Nickname: 
Password: 
Remember My Login Information:

Forget your login information?

Not Already A Member?
Sign Up Now!



Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.


While FatWallet makes every effort to post correct information, offers are subject to change without notice.
Some exclusions may apply based upon merchant policies.
© 1999-2009