click to close
help
edit

Forums
Finance

MaddHatter's AOR 8-13-07: All done, but for Citi rolling thunder in: Discussion

  • filter:
  • Tell A Friend
  • Text Only
  • Search this Topic »
  • switch to 'Classic' view
  • Go to Page :
  • 1 23457
rated:
alert mods    

Edit: Apps away on 8/13, results in quick summary

Vitals
Age: 28
HHI: 105k, 20k increase from HHI reported on last app spree (wife and I; she has crap credit so no wife-o-rama)
Credit History: 12 years worth, consisting of 4 paid car loans, mortgage, credit cards, utilities. No blemishes. I do not know my credit score, this will be a “flying blind” AOR as of now (did it get hotter in here all of a sudden?). Pulled free report last month and no erroneous info.
Assets/Obligations (no e-bragging, but in case of FR considerations): 60k in savings, 33k in Roth/401k. Will owe 50k on 80k mortgage (125k house) after 10k payment this month. In house since ’02, two cars paid-for. CC obligations below.

Current cards (Issuer and type/approx age/current bal/CL/comments)
Citi Phillips-Conoco-Unocal 76 Platinum MC/4 yrs/$0/$4000/unused in years, Citi won’t allow reallocation
Citi AT&T Universal MC/10 mos/$0/$13200/ Have two months to use “BT” for 12 mos 0%
Citi Diamond Express Rewards AMEX/10 mos/$8777/$11000/ 0% BT up in Oct
Discover Platinum/6 yrs/$0/$10000
Discover Gas Card/10 mos/$6100/$7500/ 0% BT up in Oct, gas spender
Chase Platinum Visa/2 yrs/$0/$1000/got fraud alert call and new card/# last fall, previously had reallocated 9k to below card
Chase Cash Rewards Plus MC/10 mos/$8950/$12000/ 0% up in Oct, daily spender
HSBC Best Buy Card/4 yrs/$0/$2300/used to buy TV at 0% Edit 7/20 Card is "inactive" and I'd need to mail in a request to be officially closed... since it's "not in their system", I'll expect HSBC not to deny me based on having a card

Total balance/CL: 23827/61000 = 39% util (cards with balances are estimated for month-end after purchases)
Edit: Paid all bals to <50% 7/31, overall util <30%.
The only other CC is a 3yr old Citi Platinum Dividend Select I let them close last fall following elimination of 5% and my app spree/reallocation (consolidated to AT&T and instructed them it needed to be shown as closed at my request).
Average account age: just over 2 years

Goals
1. Get as much OPM at 0% as possible thru a number of cards I can reasonably handle.
2. Overall CL to keep utilization reasonable.
3. Bonuses are nice, but not a huge deal
4. Keep a hedge for future 0% when this round is up (hello Citibank)
5. Keep it as straightforward and "easy" as it can be, i.e. keeping all BTs at 6 or 12 mos, no calls to cancel 2nd year annual fees or whatever, etc Edit 7/22 Aw nuts to this, I'm in it to win it. Enter the business cards, 2nd yr cancellations, and FRs

Planned applications Issuer and type/BT months/Max BT fee/comments or tentative post-app plans (all BT rates are 0% if applicable)
1. AMEX Blue/12/$0/targetted offer expiring 7/20 Edit 8/12: no-go thru site, application line said I could mail it in, customer service gave me a fax #. Will fax in tonight, but will it do any good?
2. AMEX In:Chicago/6/$0/$50 bonus, would reallocate to Blue before BT, or if no Blue just use it here
3. Citi Professional/12/$0/15k TYP Before You Go. request BT check to self
4. Citi Driver’s Edge/12/$0/BT offer good for 12 months after opening, plan to use this after using as daily spender for a year, may try to reallocate portion to Professional
5. BOA Platinum Plus Visa/12/$0/ phone request direct deposit
6. BOA Worldpoints Platinum Plus/12/uncapped/ would make 1 purchase for $50, payoff immediately, then reallocate to Platinum Plus before BT
7. National City Visa/6/$0/ think I’ll send this to Chase Cash Plus (not at app)
8. WAMU ESPN Total Access Visa/12/$75/ targetted offer, instead of 6 mo offer, but not requesting BT until I see CL
9. Juniper National Parks Visa/12/$50/ would wait for BT welcome checks and hope to write to wife
10. Juniper Emigrant Direct Mastercard/6/$75/No BTing here, non-EDP spender unless I get the HSBC 2%
11. US Bank Baylor Alumni Visa/12/$0 BT to Discover Gas?
12. Chase Sony Visa/12/$75/$100 bonus/ Would reallocate from existing Cash Plus and the below and hopefully get welcome check?
13. Chase USBC MC/12/$75/$35 bonus, reallocate to Sony Visa
14. HSBC/Orchard Bank 2% CB MC/NA/NA/ if I get the 2% back, no fee one with at least 1000 CL it’s my non-EDP spender. Should I be canceling my BB card about now?
15. RBS Kroger 1-2-3 MC/12/$75/ hope for BT welcome checks, otherwise ? may keep the unused CL
16. Discover Miles Card/12/$75/ 1000 miles for 1st 12 months with purchase, fortunately 0% on those too
17. Captial One Platinum/NA/NA/for $50 bonus and overall CL only

Why not business cards (Likely because I’m a schmuck…)
Edit 7/22 Yes, business cards
1. Citibusiness Card/12/$0/15k TYP "before you go", BT offer good for first 12 months and would plan to use as such
2. AMEX Gold Business/NA/NA/25k points, $100 gc thru TigerDirect, remember to cancel in 1 yr
3. Bank Atlantic Business rewards (Juniper)/15/$75
4. Chase GM Business Card/12/$75/$30 thru cardselection
5. Chase United Mileage Plus Platinum/12/$75/25k miles with $250 in purch, remember to cancel in 1 yr
6. Advanta Business/15/$50/$25 thru cardselection
7 .Discover Business/12/$75/$40 thru cardselection
8. National City Visa/6/$0?
9. M&T Bank Visa/6/$0
10. Citbusiness Premier Pass/12/$0/15k TYP, $75 annual fee in yr 2, so would use this Citi first for any BT
Edit 8/15/0711. Fifth Third Business Mastercard/12/$0/came across the link, why not apply

Plan of action and musings
1. 7/30, 7/31 payments will be applied to the three cards with balances above, taking each utilization below 70% Overall utilization would fall below 35%. These cards’ statement dates fall around 8/6.
Original plan was to leave balances on the cards to have something to launder with, but after writing it all out, it doesn’t look like I’d need much, if any, for balances to BT to. Edit 7/20 Scheduled add'l payments next week, on 8/1 all balances will be under <50% and overall util will be <30%
2. 8/6 Try for soft CLIs on existing Citi cards (or should I be doing that nowish?) Edit: Tried and failed on Citi softs 7/18 This is also when 10k would be going from savings -> mortgage.
3. 8/11 – 8/12 Confirm all web links/phone numbers. I will be on a Mac, and have Firefox as a backup for anything Safari doesn’t like.
4. 8/13 Noonish – Apps away. Selected for Monday-ness and to allow time for balances to update.
Will go in general order of desire, but should phone app(s) come first/last? Now with so many cards and instant reporting I'm more preoccupied with the "ideal order".
5. After hearing word from most/all applications, I will call Citibank to reallocate to existing AT&T/new Professional and probably get screwed.
6. Hit the AMEX crack-CLIs (keeping it under 20k/card) if I have the cards, request hard-pull CLIs from others?
7. Attempt to perform BTs as indicated in app list, as well as existing AT&T BT. Funds will wind up at Emigrant. I will try to keep well <80% overall utilization, and not go over 90% on any one card.
8. Following payoff of Citi Diamond AMEX, attempt reallocation to Professional and BT.
9. Pray for no AMEX FR if applicable.

I am appreciative of all constructive feedback and recommendations. I will either act on it or attempt to explain my reasoning for not. I also hope my experience can be of assistance to others; to give back a little to a board I’ve enjoyed thoroughly, so I will continue to post updates. I have lurked (and READ!) on the board for a year plus, conducting a mini-app spree (AOR .5) last September. This will be AOR “Version 1”, and I hope to enjoy the success many other FWers have. Thanks for reading.

Message edited by: MaddHatter on 2008-08-30 20:31:29 CDT

Application results in order, and updated as they come in

AMEX Blue/submitted with 10kish in BT - $2000 CL pffft
Citi Professional/Instant $6000, then $2000 after reallocation
Citi Driver's Edge/Deferred-Approved-$4000 via moving $3500 from existing Phillips card
CitiBusiness/Deferred-Approved-$8000- then $1000 after reallocation
Citi PremierPass/Deferred-Approved-$4000, reallocate from Professional & CitiBiz to $15000, req $14000 check
AMEX Gold Business/Approved
Advanta Platinum Bus with Rewards/Approved-$2500, online CLI rejected. Weak.
Bank Atlantic Business/Deferred-Approved $10000-CLI to $14500-BT $13000 to Citi AT&T Universal
BOA Platinum Visa/Instant $17500 - Two ACHs due to laundering, wound up at $17030/$19000 after realloc
BOA Worldpoints Platinum/Deferred - Approved $2500, realloc $1500 to above
AMEX In:Chicago/Instant $2000 - Req CLI to $21k, got 7-10 day message, denied. pffft.
US Bank Baylor Alumni/Instant $7000-No CLI for 6 mos. Requested BT check 8/17 for $6250 to CU account
Chase Sony Card/Deferred-Approved $4000
Chase USBC MC/Instant-No CL. $4000
Juniper National Parks/Iowans and Puerto Ricans can't have it!!! FAIL.
Chase GM Business/Deferred-Approved $10000, reallocated to $28000 - $25100 self-deposit check
Chase United Mileage Plus Platinum/Deferred-Approved $10000-reallocated $8k to GM
RBS Kroger 1-2-3/Deferred-Approved after call- $6000 - $5600 self-deposit check
WAMU ESPN Visa/Instant $30,000! -had requested $13k BT to Diamond AMEX
Discover Miles/Deferred- Denied for too many accounts
Juniper Emigrant Direct/Deferred-Approved $5000
Discover Business/Deferred- Called 8/24, reallocated from personals, approved for $13500- BT $12070 to BOA Platinum Visa
M&T Bank Business/Deferred - Approved $10000- Req $9900 BT online 9/11 to credit union
National City Business/Deferred- Approved $5000- Req $5000 check to CU 9/17
National City Personal/Deferred-Approved $12,500-Requested $11100 check 8/24
HSBC Snap 2%/Offered only cards with annual fees, no thanks
CapOne Visa/Reconsidering application with so many deferalls, the $50 bonus may not be worth the 3 CRA hits
Fifth Third Business Mastercard/Deferred-Denied (out of lending area, inquiries)

Bonuses listed as received
$35 Chase USBC MC statement credit - recvd 8/29 after 8/23 purchase
$95 Cardselection check - recvd 9/7 (where's the Citi Driver's Edge bonus?)
15,000 TYP Citi Professional - recvd 9/7 at close
15,000 TYP CitiBusiness Plat Select- recvd at statement close
15,000 TYP CitiBusiness PremierPass - recvd at statement close
25k MRP for AMEX Gold Business - recvd 10/25 after stmt
$150 TigerDirect GC AMEX Gold app - recvd 10/4, won't complain about the extra $50
$100 statement credit Sony Card - recvd 9/18 after 9/6 purchase
(actually 10k) 5k "Inside Rewards" points for AMEX In: Chicago - recvd 10/7ish with stmt close
25,000 pts from United Chase - recvd 10/20 after stmt close
5,000 pts from BOA Worldpoints -
$25 gift certificate to ESPNshop - redeemed points once access code arrived 9/19


Final numbers
Total Business: $79070/$91500 (all new) = 86% (includes 2 $75 BT fees, $26070 still in process, $14900 will be 6 mos, rest is 12 mos)
Total Personal: $65005/$131700 ($96000 new)= 49% (this includes 2 $75 BT fees, the rest is 0% for 12 months aside from $11.1k that's 6. Doesn't include purchase balances for bonus that will be paid in full or regular spenders paid each month. One BT on pre-existing Citi card.)

My not-very-specific-bottom-line: $25,000 for 6, $115,995 for 12, and $13,000 for 15 mos - setup,float,fees,and min payment loss + all bonuses = $7200 still (before taxes), easy. Interest earned was assumed 5.05 APY, however currently $45k (and larger percentages going forward) is earning 5.5%. I'd say estimate is fairly conservative.

Message edited by: MaddHatter on 2007-10-29 19:25:59 CDT
rated:
alert mods    

If 8/13 is your target application date, then you want to try for soft pull CLIs NOW. Give them enough time to get reported.

My recommendation would be to wait until your three cards with substantial balances are paid off. Not that we know what the effect will be on your credit score, but it might be significant.

rated:
alert mods    

I would definitely get some business cards

rated:
alert mods    

markkundinger said:If 8/13 is your target application date, then you want to try for soft pull CLIs NOW. Give them enough time to get reported.

My recommendation would be to wait until your three cards with substantial balances are paid off. Not that we know what the effect will be on your credit score, but it might be significant.

Soft pulls on Citibanks were all no-gos, ouch.
And I wouldn't necessarily even need to hold off, I could get the money out of Emigrant and against the cards by the 24th. But I guess I'd need to make that decision quickly huh. These cards' close dates are around 8-6, and I've been figuring whatever I pay down by then would report by the 13th.

rated:
alert mods    

MaddHatter said:
Why not business cards (Likely because I’m a schmuck…)
Partially due to the number of balances I want to be juggling…I don’t have MBNA BP, just signed up for Yodlee (but make all my payments thru issuer sites)
And partially because of a “feeling” that while I’m playing the system, I play within the rules of that system. Fact is, I have nothing that could ever be interpreted as a business (whether that’s explicit or implicit in the applications). My reported business income would have to be $0.

You don't have to own a business to apply for business cards. Business is a lose term - the money you make by doing an AOR can be called a business. Heck, if you play bingo then it is a business too!! Having said that I myself did not apply for business cards last time I did my AOR but am planning to do it this time. Since my reported business income will be $0 like you, I don't expect great results from my business card applications but I will try it after I am done with personal cards.

rated:
alert mods    

why aren't you using the 0% BT check that comes in the sony welcome package?

rated:
alert mods    

MaddHatter said:1. AMEX Blue/12/$0/targetted offer expiring 7-30, wonder if I could apply late via web or phone?
You could apply earlier than the others, this doesn't seem like a very difficult card to get so they might not care as much about utilization - you can poke around creditboards to see if it's an ok card to get while your report is still damaged.

Do you have any other Am3x offers that are past their expiration date that you could try starting an application with to see if the correct terms show?

rated:
alert mods    

MaddHatter said:Why not business cards (Likely because I’m a schmuck…)
GET THE BUSINESS CARDS! My mom just applied for 9 business cards as a sole prop., $0 revenue, 0 years in business. She knows nothing about business nor what a sole prop. even is. She was approved for ALL 9 and received almost 125 grand in business credit alone she can take to 95% utilization that doesn't show on your credit report. I will copy my little guide again for you:


If you do not have a business, and want to apply for business cards for 0% promos for personal use, just put Sole Propritership and your name as the business title, then use your SSN as the TIN. This is perfectly legal option (you can even ask the reps if you dont' believe me).

You are also the owner of a sole prop, so you have authorization to make transactions and get credit. As long as you have ever sold anything (ie books, electronics, especially anything online (eBay/Amazon) that could be verified) you are indeed a sole prop. There is not filing with the state need for a sole prop, and for tax purposes, your TIN is your SSN.

I DO NOT RECOMMEND using your day job randomly as the business name unless you are an authorized officer to make transactions on behalf of your buinsess. Regardless, you should not be using your day job business as a basis for your personal 0% money either way. This is fraud and could land you in serious trouble both with the credit card company and your job and the government.

To summarize:

Business type: Sole Prop.
Business name: Your exact name here
Tax Identification Number: Your social security number here.

**Do not lie about your revenue/business income if asked (never lie about anything). Be honest, it doesn't mean you will get rejected. It could just mean you are a startup to the credit company. I only had less than 1k revenue in eBay sales and managed to get almost 50k of total business credit through 6 different cards.

rated:
alert mods    

Mike, when are you going to start AORs for cousins, nieces, nephews, grandparents, the mailman, corner butcher, etc.?

rated:
alert mods    

I had 5 business apps on my wife-o-rama launched the other day (all deferred). Put income and revenue as $1,000 (she does some freelance graphic design). I'll report back on the results of those biz cards as they come.

rated:
alert mods    

lhendricks92 said:Mike, when are you going to start AORs for cousins, nieces, nephews, grandparents, the mailman, corner butcher, etc.?
I'll speak to them all this weekend, I'm posting flyers in the neighborhood as we speak

Flyer: "Come let MikeR397 trash your credit score and borrow hundreds of thousands of your credit so can can profit and buy himslef a car, put himself through law school, and max out ROTH contributions" (all courtsy of the good old credit card companies, and all the help from those on FW!) Darn I wish I had more family members (two sets of parents with 775 credit scores would be nice.

rated:
alert mods    

lrothkcsa said:I had 5 business apps on my wife-o-rama launched the other day (all deferred). Put income and revenue as $1,000 (she does some freelance graphic design). I'll report back on the results of those biz cards as they come. Great! Take advantage of those offers. Don't be bothered by the deferred status, almost all business apps get deferred at first, but typically come in as some of your highest credit lines. Good luck. Alright people, my employer is demanding I do 15 minutes of real, actual work this week, so I will return in about 45 minutes (have to eat lunch )

rated:
alert mods    

When it comes time to do over the phone reallocations or BT requests who is going to be doing the talking to the CC rep? I almost have my wife convinced to do one, but she doesn't want to do anything. She more or less will let me trash her score to make a few bucks but doesn't want to have to do the reallocating or BT requests over the phone.

rated:
alert mods    

kittenmittens said:MaddHatter said:1. AMEX Blue/12/$0/targetted offer expiring 7-30, wonder if I could apply late via web or phone?
You could apply earlier than the others, this doesn't seem like a very difficult card to get so they might not care as much about utilization - you can poke around creditboards to see if it's an ok card to get while your report is still damaged.

Do you have any other Am3x offers that are past their expiration date that you could try starting an application with to see if the correct terms show?


I don't, unfortunately. And I typo'd the expire date, it's 7-20. I think tomorrow I'll call the number on the offer, tell them I'm interested in the card but am leaving town for 3 weeks and do not want it in my mailbox over that time, could I be given another offer code/will this one still work? If no luck, looks like you're suggesting one pre-AOR inq may be acceptable if it gets me the card? Hmm...

Squeezer99 said: why aren't you using the 0% BT check that comes in the sony welcome package?
Wasn't sure there was one. If so, I'll do exactly that.

I hear everyone on the business card issue. At this point it's basically the # of cards issue. I know generally business offers > personal offers, but I think I'm doing fairly well with what I have down here. For my first AOR, and in light of my time commitments, I don't want to find myself with another 10 or so cards to manage. But there's always "version 2" (which may be close to new house time, so all the better for some business apps).

After I call AMEX tomorrow I think I'll call and cancel my Best Buy card in advance of going after the 2% card.

I'm also almost decided on scheduling another round of payments early next week for the 3 cards with balances. This would take each to below 50% after month-end payments, and overall util to < 30%.

rated:
alert mods    

MaddHatter said:I hear everyone on the business card issue. At this point it's basically the # of cards issue. I know generally business offers > personal offers, but I think I'm doing fairly well with what I have down here.

Allow me to pile on. If you don't want to manage more cards, then replace half of your personal apps with business apps. You will only be doing yourself a favor in terms of your personal credit score AND BT profits.

rated:
alert mods    

MaddHatter said:kittenmittens said:MaddHatter said:1. AMEX Blue/12/$0/targetted offer expiring 7-30, wonder if I could apply late via web or phone?
You could apply earlier than the others, this doesn't seem like a very difficult card to get so they might not care as much about utilization - you can poke around creditboards to see if it's an ok card to get while your report is still damaged.

Do you have any other Am3x offers that are past their expiration date that you could try starting an application with to see if the correct terms show?


I don't, unfortunately. And I typo'd the expire date, it's 7-20. I think tomorrow I'll call the number on the offer, tell them I'm interested in the card but am leaving town for 3 weeks and do not want it in my mailbox over that time, could I be given another offer code/will this one still work? If no luck, looks like you're suggesting one pre-AOR inq may be acceptable if it gets me the card? Hmm...

I have an expired AMEX bluesky targetted app (3.99 LOB) that, when I tried to put in the numbers online, it failed. It told me to call if I still wanted to apply, but it didn't promise me I'd be able to keep the offer. So it seems that AMEX targetted apps are only good for the life of the actual offer.

OTOH, I have a Cap1 offer that expired in march that, when I put the numbers in, it still appears online.

rated:
alert mods    

dbalkunjr said:When it comes time to do over the phone reallocations or BT requests who is going to be doing the talking to the CC rep? I almost have my wife convinced to do one, but she doesn't want to do anything. She more or less will let me trash her score to make a few bucks but doesn't want to have to do the reallocating or BT requests over the phone.Just call in and give them your name, say you are calling on your wife's behalf, they will quickly ask to speak to her to make sure this is ok, then you take it from there. You can also communicate online via thier built in message center. That has been my strategy.

Message edited by: MikeR397 on 2007-07-19 15:20:16 CDT