Has anyone ever attempted requesting an extension of the promotional APR period? While for many, AOR's are regularly scheduled 12-15 months, others may choose not to continue to the AOR2.0, AOR3.0, etc. There are a few archived threads which do not seem to support the idea, but I'd like to create a more thorough thread to explore the option.
A few quotables: (A) mrbean said CSRs are not given much power to modify terms - as far as I can tell, they are given a set of scripts to read to customers who call in, that's about it. The CC companies have their system set up so that it is easier and cheaper for them to set up new accounts than to modify old ones. Each promo has its own code, etc, and is all programed in, such that as long as the application dept CSRs know how to push some buttons (literally), everything will be ok.
(B) Econiomist said Usually CC companies do not extend 0% offers. If you were to pay it off, some may offer 0% in the future. I have had this happen with Citi and BofA cards.
(C) ProfessorKev OP'd ...I just called and the CSR stated that they have no control over that it is a marketing dept. thing...
Here's my conceptual idea and other members post away for alternative thoughts/suggestions/ideas:
During month 4 or 5 of a promo period call in to either plain Vanilla CustServ or Ninja Retention rep (great word markkundinger!). In the QS, add alternate scripts in an attempt to obtain extensions.
I have a better idea. Why don't you try defaulting on all your CC debt, wait a couple months, and then negotiate with your creditors to pay off less than you owe?
theman2 said: I have a better idea. Why don't you try defaulting on all your CC debt, wait a couple months, and then negotiate with your creditors to pay off less than you owe?
Seriously though, why bother with this?As more issuers impose no cap on balance transfers, some may consider scrapping the next AOR altogether and elect to continue arbitrage as long as possible.
The benefits are numerous: less time for new apps, less hassle, better cash flow (no break in arbitrage). Unfortunately, the probability seems very low. I will give it a try in a few months when my balances age.
theman2 said: I have a better idea. Why don't you try defaulting on all your CC debt, wait a couple months, and then negotiate with your creditors to pay off less than you owe?
Somebody must have a small degree of control as there are plenty of people on here who have called into CSR's claiming that they understood one meaning of the terms when the terms really meant something else.
I know the majority of these types of posts involved getting transfer fees and finance charges reversed, but I thought I've read some where people got the end date of their promotional offer changed.
I'll have to do some digging to find some of those posts as they weren't related threads.
gatzdon said: Somebody must have a small degree of control as there are plenty of people on here who have called into CSR's claiming that they understood one meaning of the terms when the terms really meant something else.
Back in January, I called Chase to BT to checking on my brand new Sony Card. CSR said the account wasn't open long enough to do that, but he could reallocate my credit line to another card which also had the 0% offer but had been open for four months. I didn't want the BT that expired 8-07, I wanted the Sony which expired 12-07. He claimed that the other card actually had a few more days than the Sony, all the way to 12-27-07. I took the offer. In August, I called to make sure my BT wasn't ending. Sure enough, it was ending the week I called. The CSR's manager referred it to the correspondence dept, and they sent me a letter a week later (unfortunately, after I paid it off) extending my 0% offer to December on the card I opened in August 06. YMMV, I had a transcript of the phone call in which I authorized the BT, including the CSR's name and the time and date of the call.
taxmantoo said: ... it was ending the week I called. The CSR's manager referred it to the correspondence dept, and they sent me a letter a week later ... extending my 0% offer to December on the card I opened in August 06. .... I had a transcript of the phone call in which I authorized the BT, including the CSR's name and the time and date of the call.Did you have to provide them the transcript, etc to get the mgr to refer it to corr? Or was your word good enough?
I was flipping through my notes which I had made from the 7 month old recording, and quoting over the phone. He believed me.
In other news, if you tell a Chase CSR you are recording, she tells you that her employer requires her to hang up if you are going to do that. The opening recording when you call says "all calls may be monitored or recorded", so I consider that to be notification for all parties and see no reason to say I'm recording. I record it on my mp3 player, and figure 90% of the time I'll never have a need for the recording. If I do need it, I make notes from the recording and let whoever I'm talking to assume the notes were contemporaneous. Phone drones get testy when they find out you record calls, so I don't volunteer that info.
agentgrey
Thrifty Member
posted: Sep. 25, 2007 @ 3:36p
re: Taxmantoo - Depending on your State, you may not need to tell the CSR you are recording the call. Federal law only requires one-party consent, as do most States. There are a handful, however, that require 2-party consent. More info available here.
mythosaz said: I believe he pointed out that once THEY notify you that they may record, you're BOTH aware, and there's no need to inform anyone.
Right. And when you dial a toll free number, you never know when you will end up calling a CSR in some two party state like Commiefornia which thinks its laws apply throughout the entire country. Not to mention a lot of FW'ers live in CA.
Trinidon2k said: Hmmm...never knew this was an option. I'm gonna give this a shot sometime in the next few days with citi and report backThere were 3 archived posts noted in the OP - all unsuccessful attempts but I thought it might be worth a try. Thanks in advance for your efforts and follow-up post regarding results....
taxmantoo said: mythosaz said: I believe he pointed out that once THEY notify you that they may record, you're BOTH aware, and there's no need to inform anyone.
Right. And when you dial a toll free number, you never know when you will end up calling a CSR in some two party state like Commiefornia which thinks its laws apply throughout the entire country. Not to mention a lot of FW'ers live in CA.
Wouldn't federal laws apply to inter-state calls? Meaning one party consent is okay.
kenblakely
Senior Member - 2K
posted: Sep. 30, 2007 @ 9:06a
I always record conversations with anyone dealing with money. I typically use Skype from my computer so I can see all the docs, log into my accounts and take notes at the same time. There's several Skype add-ons that will manage the whole recording thing for you. I use one called Pamela - easy to use, saves to MP3. Hope this helps....
I tried extending 6 month promos an additional 6 months with the following:
AM3X (set to expire 02/04/2008)
Wells Fargo (set to expire 02/07/2008)
Nat'l City (set to expire 02/11/2008)
M&T Biz (set to expire 03/04/2008)
All attempts were unsucessful. The only encouragement I got was "you can try back closer to the expiration of your current offer to see if there are any ne promotions."
dodgeman007
Senior Member
posted: Dec. 26, 2007 @ 10:57a
jackcrawfish said: Has anyone ever attempted requesting an extension of the promotional APR period? While for many, AOR's are regularly scheduled 12-15 months, others may choose not to continue to the AOR2.0, AOR3.0, etc. There are a few archived threads which do not seem to support the idea, but I'd like to create a more thorough thread to explore the option.
A few quotables: (A) mrbean said CSRs are not given much power to modify terms - as far as I can tell, they are given a set of scripts to read to customers who call in, that's about it. The CC companies have their system set up so that it is easier and cheaper for them to set up new accounts than to modify old ones. Each promo has its own code, etc, and is all programed in, such that as long as the application dept CSRs know how to push some buttons (literally), everything will be ok.
(B) Econiomist said Usually CC companies do not extend 0% offers. If you were to pay it off, some may offer 0% in the future. I have had this happen with Citi and BofA cards.
(C) ProfessorKev OP'd ...I just called and the CSR stated that they have no control over that it is a marketing dept. thing...
Here's my conceptual idea and other members post away for alternative thoughts/suggestions/ideas:
During month 4 or 5 of a promo period call in to either plain Vanilla CustServ or Ninja Retention rep (great word markkundinger!). In the QS, add alternate scripts in an attempt to obtain extensions.
the thing all of us fail to see is that they are LOOSING money on these very very low rates and most of the people here wine about the bt fee too so your not making the bank any money they have no reason to keep you unless you are making them money. this is a bigger ymmv than anything else, i guess it cant hurt to ask but dont be supprised when they laugh and say ummm... NO!
bofa told me straight up pay at least 2x the min payment and they will most likely extend it without guarantee as to how long.
i was very precise in asking them about the product i was inquiring about and i'm sure the call was being recorded. i forgot if it was their biz or personal card line.
just ask them or a supervisor you'd be suprised at what tidbits they can discuss.
If the promo APR was 0% w/ no fees, be willing to compromise by saying "I might accept even a double rate than the promo. Ummm, even a triple one would be fine for me".
rigor said: bofa told me straight up pay at least 2x the min payment and they will most likely extend it without guarantee as to how long.
i was very precise in asking them about the product i was inquiring about and i'm sure the call was being recorded. i forgot if it was their biz or personal card line.Very interesting. Haven't heard this before...I wonder if this represents any kind of internal BofA policy, or just one supervisor's use of discretion.
Back before my FW days, I once told Discover that not only was I going to use 0% from BOA to bring Discover balance to 0, but also cancel the card once I had done so (I was serious). This was about a week before the end of the 0% period. A supervisor extended it for 7 months.
I had only this one balance, and he may have known that. I suspect if I had 200K showing, things would have been different.
So you guys had to call and talk to them about extending the 0% period?
I am sitting on $35k+ at 0% that is due in a few months (and I actually have been paying double minimum anyway).
peabi
Member
posted: Jan. 11, 2008 @ 12:54p
I sent a message through Chase online service like ShaneM did, but got a "No" from them. I was wondering is there anything I need to write other than "I want to extend my promotional rate".
Just paid off my 25k Cambridge Trust through Elan. I called them up and got another 6 months 0% no fee BT. Supervisor was involved, but no hard pull.
lhendricks92
Senior Member - 1K
posted: Feb. 8, 2008 @ 9:49a
TyroneSchulace said: Just paid off my 25k Cambridge Trust through Elan. I called them up and got another 6 months 0% no fee BT. Supervisor was involved, but no hard pull.
I tried the same thing a few days ago, no dice. I didn't push very hard. What exactly did you say, and how did you end up talking to a supervisor?
lhendricks92 said: TyroneSchulace said: Just paid off my 25k Cambridge Trust through Elan. I called them up and got another 6 months 0% no fee BT. Supervisor was involved, but no hard pull.I tried the same thing a few days ago, no dice. I didn't push very hard. What exactly did you say, and how did you end up talking to a supervisor?Like lhendricks92, I am curious for details... How old is your Cambridge Trust account with ELAN? Do you have other ELAN cards? How does your profile look (bureau)? In the middle of an AOR with poor scores or are you now "debt" free? Are you able to see whether ELAN pulls soft monthly account reviews of you?
Congrats..... Please follow up here confirming whether what was promised actually works out for you.
jackcrawfish said: lhendricks92 said: TyroneSchulace said: Just paid off my 25k Cambridge Trust through Elan. I called them up and got another 6 months 0% no fee BT. Supervisor was involved, but no hard pull.I tried the same thing a few days ago, no dice. I didn't push very hard. What exactly did you say, and how did you end up talking to a supervisor?Like lhendricks92, I am curious for details... How old is your Cambridge Trust account with ELAN? Do you have other ELAN cards? How does your profile look (bureau)? In the middle of an AOR with poor scores or are you now "debt" free? Are you able to see whether ELAN pulls soft monthly account reviews of you?
Congrats..... Please follow up here confirming whether what was promised actually works out for you. The BT came through. I think this is hit or miss. People in the background were having a good time, and the CSR said "Let me ask my supervisor." I asked and she said no hard pull. There was a period of silence, then she asked about the weather, we joked a little, and then she said OK.
The account is 5 1/2 mos old; I paid it off a couple of weeks early as I was emptying out an account. Don't know my scores, but I'm pretty sure they suck. I'm showing 86k on one card alone, & about 120k total on others. Just paid off Am3x 68k, so I'm sure that was showing also. Pre-AOR 790's.
Don't know about soft pulls, as I don't monitor mid-cycle. One other Elan card 10k limit used for biz ~1k/mo paid in full each month.
The other thing she said was that this had to go to ONE biz card, and then no more deals for me. Fortunately, it was a perfect fit. I had a sweet offer on an existing card mid-cycle last year which was coming due. I certainly wouldn't depend on this, but it doesn't hurt to ask.
Probably the most important thing was the general mood in their office at the time. Maybe it's possible with a smaller bank to try and catch them with their donuts?
Other than rigor's possible experiencebofa told me straight up pay at least 2x the min payment and they will most likely extend it without guarantee as to how long. and Tyrone's actual experience (albeit post payoff)Just paid off my 25k Cambridge Trust through Elan. I called them up and got another 6 months 0% no fee BT. Supervisor was involved, but no hard pull.it appears that 0% APR BT extentions are either not available to most or the AOR-FWF community or we don't press hard for AORX ("X" for extension).
Best practices indicate the standard Dave Hanson rolling** and 12-15 month AOR options are champion methods. The BT extension option is not viable.
Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.
Members of our community may attach files to a post in accordance with the User Agreement. FatWallet is not responsible for the content, accuracy, completeness or validity of any information contained in any attached file. Files have *not* been scanned for viruses. Be especially wary of Excel files which may contain malicious content.