-----BACKGROUND Age= 26 Married HHI= $180K Credit scores unknown, but should be high Big 30yr fixed 6.5% mortgage with an IO option $0 Balance HELOC (up to $68K) ~$13K left on a car loan (joint with wife)
-----CURRENT CARDS Credit Limit | Balance | Age
BOA Penn State Alumni Card $22,700 | $0 | 08/2001
Citi Dividend Mastercard $16,300 | ~$2,000 | 04/2005
Chase Amazon Visa $7,000 | $0 | 08/2006
JC Penney Card $1,000 | $0 | 05/2003
TOTAL $47,000 | ~$2,000
-----NEW APPLICATIONS ON 1/25/07
BOA NEA Wolrdpoints Platinum Plus Visa 0% for 12 billing cycles, 2% BT fee, max $30DEFERRED APPROVED $8,000
Citi Driver's Edge Platinum Select Mastercard 0% for 12 months from transfer, 3% BT fee, max $75DEFERRED APPROVED $3,200
Citi Home Rebate Platinum Select 0% for 12 months from transfer, 3% BT fee, waived with offer????
Chase Platinum Mastercard 0% for 12 billing cycles, 3% BT fee, max $75INSTANT APPROVED $17,000AMEX Clear 0% for 12 months on purchasesINSTANT APPROVED $16,300
Discover More 0% until Feb 2009, 3% BT fee, max $75DEFERRED APPROVED $15,000
Capital One No Hassle Miles Ultra 0% on purchases until Oct 2008INSTANT APPROVED $30,000
PenFed Platinum Cash Rewards 5% gas, 1.25% otherINSTANT APPROVED $20,000
Advanta Platinum Business Card 0% for 15 months, 3% BT fee, max $90DEFERRED APPROVED $10,000
----POST AOR PLANS
My mortgage is probably "upside down" right now- meaning that I'm not sure that I could refinance it and still be at 80% or less LTV based on a new appraisal. Therefore, paying down principal on the loan seems to make sense to me, because of the relatively high interest rate. Best case, paying my mortgage down to a <80%LTV point or even eventually to below Jumbo limits may open better refinancing opportunities. At worst, interest rates will go back up by then, but I will still owe less on the mortgage and have a smaller minimum interest payment.
I have about $2,000 per month in my budget that I can use for this principal paydown. I plan to take some 0% BT money from the AOR, make an upfront principle reduction (probably about $25K-$30K) on the mortgage, and deposit the $2,000/mo into a HYS instead to build up payoff funds. Any 0% money beyond that will be parked in a HYS as well. I will use my HELOC as a repayment backup plan and to facilitate BTs if necessary.
-----Final Accounts and BTs:
Personal:
Card Limit | Balance | Utilization
BOA Penn State Alumni Card $2,300 | $0 | 0%
Citi Dividend Mastercard $16,300 | $1,200 | 7% (normal usage)
Chase Amazon Visa $7,000 | $25 | <1% (normal usage)
JC Penney Card $1,000 | $0 | 0%
BOA NEA Wolrdpoints Visa $37,000 | $31,000 | 84% BT via phone to checking acct
Citi Driver's Edge $3,200 | $0 | 0%
Citi Home Rebate Platinum Select ???? | ???? | ????
Chase Platinum Mastercard $17,000 | $15,000 | 88% BT check to checking acct
AMEX Clear $16,300 | $0 | 0%
Discover More $15,000 | $13,000 | 87% BT via phone to HELOC
Capital One No Hassle Miles Ultra $30,000 | $0 | 0%
PenFed Platinum Cash Rewards $20,000 | $30 | <1% (normal usage)
TOTAL $165,100 | $60,255 | 36%
Biz:
Advanta Platinum Business Card $10,000 | $8,000 | 80% BT via phone to checking acct
TOTAL $10,000 | $8,000 | 80%
You can apply for it (No Hassle Miles Ultra, "with limits up to $30k") on their web site (looks like even with the 0% deal...) or through the CapOne Cardlab; it is the only CapOne card advertised with a $30k limit cap. (Most others disclose limit cap of $20k or less) The stinker is that it's got a $39 annual fee.
And... it's not exactly like you can expect to just call CapOne and expect them to convert the card to a no annual fee version later. (Thank you, notoriously awesome CapOne customer service.)
jakeru said: That's a very attractive CapOne card. Rare 30k limit, not to mention a BT deal to boot. Was there an annual fee? Was it through a pre-approved offer?
The Capital One card was based on a pre-approved mailing invitation that I got. There was no annual fee on the card I got.
win333
Senior Member - 2K
posted: Feb. 5, 2008 @ 1:23p
CRAP1 with refund the AF if you ask, 30,000 is amazing.
Why do you think you got an instant approval for Penfed? Do you have an account with them? I thought penfed always wanted to see documented income?
I would move the 3,200 to another city and close it. It's not worth dragging down your average age. Hell juny gave me a 2,000 limit, I told them to cancel it.
win333 said: CRAP1 with refund the AF if you ask, 30,000 is amazing.
Why do you think you got an instant approval for Penfed? Do you have an account with them? I thought penfed always wanted to see documented income?
I would move the 3,200 to another city and close it. It's not worth dragging down your average age. Hell juny gave me a 2,000 limit, I told them to cancel it.
I have had an account at PenFed for a few years, but only about $10 in the share savings account. I suppose I could have gotten a bigger CL on the PenFed card, but I actually wanted to get it for regular use to replace my current Citi dividend card. It's strange how PenFed asks you what you want your CL to be.
I should be able to move some of my $16.3K line from my Citi Dividend to the Citi Driver's Edge, correct?
xjagox said: I should be able to move some of my $16.3K line from my Citi Dividend to the Citi Driver's Edge, correct?
According to this thread Citi is no longer reallocating/consolidating CLs to cards that currently have a 0% no/low fee offer on them. This certainly did not stop me from trying, but I still had no luck in trying to reallocate from my Citi Aadvantage card to my Citi Driver's Edge or Citi Professional. I didn't push any further than the generic CSR I reached though...
jakeru said: You can apply for it (No Hassle Miles Ultra, "with limits up to $30k") on their web site (looks like even with the 0% deal...) or through the CapOne Cardlab; it is the only CapOne card advertised with a $30k limit cap. (Most others disclose limit cap of $20k or less) The stinker is that it's got a $39 annual fee.
And... it's not exactly like you can expect to just call CapOne and expect them to convert the card to a no annual fee version later. (Thank you, notoriously awesome CapOne customer service.) EDIT After double checking the Terms+Conditions... It appears the Capital One card I got is not quite so hot. Balance Transfers during the intro period actually get a "special APR" of 8.5%. The 0% only applies to purchases. It looks like that won't be a 0% BT card for me. Oh well, the $30K CL is a nice padding.
markkundinger
Senior Member - 2K
posted: Feb. 5, 2008 @ 8:05p
Capone might be really convenient and give you a "purchase" check that would apply to those terms. That would be cool.
No business cards?
Paying down the mortgage would be like investing in a taxable 6.5% money market... not bad. However, bear in mind that if you pay a lot on the mortgage you may very well need to come up with funds at the end of the term, so don't overdo it. Also, what's the APR on the HELOC?
Love said: Is there anything one needs to do to get approval on deferred card? Thanks !! Love, I found you here too ! No, typically one just has to wait for the decision to be made. Rarely, if you feel that a particular thing (like a missed/wrong number on the application) has played into the deferral it may make sense to give the issuer a call ...
Hey sorry.. looks like I accidently posted in 2 different thread. Thanks for help.
cyberkost said: Love said: Is there anything one needs to do to get approval on deferred card? Thanks !! Love, I found you here too ! No, typically one just has to wait for the decision to be made. Rarely, if you feel that a particular thing (like a missed/wrong number on the application) has played into the deferral it may make sense to give the issuer a call ...
win333
Senior Member - 2K
posted: Feb. 6, 2008 @ 10:03p
I called M&T bank after my decline and asked if they could reconsider, thats it she didn't ask anything else. A few weeks later a got a card for 5,000.
I'm getting to the BT stage now that most of my cards have arrived and accounts have been set up.
It looks like I have 3 cards to BT with right now: $12,000 CL - BOA NEA Visa, 0% for 12 months, $30 fee $17,000 CL - Chase Platinum Mastercard, 0% for 12 months, $75 max fee $15,000 CL - Discover More, 0% til Feb 2009, $75 max fee
Chase Card came with a BT check. I requested BT checks from Discover when I called to activate, and I requested checks from BOA online.
I'll plan depositing the BT checks to my checking acct and then transferring them out to mortgage/HYS accounts: $10,680 from BOA $15,130 from Chase $13,350 from Discover
$39,160 total
That should put me at 89% utilization on those cards and about 25% overall. Any issues with that plan?
Hopefully I'll get some extra BT ability from the Advanta card to add to that.
xjagox said: $10,680 from BOA $15,130 from Chase $13,350 from Discover
$39,160 total
That should put me at 89% utilization on those cards and about 25% overall. Any issues with that plan?
Hopefully I'll get some extra BT ability from the Advanta card to add to that.
I would be nervous about being at 89% on three different lines right now. If I were you, I would pay the BOA down to <70% after the first month and maybe the Discover, too. I have had good success (no AA, mid-700 credit scores) keeping one line at +/- 89% and having two or three others below 70 percent (and then my montly spenders at 3-5% on average) with overall utilization below 30 %.
-Vance
win333
Senior Member - 2K
posted: Feb. 7, 2008 @ 8:02a
I take about 98% of the credit line and then make a nice payment just to look like a big spender Don't know if it really helps but your paying the fee anyway, so it doesn't hurt nothing. Also I wait until 1st statement date unless I can BT soon after approval.
Don't you want to reallocate much of your BOA Penn State Alumni Card CL to your BOA NEA VISA and then ask the CSR to BT to checking account (even in some other bank)? I mean, perhaps times have changed, but in the not so distant past reallocation (by calling CSR) was a breeze.
win333
Senior Member - 2K
posted: Feb. 7, 2008 @ 8:13a
cyberkost said: Don't you want to reallocate much of your BOA Penn State Alumni Card CL to your BOA NEA VISA and then ask the CSR to BT to checking (of course, only if you have old enough checking acct. with BOA)? I mean, perhaps times have changed, but in the not so distant pass reallocation (by calling CSR) was a breeze.
Why old enough checking? I don't have a checking with BofA, never had a problem. I was thinking the same question about CLRing some of those lines.
I'll assume it's a newb mistake to not CLR.
Let me correct that a little, BofA business has been a problem for me to CLR.
Yeah, win333 is right -- BOA directly deposits to checking accounts at other banks, at least did so in the past. I must have not been fully awake when I typed the earlier post (have corrected it since).
win333 said: Why old enough checking? I don't have a checking with BofA, never had a problem. I was thinking the same question about CLRing some of those lines.
I'll assume it's a newb mistake to not CLR.
Good call. I'll call BofA to see if I can reallocate some of my PSU card to the NEA card to open up some more 0% money.
VanceWade said: I would be nervous about being at 89% on three different lines right now. If I were you, I would pay the BOA down to <70% after the first month and maybe the Discover, too. I have had good success (no AA, mid-700 credit scores) keeping one line at +/- 89% and having two or three others below 70 percent (and then my montly spenders at 3-5% on average) with overall utilization below 30 %.
What does everyone think about the utilization? Is it that risky of me to have my three 0% cards at just under 90%.
I feel that you're going to be fine with Discover and BOA, just make timely payments, preferably above minimum. Chase (as it is now) can (and is likely to sooner or later) give you all sorts of grief ... so just make sure that you get more in after tax interest from their BT money than you pay in fees.
I just called BoA to reallocate. Appearantly my existing PSU card limit has been increased to $27,300. She let me reallocate $25K of CL to the NEA card: PSU CL: $2,300 NEA CL: $37,000
I did a $31,000 BT from the NEA to my checking account, $30 fee.
Also got my Advanta business card in the mail, $10,000 CL. I called up to do a $8,000 BT to checking, $90 fee.
$39,000 free money for $120. Not too bad.
win333
Senior Member - 2K
posted: Feb. 7, 2008 @ 5:52p
xjagox said: Wow!
I just called BoA to reallocate. Appearantly my existing PSU card limit has been increased to $27,300. She let me reallocate $25K of CL to the NEA card: PSU CL: $2,300 NEA CL: $37,000
I did a $31,000 BT from the NEA to my checking account, $30 fee.
Also got my Advanta business card in the mail, $10,000 CL. I called up to do a $8,000 BT to checking, $90 fee.
$39,000 free money for $120. Not too bad.
I left 3,000 on my BofA personal, then I saw the BofA on crack thread and CLIed it to 10,000 the next month. woohoo! If you drop the credit line too low then I don't think they'll bite. I just CLIed a suntrust FIA card that I left 600 on and they increased it to 900
Gotta love BOA, right? Now, taking cue from win's post above, wait a few days for the dust to settle (and your BT money landing in a HYS account or wherever you wanted them at) and then go back to BOA website and ask for a CLI on your PennState card. I'd say with your credit profile you should ask for a $10-15K CL.
Advanta - called CSR, BT directly to checking account, $8,000 BoA - called CSR, BT directly to checking account, $31,000 Chase - deposited BT check to checking account, $15,000 Discover - called CSR, wouldn't deposit to checking, transferred to HELOC instead, $13,000
Total= $68,000 of 0% money
Now I just need to wait until all transactions clear.
plumpuddings
Member
posted: Feb. 21, 2008 @ 2:48p
Newbie question. How long did it take for the money from Advanta to show up on your checking account? I called Advanta to BT to my checking account several days ago. My Advanta now shows balance, but my checking account has not received it yet. One more thing though, the CSR asked me for checking acct number but said no routing number was needed; and he asked for the address of my bank. I gave him one of the closest branch to my house. Just a bit worry. After all, I just do not want the money to go to a lucky bastard's checking account.
Thanks
xjagox said: BTs are complete.
Advanta - called CSR, BT directly to checking account, $8,000 BoA - called CSR, BT directly to checking account, $31,000 Chase - deposited BT check to checking account, $15,000 Discover - called CSR, wouldn't deposit to checking, transferred to HELOC instead, $13,000
Total= $68,000 of 0% money
Now I just need to wait until all transactions clear.
IMO - you've got to be careful using AOR temporary funds (IE: 6- 12- 15-month) to pay down fixed debt. It's risky if you are jeoparding being liquid and possibly in the future being slave to credit cards instead of more "fixed" type of debt.
Scenarios you should consider: * you lose income source(s) at some point before the temporarily borrowed AOR funds become due. * you make one or more mistakes on your credit accounts and the borrowed funds become due immediately. * or both of the above occur!
You should take into effect how costly a liquidity crisis would be to you (IE: bankruptcy, foreclosure, etc.) And make plans with suitable risks. Personally I am quite risk-averse.
For me, an AOR with a 12-month time horizon didn't help much with my confidence for paying down longer term debt, in the way that an alternate vehicle (IE > 3 years) could. Pre-paying 6 or 12 months doesn't provide a whole lot of additional profit, IME.
Dipping into your HELOC for some liquidity is IMO a real option, provided it's in the draw period for a suitable time horizon, and the rate is acceptable (Short terms rates, including Prime are forecasted by the market to drop to 5.5% in less than 1 month, but rise in about a 2 year time horizon.)
You might want to take notice that part of the recent federal "economic stimulus package" included the conforming limit being raised significantly above $417k. I don't know how certain it is to go into effect or when it will happen, but that should make a future re-fi for you much more profitable. More incentive to pay down your debt, keep a clean credit report and perfect payment history!
PS - am I reading you right, that you are "upside down", even with an untapped HELOC of $60k, or is your primary mortgage just below 80% LTV and you're trying to get it back to that level?
edit - nevermind, I see you are shooting to attain 80% LTV primary. I wouldn't worry too much about that, because you could always refinance along with a 90%CLTV HELOC (and then consider using the credit card 0% BT after refinance to pay that immediately off if required.)
How high is your car loan? Considered selling and downgrading to a cheaper, and "wholly owned" used car? IE: Make it a project to sell it on the private market for full market value. Assuming you aren't upside down on your car as well, you'll have some funds available to pay your primary mortgage closer to 80% LTV.
Rorer714
Senior Member
posted: Feb. 21, 2008 @ 3:41p
win333 said: Let me correct that a little, BofA business has been a problem for me to CLR. Have you had a problem going from business to personal? I was going to open a NEA card and move my business CL to it.
kiliman
Member
posted: Feb. 29, 2008 @ 7:18p
cyberkost said: I feel that you're going to be fine with Discover and BOA, just make timely payments, preferably above minimum. Chase (as it is now) can (and is likely to sooner or later) give you all sorts of grief ... so just make sure that you get more in after tax interest from their BT money than you pay in fees.
What do you mean cyberkost? How can Chase charge fees if you pay the minimum due per month on the 0% BT balance? I thought that all they could do is cancel the card, but there is no risk of any fees (besides the initial $75 max BT fee).
kiliman said: What do you mean cyberkost? How can Chase charge fees if you pay the minimum due per month on the 0% BT balance? I thought that all they could do is cancel the card, but there is no risk of any fees (besides the initial $75 max BT fee).
I did not mean to suggest that there are necessarily other fees beyond the initial $75. What I meant to say is that lately Chase tries to not leave AORs inconsequential. Among the things they do (increasingly more often) are CL trimming and card closure, gotchas when one tries to make a payment too close to the 0% APR expiration date (not more than $25K at once, have to wait at least 3 business days after each payment initiated on their site), vague and conflicting info on when 0% APR expires. $75 is not guaranteed to be the only price to pay, therefore it's important to weigh the after tax/fees gain vs. the risk of having to experience some of Chase's spite.
Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.
Members of our community may attach files to a post in accordance with the User Agreement. FatWallet is not responsible for the content, accuracy, completeness or validity of any information contained in any attached file. Files have *not* been scanned for viruses. Be especially wary of Excel files which may contain malicious content.