|
-
-
Alimo
- Member
posted: Feb. 17, 2008 @ 7:09p
Thoreau: Is 2 personal and 1 business for AMEX fine? Or would you recommend me cut it down to 1 personal and 1 business? Also, why the AMEX Blue for Students card as opposed to the regular AMEX Blue? BTW, I've added the order I plan on applying in (i think i'll need help with this lol) dmlavigne: I know the Professional card posts to your CR so I'm wondering if there's any advantage getting the CitiBusiness card instead? I have a short credit history so I figured getting a CitiProfessional would be better for me since it can help age my report. Also, I can't find where it says the Citi AT&T card gives 60k bonus points? Maybe the deal expired? win333: Is there anything special about the the Chase Professional card? IMO, it's the Chase Business card without the $35 bonus. thanks for the posts 
|
-
-
win333
- Senior Member - 2K
posted: Feb. 17, 2008 @ 7:21p
Like I said, chase prof. is like it's in a category by itself, get the biz card also. I got the chase biz card for 6,000, then the prof. for 20,000, then the Chase ups card for 15,000. They never batted an eye and seem to be pushin the prof. It also doesn't report to your credit, since you don't want to many new accounts showing. I'm not saying you'll you get 20,000, but it was my 2nd highest approval ever. |
-
-
Alimo
- Member
posted: Feb. 17, 2008 @ 7:58p
ok so maybe answering this question might help me...if I have a lot of inquiries, would that be reason for the credit card companies to take A/A or not? The reason I wanted to limit my AOR to 10 cards is so I don't have too many inquiries on my report. That's one reason why I only have 3 business cards listed...so I don't have like 20 inquiries but only 7 new accounts reported on my CR. |
-
-
win333
- Senior Member - 2K
posted: Feb. 17, 2008 @ 8:52p
Alimo said:ok so maybe answering this question might help me...if I have a lot of inquiries, would that be reason for the credit card companies to take A/A or not? The reason I wanted to limit my AOR to 10 cards is so I don't have too many inquiries on my report. That's one reason why I only have 3 business cards listed...so I don't have like 20 inquiries but only 7 new accounts reported on my CR. I think you misunderstand, # of new accounts to INQs doesn't matter in the slightest. I assume you know about B* right? I admit with so few accounts it may be harder to tell if you'll get A/A or not. But really, really, what is the worste that can happen. In Sept 07 I had 31 EQ 25TU and 20 EXP. I quickly B*ed off the ones on EQ and TU. I had an older file but I was still getting approvals. mind you I only had FICOs in the 650s and an OLD newly reported collection. Read this my aor I just take it day by day, it's not written great but you'll figure out whats going on. Read this thread to really understan the possibilities, of course you'll need to adjust for your thin file. Venturions AOR If your worried about INQs, I'm thinking you don't know about B*. I'll PM you. |
-
-
Glitch99
- Senior Member - 5K
posted: Feb. 17, 2008 @ 9:34p
Alimo said:ok so maybe answering this question might help me...if I have a lot of inquiries, would that be reason for the credit card companies to take A/A or not? The reason I wanted to limit my AOR to 10 cards is so I don't have too many inquiries on my report. That's one reason why I only have 3 business cards listed...so I don't have like 20 inquiries but only 7 new accounts reported on my CR.The number of inquiries could very well lead to adverse action, but it is unrelated to the number of new accounts (alot of new accounts could also cause A/A but unrelated to inquiries). A theory has been presented here regarding a possible inquiry-to-new account ratio, but there has yet to be even anecdotal evidence of it being utilized by any issuer. In regards to avoiding A/A, 10 inquiries for 10 Biz cards (that wont show on your report as new accounts) would actually be safer than 10 inquiries for 10 personal accounts that do show up on your report as new. Of course many other factors come into play when discussing adverse action, but apples-to-apples this will generally be the case. |
-
-
Alimo
- Member
posted: Feb. 17, 2008 @ 9:50p
Yea, I worded my last post pretty poorly. My concern is whether or not a large number of inquiries can be reason for A/A. So, suppose I want 7 new reported lines. If I have the choice between 7 personal cards + 3 business cards or 7 personal cards + 8 business cards, I'd go with the 7 personal cards + 3 business cards because I need the personal cards to report to make a thicker file (so I have a stronger base for future AORs) while at the same time not applying for too many cards to avoid A/A. So I'd like at least 6 new, reported accounts. If 10 is a "safe" number of inquiries, I don't want more than 4 business accounts. I do know about b* (thanks for the PM though) but I'm too lazy to do that. Besides, from what I hear, it could take a couple months before the inquiries are bumped and I really doubt the credit card companies are going to wait a few months before they decide to take A/A. |
-
-
win333
- Senior Member - 2K
posted: Feb. 17, 2008 @ 9:58p
You'd be suprised, most A/A doesn't happen right away, if at all. Glitch is right about the 10 biz not reporting being better than 10 that do report. You can B* in 3 to 4 weeks if you really want too! Then you get to apply for more Biz cards I use 4 services and other techniques, so I can apply for more accounts EVERY month. But, to each his own. I just thought I'd make sure you knew about B* and the rest. Also you might find that by the time your done applying you might only have a few INQs per reports. Your not going to get 7 per report. |
-
-
Alimo
- Member
posted: Feb. 17, 2008 @ 11:59p
Who knows...maybe i'll become a bumper one of these days  Anything wrong with the order I plan on applying for the cards in? Should I switch from AMEX Nest/Knot to AMEX Blue? I know I won't be spending anywhere near $6500 a year with the AMEX card...maybe I will in a couple years though? |
-
-
win333
- Senior Member - 2K
posted: Feb. 18, 2008 @ 12:46a
AMEX isn't real friendly when it comes to letting go of 50,000. So MY choices are Chase, BofA, Citi, then anything else I can get. Those are my choices. But you and I have diferent goals, I don't do bonuses much. Of course you'll be a bumper, it's only a matter of time |
-
-
Alimo
- Member
posted: Feb. 18, 2008 @ 6:51p
That may be the case now, but maybe AMEX will change? Either way, I'm not planning on getting any $50k limits any time soon  |
-
-
win333
- Senior Member - 2K
posted: Feb. 18, 2008 @ 6:56p
the point was even if you had 50K limits. Your trying to build credit with the best creditors, I would think. But I just thought I'd mention it. |
-
-
Alimo
- Member
posted: Feb. 18, 2008 @ 10:41p
Oh, ok, I thought you meant like they're not willing to give $50k limits easily. Your second sentence was pretty much the reason I'm going for AMEX. |
-
-
markkundinger
- Senior Member - 2K
posted: Feb. 19, 2008 @ 1:17a
I generally recommend applying for cards in order of desirability (so you have less inquiries on your report for the cards you really want). The exception would be cards like Capital One which pull all three bureaus. Might want to lower- or higher-prioritize such an app. |
-
-
ifyouhavetoask
- Senior Member - 1K
posted: Feb. 19, 2008 @ 5:56a
Alimo said:GOAL:
2. AMEX The Nest or The Knot...................I'm just getting this to build relations with AMEX
Any and all help is GREATLY appreciated Advice: If you want to build relations with AMEX, stop trying to get multiple AMEX cards just because a couple of people on FW told you it's a good idea to do an "AOR". Someday, you might actully earn $180k on your own. Then, it sure would be a shame to have been blacklisted by AMEX, just because you wanted to get a bunch of their cards when you were a kid. In case you haven't been reading the news, credit card issuers are beginning a tightening cycle. As this occurs, they will begin dumping worthless and underperforming customers. In other words, AOR-type customers, who bring no benefit to their banks. Read the "GOAL" you wrote in your original post. There's no financial goal there. You're spending hours of your time to mess up your credit report, and make a few hundred dollars in bonus money. What's the point? So you can brag on FW? Is this REALLY the best financial plan you can come up with? Go talk to a local financial planner. Someone who will give you real financial goals. If your family really has $180k household income, someone in your family should already have a relationship with a planner. If not, do your family a favor and sit down with one. |
-
-
win333
- Senior Member - 2K
posted: Feb. 19, 2008 @ 8:25a
Alimo said:Oh, ok, I thought you meant like they're not willing to give $50k limits easily. Your second sentence was pretty much the reason I'm going for AMEX. My 2nd sentence ment, " AMEX is not a good creditor". Applying for 3 cards could get you 30,000 - 50,000. Just try getting the money. If they F/R you, then they'll close the personal accounts and it wont help your credit building. I don't have a personal AMEX for that reason. If they closed my biz cards, I won't mind because it won't hurt my credit. |
-
-
Alimo
- Member
posted: Feb. 19, 2008 @ 5:00p
win333: Again, total misunderstanding on my end. I see what you were saying. ifyouhavetoask: (I just read through my post and it may come off as a bit defensive, but that wasn't my intention. Right now it's like you've told me "you need to go see a doctor," but if I don't see anything wrong with me, why would I see one? I need someone to show me what's actually wrong first. So yeah, I'm not being a dick, just trying to understand my situation better ) I'm actually aware of the credit situation but I suppose since I'm new to all this, I'm not really familiar with what constitutes an "underperforming" customer. I figured 1-3 cards is safe, 5+ is too much. I wasn't trying to get blacklisted. I see that I'm wrong. Would you recommend 0 or 1 card from AMEX? Also, this AOR is just for my own gains, not for FW. The way I see it, I will have one of the worst (if not the worst) starts for an AOR compared to all the others I've read. I'll post my results so newcomers know what to expect, but I'm keeping the AOR fairly conservative cause I'm in this for myself. Anyway, the way I see it, if this AOR allows for $50-100k in BT money avaialble from a future AOR, that means I have an extra $200-600 a month to pay for expenses, which is not bad for a college student. The goal for this AOR is to get myself 2-3 good rewards cards, build a base for future AORs, and get some bonus money while I'm at it. The 1st two goals are more important than the bonus money. My parents do have a financial planner. I don't see why I should sit down and talk to one. As far as financial planning goes, there's very little to plan for me at this point in my life. I'm finishing my 2nd year in college. I'm ahead. I have a part time job. I haven't worked long enough to have any real savings. Current financial goals? Finish college strong and go on to grad school. While there, make myself as strong a candidate as possible for a future job so I can hopefully come out of school with a well-paying and satisfying job. I don't see the AOR as a get-rich-quick scheme; I see it more as a method of getting some extra money to help with current expenses. That, or I may not even touch the AOR money and keep it in a savings account, but I'm not there yet as I'm not even considering BT money at this point. I want to keep my CR at LEAST at a 700 across the board. I don't see what harm is being done by getting a few more cards. Again, as I've said, I'm just looking for answers. I completely believe what you're saying is right; I just want to know the logic behind your thoughts so I can become more informed. |
-
-
Alimo
- Member
posted: Feb. 19, 2008 @ 5:08p
BTW, I'm thinking of dropping the BOA card and the AMEX Preferred Rewards Gold Card. I'm also thinking of dropping 1 or 2 business cards. Any objections to that? And recommendations on which business card(s) to drop? I'd like to hold onto the CitiProfessional card. |
-
-
win333
- Senior Member - 2K
posted: Feb. 19, 2008 @ 5:12p
ifyouhavetoask said:Alimo said:GOAL:
2. AMEX The Nest or The Knot...................I'm just getting this to build relations with AMEX
Any and all help is GREATLY appreciated Advice:
If you want to build relations with AMEX, stop trying to get multiple AMEX cards just because a couple of people on FW told you it's a good idea to do an "AOR".
Someday, you might actully earn $180k on your own. Then, it sure would be a shame to have been blacklisted by AMEX, just because you wanted to get a bunch of their cards when you were a kid. In case you haven't been reading the news, credit card issuers are beginning a tightening cycle. As this occurs, they will begin dumping worthless and underperforming customers. In other words, AOR-type customers, who bring no benefit to their banks.
Read the "GOAL" you wrote in your original post. There's no financial goal there. You're spending hours of your time to mess up your credit report, and make a few hundred dollars in bonus money. What's the point? So you can brag on FW? Is this REALLY the best financial plan you can come up with?
Go talk to a local financial planner. Someone who will give you real financial goals. If your family really has $180k household income, someone in your family should already have a relationship with a planner. If not, do your family a favor and sit down with one. Since we are giving advice, here'e mine YOU DON'T KNOW WHAT THE HELL YOUR TALKING ABOUT!
There I've said it, disregard OP some people just have no clue. You have a very good plan laid out (conservative for me) and this will teach you more than any college ever will. This is real world experience! Just think, you'll learn about CD's and the cost of money and how to make the most of the tools in your quiver. Forge on |
-
-
win333
- Senior Member - 2K
posted: Feb. 19, 2008 @ 5:14p
Alimo said:BTW, I'm thinking of dropping the BOA card and the AMEX Preferred Rewards Gold Card. I'm also thinking of dropping 1 or 2 business cards. Any objections to that? And recommendations on which business card(s) to drop? I'd like to hold onto the CitiProfessional card. Don't drop any biz cards, I'd add about 10 or 20 more. But thats just me and venturion, Mark and brian and well, pretty much everyone else doing the AOR dance. But like I said, that just my opinion! |
-
-
markkundinger
- Senior Member - 2K
posted: Feb. 19, 2008 @ 5:28p
Alimo, I like the idea of building a "bed" of credit. And AMX, Chase, Citibank, and Discover are too big NOT to have credit cards with if you're planning any strategies. Heck, I even applied for a Capital One card. Not because it looked good, but just because they were too big a player to ignore. |
Close
|
|
 |
 |
Not Already A Member?
Sign Up Now!
|
|
Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.
|
|