What is there to wonder? It's a matter of a (fairly simple) calculation. Exact valuations and timelines are different situation-to-situation, but here's an example assuming: $400 = 40K TYP (tax free) $260 = from funding with a 1% rewards CC (tax free) $197 = 2.25% APY on $25K for 6 mo - 30% tax ------------ $857 after tax gain
One of the most viable (risk-free) alternatives is sticking $26K in a 6.01% reward checking account, which results in $547 after tax gain.
CITI deal beats next "mainstream" competitor by $310 over 6 months! This is not to mention that: 1) with CC funding you can time it appropriately and float $26K for almost 2 months 2) you can still get the bonus by keeping only $6k in, while moving $20K to a better place 3) 40K TYP can be worth up to $800 if redeemed for airfare.
cameron2003 said: I'm starting to wonder if 40,000 thank you points are even worth moving money into these accounts.
There is no requirement you keep any money in this account. The only catch to the promo is that you must maintain at a minimum a "The Citibank Checking Account" which requires a min combined balance of $6k between all linked accounts. Citi will even count your Citibank credit card balances towards that balance requirement.
So for anyone currently carrying a balance on Citi card at 0% it will cost you nothing to earn either 40K(new Citibank bank customer) or 20k(current Citi Customers).
Even if you do not have a balance lets think about the real cost of the promo compared to best rate you could get ok?
You would be forced to maintain $6k between all combined Citi accounts to waive the checking account monthly fee.
So you would open "The Citibank Checking Account", "Money Market Plus" and "Ultimate Money Account" on day 1.
You deposit $25k into Money Market Plus account + $1k in Citibank Checking account on day 1 for a total of $26k. Going to assume the banks put a 10 day business hold on those deposits so your going to earn only 2.25% on $25k and 0% on $1k after that point you can move out all the money from Citibank except $6k which you put into UMA at 2.7%. Having the UMA should not be an issue as thank you point promo requires making direct deposit or paying 2 bill anyway. Your TYP will post to your account with in 30 days of completing the promo which takes at least 2 months but more than likely 3 months if your timing is off. So lets just say you have bad luck and your timing is off and it takes you 3 months to fulfill the requirements so you get your points with in 120 days of opening.
Lost interest on $25k for 10 days is $25.68 and that is assuming $41.09(if you earned 6.01% in rewards checking account) vs $15.41 you earn in Money Market Plus account at 2.25%. Lost interest on $6k for 110 days is $59.85 and that is assuming $108.67(if you earned 6.01% in rewards checking account) vs $48.82 you earn in UMA at 2.7%.
And most Reward checking accounts are down to 5.01% with some as low as 4.01% making the difference even smaller but I am going to assume you live in a place were you have a local bank still offering 6.01%.
So it is costing you $85.83 in lost interest to get 40k TYP which can be redeemed for 2 coach tickets or $400 in gift cards. If you know of a place to get $400 in GC or $800 in Airlines tickets for $85.83 please enlightened us as I would love to be able to buy them risk free at those prices all day long as Gift Cards on eBay tend to sell between 95-100 cents on the dollar and buying via eBay always carries the risk that the Gift Cards will be bogus.
cameron2003
Senior Member - 2K
posted: May. 3, 2008 @ 1:24p
Thanks, I was getting discouraged. I am looking at the gas gift card, which I can redeem for $325 worth of gas. I know its not maxing out the value of the points, but I dont want to travel to Kalamazoo or buy some crap at Pier One. And I didn't fund with a credit card. So my after tax gain is more like $525 Cyberkost, which is less than the 6% checking. I wouldn't do that anyway, I would more likely use WAMU savings. I think its around 3%, which would be $225? So I come out $300 ahead anyway. Thank you Dolmar, opening up the Ultimate account is a good idea too, it will increase my return that much more.
cameron2003 said: Thanks, I was getting discouraged. I am looking at the gas gift card, which I can redeem for $325 worth of gas. I know its not maxing out the value of the points, but I dont want to travel to Kalamazoo or buy some crap at Pier One. And I didn't fund with a credit card. So my after tax gain is more like $525 Cyberkost, which is less than the 6% checking. I wouldn't do that anyway, I would more likely use WAMU savings. I think its around 3%, which would be $225? So I come out $300 ahead anyway. Thank you Dolmar, opening up the Ultimate account is a good idea too, it will increase my return that much more.
You do understand even Money Market Plus account pays some interest. So there is no way the difference on $6k or even $25k over 120 days(worse case scenario) is $225 if you are comparing Citi promo to WAMU Savings account as it only pays 3.30% so the spread between Citi and WAMU is either 1.25% if you keep your money in Money Market Plus or 0.60% if you keep your money in UMA.
On $25k over 120 days the difference is $102.73 if you keep the money in Money Market Plus and $51.42 if you keep the money in UMA. You keep forgetting you are only required to keep $6k between all accounts to waive the monthly checking account service fee. So if you just maintain that amount the difference is $24.65 between WAMU and Money Market Plus account and $11.83 if you keep the money in UMA.
So for $25 bucks where can you get $325 in Gas GC risk free?
tolamapS
Senior Member - 2K
posted: May. 3, 2008 @ 9:48p
cyberkost said: What is there to wonder? It's a matter of a (fairly simple) calculation. Exact valuations and timelines are different situation-to-situation, but here's an example assuming: $400 = 40K TYP (tax free) $260 = from funding with a 1% rewards CC (tax free) $197 = 2.25% APY on $25K for 6 mo - 30% tax ------------ $857 after tax gain
One of the most viable (risk-free) alternatives is sticking $26K in a 6.01% reward checking account, which results in $547 after tax gain.
CITI deal beats next "mainstream" competitor by $310 over 6 months! This is not to mention that: 1) with CC funding you can time it appropriately and float $26K for almost 2 months 2) you can still get the bonus by keeping only $6k in, while moving $20K to a better place 3) 40K TYP can be worth up to $800 if redeemed for airfare.
Or you could be more aggressive and push more than $26K, like $50K into each account. Also, what if you fund w/ 2,3, or even a 5% credit card?
If you had the available credit and the right cards, you could make $3-5K just in CC points.
win333
Senior Member - 2K
posted: May. 3, 2008 @ 9:54p
tolamapS said: cyberkost said: What is there to wonder? It's a matter of a (fairly simple) calculation. Exact valuations and timelines are different situation-to-situation, but here's an example assuming: $400 = 40K TYP (tax free) $260 = from funding with a 1% rewards CC (tax free) $197 = 2.25% APY on $25K for 6 mo - 30% tax ------------ $857 after tax gain
One of the most viable (risk-free) alternatives is sticking $26K in a 6.01% reward checking account, which results in $547 after tax gain.
CITI deal beats next "mainstream" competitor by $310 over 6 months! This is not to mention that: 1) with CC funding you can time it appropriately and float $26K for almost 2 months 2) you can still get the bonus by keeping only $6k in, while moving $20K to a better place 3) 40K TYP can be worth up to $800 if redeemed for airfare.
Or you could be more aggressive and push more than $26K, like $50K into each account. Also, what if you fund w/ 2,3, or even a 5% credit card?
If you had the available credit and the right cards, you could make $3-5K just in CC points.
Did we ever get an answer about funding with the 5% citi rebate card?
I thought someone was trying to do it, but I haven't read the entire thread.
canhelp
Member
posted: May. 3, 2008 @ 11:27p
I already have a saving account. When I try to open a checking account, I choose use the existing login in user name and pwd, it do not have any option of funding with credit card. Only has fund from citi account or external account. How can I fund with CC?
win333
Senior Member - 2K
posted: May. 4, 2008 @ 12:15a
Here is another DUMB question:
This is fatwallet where we do AORs and pay some BT fees, when we BT.
So why don't we just fund new CITI bank accounts with the cards that charge a BT fee? We could get FREE CASH + Rewards + usage!
I'm working on a way to run several 100K per month thru my cards, just to get the good usage on my accounts. This should get me higher limits in the future and make EVERYONE happy.
But having 20 or 30 citi checking accounts could work also, I open new accounts with my credit reports frozen. So no need to worry about INQs.
tolamapS
Senior Member - 2K
posted: May. 4, 2008 @ 12:19a
win333 said: tolamapS said: cyberkost said: What is there to wonder? It's a matter of a (fairly simple) calculation. Exact valuations and timelines are different situation-to-situation, but here's an example assuming: $400 = 40K TYP (tax free) $260 = from funding with a 1% rewards CC (tax free) $197 = 2.25% APY on $25K for 6 mo - 30% tax ------------ $857 after tax gain
One of the most viable (risk-free) alternatives is sticking $26K in a 6.01% reward checking account, which results in $547 after tax gain.
CITI deal beats next "mainstream" competitor by $310 over 6 months! This is not to mention that: 1) with CC funding you can time it appropriately and float $26K for almost 2 months 2) you can still get the bonus by keeping only $6k in, while moving $20K to a better place 3) 40K TYP can be worth up to $800 if redeemed for airfare.
Or you could be more aggressive and push more than $26K, like $50K into each account. Also, what if you fund w/ 2,3, or even a 5% credit card?
If you had the available credit and the right cards, you could make $3-5K just in CC points.
Did we ever get an answer about funding with the 5% citi rebate card?
I thought someone was trying to do it, but I haven't read the entire thread.
I thought you were trying to do it
tolamapS
Senior Member - 2K
posted: May. 4, 2008 @ 12:20a
win333 said: Here is another DUMB question:
This is fatwallet where we do AORs and pay some BT fees, when we BT.
So why don't we just fund new CITI bank accounts with the cards that charge a BT fee? We could get FREE CASH + Rewards + usage!
I'm working on a way to run several 100K per month thru my cards, just to get the good usage on my accounts. This should get me higher limits in the future and make EVERYONE happy.
But having 20 or 30 citi checking accounts could work also, I open new accounts with my credit reports frozen. So no need to worry about INQs.
I think someone reported getting problems after funding 3rd CITI deposit account w/ credit card.
You could probably have many CITI accounts. It's just that after a while they will stop taking CC as a funding source.
win333
Senior Member - 2K
posted: May. 4, 2008 @ 12:31a
tolamapS said: win333 said: Here is another DUMB question:
This is fatwallet where we do AORs and pay some BT fees, when we BT.
So why don't we just fund new CITI bank accounts with the cards that charge a BT fee? We could get FREE CASH + Rewards + usage!
I'm working on a way to run several 100K per month thru my cards, just to get the good usage on my accounts. This should get me higher limits in the future and make EVERYONE happy.
But having 20 or 30 citi checking accounts could work also, I open new accounts with my credit reports frozen. So no need to worry about INQs.
I think someone reported getting problems after funding 3rd CITI deposit account w/ credit card.
You could probably have many CITI accounts. It's just that after a while they will stop taking CC as a funding source.
Each AOR has it's PITA cards with 3% BT fees, so Why not open as many CITI accounts as possible (funding with a credit card) then closing them. But of course leaving the 40K TYP account open to meet the requirements. Then we could apply for even MORE credit cards, since the 3% BT fees would not apply to us.
Also, there seems to be a question if funding with a CITI card if you'll get the 40K TYP. (we already know it's a purchase)
So why not fund the max on a CITI card to open, then move a NEW 25K into the account and withdraw all the money leaving a 6K+ balance on your CITI card, so you don't pay the checking account fee.
Maybe these are dumb questions, but it sure seems to be pretty darn obvious. Kinda like FREEZING EXPERIAN or Freezing 2 reports just before applying for a CRAP1 card so you only get 1 INQ.
I just opened the new checking account using the absolute savings/ checking promotion found here
did the 25k deposit and 1k deposit. lets see how long the points take.
anyone know how long you have to leave the money in the account(s) to get the points? can you move the 1k from checking to savings? does paypal deposit count as direct deposit or does citi's inter-institution transfer count as direct deposit?
cameron2003
Senior Member - 2K
posted: May. 4, 2008 @ 6:06p
hellyea81 said: I just opened the new checking account using the absolute savings/ checking promotion found here
did the 25k deposit and 1k deposit. lets see how long the points take.
anyone know how long you have to leave the money in the account(s) to get the points? can you move the 1k from checking to savings? does paypal deposit count as direct deposit or does citi's inter-institution transfer count as direct deposit?
I don't think you need to leave the money in at all. You can take money out the next day, as long as you meet the billpay/direct deposit requirements and are aware of the fees.
Is anyone making the 26000 deposit to the ultimate savings account, then transferring 1000 from ultimate savings to checking account? I am afraid of funding the 1000 by cc, since 1000 is below my cash advance limit, and they might consider the 1000 as a cash advance even if they consider the 25000 as a purchasae.
Or nothing to worry about?
ShavenYak
Member
posted: May. 5, 2008 @ 8:02a
Yipes, those rates are hideous. At least you only have to keep 6K in the account for three months. Even if you could earn 3% more on that money, that's only $45. And many of the people on this thread are angling for not just the 40K ThankYou points, but also 25K+ in rewards points from whatever card they used to make the deposit into the Citi account. So if all goes well, it's a win.
Incidentally, I had promised to report back... my Chase credit card statement closed over the weekend, both charges posted as purchases and I have 26K Flexible Rewards points.
peteypablo
Senior Member - 1K
posted: May. 5, 2008 @ 8:51a
mrlandlord said: Is anyone making the 26000 deposit to the ultimate savings account, then transferring 1000 from ultimate savings to checking account? I am afraid of funding the 1000 by cc, since 1000 is below my cash advance limit, and they might consider the 1000 as a cash advance even if they consider the 25000 as a purchasae.
Or nothing to worry about?
If you have two cards, use one for each account. My wife did $50K to Ultimate savings and $19.5K to checking. As soon as its available, transfer to savings. You have the float on the credit card to take advantage of. If not, use another checking account to fund the $1000.
freequeen
Member
posted: May. 5, 2008 @ 8:54a
Is it real ? Too good to be true..
peteypablo
Senior Member - 1K
posted: May. 5, 2008 @ 8:55a
canhelp said: I already have a saving account. When I try to open a checking account, I choose use the existing login in user name and pwd, it do not have any option of funding with credit card. Only has fund from citi account or external account. How can I fund with CC?
Over the phone.
peteypablo
Senior Member - 1K
posted: May. 5, 2008 @ 8:58a
win333 said: Here is another DUMB question:
This is fatwallet where we do AORs and pay some BT fees, when we BT.
So why don't we just fund new CITI bank accounts with the cards that charge a BT fee? We could get FREE CASH + Rewards + usage!
I'm working on a way to run several 100K per month thru my cards, just to get the good usage on my accounts. This should get me higher limits in the future and make EVERYONE happy.
But having 20 or 30 citi checking accounts could work also, I open new accounts with my credit reports frozen. So no need to worry about INQs.
Great idea. But make sure the 0% rate applies to purchases also. In fact, this is a great idea for those purchase only 0% rate cards. My wife got suckered into a WAMU purchase only 0% if you make a balance transfer with the application, but we turned it around on them by immediately paying it off and then using it to fund a 40K TYP Citibank account.
peteypablo
Senior Member - 1K
posted: May. 5, 2008 @ 9:02a
tolamapS said: I think someone reported getting problems after funding 3rd CITI deposit account w/ credit card.
I have funded a third account with a credit card three times now, for myself, my father and my son. I think the best combination is regular checking, Ultimate Savings and Ultimate Money. As soon as possible, put as much as you can into Ultimate Money, which pays the best rate. Or, take all but $6000 out if you have better options. I guess I feel a need to show Citi a little love by keeping some of the money with them.
I am an existing customer and was resisiting this offer till late but last week i went to a branch and asked a rep. They told me that an existing customer could get 40 K with a new checking and ultimate MM - but I needed some kind of code. Anyone has any recent code? Also they mentioned that I needed to maintain 25K for atleast 6 months - is this true OR is there some different offer online?
Thx
2stepsbehind
Senior Member
posted: May. 5, 2008 @ 10:40a
prem1 said: I am an existing customer and was resisiting this offer till late but last week i went to a branch and asked a rep. They told me that an existing customer could get 40 K with a new checking and ultimate MM - but I needed some kind of code. Anyone has any recent code? Also they mentioned that I needed to maintain 25K for atleast 6 months - is this true OR is there some different offer online?
Thx
Go to citibank.com. Click on the graphic that shows an airplane flying and/or two tickets. It should give you more than enough information. If you read through the thread there is some debate as to whether the 25k needs to be maintained.
Note: Already a checking account customer? How to make it happen.
1. Open a Citibank Ultimate Savings Account, link it to your existing checking account and complete qualifying banking activities.* 2. Deposit $25,000 or more into your Citibank Ultimate Savings Account, and enroll your eligible checking account in ThankYou Network. 3. Get your round-trip ticket to anywhere in the continental U.S. (up to a $400 value) by redeeming your 20,000 ThankYou Points.
Apply Now > To apply by phone, call 1-866-535-3904 and mention code: CP76
HappyGuy
Happy Member
posted: May. 5, 2008 @ 11:00a
prem1 said: I am an existing customer and was resisiting this offer till late but last week i went to a branch and asked a rep. They told me that an existing customer could get 40 K with a new checking and ultimate MM - but I needed some kind of code. Anyone has any recent code? Also they mentioned that I needed to maintain 25K for atleast 6 months - is this true OR is there some different offer online?
Thx
8 posts before yours has the link to the offer with the code in it.
glxpass
Senior Member - 5K
posted: May. 5, 2008 @ 11:55a
HappyGuy said: prem1 said: I am an existing customer and was resisiting this offer till late but last week i went to a branch and asked a rep. They told me that an existing customer could get 40 K with a new checking and ultimate MM - but I needed some kind of code. Anyone has any recent code? Also they mentioned that I needed to maintain 25K for atleast 6 months - is this true OR is there some different offer online?
Thx
8 posts before yours has the link to the offer with the code in it. Given Citi's own wording, the 40K isn't a sure thing for existing customers:
Already a customer? Sign in and you can still be rewarded if you have:
Clicking on each of these options shows 40K TYP only on the first option. The other two options show only 20K TYP. Considering the "accuracy" of Citibank CSRs, I'm inclined to believe what this says, not what a CSR tells me, unless they can clearly document it. Of course, you can still go for it, but I wouldn't expect 40K TYP under conditions other than what Citi has stated in their links.
glxpass said: HappyGuy said: prem1 said: I am an existing customer and was resisiting this offer till late but last week i went to a branch and asked a rep. They told me that an existing customer could get 40 K with a new checking and ultimate MM - but I needed some kind of code. Anyone has any recent code? Also they mentioned that I needed to maintain 25K for atleast 6 months - is this true OR is there some different offer online?
Thx
8 posts before yours has the link to the offer with the code in it. Given Citi's own wording, the 40K isn't a sure thing for existing customers:
Already a customer? Sign in and you can still be rewarded if you have:
Clicking on each of these options shows 40K TYP only on the first option. The other two options show only 20K TYP. Considering the "accuracy" of Citibank CSRs, I'm inclined to believe what this says, not what a CSR tells me, unless they can clearly document it. Of course, you can still go for it, but I wouldn't expect 40K TYP under conditions other than what Citi has stated in their links.
I called Citibank yesterday with code CSZ2 and they told me even though I already have an ultimate savings acct & checking acct, if I open a new checking acct & put in $1,000 and do the 2 bill pays/month (which you can actually mail a check to yourself & your spouse/friend) for 3 consecutive months & put in an additional $25,000 in my ultimate savings account, I can get 40,000 TYP, even though I already am going to get 40,000 TYP under offer CP74. They said I would qualify again for the new promotion. It was verified with a supervisor. We'll see if I get 20,000 or 40,000...either way it's one or 2 free tickets!!
adodotnet
Member
posted: May. 5, 2008 @ 9:22p
deleted
dodohyy
New Member
posted: May. 5, 2008 @ 9:43p
I am about to use PPE card to fund the new accout to earn some TYP. I don't have enough credit line on that card though. I was thinking is it possible that I can first pay some money into the PPE account to have the balance becomes negative, so that I can make an initial deposit larger than the credit line of that PPE account?
adodotnet
Member
posted: May. 6, 2008 @ 11:25a
Hi, Anyone can clarify if citi will do a hard pull or soft pull if I open this checking/saving/MM account? Is there anyway to not be hit by the hard pull?
Thanks.
RagingBull
Ancient Member
posted: May. 6, 2008 @ 11:34a
how much did you fund at once? can you fund some with credit card and some with ach deposit?
can you get typ if you already opened a money plus account at the bank and then open a ultimate online? and get 25k points for both?
I tried to move credit line over from my citi platinium card to my citi cash return but they claim because the cash return has 0% i won't be able to get the offer
DreamSun
Member
posted: May. 6, 2008 @ 3:31p
I have two questions:
(1) I received two check books that I didn't order. Are they for free? And I believe there is a fee around $1 for writing a check for The Citi Account checking. But if I keep above $6k balance on it, that fee will be waived, right?
(2) I opened the savings and checking online and funded it with my citi cc. But citi cc is citi affiliated, so it doesn't count into the 25k. Can I make several transfers (not one time, don't have enough money in a single account) from ING and FIDO just before 5/31(which seems to be their deadline for remote funding) and qualify for the promotion?
Thanks.
peteypablo
Senior Member - 1K
posted: May. 6, 2008 @ 5:45p
DreamSun said: I have two questions:
(1) I received two check books that I didn't order. Are they for free? And I believe there is a fee around $1 for writing a check for The Citi Account checking. But if I keep above $6k balance on it, that fee will be waived, right?
(2) I opened the savings and checking online and funded it with my citi cc. But citi cc is citi affiliated, so it doesn't count into the 25k. Can I make several transfers (not one time, don't have enough money in a single account) from ING and FIDO just before 5/31(which seems to be their deadline for remote funding) and qualify for the promotion?
Thanks.
I think the answer to both questions is yes, but would you like me to call Citi for you to make sure and then let you know?
DreamSun
Member
posted: May. 6, 2008 @ 9:22p
peteypablo said: I think the answer to both questions is yes, but would you like me to call Citi for you to make sure and then let you know?
Sure go ahead. I was even surprised that you offered to call citi for me. Thanks and look forward to your feedback.
kgkg
Member
posted: May. 6, 2008 @ 10:51p
If I open the account online, can I fund the accounts using credit cards at a retail banking center? Thanks!
DreamSun
Member
posted: May. 6, 2008 @ 10:57p
kgkg said: If I open the account online, can I fund the accounts using credit cards at a retail banking center? Thanks!
I don't think so. but you can try calling the citiphone to fund it while you fax the funding form.
RagingBull
Ancient Member
posted: May. 7, 2008 @ 12:31a
can you make the $25k funding half by credit card and half by bank transfer?
juggler451
Member
posted: May. 7, 2008 @ 12:40a
That is what I did, though I am going to have to wait and see if I get TY points.
RagingBull
Ancient Member
posted: May. 7, 2008 @ 2:38a
so how does it work? When you open the account do you start the intial funding by faxing a cc authorization then by doing an ach?
Also, anyone here ever used a business credit card to fund a checking account like the Bank of America Business. Will it be cash advance or purchase?
Just wanted to share/provide data points on my experience, which was basically identical to juggler's on the previous page.
- 04/30 -> Opened account around 1 or 2 AM. - 04/30 -> Fund with a CC deposit to both RC and Ult. S accounts. I provided a fax cover sheet AND CC deposit form clearly stating the two different account #s and dollar amounts to fund. - 05/02 -> Called customer service to ask why my deposits weren't processed yet and she said the back office takes a few days to process. - 05/05 -> Happy Cinco de Mayo - 05/06 -> Logged onto my Citi CC online account and saw my CashReturn's total CL reduced by $26k (sweet!), but also a red warning message flashes telling me to call in to verify the transaction.
I called the banking section's customer service again last night about why my Reg. Checking not being funded and they were absolutely worthless. It's safe to assume that the 'back office' doesn't read much into what people write so two deposit forms is the way to go. I just faxed mine again for the Regular Checking deposit....
Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.
Members of our community may attach files to a post in accordance with the User Agreement. FatWallet is not responsible for the content, accuracy, completeness or validity of any information contained in any attached file. Files have *not* been scanned for viruses. Be especially wary of Excel files which may contain malicious content.