|
-
-
dolmar
- Senior Member - 4K
posted: Mar. 3, 2008 @ 10:12p
You got 12 Citi Apps. Even if you get approved for all 12 cards the net result might be the same total credit between 12 cards or say 3 cards. Reason I am saying this is because last year when I did not my mini Appo-o-rama Citi called me up and explained I had reached my max exposer they were willing to allow. I make well over $200k a year, and maintain a very large balance with Citibank at all times. Well over $2 million in cash management bonds with them. I have HELOC for $1 million with a $0 balance with them and only had 2 credit cards with $90k limits combined + Diners Club card and they refused to issue me more credit when I put Citi Platium AMEX card on my App-O-Rama and opened it with $5k limit and offered to move credit from other cards. Chase pulled the same BS on me too. I have my 1st mortgage with Chase and it has a loan to value of about 20%. I offered to fax my banks accounts to chase etc and they did not care and I only had $54k in credit limits with Chase. So if you only goal is to maybe get $500 credit cards sure applying for 10 or Chase and Citi might work except once you reach a certain limit with either of them they just wont issue you more credit. App-O-Rama was in Feb 07 before the credit crunch and the $**t hit the fan. So I expect them to be much more conservative now even. |
-
-
SecondCor521
- Senior Member
posted: Mar. 3, 2008 @ 11:03p
win333 said:Well i'm here, I didn't get the alert for a new AOR thread, damn i've missed alot.
2ndcore
I guess no pics of the sister huh? LMAO
Your list is so big I can't go thru it all, but i'll add what i've been thinking for my next AOR.
Brian did 15 chase apps and got nothing (good try), but venturion got 7 new chase accounts so far. So on the outside chance that Venturion found the RIGHT chase cards and the RIGHT order of application. I would copy all his chase apps, no sense in re-inventing the wheel. If my theory is right about the different divisions in chase, then I think Venturion has hit the right ones. He also only got a few INQs from chase, so he did something right.
Triple play huh? To bad you can't freeze, i'd sure like to see you with 10 LLCs. But heck maybe a million is enough.
In 1 of your last posts you said, "the list has 10 biz cards". Is that all? So there is 46 personal apps, Jericon's A/A was explained to be because of 20 new accounts within 12 months. PolarDude did many more apps but only got about as much new credit as others with 30 or 40 apps.
Everyone on creditboards knows about the CITI Trifect, thats 3 CITI biz cards at once. So I don't know why we think there is a 2 biz app limit. It might be because they have biz credit reports and some of us don't. No real way to know, other than trying.
Over all 2ndcore, I'm impressed! Your plan looks very well laid out and you seem to feel the same way as I do about A/A. You also seem to be willing to except some A/A, I don't really see the big deal if WE lose some accounts.
Thats about all I can add, I have the popcorn ready.
Can't wait!
EDIT: The banks aren't checking DL #s on apps, just make up a number that matches your state. They ask for that, so when you make a withdrawal and they check your ID they have a number to match with. I don't see your kids going to the bank, RIGHT? win333, The more I read, the more I think either (a) this is all one big YMMV, or (b) I'm stupid and can't see the patterns in front of my eyes. You know, my sister is pretty, but c'mon, she's my sister... I was wrong, the original 56 includes 17 biz apps. I'm thinking I'll cull on the personal side somewhat. I don't think I'll make up DL #'s for the kids. Not sure what I'll do there yet except that I will try to open the accounts for them. 2Cor521 |
-
-
SecondCor521
- Senior Member
posted: Mar. 3, 2008 @ 11:04p
penumbra222 said:For those cards that have no CashBack on cardselection, try taking a look at cardbenefit.com. You can have your wife refer you for an additional $25 per application.
Good luck. Can't wait to see your results. penumbra222, Thanks for the well wishes. No wife, just a former wife and mother to my children  2Cor521 |
-
-
SecondCor521
- Senior Member
posted: Mar. 3, 2008 @ 11:05p
maddybeagle said:Banks can search for DL numbers in the state databases...and I have had to provide copies of my DL on a few bank sign-ups so I dont know how you would think making up a number would work???
I have been conservative with the AMEX-in cards and stayed less than 50% and only bt 10-12k and applied for new cards with them twice and no problems...
I have read a few close advanta and reapply and got lesser card limits, so YMWV... maddybeagle, Are you maddythebeagle elsewhere? I've seen the Advanta pattern you've described. I just got the closure letter from them in the mail today saying "So sorry, call if you change your mind." If they decline to issue me a new card, I'll call and say I've changed my mind . 2Cor521 |
-
-
SecondCor521
- Senior Member
posted: Mar. 3, 2008 @ 11:10p
dolmar said:You got 12 Citi Apps. Even if you get approved for all 12 cards the net result might be the same total credit between 12 cards or say 3 cards. Reason I am saying this is because last year when I did not my mini Appo-o-rama Citi called me up and explained I had reached my max exposer they were willing to allow. I make well over $200k a year, and maintain a very large balance with Citibank at all times. Well over $2 million in cash management bonds with them. I have HELOC for $1 million with a $0 balance with them and only had 2 credit cards with $90k limits combined + Diners Club card and they refused to issue me more credit when I put Citi Platium AMEX card on my App-O-Rama and opened it with $5k limit and offered to move credit from other cards.
Chase pulled the same BS on me too. I have my 1st mortgage with Chase and it has a loan to value of about 20%. I offered to fax my banks accounts to chase etc and they did not care and I only had $54k in credit limits with Chase.
So if you only goal is to maybe get $500 credit cards sure applying for 10 or Chase and Citi might work except once you reach a certain limit with either of them they just wont issue you more credit.
App-O-Rama was in Feb 07 before the credit crunch and the $**t hit the fan. So I expect them to be much more conservative now even. dolmar, Based on your comments and stats I guess I think I have some headroom with Citi, depending on what they consider important. I have about twice the aggregate CL as you do at Chase and my numbers aren't as good as yours. Again, is it all one big YMMV? It will be interesting to see what my results will be. If they are not as good as last time, there are several possible explanations: (a) I applied for too many cards, (b) credit crunch, (c) high existing exposure. Who knows? Thanks, 2Cor521 |
-
-
SecondCor521
- Senior Member
posted: Mar. 4, 2008 @ 12:12a
PolarDude said:Maybe others can concur, but I got a denial for more than 1 Citibusiness cards in 1 AOR. Chase seems hit or miss on multiple approvals, but Venturions AOR looks like potential. I've seen someone get 9 BofA/Fia cards in 1 aggresive AOR, but ended up getting ALL their accounts closed a few months after pulling ~200k from them. OP has a few Citi / Chase cards already, I can't remember if there's a hard limit or not. Is your biz going to have a web presence? Duns is super slow in giving the free duns, you might not see it until April, and I don't know if it makes a difference unless you have tradelines showing, but it should get you an Experian biz profile, but after several weeks of being in Duns. One thing I might mention, is I tend to like doing each bank all at once, and not skipping back in forth, reasoning you don't want the last Citi/bofa/chase app to see you lots more inquiries when your first app only showed so many. If they keep each app completely separate, then it's more doable, but I'd be interested to hear how others have fared when that many apps in between one bank (Citi AMEX at the very bottom, with them also being on top) Some may even pull the next day, or hours later depending on when you do this. I can't wait to see it, and love all the details. I kinda wish there were more issuers though (Where's GE Money?) As for discover, I think 1 personal and 1 biz is OK, but there may be a cap on cards/exposure. He may get small lines with issuers he has alot of credit already, and I think it's too aggresive for me, and would add in more issuers instead. I went looking briefly and couldn't find a capped GEMB 0% BT offer, and in my research I didn't see them regularly granting large lines for utilization purposes. So that's why no GEMB. 2Cor521 |
-
-
win333
- Senior Member - 2K
posted: Mar. 4, 2008 @ 12:47a
Or D) you picked the right cards or you didn't pick the right cards with each creditor. Chase was a PITA with the exposure, until I picked different cards to apply for, it really depends which branch of chase is backing the cards. Thats the YMMV! 12 Citi's would be to much, there must be a reasonable amount. My insurance company doesn't have my correct DL#, actually it expired 5 years ago. It was only a learners permit, because the person testing me didn't pass my car (broken blinker). My DL is even for a different state than I live in. I'm 40+ years old. If they ask, blame everything on a TYPO. If they don't ask, then your in. It's really NO BIG DEAL, I don't have to show my DL, I use my passport for everything. I just don't feel like going to get my DL, might be a problem 1 day but until then F*em! Just call me a rebel! Ya I know, I break all the rules. The post with the 1 million HELOC, Man you gotta learn how to play the game. Give me a million HELOC and I'll have several million in credit cards. I applied for 2 chase biz cards and 1 professional and I got a call from each one to verify my address, neither one new I just got a call from the other cards. Even when I told them " I just sent Utility bills" They just said " it doesn't matter, send them again"! I think the most important thing to remember is, chase has bought alot of banks and hasn't got the systems down right yet. Another idea on the bank accounts is, ask them if your kids can get the bonus. You'll need to be the custodian or whatever they call it, then no need for a DL#. Just a thought. First Tennessee gave me a hard time because of my lack of DL, After I filled out the questionare, the regional manager was calling me. I told them I wasn't interested and would be closing my account for the trouble. Thanks anyway, you can't hold someone like me to YOUR stupid rules. I can get in and out of the country with my passport, I don't need their shit. I wouldn't recommend driving in FL. without a DL, they have a habitual affender law |
-
-
thisguy
- Senior Member
posted: Mar. 4, 2008 @ 12:47a
Wow! This looks very ambitious. I would just offer one bit of advice since your list is so long and it's on order of applications. I can't confirm it but based on my experience I think you are best off doing a single lender's apps in groups especially the most important ones first. I think you get in trouble when you go through 7 Citi apps right up front and then you have a couple more in the 40s for example. Now instead of them just seeing the few pulls they see 40 pulls and all of those apps not instantly approved become questionable. I also got dinged pretty hard by the cards toward the end of my last AOR for too many recent inquiries. They show up almost instantaneously now so all in one day seems like it only helps if it reduces each lenders total pulls. Those guys at the end are going to see a lot. Just be prepared for some rejection. Also FYI when I went for 89% consumption on personal I had a lot of issues with lender's. At < 70% it's smooth sailing. For me that difference is well worth it and means I'll be comfortably doing BTs for ages to come (I Hope). Believe me that last 10% means something too when you're talking about 1.4M in credit. Trust me no hassles and not account battles/closures line reductions well worth it. Just my two cents. Good Luck!!
Thisguy |
-
-
SecondCor521
- Senior Member
posted: Mar. 4, 2008 @ 1:36a
OK all, I updated the OP with a shorter and mostly reordered list. Have at it. I may reorder some more if I can fight my lazy nature. Launch time estimated at 9:00 PM ET 3/4/08. 2Cor521 |
-
-
win333
- Senior Member - 2K
posted: Mar. 4, 2008 @ 1:53a
I like the idea of doing all apps for each creditor at the same time and not out of order. my .02 I don't know much about HSBC, but I did happen to read about the HSBC Gm card. You only have 1 HSBC card, just a thought. I think most FWFers try to do apps in the A.M. just to make sure all INqs are on the same day. TU will combine multiple INQs from the same creditor on the same day. But I have done my AORs over several days before. I'm up to .06  Nice layout, you don't look lazy at all! |
-
-
Alimo
- Member
posted: Mar. 4, 2008 @ 2:02a
Green for you. I can't believe someone gave me props for my A0R  BTW, I got 2 denials even though I only applied for 11 cards. I don't think you can really use my A0R as a data point though, seeing how vastly different our histories are. Anyway, good luck with your A0R. I, for one, will be very interested in the results. |
-
-
SecondCor521
- Senior Member
posted: Mar. 4, 2008 @ 2:40a
Alimo said:Green for you. I can't believe someone gave me props for my A0R 
BTW, I got 2 denials even though I only applied for 11 cards. I don't think you can really use my A0R as a data point though, seeing how vastly different our histories are.
Anyway, good luck with your A0R. I, for one, will be very interested in the results. Hey Alimo, I have found that going back any more than about three months, one runs into a lot of offers that have expired, changed terms, etc. Yours was a relatively recent A0R that I took note of and looked at the offers you listed. By my count, I read 27 A0R threads looking for cards. Looks like I was a bit too successful in finding offers  2Cor521 |
-
-
markkundinger
- Senior Member - 2K
posted: Mar. 4, 2008 @ 5:35a
I still think you have to many redundant Chase personal apps, and maybe one too many BofA personal apps. |
-
-
lhendricks92
- Senior Member - 1K
posted: Mar. 4, 2008 @ 8:22a
Here's what I would do: Chase - You have lots of accounts and credit with them already. I would apply for ONE business and ONE personal, maybe even just one business. Create a monster biz line and do a monster biz BT. BofA - Just get the NEA card and ask for a CLI. Based on the strength of your credit file and income, you should be able to get a max personal exposure of $75K. Apply for a BofA biz card. Yes, I know the new account offers have uncapped BT fees, but they will eventually give you a capped offer on your account. Just need to be patient. Citi - You don't need any more personal cards, and I prefer to do all my BT action on the biz side with Citi. Get the Hilton and Associated Bank - but only for CL. They seem to have separate credit buckets, and you can send the new credit to the biz side. Apply for 1 or 2 biz cards. Everything else looks pretty good. Good luck. |
-
-
TyroneSchulace
- Senior Member
posted: Mar. 4, 2008 @ 9:27a
Kudos on grouping apps by issuer. You'll likely only get one combined pull for all biz cards/bank. That should help as you move on down the list, but that's still a lot of cards. I agree with lhendricks92...You may just end up with smaller limits and lower average age. 5th3rd- you're in their area? Bank bonuses: Don't do custodial accounts. The IRS takes a very dim view of someone using money in those for anything other than the benefit of the minor, including normal expenses for the minor. One way to go is a revocable trust. x3. These can be biz or personal accounts, money comes and goes as you please, like a POD, except a TIN gets you around the "one/calendar yr" rule. Good Luck! |
-
-
SecondCor521
- Senior Member
posted: Mar. 4, 2008 @ 10:33a
TyroneSchulace said:Kudos on grouping apps by issuer. You'll likely only get one combined pull for all biz cards/bank. That should help as you move on down the list, but that's still a lot of cards.
I agree with lhendricks92...You may just end up with smaller limits and lower average age.
5th3rd- you're in their area?
Bank bonuses: Don't do custodial accounts. The IRS takes a very dim view of someone using money in those for anything other than the benefit of the minor, including normal expenses for the minor. One way to go is a revocable trust. x3. These can be biz or personal accounts, money comes and goes as you please, like a POD, except a TIN gets you around the "one/calendar yr" rule.
Good Luck! TyroneSchulace, Love the screen name, by the way. As far as too many accounts and lower ages, I plan to rapid consolidate such that the new accounts don't even appear on my credit history. This mitigates the "too many Citi/Chase apps" problem IMHO. Regarding 5/3, no, I'm not -- good catch, I'll remove that one from the list. Good hint on the revocable trust. I'll take a look at the link. 2Cor521 |
-
-
SecondCor521
- Senior Member
posted: Mar. 4, 2008 @ 10:39a
markkundinger said:I still think you have to many redundant Chase personal apps, and maybe one too many BofA personal apps. Possibly. One thought is rapid consolidation. I did that successfully in last year's A0R. Does anyone have any non-YMMV data that 7 Chase apps is too many?  A second thought is that #5 through #7 on the list are co-branded cards. I expressed confusion last year about co-branded cards and admit that I didn't do enough research to understand the implications of a card being co-branded. My hope is that they are treated differently for application purposes but the same for consolidation and reallocation purposes, which would be ideal for me. Can anyone clear this up for me or set me straight? Regarding BofA, I reduced it to three. I believe that gives me the best chance of achieving max exposure to them this round, plus the third card has a $100 bonus. I've tentatively set the bar at $100 for selling a credit inquiry. Thanks again for all the feedback! 2Cor521 |
-
-
SecondCor521
- Senior Member
posted: Mar. 4, 2008 @ 10:42a
lhendricks92 said:Here's what I would do:
Chase - You have lots of accounts and credit with them already. I would apply for ONE business and ONE personal, maybe even just one business. Create a monster biz line and do a monster biz BT.
BofA - Just get the NEA card and ask for a CLI. Based on the strength of your credit file and income, you should be able to get a max personal exposure of $75K. Apply for a BofA biz card. Yes, I know the new account offers have uncapped BT fees, but they will eventually give you a capped offer on your account. Just need to be patient.
Citi - You don't need any more personal cards, and I prefer to do all my BT action on the biz side with Citi. Get the Hilton and Associated Bank - but only for CL. They seem to have separate credit buckets, and you can send the new credit to the biz side. Apply for 1 or 2 biz cards.
Everything else looks pretty good. Good luck. lhendricks92, Thanks for the continued feedback. I'll consider it all. See my comments and questions above regarding co-branded Chase cards. I just noticed #3 and #4 may be the same card -- anyone know for sure? 2Cor521 |
-
-
lhendricks92
- Senior Member - 1K
posted: Mar. 4, 2008 @ 10:51a
SecondCor521 said:As far as too many accounts and lower ages, I plan to rapid consolidate such that the new accounts don't even appear on my credit history. This mitigates the "too many Citi/Chase apps" problem IMHO. Interesting. My experience has been once you apply and are approved, it's too late - the card will show on your report. You were able to do this with Chase AND Citi? Who else? BofA? |
-
-
lhendricks92
- Senior Member - 1K
posted: Mar. 4, 2008 @ 10:54a
SecondCor521 said:A second thought is that #5 through #7 on the list are co-branded cards. I expressed confusion last year about co-branded cards and admit that I didn't do enough research to understand the implications of a card being co-branded. My hope is that they are treated differently for application purposes but the same for consolidation and reallocation purposes, which would be ideal for me. Can anyone clear this up for me or set me straight? I've had good luck using this strategy with Citi, but I would also like to know how others have pursued this technique with Chase and BofA. |
Close
|
|
 |
 |
Not Already A Member?
Sign Up Now!
|
|
Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.
|
|