click to close
help
edit

Forums
Finance

Student loan consolidation company suspending interest rate reduction bonus

  • Text Only
  • Search this Topic »
  • switch to 'Classic' view
  • Go to Page :
  • 1 2
alert mods    

I received a letter from T.H.E. (Northstar) stating that they were suspending their interest rate reduction bonus (essentially a .75% monthly credit) due to "ongoing disruption in the global credit markets." Are other student loan consolidation providers doing this is well and is there anything that can be done? For me, and I am sure many others out there with thousands in student loans this will amount to a significant amount of money lost.

Quick Summary is created and edited by users like you... Add FAQ's, Links and other Relevant Information by clicking the edit button in the lower right hand corner of this message.

alert mods    

my bonus was a rate reduction based upon perfect payments for the first three years
I believe they have a contractual obligation to honor it

what was the basis of your bonus?

alert mods    

write a letter back saying you are suspending payments due to ongoing disruption in the global credit markets.

alert mods    

better yet --- you can offer them a collateralized debt obligation in payment for your loan

you can call it --- Satisfactual Zip Doo Dah Class B 2.49 2045

alert mods    

Graduate leverage did the same thing last fall when the feds reduced the amount of money they were going to make. So instead of 5.8% with the 1% discount, I'll be paying the full 6.8% interest rate on my graduate student loan.

alert mods    

Surely, folks have a leg to stand on with this.

alert mods    

Fascinating. I am due to have my 2.625% 30k loan drop 1% for 30 on-time payments this June. I wonder if I'll have to fight to get it. Either way I'm dragging this thing out forever because it's a wonderful hedge against rapid inflation; so glad I made a fixed-rate consolidation in 2005.

alert mods    

ask them to show you where in the loan contract that they have the right to do this.

alert mods    

These private loan companies are all scum. They're cutting the bonus because the feds decreased the free money they were giving them. If your loans are federal, stafford loans or grad plus loans are the typical ones, get into direct loans. You can consolidate into them if you got your federal loans from a third party.

I know it may be too late, but NEVER EVER take private student loans of any sort. If you're in an overpriced graduate school, you can always get grad plus loans to meet the difference between staffords and your cost of attendance. Private loans are terrible. They offer none of the benefits of federal loans but they are just as non-dischargeable.

Have you heard about the college cost reduction act? There are very significant benefits intended to encourage people to get into direct loans. Starting next year you will be able to sign up for an income based repayment plan that could greatly reduce your payments for federal loans. You will also be able to cancel the remainder of your balance after a certain number of years. 10 if you work in a public interest or governemnt job and 25 if you don't.

finaid.org is a great resource to learn about this stuff.

alert mods    

ArbolLoco said:ask them to show you where in the loan contract that they have the right to do this.


Here is their explanation.

http://www.northstar.org/undergrad/RepaymentBonus.aspx

alert mods    

I'm in the same boat. Given that this happened to my consolidation loan, does anyone have any advice on what I can do? Am I basically SOL due to the fact that I can't re-consolidate an already consolidated federal Stafford loan, since I have no new loan to add to the consolidation mix, and consolidation rules require at least two loans to reconsolidate a consolidation loan?

alert mods    

Seems like this type of suspension may be pretty common right now across other student loan companies.

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB120648516311763723.html?mod=hpp_us_personal_finance
"Borrowers may also end up paying a little more. While the maximum fixed rates on federal loans are set by the government -- 6% and 8.5% for undergraduate subsidized Stafford loans and PLUS loans, respectively, for the 2008-2009 academic year -- lenders have historically offered a variety of loan discounts and fee waivers that reduced borrowers' costs. But in recent months many lenders have scaled back these discounts and reinstated some fees they had previously waived. In some cases, they are requiring higher minimum balances for a borrower to be eligible for loan discounts."

alert mods    

munster8 said:I'm in the same boat. Given that this happened to my consolidation loan, does anyone have any advice on what I can do? Am I basically SOL due to the fact that I can't re-consolidate an already consolidated federal Stafford loan, since I have no new loan to add to the consolidation mix, and consolidation rules require at least two loans to reconsolidate a consolidation loan?

Munster8,
Who did you consolidate with? And have they sent you a letter telling you that they were suspending their benefits?

alert mods    

cowboyBill said:ArbolLoco said:ask them to show you where in the loan contract that they have the right to do this.


Here is their explanation.

http://www.northstar.org/undergrad/RepaymentBonus.aspx
need a good link. I was thinking about this thread in the car the other day and it really pissed me off... essentially what they are doing is putting this out there knowing that 99% of the borrowers won't challenge them on this. I don't think they have a legal basis to do this but I will reserve judgment until I see their statement.

alert mods    

My wife had her medical school loans through T.H.E. but we consolidated with a different company. It looks like that was a very smart choice.

alert mods    

I dunno, this could be a good class action.

alert mods    

doubtful... read the loan contract

alert mods    

ctaul,

Do you know whether something is in the contract that gives them the right to take away benefits where you have complied with your part of the contract? Odds are the contract was a quid pro quo type... you pay on time, you get borrower benefits. Of course, if they had a clause saying they could take it away at any time, then, well.... they can. However, my contract with my lender says I pay one time, I get the benefits. If they choose to suspend my benefits I will file a class action the same day.

alert mods    

ArbolLoco said:cowboyBill said:ArbolLoco said:ask them to show you where in the loan contract that they have the right to do this.


Here is their explanation.

http://www.northstar.org/undergrad/RepaymentBonus.aspx
need a good link. I was thinking about this thread in the car the other day and it really pissed me off... essentially what they are doing is putting this out there knowing that 99% of the borrowers won't challenge them on this. I don't think they have a legal basis to do this but I will reserve judgment until I see their statement.


You just need to crank up the time machine.
http://web.archive.org/web/20070608195010/www.northstar.org/undergrad/RepaymentBonus.aspx

"The T.H.E. Bonus is treated as a reduction in the interest cost. This amount is based on current financial market conditions and portfolio performance and is therefore subject to change."

 Close

Sign Me In
Nickname: 
Password: 
Remember My Login Information:

Forget your login information?

Not Already A Member?
Sign Up Now!



Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.