click to close
help
edit

Forums
Finance

IRA mutual fund question - VFINX best choice for my mom? Short horizion time ~6yrs Archived From: Finance

  • Text Only
  • Search this Topic »
  • switch to 'Classic' view
  • Page :
  • 1
alert mods    

hey guys,
sorry for the dumb question, I'm hoping some of the gurus on this board can help with the simple question.

My mom is looking to invest her tax return into an IRA with WAMU. It's not a lot, only $4k and she has a short horizon time of 6yrs before she retires. I'm not looking for the hottest mutual fund or expect incredible returns but something that's respectable like 8% to match the S&P.

My first thought was index fund and then vanguard since they have low expense ratios.

Any inputs? Is WAMU a good place and is Vanguard's 500 Index a good choice? Thanks in adv!

Quick Summary is created and edited by users like you... Add FAQ's, Links and other Relevant Information by clicking the edit button in the lower right hand corner of this message.

alert mods    

ExperiencedNewbie said:I'm looking for the hottest mutual fund
Surely a boring old S&P fund like the one you suggest from Vanguard won't meet that criteria. Maybe a concentrated bet on China or India? Some India funds (IIF/IFN) were up 15% just one earlier this week for example.

More seriously, check out diehards.org for these types of questions. Vanguard's a good company, but it's not clear from what you describe whether a 100% stock fund is appropriate for your mom. No guarantees with any of 'em in any case.

alert mods    

ExperiencedNewbie said:My mom is looking to invest her tax return into an IRA with WAMU. It's not a lot, only $4k and she has a short horizon time of 6yrs before she retires. I'm looking for the hottest mutual fund or expect incredible returns but something that's respectable like the 8%.

My first thought was index fund and then vanguard since they have low expense ratios.

Any inputs? Is WAMU a good place and is Vanguard's 500 Index a good choice?
Just because your mother will retire in six years doesn't necessarily mean her time horizon is just six years. It is if she'll have very little income and will need to preserve every penny, in which case she should avoid any stock fund and instead stick FDIC-insured bank accounts or CDs (never invest in a CD through a broker!) or a money market mutual fund (not to be confused with bank money market accounts, which are different). But if she'll have an adequate pension and can afford to lose lots of money in an investment, maybe a stock mutual fund is suitable for her. There are more conservative funds, such as equity-income funds (they invest in high-dividend stocks), balanced funds (they hold both stocks, usually conservative ones, and bonds), and target funds (several funds in one, targeted toward different retirement years, and the ones aimed at earlier years are more conservative than those with longer target dates.

If your mother wants a mutual fund IRA, then it's best to invest directly with the fund company because places like WAMU offer only load funds, which charge sales comissions.

alert mods    

xerty said:ExperiencedNewbie said:I'm looking for the hottest mutual fund
Surely a boring old S&P fund like the one you suggest from Vanguard won't meet that criteria. Maybe a concentrated bet on China or India? Some India funds (IIF/IFN) were up 15% just one earlier this week for example.

More seriously, check out diehards.org for these types of questions. Vanguard's a good company, but it's not clear from what you describe whether a 100% stock fund is appropriate for your mom. No guarantees with any of 'em in any case.

Oops, typo on the original post, I meant to say "not" the hottest fund

alert mods    

larrymoencurly said:ExperiencedNewbie said:My mom is looking to invest her tax return into an IRA with WAMU. It's not a lot, only $4k and she has a short horizon time of 6yrs before she retires. I'm looking for the hottest mutual fund or expect incredible returns but something that's respectable like the 8%.

My first thought was index fund and then vanguard since they have low expense ratios.

Any inputs? Is WAMU a good place and is Vanguard's 500 Index a good choice?


Just because your mother will retire in six years doesn't necessarily mean her time horizon is just six years. It is if she'll have very little income and will need to preserve every penny, in which case she should avoid any stock fund and instead stick FDIC-insured bank accounts or CDs (never invest in a CD through a broker!) or a money market mutual fund (not to be confused with bank money market accounts, which are different). But if she'll have an adequate pension and can afford to lose lots of money in an investment, maybe a stock mutual fund is suitable for her. There are more conservative funds, such as equity-income funds (they invest in high-dividend stocks), balanced funds (they hold both stocks, usually conservative ones, and bonds), and target funds (several funds in one, targeted toward different retirement years, and the ones aimed at earlier years are more conservative than those with longer target dates.

If your mother wants a mutual fund IRA, then it's best to invest directly with the fund company because places like WAMU don't offer only load funds, which charge sales comissions.

Any suggestions on some money market funds? Guess I'm getting confused with that and your typical index mutual fund.

alert mods    

Does it really matter? $4k isnt going to help her retire in 6 years. Thats going to be like 2 months living expenses. The best you are likely going to do is turn it into $10k and the worst you are going to do is turn it to $0. Either way its not going to help her much. Maybe she could get a time machine and start her retirement savings in her 20s instead of 60s.

alert mods    

SimpleMoney said:Does it really matter? $4k isnt going to help her retire in 6 years. Thats going to be like 2 months living expenses. The best you are likely going to do is turn it into $10k and the worst you are going to do is turn it to $0. Either way its not going to help her much. Maybe she could get a time machine and start her retirement savings in her 20s instead of 60s.

wow, what a freakin' ass, did your mom not love when you were little? Or was it your dad who gave you too much lovin'? The time machine would prob. serve you better so you wouldn't have to turn out the way you are.

alert mods    

ExperiencedNewbie said:he or expect incredible returns but something that's respectable like 8% to match the S&P.

8% is "incredible" return in the next 6 years. On the other hand, I am not surprised you may get 8% total return for 6 years. Unfortunately, the value of dollar will go down another 50%.

alert mods    

ExperiencedNewbieAny suggestions on some money market funds? Guess I'm getting confused with that and your typical index mutual fund.[/Q said:Generally, the lower the expense ratio, the better, because money funds of any type (type mostly means tax status -- fully taxable, state tax exempt, federal tax exempt, completely tax exempt) all invest in the same things, meaning profits depend almost exclusively on how little is taken out by expenses. BTW there's no benefit to using a tax-exempt fund in an IRA.

For safety, some experts recommend that money funds be rated AAAm by Standard & Poor's (some money funds try to boost yields by making riskier investments rather than charge lower expenses), have no investments comingled with those of an institutional money fund (they're considered riskier than retail funds, and, unlike the latter, have lost money at times), and hold at least $1B in assets.

Some other things to consider are the minimum required account balance, charges for dipping below the minimum (usually assessed only once a year, not every month as with bank accounts), and minimum investment and withdrawl amounts. And for nonretirement money market fund accounts, look at check-writing policies (minimum amounts -- usually $100-500, charges for bounced checks, how cancelled checks are handled -- returned or images available).

iMoneyNet.com has information about money funds, as does Morningstar.

alert mods    

ExperiencedNewbie said:SimpleMoney said:Does it really matter? $4k isnt going to help her retire in 6 years. That's going to be like 2 months living expenses. The best you are likely going to do is turn it into $10k and the worst you are going to do is turn it to $0. Either way its not going to help her much. Maybe she could get a time machine and start her retirement savings in her 20s instead of 60s.wow, what a freakin' ass, did your mom not love when you were little? Or was it your dad who gave you too much lovin'? The time machine would prob. serve you better so you wouldn't have to turn out the way you are.But SimpleMoney is right, and if your mother won't have money to spare, she should invest the $4K very conservatively, such as in a money fund.

BTW, in my earlier message I miswrote, "...it's best to invest directly with the fund company because places like WAMU don't offer only load funds, which charge sales comissions." That should have read: "...it's best to invest directly with the fund company because places like WAMU offer only load funds, which charge sales comissions."

alert mods    

It depends on her overall asset allocation. If she doesn't have one right now, that's much more important than deciding on some arbitrary fund. She should read a book like "A Random Walk Down Wall Street" or "All About Asset Allocation".

alert mods    

larrymoencurly said:ExperiencedNewbie said:SimpleMoney said:Does it really matter? $4k isnt going to help her retire in 6 years. That's going to be like 2 months living expenses. The best you are likely going to do is turn it into $10k and the worst you are going to do is turn it to $0. Either way its not going to help her much. Maybe she could get a time machine and start her retirement savings in her 20s instead of 60s.wow, what a freakin' ass, did your mom not love when you were little? Or was it your dad who gave you too much lovin'? The time machine would prob. serve you better so you wouldn't have to turn out the way you are.But SimpleMoney is right, and if your mother won't have money to spare, she should invest the $4K very conservatively, such as in a money fund.

BTW, in my earlier message I miswrote, "...it's best to invest directly with the fund company because places like WAMU don't offer only load funds, which charge sales comissions." That should have read: "...it's best to invest directly with the fund company because places like WAMU offer only load funds, which charge sales comissions."

His reply might have been right but he didn't have to be an ass about it.

Thanks for the tips, I'll prob. go with one of the vanguard retirement funds since it adjusts depending on how much time you have left to retire.

alert mods    

Isn't this a variation of:


1. Q: What do I do / where do I invest $xxxx amount of money for XXX time?
A: See Bycracky's The "What do I do with $XX,000 question?" we love to hate thread!
Presidential, ING Direct, VirtualBank and many others all offer good rates that are usually much higher than local banks.
See the FAQ The Daughter of The Mother of All Online Banking, Checking, Saving, and Money Market, Interest Rate Threads.

alert mods    

PBT: 10-14% disbusements (monthly, and if you auto-reinvest, they are higher)
+ any price appriciation as the cost of oil rises (or Cramer pumps them again, thanks Jim!)

And I think discussions about individual stocks/funds are not allowed on fatwallet...

 Close

Sign Me In
Nickname: 
Password: 
Remember My Login Information:

Forget your login information?

Not Already A Member?
Sign Up Now!



Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.


  • © 1999-2008
  • Message Board Statistics RSS Feed Information
Sign up for free today, because you don't want to miss out on any more cash back than you already have! There are currently 1,027,701 people just like you registered to earn Cash Back From FatWallet. Be the next! Sign up to join the discussion & earn Cash Back from FatWallet:
close