UPDATE - DAD Business O'Rama w/ Cash Back personal cards - He pretty much wants to keep his personal report clear of balances so as to be fleixible and ready to act should an opportunity to refinance come up or another opportunity present itself. So here's the planned list:
Cash Back Cards: 1) EX - Charles Schwabb 2% - need to open brokerage account also - Link to app 2)? 3)? 4) Penfed - CL up to $50k, good overall Cash Back tiers - Link
Concerns (1) Bank Atlantic, Advanta, and National City won't let you have multiple business cards. The close and apply quickly works for Advanta, but with Bank Atlantic, Mom waited a week before reapplying and they denied her for "sufficient credit issued by Barclays" despite her card being closed. They would not reconsidered without another hardpull. (2) Not sure about the Chase link, online terms say no cap, but it may hvae a cap when it comes. With a dormant $50k CL already, its worth a shot.
-----------------------------------------
Background This will be my second AOR. The first one was launched in June last year and was a huge success. I started with one credit card with a $4,000 CL. My first AOR bumped me up to $130,000 in total CLs, but I did experience several lowered limits over the course of the year. This thread is for my upcoming personal AOR only, but during my AOR 1.0, I did a family AOR with my parents as well (who got the bulk of the AOR $ given my previously weak history). Total CLs achieved during AOR 1.0 was just over $1MM, with around $880,000 of BT $ invested over the last year. My balances are almost all at $0 now, and this is my personal AOR. The parents will be ready in about one month from now. The goal this year is to get $1.5MM+ in total credit lines.
AOR 1.0 Current Existing Lines Current Cards / CL / Adverse Action Over Past Years AOR --- All have $0 Balance
Personal Cards 1) American Express IN NYC - $500 --- Reduced from $13,000 -- UPDATE - RESTORED TO $13,000 2) American Express IN Chicago - $500 --- Reduced from $24,900 -- UPDATE - RESTORED TO $24,900 3) Bank of America Platinum Plus - $7,000 (Soft CLI to $12,000) 4) Chase VW Platinum - $5,500 --- Reduced from $7,000 5) Citi Dividend $5,500 6) Citi ATT - $4,000 --- Soft CLI +$500 --- $4,500 7) Discover More - $3,000 8) GE Money - $5,500 9) HSBC GM Flex - $3,000 10) Juniper National Parks - $2,000 11) National City Personal - $5,000 12) PNC Platinum - $4,100 -- - Reduced from $5,000 13) WAMU ESPN - $1,613 --- Reduced from $2,000 14) Citi - Professional $20,000
Business Cards 1) Advanta Platinum - $4,350 --- Reduced from $5,000 2) Chase GM Business - $8,600 --- Reduced from $10,000 3) Chase Business Platinum - $4,400 Reduced from $5,000 4) Citi - Business TY - $4,000
Total Existing Credit Lines $88,563 (I also have about $35,000 of AU Credit lines reporting in addition to these cards)
AOR 2.0 Upcoming Applications:
Personal Cards (Agency Pulled for me/Issuer/ Card) 1) EX - APPROVED - $2,500 - Consolidated to $14,400- Bank of America Platinum Plus - Link to App 2) TU - APPROVED $5,000 - Consolidated to $8,000 - Sending $7,500 to Citi Pro - 07/03/08 - Discover Garmin Offer - Discover Garmin Offer - w/ 6 mo 0% BT FWF List of Current Discover Signup Goodies 3) TU - APPROVED - $17,000 - Consolidated to $22,500 Chase Platinum Visa - Link to CardSelection $25 signup bonus 4) TU - DENIED- Juniper - Ifly Link to App 5) TU - DENIED - I never sent in proof of income becuase my "overall debt was less than 25% of my HHI - 07/02/08 Asked for $24,250 BT to CW Acct - US Bank Baylor Alumni Card Link to App 6) EX - APPROVED - $4,800 CL - Citi Cash Rewards Link to App 7) EX - APPROVED - $4,500 CL- Citi - Upromise - Link to App 8) EX - APPROVED - $20,000 CL - Citi - Associated Bank Card Link to App 9) EQ - DENIED- National City - National Quilters (thanks ahself) Link to App 10) ?? - DENIED - Wachovia Personal Card Link to App
Business Cards 1) TU - DENIED - Juniper - Bank Atlantic Card Link to App 2) EX - APPROVED - $8,000- Citi Business 15k TY - Link to App 3) EQ - DENIED- National City Business Card Link to App Apply by phone: 1-800-622-4036 x67291 4) EQ DENIED- 5/3 Business MasterCard (regular, 0% 12mo $0 BT fee) Link to App 5) EQ - APPROVED $10,000 - Consolidated to $23,000- Chase Business Cash Rebate Link to CardSelection $35 Signup Bonus 6) EQ - APPROVED $10,000 CL - Advanta - Closed previous card on 6/18, will see if I can get a new one. Link to CardSelection $30 signup bonus
TOTAL CURRENT AVAILABLE AOR 2.0 CREDIT LINES (including all Citi lines???) = $149,200
Edit: HHI for 2008 is going to be ~$250k for the family. My FICO at the beginning of AOR 1.0 was ~760, and right now with $65k of balances reporting, it is ~670. Also, I have no inquiries on TU or EQ, and 5 inquiries a year old from EX. Update: FAKO's today (with $9k of CC balances, $5k from parents AU daily spender, and $20,500 of new student loans) are 756/758/733. Not too bad considering this is $28k more debt (showing, not that I really have) than I had last year.
Existing Cards AMEX In NYC $20,200 Chase Sony $7,000 BOA Platinum Plus $12,000 Citi ATT - $2,000 Citi Professional - $12,000
New Applications/Status
Personal Cards 1) Bank of America Platinum Plus - Approved - $2,500 - Consolidated to $14,500 2) Discover More - Denied 3) Chase Platinum Visa - Approved $7000 - Consolidated to Chase Business 4) Juniper National Parks Denied 5) US Bank Baylor Alumni Card asked $19,750 BT to Countrywide - Denied, never sent in proof of income since total debt was less than 25% of HHI. 6) Citi Cash Rewards Link to App - Approved $25,000 7) Citi - Upromise - Link to App - Denied 8) Citi - Associated Bank Card Link to App - Approved $15,000 9) National City Life Springs Visa Asked $19750 BT to Countrywide - Approved - $10,000 10)Wachovia Personal Card Link to App - Denied
Business Cards 1 Juniper - Bank Atlantic Card - Denied 2) Citi Business 15k TY - Approved - $8000 3) National City Business Card Link to App Apply by phone: 1-800-622-4036 x67291 - Denied 4) Chase Business Cash Rebate Approved - $9000 - Consolidated to $24,000 5) Advanta - Approved $7,500
Total Sister-o-Rama AOR Credit Lines (including Citi credit lines???) - $118,000
RUNNING OVERALL TOTAL OF ALL CREDIT LINES - $267,200
************************************************************** Update: 10/12/08 - Mom-o-Rama (work in progress)
Personal Cards (Agency Pulled for me/Issuer/ Card) 1) EX - APPROVED- $25,000 - Exisiting CL with BOA personal - Bank of America Platinum Plus - Link to App 2) TU - APPROVED- $11,500 - Discover More 3) TU - APPROVED- $47,500 - Chase Disney Card - Link to App - $75 Cap 4) TU - DENIED- Asked $20k to 5/3- $2,500 exisiting - Juniper - Ifly Link to App 5) TU - APPROVED - $25,000 - Check mailed to 5/3 - US Bank Baylor Alumni Card Link to App 6) EX - DENIED- Citi CR Card - Damn you Citi and your credit lock, still in place. Third attempt failed. 7) DENIED- People's United - RBS - 9 month, $60 cap 8) APPROVED - $15,000 + existing $5,650 CL = $20,650CL - Asked for $20k BT to 5/3 (did it go through with $15k CL originally?)- WaMu Espn Card - Link to App - 6 month, no fee
To enter a coupon code in your post please enter the following info:
Coupon Code:
Coupon Offer:
Merchant:
Expires (optional):
Restrictions (optional):
saving...
Quick Summary is created and edited by users like you... Add FAQ's, Links and other Relevant Information by clicking the edit button in the lower right hand corner of this message.
1) Yes, for Citi anyway. I have two Diamond Preferred's, one normal (oldest Citi card) and one with 0%-for-life. I don't think you'll have a problem here. Other issuers, not sure.
2) No, you cannot have two Advanta's. Multiple, multiple people have tried. I cancelled mine last year, before applying and being accepted for a new one, with a higher CL (10k up from 5k). Don't assume it will be higher though, some people have experienced lower CL's the second time around.
4) I have 4 Personal, 2 business, have experienced no AA yet. I've heard claims of up to eight here. I would maybe go with the best Personal and best Biz app first, then maybe delay a couple others. I'm sure you've read the recent Citi AA Approach thread, so you'll know we're all guessing right now.
With Advanta, how long between closing and reapplying do you think will work? Less than one week? I might try to do them last, as it can't hurt to try and I doubt I'll be denied for 4 inquiries with them (they pull EQ for me). Otherwise I have no use for thier card. I'll cancel it tonight and at least we'll get a data point with Advanta.
Edit: Ok, I cancelled the Advanta card for better or worse. Will add it as a later application with no great expectations, but it will be a good data point to have.
May I suggest The Nuclear Option? Do the entire family's AOR all at once, and document it in one thread? It would be great fun.
1) Not completely sure about multiple RBS cards. I did, however, get a Kroger card while I already had a regular platinum card. So it's probably okay to get two identical ones? (I may find try myself in several months, let me know how it works).
4) I think the total sum of Chase/Citi cards is variable, but very large. I mean, I've had 8 or so without problems. But the as has been previously demostrated, too many new apps is more likely to be bad.
I can do the nuclear option, but the parents have another month on their promo's to go, and I'm almost ready for launch. Also, I like to do them a little staggered for orgainzational purposes. My sister will be included in this round as well, so total apps will be 80-100, and simplification/organization will be a good thing. I can make a master post with all the results and issues though.
Also, I have the RBS platinum and RBS kroger at the same time also with no probs. I'm going to try for a new Kroger b/c I have an extra EX pull to spare.
Mike, congrats on your success at round 1 with the family. $880,000 is huge! To think of all the work you would have to do to keep those rewards checking accounts going with a only $100,000 FDIC per account. I for one have appreciated all your insights about Business AORs. That has been very valuable for FWF.
On to the questions:
1) As djspray mentioned, you can usually have multiple of the same card open with a creditor. The only exception to this that I have heard of is Advanta Business. Also worth mentioning, Discover will only allow one Personal and one Business card to be opened during a time frame (I believe within a 6 month period, but not certain). It doesn't look like you will will have this problem though.
2) I am not sure how long it takes Advanta to update their system when closing out a card. I would be safe and suggest waiting a full billing cycle (30+ days after close) before applying for a new one. It might be possible to close and re-open in a single phone call though. Anyone have more info on this? I am curious as well.
3) It is generally agreed by the FWF community that consolidating lines (canceling the card to add the limit to an existing line) has a negative (or at least not a positive) effect on your credit score. The general rule is never close a card unless it is specifically requested or required when applying for a new card or loan. Instead, reallocate the lines by moving as much of the limit to the new card as you can. All cards have a specific minimum you need to keep the line open (usually $500 or $1,000). Reallocate all but the minimum and keep the card open to help provide history to your credit report, thus helping your score in the long run since an open card will take longer before it falls off than a closed card. I would usually do this after you receive your new cards before you balance transfer (if you don't request the transfer at the time of application, that is).
4) Most have reported around 8-9 cards for each City and Chase before getting denied for additional cards. Some can have up to 12, others get denied after 6, so YMMV. So (and this is an exception to #3 above) consolidating your lines down to 5-7 before applying for more cards should provide a better chance of not getting denied for too many lines.
MikeR397 said:(3) It would probably help to consolidate my lines to get as many larger limits as possible, but Im not sure I want to wait for the credit reports to update. I have disputed my balances recently, and should be ready to fire AOR 2.0 off soon. I think asking for large BTs on the applications is still the best way to get large CLs.Personally I have seen issuers match the highest limit on a report (both for myself and my husband). Not to say BT requests won't help but why skip the step of making yourself as attractive as possible.
Have you talked to any issuers that cut your lines about restoring them now that everything's paid off? From what others have reported Chase seems forgiving when you call them back with lower utilization. You may as well find out now where you stand with those companies rather than after wasting inquiries.
MikeR397 said:Also, I have the RBS platinum and RBS kroger at the same time also with no probs.A bit OT, but did you ever try reallocating between the two?
kittenmittens said:MikeR397 said:Also, I have the RBS platinum and RBS kroger at the same time also with no probs.A bit OT, but did you ever try reallocating between the two?I've tried this during AOR 1.0, and it was a no go. Tried 3 seperate times, but they won't consolidate (or move partial CL) between the RBS platinum and the RBS kroger card. They seem to give the exact same Cl's on both though and are pretty inquiry friendly.
Corndog - When I said consolidate, I actually meant just move CL. I wouldn't close a line unless there is a reason to do so (like Advanta).
Also, I'm planning on calling all the issuers and asking for no pull CLI's to get the lines as beefy as possible. I'm still debating waiting for the moved CL's to show up, but I am leaning toward it. Does anyone know if changes in CL take as long as changes in balances to reflect on your credit report? Do they update in the same way?
Currently, there are about 4 cards that needs to hit $0. I've disputed the balances, so they should be at $0 by the end of the week hopefully. I think I'm going to call and move CL's around tomorrow and hope they update on the report fast, its likely worth the wait (I don't think you can dispute CL levels as easily as balances).
I also recommend waiting for your prettied up credit profile to hit the bureaus. The new cl's report after statement cycle date, except for the usual weirdness (AXP is slow, etc).
a) The Citibank Professional card is personal, in that it appears on your credit report. b) I don't know of a Sony $100 bonus that's current. c) If you want to maximize seperate buckets for Citibank, maybe try the Hilton or American Airlines personal card instead of the Preferred Rewards. There have been indications that those are seperate buckets. (but they are NPSL cards, which makes reallocation tougher). d) I would personally avoid WAMU unless you had a targeted offer. e) I would apply for a Citibank business card that has a good TYP signup bonus (either the TYP card, Premierpass, or the regular business with a "before you go" bonus. f) Maybe give AXP a break on this one? Apply for a rewards card or two, and built up some credit that won't be slashed on the inevitable financial review.
You'll included your reported HHI and scores before you apply, right?
I love the fact that you bunched the apps by credit bureau being pulled - great early research/prep! I'll be watching this one closely. I expect 30+ green for you on this one.
I personally like the Wells Fargo credit card. No BT fee for first 30 days. 0% for 9 months. The only catch is they require an existing relationship (I believe the app allows for you to apply for both checking and credit card at the same app). Easy BT to checking accounts also (just like BOA).
They pulled EX for me (South Dakota). They pull EX for any hard CLI requests too.
Corndogg said:I am not sure how long it takes Advanta to update their system when closing out a card. I would be safe and suggest waiting a full billing cycle (30+ days after close) before applying for a new one. It might be possible to close and re-open in a single phone call though. Anyone have more info on this? I am curious as well.You can re-apply virtually immediately - a day or two prior to the new application is more than necessary. When I did this last fall, the CSR asked why I was closing the account, I told him why, and he offered to take my new application right then.
I am curious, how are people making AORs beneficial with such low interest rates? Are you using several different rewards checking accounts to get APY of ~5%?
DNLS said:I am curious, how are people making AORs beneficial with such low interest rates? Are you using several different rewards checking accounts to get APY of ~5%?
Why not? The added bit of effort is about 2-3% extra on upwards of a couple hundred thousand bucks? Adds up a lot over time.
DNLS said:I am curious, how are people making AORs beneficial with such low interest rates? Are you using several different rewards checking accounts to get APY of ~5%?
400K @ 3.75% is still worth my time.
Mike, You got hit with some serious adverse action on AOR #1.
From experience, be careful with Discover, they were fickle with me over a second personal card when the first one was not being used at all.
I would nix the kroger and WAMU cards for fear of crappy limits and denials. I will also never ever apply at HSBC.
On my wifes AOR she did a juniper personal and biz (bank atlantic) and got denied for the biz with the explaniation that enough juniper credit already exists. You may want to stick to biz only.
I have a citi professional cash and typ card (2 total cards) so you could do a duplicate
CAll RBS and ask to upgrade your Plat card to the CustomCash version. It should be doable. I got mine last Aug doing a trick found in the archive: there is a link to it where I applied, but I received the Plat. I called and asked the CustomCash instead, since I had the application printouts, and the upgrade raised no problems (printouts were never asked). Does RBS send you regularly no-fee BT checks good for BT laundering?
markkundinger said:I also recommend waiting for your prettied up credit profile to hit the bureaus. The new cl's report after statement cycle date, except for the usual weirdness (AXP is slow, etc).
a) The Citibank Professional card is personal, in that it appears on your credit report. b) I don't know of a Sony $100 bonus that's current. c) If you want to maximize seperate buckets for Citibank, maybe try the Hilton or American Airlines personal card instead of the Preferred Rewards. There have been indications that those are seperate buckets. (but they are NPSL cards, which makes reallocation tougher). d) I would personally avoid WAMU unless you had a targeted offer. e) I would apply for a Citibank business card that has a good TYP signup bonus (either the TYP card, Premierpass, or the regular business with a "before you go" bonus. f) Maybe give AXP a break on this one? Apply for a rewards card or two, and built up some credit that won't be slashed on the inevitable financial review.
You'll included your reported HHI and scores before you apply, right? Yes, I know about the Professonal card and am thankful. I'm hoping that $20k line will make some other issuers think about giving me $20k lines to match my highest line given that my big AMEX lines were slashed.
My biggest concern with Citi is consolidation/moving CL's to my Cash Returns Card (at least for the first 3 months), then do a BT later. That is why I've chosen the citi cards I have.
Ya, with WAMU, I'm only applying if I get at good targeted offer. Defnately do the Citibank Business (just one) with the best TY offer.
I may give AMEX a break. I tried getting my lines back up, but they said I have to wait 6 months (Nov) before they will reevaluate it. I may try again, but I have no use for a $3,000 6mo BT on the LA card considering thier crack CLI will likey not work for me anymore.
g10ny said:CAll RBS and ask to upgrade your Plat card to the CustomCash version. It should be doable. I got mine last Aug doing a trick found in the archive: there is a link to it where I applied, but I received the Plat. I called and asked the CustomCash instead, since I had the application printouts, and the upgrade raised no problems (printouts were never asked). Does RBS send you regularly no-fee BT checks good for BT laundering?I have not received any checks from them since the original BT's. Then again, I pushed all the issuers hard with BT's given my slim history, so I'm sure they weren't inclined to give me good offer's over the last 12 months. It was worth it
DNLS said:I am curious, how are people making AORs beneficial with such low interest rates? Are you using several different rewards checking accounts to get APY of ~5%?I have 4 reward checking accounts with a $50k cap (total $200k), and was planning on opening more until they started slashing rates and max balance amounts. I'm still interested in the $50k capped accounts. At $25k cap, the extra ~1.5% after forced purchases is not worth my time as compared to dumping the bulk of the $ in 4% savings accounts. I have CW (3.75%) and Indymac (3.85%) and (AARP (4.05%) right now. I'm hoping rates will creep up over the coming months due to inflation. In any event, I'm currently a law student that has little other income, so my tax bracket is so low, I still make great profit ratios.
Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.