|
-
-
ppatin
- Senior Member - 1K
posted: Jun. 26, 2009 @ 7:22a
largeeyes said:He can try to do what I saw done recently. Waive all parental rights in return for no child support. Even if we ignore the moral/ethical implications of this it would still require the girlfriend to agree, and I can't imagine why she'd say yes to such a proposal. The guy will probably be moving in a year (I assume that he's in some middle of nowhere college town, and once he finishes school he'll have to go somewhere else to put his PhD to use) which means that if the GF is feeling evil she could deny him contact with his kid still collecting a nice fat child support check every month. The family court system has a bad reputation for treating non-custodial parents like nothing more than walking wallets, which means there will be few consequences for her if she cuts him out of the kid's life. The smartest thing to do is to stay on the best possible terms with her, marry her if she turns out to be a keeper, and if she isn't then try as hard as possible to maintain a respectful, adult relationship with her for both the kid and his own sake. |
-
-
gtalum
- Senior Member
posted: Jun. 26, 2009 @ 7:41a
Always wear a condom. Oh wait, too late for that... |
-
-
captainwho
- Senior Member
posted: Jun. 26, 2009 @ 7:45a
It's cute how you call your "little friend", "Dan". |
-
-
marketingmike
- Cranky Member
posted: Jun. 26, 2009 @ 8:15a
a) baby may miscarry, if there is a baby there at all (girl could be trying to extort a ring from your friend) b) if baby shows up, it deserves to be cared for, financially and otherwise b1) your friend needs to decide whether he wants to participate only financially, or in some additional way b2) there is NO realistic option for your friend to walk away from the financial obligation he has incurred c) marrying someone he doesn't want to be with because she happens to be pregnant is the definition of throwing good money after bad If this isn't a troll, good luck to your friend. |
-
-
ppatin
- Senior Member - 1K
posted: Jun. 26, 2009 @ 8:27a
Dropping the A-word is a good way to get this thread locked very quickly. |
-
-
fredEcat
- Member
posted: Jun. 26, 2009 @ 8:32a
devastated2 said:BlueEyesAustinTexas said:If she's the custodial parent then she determines how the child support is used. Period, end of story.
A little hint--thinking about this situation in this way is a sure fire guarantee to ensure that he has the worst possible relationship with this girlfriend. Does she, for example, have any idea he does NOT intend to make an honest woman out of her and propose?
Apparently she has stated she does not want to get married until after the baby arrives. My friend was too upset for me to interrogate him about what that meant -- but I know their relationship is rocky to say the least. Probably means she wants to wait until she gets her figure back before having her $20K+ wedding. Ouch, OP and Dan. I'm really sorry. |
-
-
ppatin
- Senior Member - 1K
posted: Jun. 26, 2009 @ 8:36a
If the topic of marriage does come up with the GF then your friend should mention that because of their financial situation and the expense of raising a child they should have a cheap wedding and skip the cost of an engagement ring. If she reacts badly to that then that's a good sign that she's bad news. |
-
-
scrouds
- Addicted Member
posted: Jun. 26, 2009 @ 8:38a
He should play hardball with the baby momma. Drop the bomb. Tell her straight up he has absolutely no plans of marrying her, and that he knows ways to get out of paying child support. He should then tell her that he will cover any abortion expense, and explain that its best for her to not be weighed down as a single mom with no good means of support. Convince her its the best option, and that he'll be there to support her in this. Lie through your teeth if you have to. (at least I believe) the best option is to not have a kid right now, for either one of them. Its not too late to take care of that. Also, to people saying for him to pay off her 20k debt and enable her to rack up some more cc bills, just leave FWF and go back to hot deals, mmmkay?
|
-
-
scrouds
- Addicted Member
posted: Jun. 26, 2009 @ 8:41a
ppatin said:Dropping the A-word is a good way to get this thread locked very quickly. Abortion is the most cost effective option at this point. Condoms are even more cost effective, in hindsight. So is the pullout method, which has similar real world failure (pregnany) rates. |
-
-
dcwilbur
- Ancient Member
posted: Jun. 26, 2009 @ 8:41a
devastated2 said:They've been going out for a little over a year, and I know that Dan never saw himself in a long term relationship with her...I'm having trouble with this part. He's around thirty years old, dating a woman over a year, sleeping with her, and didn't see himself in a long term relationship? What is all that supposed to mean? So a young single woman spends all her money on clothes. What's so unusual about that? This guy needs to nut up and be a man. |
-
-
tripleB
- Senior Member - 2K
posted: Jun. 26, 2009 @ 8:41a
devastated2 said: Dan is in the final year of a PhD program, so his annual income now is only his $25K stipend, but this will likely increase substantially in the next year or two. Apparently he has about $10K in savings.
Dan knows he'll be on the hook for child support, but from a financial perspective what can he do to protect his future earnings and to ensure child support actually is supporting the child? (Going off the grid codename47 style is not an option.)
Tell "your friend Dan" that he should consider extending his PhD program another year. There's no official timeline with a PhD. Maybe he screwed up and needs more data. If he is in a research field, perhaps after he gets the PhD he can get the lowest paying post-doctoral position (~$30k/year) possible. Then demand to go to court immediately after the child is born to determine child support. Show the judge how poor you are... I mean "your friend" is. The child support payments will be based on those low income earnings. I frequently hear celebrities and sports athletes earning millions of dollars, and having child support based off that. Then the following year their career is over and they are still on the hook for the huge child support. So this is basically a trick reversing that situation. |
-
-
skibum43
- Senior Member - 4K
posted: Jun. 26, 2009 @ 8:42a
I went through something similar about 19 years ago. Although not financially irresponsible, my ex-girlfriend let me know she was pregnant about two months after we had broken up ( one of many previous breakups). At the time, I thought it was the worst thing that could have happened to me, because at 37 and already dating someone else, I had no great desire to become a father. We tried one last time to make it work, but it was not meant to be. However, after a difficult initial year or so, we both agreed to put our daughter first and actually became friends. She eventually married someone else and I am an extended part of their family. I just paid my last child support check this month since she just graduated high school and now I will also be voluntarily paying a portion of her college expenses. In retrospect, it was the best thing that ever happened to me. Sure there were some difficult times, but she has added immensely to my life and I am very proud of her. Tell your friend not to just look at this from a financial aspect. Be a part of his child's life (although she lived about 90 minutes away my daughter spent almost every other w/e and many vacations with me starting when she was nine months old) and he may experience rewards that more than outweigh the financial aspect. |
-
-
EvilCapitalist
- Senior Member - 1K
posted: Jun. 26, 2009 @ 8:59a
States have different laws regarding custody/support for non-married parents. He should educate himself about those. In some states it is nearly impossible to drop child support payments if his name is on a birth certificate even after it has been established that he's not the father. He's ought to make sure it will be his kid before putting his name on the birth certificate. |
-
-
PolarDude
- Senior Member - 1K
posted: Jun. 26, 2009 @ 9:00a
scrouds said:He should play hardball with the baby momma. Drop the bomb. Tell her straight up he has absolutely no plans of marrying her, and that he knows ways to get out of paying child support. He should then tell her that he will cover any abortion expense, and explain that its best for her to not be weighed down as a single mom with no good means of support. Convince her its the best option, and that he'll be there to support her in this.
Lie through your teeth if you have to. (at least I believe) the best option is to not have a kid right now, for either one of them. Its not too late to take care of that.
Happened to a close buddy of mine. Same situation, and looked as dire as the OP. She lived out of state, but he flew out and was ruthless to her. To this day, best decision he ever made. He just lectured her, and was very firm. He took her to get the abortion, and paid for it.. it all was smooth.
Oh, and the chick was supposedly on the pill...but she was lying. Friend found out she hasn't taken them for weeks.
Don't forget. This is FWF. What kind of response do you expect? Marriage, keeping the baby would not be in the best financial interest for OP. Aggregate cost of baby alone could be $1MM over life of the child. Throw in marriage to financially irresponsible wife, and you can double or triple that. If all else fails.. get her to to give up the kid to the state. You can drop babies off at hospitals no questions asked in many states, or put it up for adoption formally. If you choose adoption, You can interview potential parents, and take your time. The prenatal care will be nothing compared to keeping it. Have to make sure she doesn't change her mind. When the baby is delivered, you can put the adoptive parents on the birth certificate, so there's no record of you having the kid. Don't understand all the red.. Must be the morning crowd. OP should have posted this for the late night H&B crowd. |
-
-
patch96
- Senior Member - 1K
posted: Jun. 26, 2009 @ 9:01a
Lets review the record for clarity: 1. He is financially responsible and in a PHD program. 2. He know ONE thing for sure. He does not want a long term relationship with her. 3. She is financially irresponsible. 4. She is pregnant. 5. The OP is a new member with the name - "devasted." But his is his "Friend." Here are the GUARANTEES from this situation. 1. The baby is his. This is his last way out of this with some honor. Pitiful (late) wishful thinking. Its not going to happen. The nino is his. 2. Her religion says no abortion. Did her religion say no sex without marriage? (Google - the catholic woman's paradox - but i digress) WHY should she abort it . . . she has him to pay for it. 3. Everything he is doing. Abortion, paternity test, not getting married - is INSURING a crappy relationship with his wife and kid in the future. HERE SOME ADVICE FROM SOMEONE WHO HAS BEEN AROUND. The only thing he can do NOW - is the right thing. If he even hints the word abortion, she has that "card" to play the rest of the child's life. So let that option go. If he does not marry her, why was he "baby-makin" like they were married. These are the consequences in life and we don't always win (except if you have Bush and Obama in your back pocket and are too big to fail.) In my opinion he does not even have the right - unless there is CLEAR evidence of another guy having sex with her - to ask for a paternity test. Most importantly, That baby has the right to a doting MOM and DAD, and the best life his parents can provide for him. Tell your friend as a parent - it just is not all about him anymore. Your friend obviously thinks he is being screwed - he is right. This is just the beginning. The kid, her family, the world, and the law are all on her side now. |
-
-
glocks
- Member
posted: Jun. 26, 2009 @ 9:05a
This is not 1955. Why are so many people even thinking about suggesting marriage at this point? If that is a possibility down the line, why not work on the relationship(s) for a few years, first? Religious family or not. |
-
-
ppatin
- Senior Member - 1K
posted: Jun. 26, 2009 @ 9:10a
patch96 said: In my opinion he does not even have the right - unless there is CLEAR evidence of another guy having sex with her - to ask for a paternity test.
I've got to disagree with this part. A paternity test won't harm the kid, and if he gets on the hook for child support and later discovers he's not the dad there's a very good chance he'll be screwed. There's no reason not to ask for a paternity test in this situation. |
-
-
curtisekarr
- Senior Member
posted: Jun. 26, 2009 @ 9:10a
devastated2 said:Apparently she has stated she does not want to get married until after the baby arrives. Maybe she wants to have a paternity test to establish the real father first. Obviously, a marriage here will (almost) never work. Hubby will be bitter about the circumstances; wifey upset that "loving" hubby not willing to waste money on her wardrobe. Child suffers. I'd advise "your friend" to offer to pay off her $20k debt in exchange for "doing the right thing" for the 3 persons involved. It's that simple. |
-
-
oopsz
- Happy Member
posted: Jun. 26, 2009 @ 9:12a
BlueEyesAustinTexas said:If she's the custodial parent then she determines how the child support is used. Period, end of story. Varies from state to state. In my state, the noncustodial parent can go to family court and demand an accounting. The custodial parent has to prove child support is being spent for the child's benefit. If not, the custodial parent is liable for waste. |
-
-
toomatoo
- Frivolous Member
posted: Jun. 26, 2009 @ 9:14a
tell Dan to suck it up... He did not want to have a long term relationship with this girl.. but was willing to sleep with her as long as he could...(they have been going out for a year...) and is now surprised that she is pregnant... Just how long does it take to figure out that someone is not right for you? is that at the very least not dishonest on his part... |
Close
|
|
 |
 |
Not Already A Member?
Sign Up Now!
|
|
Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.
|
|