Edit

Forums
Finance

Why is there so many multi-level marketing gimmicks out there? Archived From: Finance

  • tweet this
  • Post to Facebook
  • Text Only
  • Search this Topic »
  • Classic
  • Go to Page :
  • 12 3 4
alert mods    

Utah has the most MLMs in the country. It's a combination of the usual, plus desperation. You have big families, lots of tithing, an environment that favors business over labor. Add in a lot of people who spent 2 years honing sales skills on a church mission. Presto, MLMs erupt.

A lot of these schemes are 'affinity fraud', as with Madoff. If someone you trust does it, you sometimes forget due diligence.

Estimates are that 99% of participants lose money - often over and over.


alert mods    

janwad said:Utah has the most MLMs in the country. It's a combination of the usual, plus desperation. You have big families, lots of tithing, an environment that favors business over labor. Add in a lot of people who spent 2 years honing sales skills on a church mission. Presto, MLMs erupt.

A lot of these schemes are 'affinity fraud', as with Madoff. If someone you trust does it, you sometimes forget due diligence.

Estimates are that 99% of participants lose money - often over and over.
The affinity fraud is especially prevalent among religious and ethnic groups. The same trust and blind faith found in Utah among those of a shared religious belief is the same thing we see with Asians and WFG, or Indians and Quixtar, etc.


alert mods    

ken76 said:I don't think most people realize the difficulty in building a downline in any MLM.

What taught me of the difficulty was AllAdvantage back in 2000. They paid you to surf while using their ad bar, and you were also paid for the surfing of your downline. It seemed like you could have a giant downline in no time. I don't think I signed up more than a few people, and they didn't surf much.

At least it was free to join, and they did pay out for about a year before they went bankrupt. In the end it was a good lesson in MLM.

I was getting checks for 200 bucks a month before it died down


alert mods    

SUCKISSTAPLES said: The affinity fraud is especially prevalent among religious and ethnic groups. The same trust and blind faith found in Utah among those of a shared religious belief is the same thing we see with Asians and WFG, or Indians and Quixtar, etc.

The MLM fat cats at the top have realized sharing the same faith or the usually tight-knit network of ethnic groups become a secondary but very powerful factor in selling the scam. Many Asian culture would dictate that you politely sign up so your friend/relative would ago away versus telling them off and making them lose face. The MLM people also recruit professionals like physicians and dentists. Once you get them in, their patients are more likely to go along. After all, your trusted doctor thinks it is the best way since sliced bread.


alert mods    

There's a patsy in every game, if you don't know who it is, it's you.


alert mods    

My wife always meets new ladies at work or at the kids school. And they always invite her over to their homes.

It is always so sad and dissapointing when she finds out that their true intention was to get her to buy something from them.

The other sadness is when you are given a peek behind the curtain and find out that so many people who you swear are doing great financially, really aren't at all.


alert mods    

Im not going off a "true" dictionary definition but to me MLM is making more money signing others up than selling or using the product.


alert mods    

With risk of being flamed here goes my fellow FW'ers I am a professional network marketer and earning a full time income with PT efforts. There are good and bad companies. check out this video for info on how to identify a pyramid scheme http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8iu-MvDbPjA

educate yourself it is a legit form of business.


alert mods    

mt2va said:nycll said:
Simply put, you work X years while paying Y% of your income into social security while enjoying a pension during the final Z years of your life span. If you keep the ratio X/Z constant, you don't have to raise Y. Right now we keep X constant (retirement age=65), and Z is increasing, then Y will need to rise a lot.


Actually this is not correct. When I get my social security statement 3 months before my birthday each year it clearly shows (based on my date of birth) that I have to be 67 to draw social security & not 65 so they are changing the retirement age.
You are noticing a very small shift of the full retirement age from 65 to 67. But you are also eligible for partial distribution from age 62. Everything is spelled out in the official website of social security. The small shift far from enough offset the cumulative increase of life expectancy since the beginning of the program.

Right now the only rich country that indexes public retirement benefits is either Denmark or Norway. We still need to do it otherwise the program will run out of money.
dumroo said:But nevertheless it is a IOU that is owed... I save or not is my problem. What the govt has to pay what it implicitly or explicitly promises is the govt's problem.When the government has to dramatically increase the payroll tax to pay babyboomers benefits as promised, it will become your problem (assuming you are of one of the post boomer generations).


alert mods    

SUCKISSTAPLES said:janwad said:Utah has the most MLMs in the country. It's a combination of the usual, plus desperation. You have big families, lots of tithing, an environment that favors business over labor. Add in a lot of people who spent 2 years honing sales skills on a church mission. Presto, MLMs erupt.

A lot of these schemes are 'affinity fraud', as with Madoff. If someone you trust does it, you sometimes forget due diligence.

Estimates are that 99% of participants lose money - often over and over.
The affinity fraud is especially prevalent among religious and ethnic groups. The same trust and blind faith found in Utah among those of a shared religious belief is the same thing we see with Asians and WFG, or Indians and Quixtar, etc.

Amen!

unfortunately for me the probability of getting into these discussions is way too high (Utah,religion and ethnic)


alert mods    

patch96 said:My The other sadness is when you are given a peek behind the curtain and find out that so many people who you swear are doing great financially, really aren't at all.

I run into Amway nuts in Baskins Robbins and other places. They mention they are diamond members, platinum members and so on. I ask them if they can verify by showing the money credited into their bank accounts. Usually these people make an excuse to leave the store.


alert mods    

Are people really that naive? There was one some guy tried talking to me about for a prepaid legal service. I told him no way and to leave me along.

We really need to have a minimum education requirement to post on here as half the posts these days are indecipherable.


alert mods    

fljeremy said:With risk of being flamed here goes my fellow FW'ers I am a professional network marketer and earning a full time income with PT efforts. There are good and bad companies. check out this video for info on how to identify a pyramid scheme http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8iu-MvDbPjA

educate yourself it is a legit form of business.
Im not going to flame you - but I am going to ask you to BACK UP your 2 line marketing script designed to get people interested in MLM.

First of all, detail what the MLM is, how many people are in your up/downline, how much you personally sell, how much you personally buy, and what your gross and net income are.

Product-based MLMs are actually WORSE and MORE DANGEROUS than pure pyramids, because they can last longer and scam far more people. Just because Quixtar, Herbalife, etc are LEGAL businesses , does not mean the majority of people who get involved are misled and deceived, and end up losing more than they ever earn


alert mods    

tripleB said:Because its an easy way to make money!Please, I want to learn more this exciting opportunity for unlimited wealth. I am not a shill.


alert mods    

Cerdo said:Another good reason to avoid bars....between women expecting me to buy them drinks and a loser talking about how he's going to make 10k a month doing nothing, I'd rather sit at home.Don't put down bars. I met my wife in in a singles bar. OK, it was two years after we got married, but...


alert mods    

Not all MLM are created equal. Some are legitimate, but most you hear about are not. Can you get rich? In most cases winning the lottery would be a better chance of getting rich.

I remember a "party" by a friend many years ago. It was a presentation on everything about the "good life" and it wasn't until the end when you found out the actual "products" of the MLM. Did I get into it. NO! I was surprised when other friends (who I would have pitched it to) were into it, too. Most were just at the break-even point [excluding the cost of time], but I saw not way to make the downlines that would make it profitable. I didn't "believe" in the product like the "makers" and "shakers" that had the big downlines.

Over the years I got into the PTC/PTS/PTP internet industry and still get residual checks every once in a while from some active downlines if the companies don't go out of business.


alert mods    

"Trade Commission “requires Amway to label its products with the message that 54% of Amway recruits make nothing and the rest earn on average $65 a month"
source


alert mods    

"Product-based MLMs are actually WORSE and MORE DANGEROUS than pure pyramids...."

I think there are exceptions; I like my Cutco knives, for example, as a product and never considered getting into Vector Marketing after buying them.


alert mods    

yes, but most of the students who get involved as cutco sales reps feel tricked and misled... There are even online forums like fw where they post all the slimy tactics that they encounter


alert mods    

Our neighbor was big on Reliv, which she pushed fairly hard. She went to the convetions and everything. I think she did pretty well with it, but she had the whole chain thing workin for her. Overpriced milkshakes if you ask me.


 Close

Sign Me In
Nickname: 
Password: 
Remember My Login Information:

Forget your login information?

Not Already A Member?
Sign Up Now!



Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.


While FatWallet makes every effort to post correct information, offers are subject to change without notice.
Some exclusions may apply based upon merchant policies.
© 1999-2009