I used 4 cards per account with no issue (as of yet)
nicetimes
Member
posted: Jul. 10, 2009 @ 9:24a
i used the same citicard to fund 4x$5000. Balance is still zero
dukeboy
Member
posted: Jul. 10, 2009 @ 9:25a
It seems at midnight the volatility is lowest. So if you just want to make one trade. it is better to do it at midnight.
joec1960
New Member
posted: Jul. 10, 2009 @ 9:50a
nicetimes, why $20k?
nicetimes
Member
posted: Jul. 10, 2009 @ 9:56a
joec1960 said: nicetimes, why $20k? i am to greedy. I want to get the 1% credit card CashBack as well (since they are counted as purchases).
canhelp
Member
posted: Jul. 10, 2009 @ 10:00a
You need a call or there is option in the account to use credit card as funding?
kenfeyl
Member
posted: Jul. 10, 2009 @ 10:01a
nicetimes said: joec1960 said: nicetimes, why $20k? i am to greedy. I want to get the 1% credit card CashBack as well (since they are counted as purchases).
That sounds like a big risk. What if it gets marked as a cash advance? You'll be out 3% * $20k = $600, or $400 after the bonus. With $10k, you'll only be out $100 in the worst-case scenario.
Could we get some people who saw it as a purchase to chime in with what CC they used? Either in here, or the wiki would be great.
joec1960
New Member
posted: Jul. 10, 2009 @ 10:08a
I am not trying, dont want to risk the cash advance fees! Nice catch though guys!
dukeboy
Member
posted: Jul. 10, 2009 @ 10:09a
That's scary. My cash advance limit is well below $5000. So my three $5000 charges won't count as cash advance.
kenfeyl said: nicetimes said: joec1960 said: nicetimes, why $20k? i am to greedy. I want to get the 1% credit card CashBack as well (since they are counted as purchases).
That sounds like a big risk. What if it gets marked as a cash advance? You'll be out 3% * $20k = $600, or $400 after the bonus. With $10k, you'll only be out $100 in the worst-case scenario.
People please: those of you in a panic over a possible cash advance, just call your card issuer and LOWER your cash advance limit BELOW what you're going to try to fund at. Worst case is the transaction doesn't go through if they try to run it as a cash advance then. CC companies don't let you blow through a cash advance limit like they might on your overall credit line.
You all are so worked up over this, when the bigger cloud is whether anyone who didn't get the e-mail will actually get the bonus considering the T&Cs indicate the intent was as a targeted offer.
nicetimes
Member
posted: Jul. 10, 2009 @ 10:45a
teammjs said: People please: those of you in a panic over a possible cash advance, just call your card issuer and LOWER your cash advance limit BELOW what you're going to try to fund at. Worst case is the transaction doesn't go through if they try to run it as a cash advance then. CC companies don't let you blow through a cash advance limit like they might on your overall credit line.
You all are so worked up over this, when the bigger cloud is whether anyone who didn't get the e-mail will actually get the bonus considering the T&Cs indicate the intent was as a targeted offer.
My cash advance limit is only $1000 (while credit limit is $30000). If the transaction went through, it can not be counted as cash advance. But, who knows. Fortunately (or unfortunately), my zecco balance is still zero..
Zecco said they are not even capable of classifying this as a cash advance.
Schwab said that though my charge is just a temp. authorization at this time, that it would surely be a purchase since it was a deposit of cash into an account and not an advance of cash directly to me.
krk77
Senior Member
posted: Jul. 10, 2009 @ 11:04a
There is a option to fund your account using ACH (after your account is approved and you get your user id).
Also I got a call from someone named Tony, he told me that as I am opening my acount with $10000, I am eligible for a free one-on-one session explaining basics of Forex Trading by someone like him. So if you are interested, you can ask for it too (call customer Support)
nicetimes said: joec1960 said: nicetimes, why $20k? i am to greedy. I want to get the 1% credit card CashBack as well (since they are counted as purchases).
Report back your success/failure. I tried this at fxcm and on withdrawl they charged back the credit card.
nicetimes
Member
posted: Jul. 10, 2009 @ 1:09p
fatbill said: nicetimes said: joec1960 said: nicetimes, why $20k? i am to greedy. I want to get the 1% credit card CashBack as well (since they are counted as purchases).
Report back your success/failure. I tried this at fxcm and on withdrawl they charged back the credit card.
I am going to request withdraw with check (if my funding finally goes through). Did you request for check withdraw?
nicetimes said: fatbill said: nicetimes said: joec1960 said: nicetimes, why $20k? i am to greedy. I want to get the 1% credit card CashBack as well (since they are counted as purchases).
Report back your success/failure. I tried this at fxcm and on withdrawl they charged back the credit card.
I am going to request withdraw with check (if my funding finally goes through). Did you request for check withdraw?
Yes. Requested check. FXCM said no because credit card funding used, I get a chargeback. Now maybe if I had actually used the money to trade (I did not).
YMMV. Please report back.
nicetimes
Member
posted: Jul. 10, 2009 @ 1:20p
fatbill said: nicetimes said: fatbill said: nicetimes said: joec1960 said: nicetimes, why $20k? i am to greedy. I want to get the 1% credit card CashBack as well (since they are counted as purchases).
Report back your success/failure. I tried this at fxcm and on withdrawl they charged back the credit card.
I am going to request withdraw with check (if my funding finally goes through). Did you request for check withdraw?
Yes. Requested check. FXCM said no because credit card funding used, I get a chargeback. Now maybe if I had actually used the money to trade (I did not).
YMMV. Please report back.
Damn! I should have used ACH to fund the account then. Anyway, I'll report back once there is an update.
livedog
Senior Member
posted: Jul. 10, 2009 @ 1:32p
fatbill said: nicetimes said: fatbill said: nicetimes said: joec1960 said: nicetimes, why $20k? i am to greedy. I want to get the 1% credit card CashBack as well (since they are counted as purchases).
Report back your success/failure. I tried this at fxcm and on withdrawl they charged back the credit card.
I am going to request withdraw with check (if my funding finally goes through). Did you request for check withdraw?
Yes. Requested check. FXCM said no because credit card funding used, I get a chargeback. Now maybe if I had actually used the money to trade (I did not).
Did the chargeback actually cost you anything at the end of the day? It just got credited back to your credit card, right? I guess if you had paid off the balance early, then you would end up with a large negative balance...
Any fees?
drosenth613
New Member
posted: Jul. 10, 2009 @ 2:26p
I tried to withdraw the funds and it basically gave me a sheet to print out and sign and fax it back to them. Does that mean it was successful? I left my small profit in the account...
when i called them yesterday, the lady claimed that if you fund using your cc, it only goes back to the cc if you DON'T make a trade. take it for what a CSR is worth...
kenfeyl
Member
posted: Jul. 10, 2009 @ 4:07p
Look what just showed up in my e-mail.
Zecco CSR said: You are all set up with the promotion. As long as you place the trade sometime this month you will be set up with the $200 cash promotion. It takes about 3-5 business days for the funds to hit the account after the first trade is placed. Please let me know if you have any additional questions.
Over the phone, she also promised me that it would be a purchase, not a cash advance. So far, I have not gotten cash advance fees in any of the three cards (I diversified to spread the cash advance risk) I used to fund my $10,250. These were my Chase Freedom card, my Citi Forward card and my BofA Worldpoints card. Don't laught at me for having a BofA Worldpoints card... it's my oldest card, I got it in college, I haven't used it in years before today and I wanted to diversify rather than use only Chase and Citi.
worth
Member
posted: Jul. 10, 2009 @ 4:19p
It says it's limited to those people that personally received the offer on July 8th. So no go for the rest of us?
teammjs said: when i called them yesterday, the lady claimed that if you fund using your cc, it only goes back to the cc if you DON'T make a trade. take it for what a CSR is worth...
Isn't it possible to trade the entire 10k for 1 transaction (buy & sell immediately) then get the remaining balance back by check?
The initial web page now says (in the image, below the Open an Account button): "This promotion is limited to Zecco members who were sent the promotional email on July 8th, 2009. This offer is not transferable." I don't remember seeing that there when I looked at the page yesterday. I guess this is dead now for people who didn't get the email.
Yes, when you log in, under funding options there, there is an ACH option. However, the range to fund is $250-5000. Don't do what I did. I did $5k then $5k, then tried to do $1, but you have to do a min of $250. So, I had to ACH a total of $10250.
kenfeyl
Member
posted: Jul. 10, 2009 @ 7:44p
I have the same story walletfart did, but with CCs, not ACH. However, I would add that a CSR personally called me to inform me that the money had to be in the account by 72 hours after the account is opened to qualify for the bonus. She said the only transfers that would hit that limit were CCs and wire transfers, so I did CCs.
staci86
Senior Member
posted: Jul. 10, 2009 @ 9:18p
There has been a report of one member having been assessed a cash advance fee.
If you fund via credit card, please post your issuer, and whether the transaction was classified as a purchase or a cash advance. With a few datapoints, we can identify the safe issuers to use.
kenfeyl said: I have the same story walletfart did, but with CCs, not ACH. However, I would add that a CSR personally called me to inform me that the money had to be in the account by 72 hours after the account is opened to qualify for the bonus. She said the only transfers that would hit that limit were CCs and wire transfers, so I did CCs.
Then why do they offer a check funding option? I didn't see anything in the terms saying when the funds need to be there, just that you need to make your first trade by july 31.
The terms in the email make no mention, so I think it's safe: To qualify for cash bonus, you must open and fund a new Zecco Forex trading account by July 31, 2009. After first trade is initiated, cash bonus will be deposited to your account within 3-5 business days. Bonus amount varies based on amount of deposit according to the following schedule: $200 bonus with deposit of 10,000 or more; $100 bonus with deposit of $2500 -$9999; $75 bonus with deposit of $1001-$2500, $50 bonus with deposit up to $1000. Cash bonus cannot be withdrawn within 90 days of initial funding. Existing Zecco Forex customers who have funded and traded are not eligible to receive this promotion. Self-directed trading accounts only; managed accounts and accounts referred by an Introducing Broker are not eligible to receive this promotion. Limit one cash bonus per customer. This offer is non-transferable.
kenfeyl
Member
posted: Jul. 10, 2009 @ 10:39p
walletfart said: kenfeyl said: I have the same story walletfart did, but with CCs, not ACH. However, I would add that a CSR personally called me to inform me that the money had to be in the account by 72 hours after the account is opened to qualify for the bonus. She said the only transfers that would hit that limit were CCs and wire transfers, so I did CCs.
Then why do they offer a check funding option? I didn't see anything in the terms saying when the funds need to be there, just that you need to make your first trade by july 31.
I agree with you, but I felt it was safest to abide by what the CSR told me. I would call them yourself (you should have an account manager) to see what they say about qualifying for the bonus.
mogambo
Member
posted: Jul. 10, 2009 @ 10:53p
If this is the same setup as forex.com, I can confirm that there is no way to get money out unless it goes back to the same credit card from which the account was funded. And this was when I tried to withdraw the money more than a year after funding with the credit card.
Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.
Members of our community may attach files to a post in accordance with the User Agreement. FatWallet is not responsible for the content, accuracy, completeness or validity of any information contained in any attached file. Files have *not* been scanned for viruses. Be especially wary of Excel files which may contain malicious content.