James Hasty AOR 4.0

Archived From: Finance
  • 1 23459
  • Page
  • Text Only

James Hasty's AOR 4.0

Application Results

Round One - Saturday, September 26th

1. PFCU - Visa Platinum CashBack Rewards ($50,000 credit line applied for online) - rejected will apply for a new card with a limit of $5,000 after I complete my balance transfers.

2a. BOA - Schwab Bank Invest First Visa Credit Card (applied online) - approved - $5,000
2b. BOA - NEA WorldPoints® Platinum Plus® AMEX® Card (applied by phone name might not be exact) - approved - $5,000 now $25,000 (moved line from other card)
existing BOA NEA WorldPoints Platinum Plus Card (VISA) cut from $44,600 to $20,000; moved to AMEX card, now this card is closed

3a. Barclay's - Bank Atlantic Rewards Business Card (applied online) - called to follow up 10/5, approved for $25,000 - 0% through 11/26/10
3b. Barclay's Coast to Coast Visa Signature Card - Online instant approval $7,500 - 0% through 09/10/10

4a.5th Third Bank - Insurbank Business Visa (requested $30,000 limit online) - pending, I have sent my tax returns for the last two years, they are waiting for confirmation from the IRS that the information I sent to them matches the IRS records
4b. 5th Third Bank - Responsible Credit Card - Call (877) 579-5353 to apply during weekday business hours
4c. 5th Third Bank - 5th 3rd 1st Southwest bank (applied online) - approved $9,500 limit

5a. Chase - Disney Rewards (online application) - approved - $6,000 now $36,877
5b. Chase - Chase Sapphire Preferred Card (online application) - approved - $7,000 now $4,000
Moved inactive card balances (and closed the accounts) and $3,000 from Chase Sapphire Card to Disney Card

6a. National City - Nat City Lifespring Health (applied online) - approved $10,000 - account closed
6b. National City - Nat City Quilter's Rewards (online application) - approved $5,000 - acount closed

7a. Citi - Citi ProfessionalSM Card (online application completed) - approved $1,800 (seriously WTF?)
7b. Citi - Citi Forward Card (online application) - approved $4,800
7c. Citi - Associated Bank Rewards Credit Card (automated telephone application - time consuming and tedious) - rejected, "too many applications with Citi"

Round Two - Saturday, October 3rd

8. Wachovia / Wells Fargo - Wachovia Visa Business Platinum [rate increased from 0% to 1.99% with max $99 fee on 12 month BT offer; personal cards no longer have attractive terms](applied at bank branch) - rejected, not sure why - I was told to call the underwriting department at (866) 420-7940 during business hours
9. Capitol One - No Hassle MilesSM Ultra for Professionals (online application) - declined, no point following up further as the decision is computer driven
10. AMEX - hilton HHonors® Card from American Express (online application) - declined, called 10/6 they will take 5-7 days to reconsider the application

Round Three - ???

11. Bank of Kentucky - Visa® Credit Cards from The Bank of Kentucky - I submitted a request to be contacted by a representative with instructions on how to apply for the card.
12. US Bank
13. RBS
14. HSBC
15. Discover
16. State Farm

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

Key Links

0% Thread
5% Rewards Thread
What credit card should I get?
SIS Apporama
My second AOR rolling
US Elan
Credit Cards that allow your to shift credit lines
A summary of techniques for receiving BT money into your checking
Credit Card Signup bonuses 1 of 2
Credit Card Signup Bonuses 2 of 2
BT Credit Cards


High Yield Checking by State
Rewards Checking FW Thread
Daughter of the Mother of liquid accounts thread
Best Nationally Available High APY Liquid Accounts

Credit / Debit Cards with low foreign trnsaction fees
FW CC Foreign transaction fee thread


Credit Card Application Status Thread

Background

I plan to launch my AOR 4.0 by Saturday, 9/27/09.

I am a Jets fan, my real name is not James Hasty.

My AOR 3.0 started in August of 2007 and paid off by November of 2008. I raised a total of approximately $250,000 last time.

I utilized 100% of my credit limits with no adverse action from any company apart from Chase and Barclays. Chase reduced five of my credit lines by $50,923 to $22,077 (initially the lines totaled $73,000). To add insult to injury, they cut my rewards card that I use for purchases from $2,500 to $1,200.

Inactivity also resulted in some card closures and CLI reductions several months after the cards were all paid off.

Also, if anyone can tell me how to arrange columns (on chart(s) below I wuold be greatful.

Goals (in order of priority)

1. Maximize low APR balance transfers (target is $120K)
2. Maximize low APR purchases
3. Upfront rewards for first purchase(s) - cash, airline tickets, etc.
4. Rewards card with highest Cash Back for general purchases
5. Rewards cards for highest Cash Back for specific categories (Gas, Groceries, etc.)
6. Card (s) with low foreign transaction fees (hopefully none)

Existing Credit Lines - Summary Below, details attached

			                                                     Initial	 Adverse	Current
Type	Sponsor	             Card Name	                                      Limit	 Action	        Limit
					
P	AMEX	             Blue from American Express	®	             2,000.00 	      0.00      2,000.00
P	BOA	             BOA NEA Worldpoints Platinum Plus Visa	    44,600.00  	      0.00     44,600.00 
P	Chase	             Chase Freedom Card	                             2,500.00    (1,300.00)     1,200.00 
P	Chase	             Washington Mutual Platinum MasterCard®.	     3,000.00 	   (236.00)	2,764.00 
P	Chase	             Washington Mutual Visa Card	             8,500.00 	   (687.00)	7,813.00 
P	Chevy Chase Bank     Small Business Credit Card	                    11,000.00 	 (1,200.00)	9,800.00 
P	Citi		                                                     1,000.00 	    500.00 	1,500.00 
P	Discover	     Discover Open Road Card	                    22,500.00         0.00     22,500.00 
P	Discover	     Discover Miles Card	                     2,500.00         0.00 	2,500.00 
P	General Electric     GE Money Platinum Visa	                     4,000.00    (3,500.00)	  500.00 
P	HSBC	             HSBC - The GM Flex Card	                     3,500.00 	 (3,200.00)	  300.00 
P	LaSalle Bank         The LaSalle Bank Platinum MC	            11,000.00 	 (1,200.00)	9,800.00 
					
Personal Card Subtotals			                                   116,100.00 	(10,823.00)   105,277.00 
					
B	Chase	             "GM Business Card"	                            48,000.00 	(47,500.00)	  500.00 
B	Citi	             CitiBusiness Card	                            37,500.00 	      0.00     37,500.00 
B	Discover	     Discover® Business Card	                     8,000.00      (700.00)     7,300.00 
					
Business Card Subtotals			                                    93,500.00 	(48,200.00)    45,300.00 
					
O	Kohl's/Chase	     Kohl's Card	                             1,000.00 	      0.00 	1,000.00 
O	Macy's	             Macy's card	                               500.00 	      0.00 	  500.00 
O	Sears	             Sears Card	                                    14,000.00 	      0.00 	14,000.00 
					
Other Card Subtotals			                                    15,500.00 	      0.00 	15,500.00 
					
Total			                                                   225,100.00 	(59,023.00)    166,077.00 

Thanks again for the great feedback! (keep it coming)


  • Also categorized in:

Before you continue... I would highly recommend you change your user name and name of this thread. You are going to be posting a lot of financial information and all of it will show up on a Google search.


I have 2 BOA Platinum cards with no issues. I'm pretty sure you can apply for multiple BOA cards without issue.


unless hie is This Guy I think he's safe


James Hasty is not my real name.

I am a Jets fan.


I think Discover gave me trouble when I applied for two of the same exact card.

I wasn't sure what to expect from BOA since the NEA card has vastly superior terms to all other BOA cards that I could find.


I wouldn't app on the weekend. You have a better shot of instant approvals and it's easier to follow up, if needed, with the correct departments on weekdays.


Post the list of apps you're considering to receive input.


My last apporama was done on a Saturday and worked out ok.

With the quantity of application that I am considering I couldn't imagine trying to do this at work.

I will post a full list of the cards I will apply to tonight (I may add more tomorrow as I go).

Thanks again.


One other question for now.

If I remember correctly, online applications take less time to complete than telephone applications. Is there any advantage (time to obtain credit line, amount of credit line, probability of approval)to applying for a credit card by phone?

Conversely, would an internet application have any of these advantages over a telephone application?

Thanks again.


jameshasty said: One other question for now.

If I remember correctly, online applications take less time to complete than telephone applications. Is there any advantage (time to obtain credit line, amount of credit line, probability of approval)to applying for a credit card by phone?

Conversely, would an internet application have any of these advantages over a telephone application?

Thanks again.

if you're fast, you can rattle off all your internet apps before the first inquiry posts, effectively removing that possible complication. if you perform bureau utilization and the next-day TU dropoff technique, you can further avoid the potential for INQ denials.


solarUS said: jameshasty said: One other question for now.

If I remember correctly, online applications take less time to complete than telephone applications. Is there any advantage (time to obtain credit line, amount of credit line, probability of approval)to applying for a credit card by phone?

Conversely, would an internet application have any of these advantages over a telephone application?

Thanks again.

if you're fast, you can rattle off all your internet apps before the first inquiry posts, effectively removing that possible complication. if you perform bureau utilization and the next-day TU dropoff technique, you can further avoid the potential for INQ denials.

Thats easy, just have multiple tabs open....


You'll want to save the printouts / file copies of all cards TOS's, and it does take time. Do it either before or after filling out the applications.


I made many changes to the original post, more to follow.

I have done this before so finding the best cards to meet my goals is where I could use the mosr help.

Also, any information about company sepecific strategies (how many of their cards to apply for, will they transfer crdit lines?, possible adverse action, high or low credit lines, etc.) would be very helpul.

Thanks again.


I'd app for two personal Barclays cards and one Biz (bank atlantic 0% for 13 months with capped $75 fee). Once approved move the personal CL's to the biz card then do the BT. You can move all but $500.00. I'd app the Biz card first.


Thaks for the info.

I did a web search for Bank Atlantic and only found 0% APR for 6 months with a maximum fee of $99.

Do you have a link for a better offer for their card?

Thanks again.


jameshasty said: Thaks for the info.

I did a web search for Bank Atlantic and only found 0% APR for 6 months with a maximum fee of $99.

Do you have a link for a better offer for their card?

Thanks again.

Bank Atlantic 13 months 0%
It looks like they changed it to a $99 max BT fee


Don't sweat the $24, 13 months at 0% is hard to come by these days.

Boy do I miss Advanta.


Since you weren't aware of that BT card I assume you can't find this 0% BT thread. The decision makers have decided to hide it so only people in-the-know can benefit. (lame)


As you might tell, this AOR is going to be a bit rushed. Unfortunately, the list of cards I posted so far was only a rough draft.

After the next big revision to the original post in the next hour or two (where I will try to include the best cards from the 0% thread in your last post)I could really use a lot of help from anyone who can point out any good cards that I overlooked.

Thanks again.

PS, the 0% thread does not have any cards from the following institutions that may or may not have 0% BT offers:

Discover
AMEX
Chevy Chase / First USA - may have been bought by Chase
First National Bank of Omaha
Capitol One

Any offers from these banks that beat the ones in my original post would be appreciated.


- Check out Gold Delta SkyMiles Credit Card (25k miles after 1st purchase + 10k miles after 1k in purchases in first 3 months. No annual fee for the first year, then $95).

- Once approved for Linux, call their underwriting dept and politely ask for a real substantial CLI with documentation. I had fast turnaround, no hard pull. YMMV.

- No bank these days likes to see more than one application at a time. E.g. BofA/FIA put my application for Schwab on hold/manual after instantly approving the NEA. (Note that Schwab Bank Invest First Visa Credit Card is FIA, not Chase.)

- In my experience, Citi Professional and Wachovia give disappointing CLs. I am interested in your experience. Keep us posted.


My plan is to wait about 2-3 weeks until I get all of the cards to do my CLI-o-rama in one day. That strategy helped me get a lot of approvals last time.

Also, the 0% thread in the link has columns, can anyone tell me how they did that so I can fix the formatting in the original post.

Thanks.


I've heard Discover jacked BT fees to 5%
FNBO is known as a stickler, but often has some of the best offers. They also pull atypical bureaus. First Usa IS Chase. and I thought you already had cap1 and AMEX listed in your aor?


You are absolutely right about discover, their BT fee is 5% for 12 months, 3% for 6 months. I was just hoping that one of my FW brothers knew about some secret co-branded card that the rest of us forgot about.

Thanks again everyone!


I am in the process of merging my potential credit card list with the 0% thread. I have only started to drill down into the offer details but the PENFED offer listed as 3.99% for life (2.5% BT fee up to $100) showed up as 4.99% for 24 months (2.5% BT fee up to ($100) when I clicked the link to apply.

Does anyone have a link to the 3.99% lifetime offer (assuming it still exists)?

Also, any updates to other cards in the 0% thread that have changed would be appreciated. I will post the merged list in the original post of this thread when I have completed my review.

Thanks again.


I merged my BT credit card list with the 0% thread (including links to all applications).

The Excel file with all 49 cards is attached to the original post.

I confirmed that five of the dead cards on the 0% thread are truly dead.

If anyone can provide further updates on any of these cards it will save me some time.

Given the rushed nature of this AOR and the amount of details left to research, I will probably set up all of the applications on the internet on Sunday and launch them before work Monday morning.

After I finish reviewing and updating the terms of the BT cards, I still have to go through the rewards cards.

If anyone has any information on credit cards that do not charge a foreign currency / international purchase fee I would be greatful.

Thanks again.


From my AOR a year ago....

1. Don't mess with AMEX. They are the only ones that did not reverse my AA. Even after showing SUBSTANCIAL assets.
2. Juniper will deny you on multiple apps with "sufficient Juniper credit already exists" Do the BA application only even if you already have a card with BA, they will deny you, then call to close and reopen with the same credit line. BA BT offer is only good for 20K per fee. If you get a 25K line you will be wasting 5K because you are not going to pay $99 for 5K of money.
3. Discover is junk. I wouldn't bother. They were a pain 2 years ago and I didn't bother last year.
4. Citi professional limits to one card. If you already have one, apply, get denied and call like on juniper above.
5. CLR is getting close to impossible on all but BOA cards.


Saturday afternoon should work.

I would not recommend so many applications.

I would recommend 3-4 strategically chosen application. Try banks / companie that:

- either will grant large lines from the getgo, or
- that will reallocate from other large lines.

You dont want to end up with 20 $5K lines. You should aim to end up with 3-4 $20-$50 K lines, reallocatable, or initially large, and just take 55-75% from those lines.


tolamapS said:
You dont want to end up with 20 $5K lines. You should aim to end up with 3-4 $20-$50 K lines, reallocatable, or initially large, and just take 55-75% from those lines.

i disagree completely. the guy will only get 100k if he's lucky. taking less than 89% is dumb IMHO - there will probably be rate chasing / CLR no matter what he does, especially from Citi and Chase. better to max the benefit, considering that the risk to issuer relationships is relatively great anyways.

and my understanding is that the magic number on the low end is 35% util. where did you get 55-75??


jameshasty said: I have done this before so finding the best cards to meet my goals is where I could use the mosr help.

not trying to be a PITA, but how is that you've done this before but werent sure if doing phone apps was better?? were your previous 3 AORs much smaller in scale?


Last time I focused on internet applications first and only did the phone applications if possible. I applied for 38 cards in one day and my only priority was speed. I did not care which was better last time. Now I am trying to be more precise.

Also, I raised $250k last time so my last AOR wasn't so small.


P AMX Blue from Amrican Express(r)               2,000.00         0.00     2,000.00
P BOA BOA NEA Worldpoints Platinum Plus Visa    44,600.00         0.00    44,600.00
P Chase Chase Freedom Card                       2,500.00    (1,300.00)    1,200.00
P Chase Washington Mutual Platinum MasterCard®.  3,000.00      (236.00)    2,764.00
P Chase Washington Mutual Visa Card              8,500.00      (687.00)    7,813.00
P Chevy Chase Bank Small Business Credit Card   11,000.00    (1,200.00)    9,800.00
P Citi                                           1,000.00       500.00     1,500.00
P Discover Discover Open Road Card              22,500.00         0.00    22,500.00
P Discover Discover Miles Card                   2,500.00         0.00     2,500.00
P General Electric GE Money Platinum Visa        4,000.00    (3,500.00)      500.00
P HSBC HSBC - The GM Flex Card                   3,500.00    (3,200.00)      300.00
P LaSalle Bank The LaSalle Bank Platinum MC     11,000.00    (1,200.00)    9,800.00
Personal Car Subtotals                         116,100.00   (10,823.00)  105,277.00
B Chase "GM Business Card"                      48,000.00   (47,500.00)      500.00
B Citi CitiBusiness Card                        37,500.00         0.00    37,500.00
B Discover Discover® Business Card               8,000.00      (700.00)    7,300.00
Business Card Subtotals                         93,500.00   (48,200.00)   45,300.00
O Kohl's/Chase Kohl's Card                       1,000.00         0.00     1,000.00
O Macy's Macy's card                               500.00         0.00       500.00
O Sears Sears Card                              14,000.00         0.00    14,000.00
Other Card Subtotals                            15,500.00         0.00    15,500.00
Total                                          225,100.00   (59,023.00)  166,077.00


green for actually reporting your 4.0 experience... (although your Sep 2009 member since date has some of us suspicious)

so many of us now simply utilize the rolling strategy (although with reallocation dead/dying at many issuers that strategy is also in jeopardy).

the utilization many members speak of is 89% per card with 35-50% utilization in total (although some prefer less than 89% - tolmapS).


For AOR 2.0 I lowered my utilization from 100% to under 10% ($2-3k of remaining debt) for a full month before launch. I raised $50-60k on 6 cards (one for each major issuer - Citi, Discover, BOA, Chase, etc.)

For AOR 3.0 I paid off all of my debt with the exception of my card used for monthly purchases (I made payments to keep the debt below $500). Once the debt was paid off I waited 60 days to launch. After the first round of applications (38 apps on one Saturday) I waited 2-3 weeks to get the cards before requesting CLIs on all new and existing cards the following weekend. I then waited 2 weeks for all of the CLI approvals before consolidating all multiple lines from one company. I deposited the BT checks (or requesting BTs from those that wouldn't give BT checks)the following day for 100% utilization.

Citi gave me instant approval on a business card for $20-33k (I forget initial amount). This card was used to get funds from all cards that wouldn't allow BT directly to bank account (card had $0 fee 0%).

My local bank then put a 6 business day hold on the funds before I could transfer them to interest bearing accounts.

After I deposited all of the checks, I found 8 additional cards on fatwallet that I missed. I applied for all 8 and was accepted for 6 of them. I called to request CLI increases from the parking lot of the bank before depositing the BT checks for each of these accounts.

I paid off all of my cards over nine months ago (except for the monthly purchase card)and will try a similar approach as AOR 3.0 this time.


I have finished my review of the low APR BT credit cards in the file attached to the OP. The file also includes foreign transaction fees (I found only two cards that don't have any).

I also added relevant links and improved the formatting in the OP.

Over the next two days I will add some Cash Back and rewards cards.

I will also begin to lay out which cards I will apply for (and in what order).

Any feedback would be appreciated.


...


Rorer714 said: retmil said: Since you weren't aware of that BT card I assume you can't find this 0% BT thread. The decision makers have decided to hide it so only people in-the-know can benefit. (lame)Why don’t you just start a new thread for each card listed in that thread? Maybe that way they will get shut down a lot quicker. What is lame are those (not referring to OP) that feel they are entitled to be spoon food.
That's funny considering you repeatedly point out the link to the new BT card thread for anybody that asks on creditboards.
http://creditboards.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=410660


...


Rorer714 said: retmil said: Rorer714 said: retmil said: Since you weren't aware of that BT card I assume you can't find this 0% BT thread. The decision makers have decided to hide it so only people in-the-know can benefit. (lame)Why don’t you just start a new thread for each card listed in that thread? Maybe that way they will get shut down a lot quicker. What is lame are those (not referring to OP) that feel they are entitled to be spoon food.
That's funny considering you repeatedly point out the link to the new BT card thread for anybody that asks on creditboards.
http://creditboards.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=410660
You might want to get your facts straight. I did not post the link or start a new thread for every BT card that comes out. By the way have you found any new links for Citi BT cards yet? ROFLAMO!!!
Helping is one thing, spoon feeding is another.

I'll make sure you are the first to know. That way you can admonish me here and then run off to credit boards and post the link there like you did the last cards. Then you can run back over to FW and cry about the info being shared and the links going dead. This will be followed by idiotic statements like "give a man a fish and he'll eat for a day...." Now you know what lame actually looks like.


Skipping 297 Messages...

It's been quite a while since I've visited the good ole FWF, and I was checking in on BT offers. My current AOR is up the end of Dec, and I was hoping to execute another in Feb. Much to my dismay, I filter for AOR, only to find just FOUR threads?! One of which is about ARMs (which looks oddly familiar...). Are there no active threads detailing current offers?! This...is...devastating.

jameshasty, holding off for a couple months? How uncharacteristic of you to not rush into things... When you do plan for the next, could you start it on a fresh thread please?




Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.


While FatWallet makes every effort to post correct information, offers are subject to change without notice.
Some exclusions may apply based upon merchant policies.
© 1999-2012