Edit

Forums
Hot Deals

Antec MX-1 USB/e-SATA NOW $24.99 AR at Amazon hard drive enclosure Archived From: Hot Deals

  • tweet this
  • Post to Facebook
  • Text Only
  • Search this Topic »
  • Classic
  • Go to Page :
  • 1 2 3456
alert mods    

This is perfect! I've been waiting for an enclosure like this for some time now, since I got a deal on a large drive, through these forums of course.


alert mods    

For those of you that own a pair or more of these, do they stack nicely one over another? Hard to tell by the pics and it's a make or break thing for me!

TIA


alert mods    

gemsurf said:For those of you that own a pair or more of these, do they stack nicely one over another? Hard to tell by the pics and it's a make or break thing for me!

TIA

The feet on these are VERY short, as in just standard rubber feet... Thickness of a nickel coin, maybe.
To stack these, I've bought some half-inch height 3M Bumpon rubber feet (SJ-5018)blister pack from Amazon with Amazon Prime... It was around $8, free shipping with AP, and I don't remember exactly, but I think the blister pack is like 80 rubber feet in matrix = a LOT of rubber feet to go through...

With the rubber feet attached to them, these hdd cases do stack quite nicely.

If you want a pic of three stacking up, here's a link to a pic I've taken.
Picture


alert mods    

In for 2 to separate addresses for rebates.


alert mods    

They have very short legs but they do stack together. Most importantly, the intake air comes from the front edge, go inside, and make a U turn at the back and comes back out. What I am saying is stacking will not negatively impact the airflow.


gemsurf said:For those of you that own a pair or more of these, do they stack nicely one over another? Hard to tell by the pics and it's a make or break thing for me!

TIA


alert mods    

gemsurf said:For those of you that own a pair or more of these, do they stack nicely one over another? Hard to tell by the pics and it's a make or break thing for me!

TIA

They stack very nicely, but the problem is the one on top totally blocks the air intake on the lower unit.


alert mods    

can anyone recommend a good, cheap SATA PCI Host Card?


alert mods    

lochness said:after reading the forum at silentpc,
i think my mx-100 that spins down might be better, with no noise and all.
just have to decide how important eSATA is.

Anyone else have an opinion on whether the MX-100 is better than the MX-1? Or just an opinion even would be nice. I'm debating between the 2. TIA


alert mods    

jlppimb said:lochness said:after reading the forum at silentpc,
i think my mx-100 that spins down might be better, with no noise and all.
just have to decide how important eSATA is.


Anyone else have an opinion on whether the MX-100 is better than the MX-1? Or just an opinion even would be nice. I'm debating between the 2. TIA

The speed of USB 2.0 usually caps off around 30MB/s, while eSATA gets you around 60MB/s, depending on your drive speed (most recent drives should be able to exceed 60MB/s). I can see why MX-1 doesn't support spin-down for the max. compatibility with most SATA controllers. So if you care more about power saving/hard drive shelf life, go with mx-100. If you process a lot of photo/video stuff or intend to use this enclosure for massive back-ups, go with mx-1. Just my 0.02.


alert mods    

vws said:jlppimb said:lochness said:after reading the forum at silentpc,
i think my mx-100 that spins down might be better, with no noise and all.
just have to decide how important eSATA is.


Anyone else have an opinion on whether the MX-100 is better than the MX-1? Or just an opinion even would be nice. I'm debating between the 2. TIA

The speed of USB 2.0 usually caps off around 30MB/s, while eSATA gets you around 60MB/s, depending on your drive speed (most recent drives should be able to exceed 60MB/s). I can see why MX-1 doesn't support spin-down for the max. compatibility with most SATA controllers. So if you care more about power saving/hard drive shelf life, go with mx-100. If you process a lot of photo/video stuff or intend to use this enclosure for massive back-ups, go with mx-1. Just my 0.02.

Thanks, just wanted another opinion.


alert mods    

Just ordered one. I got one back this Jan for the same price after MIR. It's very very quiet. It comes with a eSATA bracket (good for my Dell i530). When I checked out, there is a mysterious $10 promo code. No clue where it comes from?


alert mods    

andywanker said:can anyone recommend a good, cheap SATA PCI Host Card?

If you can use a PCI Express card, Newegg has the Rosewill RC-213 for $24.99 with a $20 MIR.
Newegg Link

The board uses the Silicon Image SIL-3132 and has 1 external eSATA port + 1 internal SATA port. Driver and firmware downloads are available from the Silicon Image website.
Silicon Image download link

I bought an RC-213 when it was on special last month ($20 - $20 MIR). With this board, I'm seeing sustained read data rates of 73 MB/sec from an eSATA connected 320GB Seagate 7200.10 drive (Linux, outer tracks); another PCI Express board using a JMicron 363 controller chip gave less than 60 MB/sec read data rates with the same drive.


alert mods    

Hey thanks for the great explanation! And the idea to use the bumpers for stacking! My mind is racing with other possibilities in this messy office!

SGinWL said:gemsurf said:For those of you that own a pair or more of these, do they stack nicely one over another? Hard to tell by the pics and it's a make or break thing for me!

TIA


The feet on these are VERY short, as in just standard rubber feet... Thickness of a nickel coin, maybe.
To stack these, I've bought some half-inch height 3M Bumpon rubber feet (SJ-5018)blister pack from Amazon with Amazon Prime... It was around $8, free shipping with AP, and I don't remember exactly, but I think the blister pack is like 80 rubber feet in matrix = a LOT of rubber feet to go through...

With the rubber feet attached to them, these hdd cases do stack quite nicely.

If you want a pic of three stacking up, here's a link to a pic I've taken.
Picture


alert mods    

fpm1703 said:.. I bought an RC-213 ... I'm seeing sustained read data rates of 73 MB/sec from an eSATA connected 320GB Seagate 7200.10 drive (Linux, outer tracks); another PCI Express board using a JMicron 363 controller chip gave less than 60 MB/sec read data rates with the same drive.
That would be native SATA speeds in my book.


alert mods    

WhiteBoi said:fpm1703 said:.. I bought an RC-213 ... I'm seeing sustained read data rates of 73 MB/sec from an eSATA connected 320GB Seagate 7200.10 drive (Linux, outer tracks); another PCI Express board using a JMicron 363 controller chip gave less than 60 MB/sec read data rates with the same drive.
That would be native SATA speeds in my book.

Well theoretically, eSATA's really no different than internal SATA in speed, right? The two are 100% compatible (or so they say), and the only difference is the connector. I think you can get a eSATA to SATA cable and just plug in your eSATA case into your internal SATA connector as well.
So native SATA speed indeed.


alert mods    

SGinWL said:.. eSATA's really no different than internal SATA in speed, right? The two are 100% compatible (or so they say), and the only difference is the connector. I think you can get a eSATA to SATA cable and just plug in your eSATA case into your internal SATA connector as well. So native SATA speed indeed.
Right, I didn't want to make it too obvious. It's all about the teaching you know. The way I do it is by asking the question in reverse. What I am really wanted to get to is if you are buying a HD enclosure now, I would pick eSATA first then USB/Firewire for backup connectivity. Its true many PCs/laptops do not have this eSATA port as yet. It should be mandatory.


alert mods    

Great deal on a great enclosure. Paired it with a Western Digital GP drive and have it connected to my Series3 and it's awesome. The fan's not as silent as I had thought, but apparently it's hit or miss.


alert mods    

Have two, in for another. These enclosures are great. Run relatively quiet and keep the drive cool.
Thanks OP!


alert mods    

I go for MX-100,
1, fanless -- the true way to be silent
2, new fan could be quiet, but old one makes a lot of noise.
3, alum shell is way better then plas
4, I use the external HDD to backup daily, don't want to keep it running.
5, spin down is better than fans
6, If you open MX-100, You can find a ESATA connector position. You can mount an esata connector by yourself. Any sata HDD itself can be used as external HDD. Chipsets is needed for USB only.
7, the absent ESATA seems like a market plot. Antec tries to avoid the competition between MX100 and MX-1

jlppimb said:lochness said:after reading the forum at silentpc,
i think my mx-100 that spins down might be better, with no noise and all.
just have to decide how important eSATA is.


Anyone else have an opinion on whether the MX-100 is better than the MX-1? Or just an opinion even would be nice. I'm debating between the 2. TIA


alert mods    

in 4 two. thx op!


 Close

Sign Me In
Nickname: 
Password: 
Remember My Login Information:

Forget your login information?

Not Already A Member?
Sign Up Now!



Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.


While FatWallet makes every effort to post correct information, offers are subject to change without notice.
Some exclusions may apply based upon merchant policies.
© 1999-2009