posted: Jun. 6, 2008 @ 3:56p
NeverPayRetail said:Anyone know how this compares to the AMD 5200+ w/ECS Geforce 6100M deal that Fry's had last weekend for $89.99? It's awfully hard to tell how much of a performance difference there is between different Fry's mobo/CPU combo deals in the sub-$100 price range.
I almost bought the AMD 4800+ w/ECS NForce 6A mobo a week or so ago for $69.99, but the CPU was a tray processor, not retail boxed. I really wanted it to replace a bad NForce 6A mobo, but I turned it down anyways.
If you are only comparing the CPU power then a AM2-5200+ at stock speed is a little faster then a E6400.
As for the mobo, if you plan to game then both are junk especially if you play to use the onboard. Outside of that, there are plenty of things to look into. At stock speed then I would take the 5200+ over E2200. If you plan to get a better board and overclock then maybe the E2200... maybe... since the 5200+ can o/c well even with that crap 6100M.
Another thing the E2200 is a Allendale with 1MB so half the cache of E6400 and no VT plus it is NOT C2D meaning no shaing of cache which made the C2D superior which means it has nothing special over AMD... Benchmark aside, I am still with 5200+ eventhough I am an ex-AMD guy that switched to C2D/C2Q but picked up 4 x 5200+ recently for gifts and light PC/server. My gaming rig is still a C2Q and spare gaming is C2D both o/c to 3.6 with 4GB 1066 each... BUT for the price, I would go 5200+ especially if you do not plan to put money into a quality mobo, GPU, RAM, PSU, etc.
Hope that helps