|
-
-
spdsl
- Member
posted: Jul. 6, 2009 @ 10:14a
Propane weed eaters saving the environment.....Not! Low torque makes you run the motor longer. Propane is a expensive fuel and it yields less btu's than gasoline. In other words you will use more propane in this weed eater vs a conventional gas and run the engine longer. Much like bottled water, bottled propane has a huge carbon footprint on the environment. You have to consider fabrication of the steel containers, paint, plastic decals, transportation of the steel container too the fuel source. Now factor in the energy used to contain the fuel source and transport the final product in its container. Transportation from the different factories, distributor and your local hardware store. Disposal of the spent container also comes into play. Fuel used in the garbage trucks and landfill space the empty bottles occupy. |
-
-
GeorgeGarman
- Senior Member - 1K
posted: Jul. 6, 2009 @ 10:16a
From the HD site 2 Hours run time on a single canister mushman said "I just got a 6-pack from BJ's Wholesale Club for $17.99" = $3 per canister $3 to run for 2 hours. You've got to be kidding me. At $3 per gallon for gas, I can get a lot more than 2 hours from a gas (2 or 4 cycle) trimmer. You really are doing this if you care about the environment? |
-
-
Canucklehead
- Broke Member
posted: Jul. 6, 2009 @ 10:27a
They should have designed it to run a BBQ/Rotisserie attachment as well. |
-
-
spdsl
- Member
posted: Jul. 6, 2009 @ 10:39a
GeorgeGarman said:From the HD site 2 Hours run time on a single canister mushman said "I just got a 6-pack from BJ's Wholesale Club for $17.99" = $3 per canister $3 to run for 2 hours. You've got to be kidding me. At $3 per gallon for gas, I can get a lot more than 2 hours from a gas (2 or 4 cycle) trimmer. You really are doing this if you care about the environment? Point proven... I use my echo 230 weed eater an average of 1 hour every weekend. One gallon of gas last me about 6 months. That's one trip to the gas station every six months and I reuse the container for transportation. Explain to me how propane and its steel containers save the environment. |
-
-
glenatuf
- Senior Member - 3K
posted: Jul. 6, 2009 @ 11:11a
if you actually start using a lot of propane and you're concerned about the bottles...reuse them: http://www.harborfreight.com/cpi/ctaf/displayitem.taf?Itemnumber=45989 |
-
-
wackyrabbit
- Senior Member
posted: Jul. 6, 2009 @ 11:25a
glenatuf said:if you actually start using a lot of propane and you're concerned about the bottles...reuse them:
http://www.harborfreight.com/cpi/ctaf/displayitem.taf?Itemnumber... I do this but it is illegal in many states, be warned. Plus you need the right canister, some of the ones from the hardware stores are not designed to be refilled and the valve will fail after attaching that refill hookup. On another note many hardware stores sell these propane canisters for $1.50 each so whoever got them at BJs got ripped off. Should be no more than $10 for a 6 pack if u shop around. At some camping supply stores I bought them for .95 cents each last summer, but I had to buy 10 of them. |
-
-
goat6500
- Member
posted: Jul. 6, 2009 @ 11:48a
Actually, I don't know why we haven't been made to switch to propane for mowers, especially in California. It's safer, less polluting and if it's a riding mower the extra weight won't matter. There's ways to get propane cheaper so you end up spending about as much to run a vehicle on propane as gasoline, gasoline is just more conventient. Personally, I'd rather lug around a couple of propane tanks than deal with nasty-ass gasoline tanks in my garage just to save a few bucks during the mowing season. I already have to get tanks for the grill, so whatever. However, I don't trust any 4-stroke for a weed whacker. You need an engine that's meant to run while turned upside down and that's a 2-stroke(oil is in the gas so no oil sump). I'd be curious to see how many of these are still running in 3 years. 2-strokes are dirty but they can only be killed if someone forgets to pre-mix the gas. |
-
-
fathandbag
- Senior Member
posted: Jul. 6, 2009 @ 12:17p
my local HD has these listed at $199.99, but they ring up as $149.99...$99 price is a YMMV for me. |
-
-
chitownmlt
- New Member
posted: Jul. 6, 2009 @ 1:06p
What city/state did you find it? I need a sku because the morons at the HD over here in Elgin, Illinois cannot figure out how to find one w/o a SKU. |
-
-
insightcdc
- Shopaholic Member
posted: Jul. 6, 2009 @ 1:23p
Thanks OP, I have been looking for these to go on sale. I went over to the HD in Downingtown, PA and they had a half dozen of the curved and two straight. The item number for the curved is 812524010003. I took it home and unboxed it. The oil bottle had leaked a little so I had to rely on the dipstick to make sure the oil level was right. The first start took about 10 pulls but thats because the propane has to get to the engine. I weedwacked the yard, stopping several times to see how it starts...first pull every time. The Amazon reviews are right about the curve. The angle is a bit off, especially if you are short. I am 5-8 and I found I was having to hold the engine side up a little higher than I do with my 2cycle Poulan. And, its a bit heavy. Now for the good news. MUCH less vibration and noise. No bad smells (except burn in). Though its not perfect, I think it was a good deal and the shoulder strap seems to handle the weight issue. |
-
1
-
-
codydog
- Addicted Member
posted: Jul. 6, 2009 @ 2:19p
-
-
Scubaru
- Member
posted: Jul. 6, 2009 @ 3:16p
Got the last one in College Point, New York (Queens). Straight shaft $99. Great deal, Thanks OP!! |
-
-
thatch68
- Member
posted: Jul. 6, 2009 @ 4:20p
I just bought a straight shaft from Home Depot Friday and used it for about an hour that day. It starts up with no problem at all and is quite powerful. However, it leaked oil all over itself. I am going to have to return it for another one. |
-
-
thatch68
- Member
posted: Jul. 6, 2009 @ 4:40p
I just talked to their customer service. The amount of oil that is supposed to be used in the engine is 1.7 ounces, but the oil included is 2.7 ounces. |
-
-
jayrxlaw
- Cranky Member
posted: Jul. 6, 2009 @ 4:48p
They were available this morning in Exton, PA and Naamans Rd., DE stores. In-store personnel have no clue about these (despite the large, handdrawn poster they have hanging), as to what they are, where they are hidden, etc. I had to find the seasonal dept. mgr. to assist. The package is nearly 6ft. long and bulky. |
-
-
bpd67
- Senior Member
posted: Jul. 6, 2009 @ 4:52p
I just ordered new batteries for my battery powered one on Saturday, had it 4 years and just now had to replace the batteries. Personally, for me, battery powered is the way to go for a weed eater, the only time it wouldn't run was when the batteries were shot. |
-
-
Apple2c
- New Member
posted: Jul. 6, 2009 @ 5:55p
It's not the weedeaters, or cars that are the big polluters - it's coal fired power plants. |
-
-
pdxpro
- New Member
posted: Jul. 6, 2009 @ 6:22p
Okay.....is now the time to turn off my frig/lights/TV/washer/dryer, etc.? |
-
-
cnIsfg
- Senior Member - 5K
posted: Jul. 6, 2009 @ 7:29p
goat6500 said:Actually, I don't know why we haven't been made to switch to propane for mowers, especially in California. It's safer, less polluting and if it's a riding mower the extra weight won't matter. There's ways to get propane cheaper so you end up spending about as much to run a vehicle on propane as gasoline, gasoline is just more conventient. Personally, I'd rather lug around a couple of propane tanks than deal with nasty-ass gasoline tanks in my garage just to save a few bucks during the mowing season. I already have to get tanks for the grill, so whatever.
However, I don't trust any 4-stroke for a weed whacker. You need an engine that's meant to run while turned upside down and that's a 2-stroke(oil is in the gas so no oil sump). I'd be curious to see how many of these are still running in 3 years. 2-strokes are dirty but they can only be killed if someone forgets to pre-mix the gas. Propane is far from being the safe and economical fuel source you claim. Propane is STILL a carbon based fuel and releases the SAME NET levels hydrocarbons as it's room temperature liquid carbon based fuel counterparts so propane by no means is a less polluting fuel source. The main problem with propane is that typical compressed propane only burns at ~ 64% efficiency compared to ~93% for liquid combustion carbon fuels. Where do you think that 36% of unburned propane gas using by most propane devices usually goes? Commercial vehicles using propane as a fuel source overcome this inefficiency by recapturing exhaust and then continually re-mixing it into the combustion chamber until it is 95% consumed. However such propane reclamation systems are impractical for even riding lawn mowers sized engines letlaone those small single chamber units used in hand-held propane powered weed eaters.
Reliable and extremely fuel efficient small cc 4 cycle engines have been available for over 50 years. Modelers have been using them in large scale radio control planes since they were first introduced in the late 50s. If you knew anything about small CC 4 cycle engines you would already know the oil source feeding them in them is pressurized from the cylinder backplane suction so you orientation concern posted above is meaningless. If a 4 cycle engine can reliably and efficiently work in model planes that are repeatedly flown w in inverted high G situations they can easily withstand any orientation movement a homeowner can give them. Then there are those who are actually delusional enough to think battery powered equipment is the environmental solution? Environmentally friendly battery powered lawn equipment is a joke at best. Such battery powered devices are considered deferred pollution devices since their real pollution output occurs at the point the electricity used to charge them is generated and then again by the “environmental cost” to do to dispose of batteries. For most US residents, that means a coal fired power plant which is by far the greatest source of hydrocarbon emission pollution on the planet. |
-
-
Divalent1
- Member
posted: Jul. 6, 2009 @ 8:31p
Did have this line in the Fenton, MI store |
Close
|
|
 |
 |
Not Already A Member?
Sign Up Now!
|
|
Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.
|
|