click to close
help
edit

Forums
Deal Discussion

Official Thread of Baby Product Reviews in: Reviews

  • filter:
  • Tell A Friend
  • Text Only
  • Search this Topic »
  • switch to 'Classic' view
rated:
alert mods    

For all the parents of little ones out there, I would like to start a thread where baby products are reviewed. Let's face it, children are really expensive! For our 7-month old, we've certainly purchased many items that didn't quite work out as expected or were just not worth the money.

In the Fatwallet spirit, it would be great to compile a list of the REAL essentials for infants and toddlers. (There have been some good threads on this forum, but it's scattered.) Please include your opinions on EVERYTHING, from the cheapest leak-proof diapers to the best baby bottles to the most functional strollers, as well as your favorite kids' toys, links to great websites, or any other deals/finds you have discovered on your own parenthood journey.

Bon voyage!

Message edited by: achapino on 2006-09-19 03:06:12 CDT

Quick Summary is created and edited by users like you... Add FAQ's, Links and other Relevant Information by clicking the edit button in the lower right hand corner of this message.


rated:
alert mods    

Aaaaaah - where was this thread 3 years ago when I really really needed it??

Seriously, this is a great idea - coming from a Mommy who bought 5 - yes 5!!! - different strollers in the first two years (the biggest waste of money in my whole life I think!)

The Fisher Price Wonders Aquarium (that attaches to the crib) is an excellent buy at less than $25. My son loved his so much that I bought it as baby gifts for at least 6 other moms in the past few years and everybody has raved over it. You can check reviews all over the internet and see that it is a much loved baby item!

rated:
alert mods    

I also like Fisher-Price. We've bought several of their products and have not been disappointed. They are generally well-designed and of excellent quality. They usually focus on some aspect of learning or development, and yet is still a lot of fun for the child. And you can usually find a great deal somewhere.

When we wanted a baby swing for our small house, we ended up choosing the Fisher-Price Aquarium Take-Along Swing, which provides all the features of a full-sized swing but takes up so much less space. It's also nice to be able to move the swing easily from room to room. Here's a link for a demo. (It's the same series as the Fisher-Price Wonders Aquarium.)

Another Fisher-Price item that our 7-month old absolutely LOVES is the Intellitainer. IMO, it's the better alternative to the more popular Evenflo Exersaucers. Here's the link to a past thread with my full description. There's also a discussion there on the safety of walkers. Note that this is not a walker; it's a stationary entertainment center, which has been deemed safe by the Amer Academy of Pediatrics (AAP). There's no controversy -- walkers are considered dangerous and are not recommended by the AAP as well as many other authorities.

rated:
alert mods    

BrooklynSHOPPER said:Seriously, this is a great idea - coming from a Mommy who bought 5 - yes 5!!! - different strollers in the first two years (the biggest waste of money in my whole life I think!) Would you be able give us your low-down on strollers then?

Our baby has been in the Graco SnugRide Infant Car Seat, which snaps nicely into the SnugRider Stroller (really just a car seat carrier), for a compact and lightweight travel system. It's worked GREAT! When we researched this last year, very few car seats actually SNAP into the stroller; most use straps. It's really ideal to have one that really snaps in and comes out so effortlessly! (I think the Peg Perego car seats do snap into one of their strollers, but it was very hard to line up the two, particularly when you're carrying a 15-LB baby in it.)

Now that he's 7-months old, we're ready for move up to a real stroller, but there are too many options! Many people we know seem to end up buying at least 2 -- one full-featured stroller and another light-weight one for traveling. Some even buy a 3rd one for jogging or hiking. Isn't it overkill?! I would be interested in the experiences of Fatwallet parents and what you all recommend. Thanks!

rated:
alert mods    

First I bought one of those expensive $300+ "systems" - in retrospect those are really a waste of money unless you really need it (I didn't). Oh boy, I had to have all the bells & whistles, too (cup holders, easy closing mechanism, etc.) In the first few months, I barely used it at all - and then he outgrew the carrier so fast it made my head spin. You really don't take your newborn baby out very much unless you live in a perfect climate AND walk alot everyday (my son was born in the summertime in NYC). So before he was even 9 months old I had already given away the carrier and the carrier base for the car. Then I was left with this huge stroller that I found inconvenient and I really didn't use it unless I was taking a walk, so I wound up giving that away too - and it was still practically brand new. Otherwise, If I had to go out with my baby, it was usually to do some shopping and in that case it was so much more convenient to have him in those carriers that strap on to you so you can push a shopping cart around. Then, I was either in the car, or maybe going out to visit family or friends, and you certainly don't need a big stroller for these outings either
Then I invested in a $200 Maclaren stroller but that broke which really infuriated me because it was so expensive. The stroller wasn't misused or anything, it was just a piece that bent slightly on one occassion where his dad was trying to close it but it one of the baby's stroller toys was making it hard to close -- but that one incident made the stroller unusable. I went to an authorized repair place, but they wanted almost $100 to fix it, and they said they see that problem alot with Maclarens - so I didn't want to throw another $100 into that stroller. So I bought another stroller, I can't remember what make but something that starts with a "C" -also expensive - but then you realize how FILTHY these things get once your baby starts eating solid foods! LOL. I was taking it apart and washing the seat every week! Once he was big enough, it was just so much easier to buy what I call "disposable" umbrella strollers at Toys R Us. For $20, I don't care if he spills his fruit juice or drops pieces of banana in the seat and it gets all mushy - I'd just toss it and get a new one. And honestly, the cheap umbrella strollers NEVER broke on me. So I do think you need ONE good stroller for a baby (one that reclines, good padding, etc.) - and use this one for a long day out where you want the baby to be extra comfortable - but don't get one that's so big and heavy and cumbersome that you hardly ever lug it out of your house. After that, when the baby is old enough/sitting up/etc., just invest in a couple of the umbrella strollers for quick outings - they're SO much easier to lug around and throw in the trunk of the car. They're even easier to throw in a shopping cart at the grocery store (try throwing a big stroller in there -- you won't have any room left in it for your groceries!).
Hope this helps somebody

rated:
alert mods    

Regarding one of the biggest baby expenses -- DIAPERS:
We've all been had!!! by those brand-name diaper companies...
There's no need to search and wait for Amazon's $30 gift code or any other deals.

The VERY BEST AND CHEAPEST diapers of all are WalMart's WHITE CLOUD diapers.
At their regular price of $14.97 for a box of 104 diapers in the Step 3 size, it's only 14.4 cents per diaper. Compare that to Pampers Cruisers (16.6 cents each with the Amazon sale), Costco's Kirkland diapers (16.3 cents each), or Huggies at Costco (16.9 cents each).

As first-time parents, we wanted nothing but the very best for our son. We started out with Pampers Swaddlers, which we liked (over Huggies Supreme, Huggies, and Kirkland). Until he grew out of their maximum size of Step 2. So we tried Pampers Cruisers and Pampers Baby-Dry. Then, at 7-months old and 17 pounds, the baby caught a bad case of stomach flu, with up to 8 episodes of watery diarrhea daily for quite a few weeks. Although he's better now, oh what a nuisance it was for the parents! But it was great for REALLY putting these so-called diapers to a REAL-LIFE TEST!

Almost immediately, we found the Cruisers to be too stretchy at the legs causing leakages there. Baby-Dry, on the other hand, were not stretchy enough around the waist, so he would leak up the back when he's lying down. Huggies Supreme didn't fare any better. Then a friend with a 9-month-old of her own recommended White Cloud diapers from WalMart. We didn't believe it at first and didn't try it for a while. Now we regret our delay. Because they're wonderful! Just stretchy enough without being too loose. Soft and comfortable for baby to move around in, yet there's enough elastic to contain leakages. We're in love... if that's possible with diapers. Sure makes life easier. And you don't even have to wait for a sale to get the best deal.

UPDATE 10/10/2006: After using the White Clouds for the past couple of months, we've found that its absorbency and maximum capacity are not as quite good as the Pampers Cruisers or Baby-Dry. It's perfectly adequate during the day, but we've gone back to using Pampers at night, when the diaper is not changed as frequently. We still like the White Cloud for its nice fit and stretchiness.

At 17-18 pounds, our baby is borderline between the step 2 and step 3 sizes. At this time, White Cloud fits beautifully, followed by Pampers. Kirkland and Huggies Supreme are still too loose on him, although the weight ranges (12-18 lbs for step 2, 16-28 lbs for step 3) for all these brands are the same. Maybe after he gets bigger, the others will fit better too. Will let you know then.

UPDATE 1/4/2007: Newer packages of Pampers Baby-Dry now have a new feature called "Caterpillar-Flex", which just means that the 2 back tabs are now made of a flexible contract-and-expand material, rather than the previous tabs that were not flexible at all. It's not as creative as they try to make it sound, since other diapers have their versions of this feature, but it is a terrific improvement on the product and does directly address my prior complaint (above). Since the Baby-Dry is hands-down the most absorbent diaper we've tried by far, it has become our diaper of choice. It is less expensive than the Cruisers. The Step 3 size fits our now 21-22 pound baby perfectly. It is flexible enough for day or night use, and can hold an AMAZING amount of fluids. We haven't had any problems with leakages.

Message edited by: achapino on 2007-01-04 10:43:24 CST
rated:
alert mods    

Here is a link to get a FREE sample of the new Huggies Supreme diapers by mail from WalMart.

rated:
alert mods    

I'm afraid my kids are all too old for me to have much up-to-date information to pass on. However, this thread is a great idea, and I imagine it will be most helpful to those new to the parenthood game.

Remember to read to your children every day!

rated:
alert mods    

TO ALL PARENTS:

For this thread to be successful, PLEASE share your opinions on your favorite (and least favorite) baby products!!!

Thanks.

rated:
alert mods    

Does anyone have a recommendation for a good and reasonably-priced crib?

rated:
alert mods    

Does anyone have the new Phil and Ted stroller? what are your thoughts. i'm seriously considering. but its like $400!! pretty crazy but maybe well worth it?

here are my product raves and rants
after the 1st kid, boy have i ever learned

Diapers
For diapers, forget the name brands
target diapers work fine
if you can, costco diapers are a step above

Wipes
the very BEST wipes are from COSTCO well worth it!!! I REALLY MEAN IT
but for our newborn, we mainly used wet paper towels.

Carrier
we've tried all types of carriers. the baby bjorn is the easiest. we bought a used one from a resell shop for about 25 bucks

Carseat
Dont skimp on baby carseats, this is the one purchase that we did not skimp on. The marathon from Britax is awesome. I don't suggest the roundabout because it gets outgrown faster.

The Graco infant seat works GREAT

Stroller
AVOID the travel system at all costs! So bulky, and tacky. That was my biggest mistake.

Highchair
The first years reclining seat. Forget those other expensive chairs. This one works with your existing dining chair at home. Easy to clean, saves alot of space.

Potty Seat
I like the Bjorn potty seat. But it's the only one I've tried. Easy to clean, simple, compact. May not be for boys though because there's lesser "AIM" space

Lifesavers
a Swing!
a Carrier
Leapfrog learning table
baby papsan

Stay away from
walkers, they are a safety hazard
name brand clothes, if u need to, buy them used. they get outgrown so fast

JUST my opinions.

rated:
alert mods    

This is a simple one... and free!! One of our baby's favorite things is listening to music that we downloaded for free from Leap Frog. We have a bunch of bay CDs but this is her favorite by far. Make sure to click the "Download All" button so that you don't have to download them one at a time.
http://www.leapfrog.com/do/findpage?pageKey=babymusic

Other thoughts...
- when possible, buy in bulk. We like costco the best.
- Fisher Price swings and bouncies are great. The side-to-side rock is preferred by babies to the back and forth. We didn't like the Graco swings at all... they were too fast even on the lowest speed.
- If you have a cranky baby (doesn't sleep well, reflux problems, gas, crying), be careful of folks that say you can't add rice cereal to a newborn's formula. Everyone we know (including us) tried this AND IT WORKS.
- We really like the diaper pail from Safety 1st... so much better than the diaper genie.

If anyone thinks this info is useful, I'll be glad to add more.

rated:
alert mods    

That's a great idea! We also like to tape the Classical Baby series off HBO. Very soothing. We play it when he's nursing. It's similar to the Baby Einstein DVDs and it's free if you already have cable anyways.

Thanks for your useful info -- please do share more!

rated:
alert mods    

My wife borrow a lot of baby Einstein cds from the local library and she burns it.

rated:
alert mods    

What are some of your favorite books on babies, childcare, or parenting?

We found these to be indispensable:
What to Expect When You're Expecting -- the best pregnancy book out there, mandatory read for new moms-to-be
The Expectant Father -- great for first-time dads, written by a dad, general advice geared towards upcoming fatherhood, with lots of encouragement on how to care for and support your pregnant wife (hint: ladies, buy this for your hubs when you order your own What to Expect book; do it EARLY in your pregnancy and it'll make YOUR life easier! It'll get him involved in the pregnancy and help him to understand better what you're going through.)
What to Expect the First Year -- not quite as stellar as their pregnancy book, but still one of the better books available for new parents; fairly comprehensive, with good and helpful info, but a little disorganized, sometimes hard to find the specific topic you're looking for
Baby Bargains -- fairly comprehensive review of the basic baby gear, what to buy, what not to buy, how to find bargains (MUCH better than their Toddler Bargains book)
DrJackNewman.com -- a excellent on-line visual breastfeeding resource, with videos and handouts on everything to do with breastfeeding, authored by a Canadian pediatrician. ABSOLUTELY FABULOUS! Mandatory for first-time moms: WATCH the free video clips in the weeks BEFORE your baby's born. It'll show you exactly how help the baby latch on, know when he's swallowing and if he's getting enough milk, etc. It'll save you a lot of heartache once the baby's out and ravenously hungry! Then you can use the website if any problems (difficulty latching on, inadequate milk supply, newborn jaundice, sore nipples, mastitis, etc, etc) should arise. It's free and better than most books or DVDs out there.
AskDrSears.com -- good reference for all the common baby-rearing questions

Useless/waste of money:
The lilaguide: Baby Gear Guide -- just a haphazard list of some baby products, not complete at all, no real reviews, totally useless

Everyone, please feel free to add to this list!

Message edited by: achapino on 2006-09-24 10:05:29 CDT
rated:
alert mods    

The best thing we have gotten is the baby baby einstein activity mat. A little pricey but well worth the money. This kept my daughter busy from about a month old and still does at 6 months old.

Although now that she can roll and scoot I also have the baby einstein activity center (79.99). This was also pricey (though not the most expensive), but the best imo. The high cost was worth it because I feel as though it eliminates the need to really buy any other toy other than the few things we have to take on the go.

I also have the fisher price ocean wonders aquarium - the new style. This has really been a life saver at bedtime. My baby used to scream and scream at night and just wouldn't go to sleep till we got this.

An obvious money saver is nursing. Formula costs on average $12 a can and I'll estimate babies use 10 cans a month (I really don't know though because we don't use formula). That is $120 a month! Baby gets great benefits from it as well, even if supplementing with formula. If you do use formula go to the health department and if you qualify you get it for free, along with other things such as milk,cheese,juice,cereal,peanut butter, and eggs.

I will add more when I have time baby is calling

Message edited by: soxandwaffles on 2006-09-27 14:52:37 CDT
rated:
alert mods    

achapino,

We've just gone through the whole stroller struggle. Like, you, we had the Graco snap-in frame while our son was in his infant seat. (Note to other parents, we would still make that decision today -- the frame was lightweight, easy to use, easy to maneuver. We had no complaints at all). However, we were entirely up in the air when it came to the next stroller. After A LOT of reading reviews, comparing models, weighing our inherently cheap nature against the willingness to get our son anything and everything he wants (which, at 10 months now, is mostly food and some random household items to play with), we decided on the Inglesina Espresso 2006 model.

This decision was made harder given that no stores in Michigan, Indiana or Ohio had this model in stock for us to see/test. After the stroller arrived, our fears were alleviated and research effort justified. This stoller is great. At $140 shipped, it was relatively cheap, it is easy to maneuver, comfortable for our son, astoundingly easy to open and fold, lightweight and even looks good. Make sure that you find a reputable store that will actually sell you the 2006 model (many online stores had 2005s, but said they were 2006). They corrected some earlier problems with this stroller with the new model.

That having been said, we are also planning on buying an umbrella stroller in the near future for quick trips. This was planned even as we were buying the Espresso, just for the umbrella's ease of use and small size when folded. We may be going overboard on an umbrella since the generic $15 umbrellas get so much mention, but were looking currently at a Maclaren Triumph or Quest.

Message edited by: joshsipes on 2006-09-29 10:20:26 CDT
rated:
alert mods    

joshsipes said:achapino,

We've just gone through the whole stroller struggle... ...After A LOT of reading reviews, comparing models, weighing our inherently cheap nature against the willingness to get our son anything and everything he wants (which, at 10 months now, is mostly food and some random household items to play with), we decided on the Inglesina Espresso 2006 model.
Thanks, joshsipes. That's really helpful! The Espresso is one of the strollers we are considering. The other top contenders at this time are the Peg Perego Pliko Lite and the Maclaren Techno XT. By the way, we TOTALLY can relate to what you said about trying to balance the $$ factor with wanting everything for our son.

Costco.com currently has the Inglesina Espresso in Navy for only $99, but I can't tell if it's the 2006 or an older model. For that price, I would assume that it's 2005. Do you know what the differences are between the 2005 and 2006?</blockquote></blockquote>

rated:
alert mods    

What a great thread. I have triplets about to turn one year old, so I am learning to cut costs while trying to keep the "great quality" factor in play.

I started off with the big, heavy bulky strollers. That did not last long at all. The stroller I got was the "Jeep Wrangler" strollers. I got a double and a single. They are built like umbrella strollers, but much more durable. They have canopies, cup holders and side compartments. They are very easy to steer as well. I got them at toys 'r us.

I tried every diaper imaginable. Target has been the only ones that my kids havn't leaked through. They are more affordable, as well.

As for the toys. I went crazy this year buying all the toys with bells and whistles. That was a mistake in my opinion. My children all flock to the rattles and smaller teething toys. Some of them I got at the local dollar stores.

Although I love the Pamper wipes, they become expensive when your wiping for three. I found that Parent's choice (WalMart) wipes work great! They do not pop up out of the dispenser, however, it's worth the savings.