posted: Feb. 20, 2007 @ 1:21p
During the past year, I've been visiting Vegas approximately once a month usually under a free or heavily discounted room offer from Harrah's, Sahara, Aladdin, or Palace Station. I echo Claptonisgod96's and QuakerPC's findings regarding how comps work in Vegas, although there are differences between the player's clubs from the above casinos.
In general, I've been playing $15 hands at the BJ tables. At the Sahara, I earn approximately $10/hr in comp-credits that I can use at their restaurants, shops, etc, but sparingly receive free room offers. Presently, I have over $300 in my club account that I've only use for food. At my level of play, they also give me $25 or $50 in table play every other week (if I was a local, this would be pretty nice bonus). On the other hand, I earn approximately $1/hr in comp-credits thru Harrah's Total Rewards for a grand total of $12 in rewards, but have been receiving monthly free room offers until recently. At the end of last year, I checked my win/loss record at Harrah's website - they have recorded my play and I am ahead by approx $1500. I think I have been uninvited by Harrah's, since I no longer receive their free room offers. Actually, I believe that my play was not high enough for them to continue offering free rooms (I've calculated that I've played over 2000 hands at Harrah's and since I am $1500 ahead at $15/hand, it seems that I am approx 100 hands ahead which represents about a 5% edge against the house - not great, but better than the house having the advantage over you). At the Aladdin, my table play doesn't seem to earn or accumulate any comp-credits - I am required to ask the pit boss for free food, etc, which so far, I have not been turned down. For Palace Station, I do earn comp-credits, but I have not yet figured out the earnings rate (from a cursory review, it seems to be approximately $2/hr for play at $15/hand). In addition, I do receive their quarterly mailings for discounted and free rooms (usually for their "courtyard" or motel-type rooms).
Another difference between these clubs is the expiration rule. Total Rewards will remove the earned comps if there are more than 6 months between recorded activities. The Sahara comps expire after 18 months of no activities. I do not know the rules for Palace Station.
At some casinos, there seems to be two different comping systems - 1) earning comp-credits thru the above player's club and 2) thru a host or pit boss who grants the freebie, separate from the earned credits on the player's card. At Palace Station, I was introduced to a host, who advised me to submit my bill to him at the end of my stay and he would take care of things depending on my level of play. Since I did not really play very much there, I only used my earned credits to pay for a meal and did not seek his help. However, if you do use a host, make sure they don't first deplete your earned credits before granting the freebie.
The reason I still have so much comp-credits in my Sahara account is that there is not much I want to spend that money on at the Sahara. I only use it to purchase brunch at their buffet and the occasional dinner in their cafe. Their dinner buffet is not very good. So this account generally grows a litle after each visit. In fact, the last few trips, I have been eating comped dinners at the Aladdin's Spice Market Buffet and the $4.95 steak special at Ellis Island (which can be free after winning a hand of BJ using the $5 match play coupon) and not using the comp-credits in my Sahara account.
Most casinos will only track your play for comps ("rate" you) if you play $15/hand or above. That is why I settled on the $15/hand standard playing rate. This lets me compare the different player's club comp systems. Plus, it is at a rate that I can comfortably afford to lose when the cards temporarily turn against me.
And I agree with isles1: Do not gamble to earn comps; Do not gamble more than you can afford to lose - gamble only at a comfortable rate; Gamble if you are entertained by games of chance and enjoy socializing with the dealers, pit bosses, and other players; Gamble after you have thoroughly understood the games and the theories behind the winning strategies (i.e. for BJ, learn basic strategy, and at least a simple card counting method).
Good luck and have fun!