help
edit

Forums
Travel Deals

REQUEST Moving 2 tons of books from New York to San Francisco Archived From: Travel Deals

  • Text Only
  • Search this Topic »
  • Classic
  • Go to Page :
  • 1 23
alert mods    

I'm looking to move about 2 tons of books (about 2000 to 2500 mostly hardcover) from my home in the suburbs of New York City to a library in the suburbs of San Francisco. I'm donating these books and I want them to go to this specific library because of a family connection.
I found UPS Critical Express which will move 100 boxes of total weight 4000lbs for $9772. It looks like regular UPS will be more ( I could be wrong).
The other option I thought of is to rent a UHaul and drive the books to California with a friend. I'd then have to fly back to New York. This would cost 4(or more) days of my(and a friend's) life, about $1350 for the truck, about $1200 for gas(3000miles/10mpg*($4/gallon)), between $400 and $600 to fly back (depending on when we go) and food/motels over the course of the trip. Me and my friend are both college students so we would be doing this over one of the breaks.
Which option is better and/or do you have any other ideas? Thank you in advance.

Quick Summary is created and edited by users like you... Add FAQ's, Links and other Relevant Information by clicking the edit button in the lower right hand corner of this message.

alert mods    

If you have the time, and are willing to put in the effort, then doing it yourself is likely to be the cheapest.

I was initially thinking that one of the less-than-truckload options might be cheaper, but you may not have enough to ship to make it cost effective.

alert mods    

First off, thanks for the response.
Using UPS's LTL service cost estimator it came up with almost $7,000 and that was assuming the lowest class, meaning the real cost if I were to use UPS's LTL would be closer to $10k.
Unless you have any other ideas, I'm thinking a UHaul roadtrip is going to be the most effective means of transportation.

alert mods    

if it's going to cost you 7k ~ 10k, why don't you just donate that money???

alert mods    

I'd consider rail freight. Much less fuel involved; they're something like 3x more fuel-efficient than autos. Companies like CSX do this. I'm sure you can find many others by searching for "shipping by rail", "rail shipping", "intermodal transport", or something similar.

Here's the n00b page for CSX: New to CSX or Rail?. They have a Price Look-Up Tool towards the bottom of the page. Another biz called Ship by Rail has a similar tool on their home page, as well as a sample cost comparison: Seattle to Baltimore, $795 by rail, $1095 by truck. These might be good places to start...

Good luck.

alert mods    

I would check with various freight shipping/transportation shipping companies that are more suited for hauling items like this. FedEx/UPS/etc are not the cheapest to ship items like this. Also, a moving company would be a good bet. If you're not on a time-table, you might be able to get one on a return trip for a good price.

alert mods    

USPS Media Mail. 70lbs max per box (108in length+girth limit too). 4,000lbs of books = ~60 boxes. Each box runs $27, so about $1,620 for shipping. Priced some quality boxes at about $110 for enough of them (75 pack), tack on another $30-40 for packing tape. Presumably the same amount of labor is needed to get them ready by this method than any other. Figure $2,000 to get your buddies some pizza & beer to help box them up, rent a U-haul for the day to bring them to post office (maybe will they pickup??), labels (recommend numbering boxes 1/60, 2/60, etc. to make sure they all get there), plus anything else you might need.

Never done this much media mail but it is EXACTLY what it is meant for (libraries)...recommend calling your local main post office and running the idea by them first.

G'luck and be sure to document it all for tax purposes (if you need the deduction).

alert mods    

go to your post office and send it as media mail. that is the cheapest around. it is not treated as first class mail so it may take 3-4 weeks to come - but its worth it!

alert mods    

Have you actually made a contact with the library to see if they want your donation? If so, I am assuming that you have already asked them if they can either pay for the transport or if they are aware of a less expensive method. You would still get the tax deduction for the books but not the transport.

alert mods    

These shipments would seem to be eligible for the USPS Library Rate. It is $24.58 for 70 pounds. This would save you over a hundred bucks over Media Mail. A library must be either in the return address or the address to use this rate. This would appear to be the case in this instance.

alert mods    

Basketb926 said:First off, thanks for the response.
Using UPS's LTL service cost estimator it came up with almost $7,000 and that was assuming the lowest class, meaning the real cost if I were to use UPS's LTL would be closer to $10k.
Unless you have any other ideas, I'm thinking a UHaul roadtrip is going to be the most effective means of transportation.

Dear Basket,

Unless you have time constraints, one of the trucking company's LTL services would cost you between 2-3K. plus metro area surcharges if any. 4000 lbs does not seem to be that big of a load. So you may be able to save even more. However trucking companies typically ask for how many pallet spaces the goods are going to take. One pallet is L=48" x W= 40" x H= 48" If these books can fit on 8 pallets at the most, you can definitel do it for less than 3k.
Here is one of the trucking companies that might be able to help you. Remember it does not need to be your local company. It is always a good idea to buy insurance as well. Echoglobal Logistics= 800.354.7993

alert mods    

Check Forward Air, it is a trucking/freight company. Looks like they have locations in San Francisco and New York. Price was real good when I used them. You would have to take the boxes to their location and someone would need to get them at their San Francisco location upon arrival.

Forward Air

alert mods    

Check trucking companies. I used have 2 or 3 tons of clay shipped to me and the shipping was only $300. The shipping actually cost more than the clay (dirt is cheap - pun intended). Prices have probably gone up since gas prices have gone up, but I would think that that is your best bet. You would prbably have to work with them to get the boxes of boxes palletized, but once they are on pallets - the rest is easy.

Good luck.

alert mods    

I second Media Mail or Library Mail. Definitely the easiest and best way to go. Technically you could do all the weighing and postage at your house, then also ship one item Priority Mail (even just an large envelope) which would qualify you for a free USPS pickup. Man I would NOT want to be that USPS pickup driver

alert mods    

I transported my books media mail when I moed, and used Fedex ground for everything else. Make sure you pack the stuff well - one of my boxes accidentally split during transport, and it actualy arrived in two separate boxes, but gingerly repacked by the USPS crew, with a note that said my thesis (which happened to be in that box) was interesting and asking me to send a copy to an email address if I would

alert mods    

heathriel said:I transported my books media mail when I moed, and used Fedex ground for everything else. Make sure you pack the stuff well - one of my boxes accidentally split during transport, and it actualy arrived in two separate boxes, but gingerly repacked by the USPS crew, with a note that said my thesis (which happened to be in that box) was interesting and asking me to send a copy to an email address if I would

What about some sort of POD type company (they drop off a container at your address, you load it, they pick it up and load it on a truck with other pods, and drop the pod at your destination)? I'm not sure how the costs would pan out, but since they are just moving a single prepacked container, may be a competitive price.

alert mods    

All those shippng companies have a minimum charge. My overall move cost for my *stuff* (around 1200lbs, but a lot of weirdly shaped things, like rc airplanes in bicycle boxes and stuff) from MA to CA was $1700, and the minimum for a storage company would have been $2500. I put the heaviest stuff in the trunk of my car (tools, cast iron cookware, etc), and got that transported for under $1000 more (didn't pay extra for fast shipping, and it took 18 days).

But the books went media mail, and actually arrived very quickly - around 5-8 days each box. Very cheap, and as I said, the exception was the one box that split open because I was careless in my packing. I lost nothing though.

LTL, POD and all the other freight options were more expensive than Media Mail + Fedex.

alert mods    

Why don't you ask the library? It is their business and they should immediately know of should easily be able to get your answer.

alert mods    

PM Sent. I can help you out.

 Close

Sign Me In
Nickname: 
Password: 
Remember My Login Information:

Forget your login information?

Not Already A Member?
Sign Up Now!



Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.


  • © 1999-2009
  • Message Board Statistics RSS Feed Information
Sign up for free today, because you don't want to miss out on any more cash back than you already have! There are currently 1,091,995 people just like you registered to earn Cash Back From FatWallet. Be the next! Sign up to join the discussion & earn Cash Back from FatWallet:
close