I have developed a plan for a follow-up to my casual AOR from early January, I wanted to run the plan by the sages here so they could tell me if it’s a stupid idea and not to bother.
My first (Casual) AOR:
Began early January 2007
HHI $90k
FICO: approx 790 (I didn’t do any credit monitoring, that was what I was told my score was when I applied for a HELOC (which I did not close on) about a year ago)
Original Cards:
Chase BP CL: $30k (12 years old) balance approx 2k, paid in full every month
Chase plat visa: $5k (14 years old) bal 0 (never use card)
Cards and limits (all cards I applied for I received):
B of A NEA Card (0%, 12 statements, $30 max fee) $12.6k, increased to $20.1k via consolidation with BofA Financial Rewards plus) BTd $12k
Citi Professional (0%, 9 months (oops). $16.8cl, BTd $8k
Citi Diamond Preferred Rewards (0%, 12 months, cl $5.7k) BTd $2.6k
ATT Universal: (0%, 12 months, cl $4.5k) BTd $2k
Discover Miles: (0%, 12 months, cl $5k) Btd $2.4k
GE Money Plat MC: (0%, 12 months, cl $20k) Btd $12k
Juniper Natl Parks: (0%, 12 months, cl $15k) BTd $7.5
Total New credit: $87k
Total BT to HYS: $46.5k
Overall Utilization: 38%
Highest utilization 59% (on GE and BofA cards)
All other cards below 50%
I do see several newbe mistakes (no Chase or AMEX lines, the ‘unconsolidatable’ ATT card, etc.) and I do realize I have been conservative with my utilization. However, this conservatism resulted in a credit score that still seems reasonable: 3/31/07: 736 (via the TU freebie promotion from another thread, all lines and balances had reported)
I was generally pleased with how the AOR went despite its informality (I did not apply for all the cards in one day, the process stretched over a month). However, the small Cls with Discover, ATT and Citi Diamond seem silly, I tried to consolidate the ATT and Citi cards in every possible combination but the CSR told me it was impossible. I would like to make the small lines more usable, extend my 0% (the Citi Professional card 0% BT will expire in September) and get some more $$$ in my HYS.
These small credit limits, combined with:
my surprisingly healthy credit score (correct me if I am wrong)
An increase in HHI to $140k in July
My lack of BT money from Chase
Has led me to consider a follow on mini AOR in August. My plan is this:
Late May:
Pay down GE and BofA below 50%
Pay off Discover, Citi Diamond Preferred and ATT. This payoff would be about 5 months before expiration but I think it would provide a worthwhile bump in scores in return for paying off small balances.
Mid August:
Apply for a Chase 0% BT card, (reallocate approx 30k to the promotional card from my other chase cards) BT 50% (wish I jumped on the Freedom promotion).
Apply for another Citi card and consolidate Diamond and ATT (hopefully) CLs to it BT 50%
Possibly apply for three(?) other cards that I don’t have yet. (if I can find decent BT terms)
My questions are:
Am I being greedy? (is it stupid to try again after six months?)
Would I be better off if I wait until the bulk of the 0% approaches expiration?
Some have said that if you don’t get any denials you haven’t pushed hard enough, should I keep pushing?
What about CLIs? Should I ask for them before applying for new 0%? (so far, I have had no ‘free’ opportunities for CLI with my cards, but it has only been a few months, my new and improved HHI will help, but the duration of the 0% offers on those cards is getting shorter)
I guess I am just looking for advice from those folks who have done more than one AOR, is rushing the next one (including paying down small BT balances prematurely) a foolish strategy or is it worth a shot?