What kind of refrigerator ts better investment Side by Side or French Door?

Archived From: Deal Discussion
  • Page :
  • 1
  • Text Only
rated:
A refrigerator is a investment since it is so expensive. Which is better French Door or Side by Side for home use?

Member Summary
Staff Summary
Thanks for visiting FatWallet.com. Join for free to remove this ad.

this reminds me of the time my brother in law told me his season tickets for hockey were an investment. He is 22 and stupid.

Why a  refrigerator is an investment?  Does it provide any return or appreciate in value?   Anyway, French door or side by side are personal choice and everyone has different taste/opinion.  Wife first liked the side by side style which we have for the last 10 years and now she wants a bottom freezer type.

What part of "expensive = investment" do you not get?

dfres said:   A refrigerator is a investment since it is so expensive. Which is better French Door or Side by Side for home use?
 

  
So a car, big tv, etc are investments too? Its an appliance, check out both types and see what you prefer. Head over to hot deals and look for a deal.

Are you speaking of buying one for resale value on your home? We will be selling our home in the next year and had to get a new fridge. I ended up going large capacity side by side with door water and ice maker and same color and brand as the rest of my appliances( I had to wait a while for a deal on the brand). While the French door might be a trend of look prettier to some buyers, after using one I hated the freezer organization and the lower cost models had no or poorly rated ice makers. I think no one is going to be turned off from buying a home with a new(er) large side by side fridge but some buyers might not like the French door especially older buyers. My mom had to get rid of hers after knee and hip surgery.

Go on Craigslist, buy a fridge for $100...Great investment!

What you should look at is from a best performance perspective.

Cold air goes low, hence the best type would be those that have a freezer on the bottom. Therefore a french door would perform better. Also, you only open half of the top, keeping more of the cold air inside.

rsuaver said:   What you should look at is from a best performance perspective.

Cold air goes low, hence the best type would be those that have a freezer on the bottom.
You have it backwards. You want the freezer on top.
  

ditto, cold air from top freezer helps cool the refrigerator portion. bottom freezer's cold air cools the floor.

Having the freezer on the bottom of a combination fridge-freezer has been the standard in the EU for several decades, and that's for a reason -- bottom freezers are more efficient with electricity.

I recall that Consumer Reports said the same thing about the "freezer on the bottom" vs. "freezer on the top", the last time I read a report of theirs on refrigerators, which was about 5 years ago.

-----
ANYWAY -- OP, I would suggest that you locate and read the most recent Consumer Reports magazine article about refrigerators. They will look at a wide range of the current models, and they will generally discuss the purchase price, electricity usage, the lifespan, the spatial organization of the inside, the repair history, etc., of the various types of refrigerators.

The design of refrigerator is a matter of taste, as each one has its own pros and cons. Refrigerators with freezer portions at top and bottom of the standing unit are considered to be most energy efficient. But if we look in deep, refrigerators with freezers on top are much efficient than bottom freezer models.

https://www.zopper.com/blog/top-or-bottom-freezers-an-inside-out...

In general, refrigerators with top-mounted freezers use less energy than refrigerators with either side-mounted or bottom-mounted freezers.

https://energystar.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/211439598-What-...

"A Bottom Mount (or Bottom-Top) model, which accounts for about 3% of sales, has the freezer compartment on the bottom.... Energy consumption is slightly better than that of Top-Bottom units for newer models."
https://www.energyguide.com/library/EnergyLibraryTopic.asp?bid=austin&prd=10&TID=17257&SubjectID=8371 

======
As I said, I definitely read in Consumer Reports a number of years ago that bottom-freezer models were more efficient than top-freezer models.

Maybe that was because, at that time, bottom-freezer models were pretty rare in the US, and were mainly made by the higher-quality, more-expensive manufacturers, because they sell them in Europe in countries where bottom-freezer models are MUCH more common and are actually the norm, like in Germany and the UK.

=======
I know that when I was buying fridges for my personal use in Germany and the UK, several times in the last 25 years, all the salespeople in numerous retailers (and my local work colleagues in several companies) told me that the bottom-freezers on the market were more energy-efficient than the top-freezers on the market.

Maybe they were all talking off the top of their heads; however, I expect that, at that particular time, the bottom-freezers available for purchase probably were were more energy-efficient than the top-freezers available for purchase.

======
I would be quite surprised that the EU would not be heavily promoting top-freezer models, if they were massively more energy-efficient than bottom-freezer models.

(Indeed, one of the small irritants that pushed people towards voting for Brexit was how the EU had determined that the UK had to stop selling high-powered vacuum cleaners because they wasted too much energy, and people were clearing out the retailers' stocks of those before the rule came into effect.
some links:
"Anger as EU bans most powerful vacuum cleaners", https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/aug/21/anger-as-eu-bans-most-powerful-vacuum-cleaners 
"Ten days left to vacuum up a powerful cleaner", http://www.bbc.com/news/business-28878432 
"Consumers warned to “act quickly” before top-rated powerful vacuum cleaners sell out forever", http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/eu/11047127/EU-rules-against-powerful-vacuum-cleaners-ban-best-models-Which-warns.html )

====
Here are some of the major manufacturers' ranges in the UK, currently.

You can see that even today, in the UK, the vast, vast majority of fridges have bottom-freezers.

They also have some side-by-side fridges, which they call "American-style".

I don't think I saw even ONE top freezer model on these sites:
Siemens: http://www.siemens-home.bsh-group.com/uk/products/refrigeration-... 
Bosch: http://www.bosch-home.co.uk/products/fridges-freezers.html 
LG: http://www.lg.com/uk/fridge-freezers 

=====
The UK's equivalent to our Consumer Reports is called Which?
and their guide to buying fridges doesn't even talk about top freezers as being an option there:
http://www.which.co.uk/reviews/fridge-freezers/article/how-to-bu... 

=====
Here is the John Lewis dept. store guide to buying fridges -- no mention of even having a choice about whether to have a top-freezer or a bottom-freezer in the whole buying guide: https://www.johnlewis.com/buying-guides/fridges-buying-guide 

I once bought a top-freezer fridge at their store on Oxford Street in London, so I know that they do sell top-freezer models, but it was not one of their commonly-sold models...

Yes, it was a Zanussi (which at the time was an Italian brand, now I don't know if it's been taken over by a different company), 
and it was something like this little feller: https://www.johnlewis.com/zanussi-zrt23103wa-freestanding-fridge-freezer-a-energy-rating-55cm-wide-white/p2913178 

=====
"I keep hearing that those with freezers on the bottom are more energy-efficient than top-freezer fridges, with something about how heat rises and cold air sinks along with a behavioral argument that people will open the freezer less frequently if it’s not conveniently located at eye level.
I was pretty surprised, therefore, when the ClearlyEnergy team ran the numbers and discovered that, amongst today’s newest EnergyStar models, the average mid-size freezer-on-top models are actually slightly more efficient as an appliance.
Both top and bottom freezers are more efficient than side-by-side models, but even those notable energy bad boys are closing the efficiency gap and now cost on average $15 per year more in electricity than a top freezer."
https://www.clearlyenergy.com/blog/posts/fridge-facts-scrapping-the-old-saves-on-keeping-things-cold 

=====
OP, this seems to be the most recent Consumer Reports buying guide for fridges:

"All new refrigerators are a lot more efficient than they were a decade ago"
http://www.consumerreports.org/cro/refrigerators/buying-guide.ht... 

OP, I completely understood your use of the word 'investment' to mean something that costs quite a sum of money, but which isn't an "investment" in a strict sense. The word is often used like that in American English.

If you didn't understand why some people in their comments here were snippy/rude about your use of the word "investment", the following blog post might explain: http://www.getrichslowly.org/blog/2011/04/27/the-investment-piec... 

Also, someone earlier said that you might mean it to be an investment in the sense that you might be getting ready to sell or rent the house, and you want to have a nice, new fridge which can be a selling point for the property, which also would make sense.

The one that with the freezer that passes the large horizontal pizza test.  

oppidum said:   Having the freezer on the bottom of a combination fridge-freezer has been the standard in the EU for several decades, and that's for a reason -- bottom freezers are more efficient with electricity.
I recall that Consumer Reports said the same thing about the "freezer on the bottom" vs. "freezer on the top", the last time I read a report of theirs on refrigerators, which was about 5 years ago.

There's no inherent reason why having the freezer on the bottom should result in better energy efficiency, and if anything it should be worse because the compressor is always on the bottom and runs hot, so a freezer compartment down there will absorb more heat than a refrigerator compartment there. And Consumer Reports said, "The most efficient bottom -freezer we tested cost almost two-thirds more to run than the most efficient top-freezer. The top-freezers we tested were without exception more energy-efficient than the bottom-freezers."

But once manufacturers switched to much better insulation that virtually blocked all compressor heat, the inherent difference in energy consumption went to nothing, and if efficiency for bottom-freezers is now usually better, it's probably because manufacturers try to make such refrigerators more efficient, probably because they tend to sell for more than top-freezers do.  

So instead of making assumptions, check the actual energy efficiency ratings of the individual models.

ach1199 said:   Why a  refrigerator is an investment?  Does it provide any return or appreciate in value? 
  Compared to having no refrigerator and having to eat food the same day it's bought or restrict yourself to food that's nonperishable, canned, dried, or grown in your garden?



Disclaimer: By providing links to other sites, FatWallet.com does not guarantee, approve or endorse the information or products available at these sites, nor does a link indicate any association with or endorsement by the linked site to FatWallet.com.

Thanks for visiting FatWallet.com. Join for free to remove this ad.

While FatWallet makes every effort to post correct information, offers are subject to change without notice.
Some exclusions may apply based upon merchant policies.
© 1999-2017